I just noticed. Sorry for saying this but, Toffee looks upseted at the meat's "sorry" letter, then looked a bit sad?
Some monsters worship Toffee, but some monsters are bitter towards him. I wonder if that might depend on what he wants to do about Butterfly Family.
He might be reluctant to kill Comet/Moon. If so, he'd couldn't stop the monsters, who had grudges against Butterfly Family. Probably he wasn't one of the young Septarians affected by Seth, but it seemed Rasticore most trusted him.
btw I think I was wrong, everyone would know the letters of meat. As Moon served meat, more monsters had stand front of her.
Although it's strange, Toffee may had watching monsters to let them not do terrible to Moon/Star. He also looks to be making a threat rather than proactive attack, except for most of S2 screen times. but he might a bit aggressive with Marco.
Toffee might have hatred of Glossaryck more than Butterfly Family. He was a historian and magic researcher, apparently. dunno how much he knows about Mewni's history and magic, but Glossaryck created Mewman and Butterfly Family then let them steal the monster's land. Although that doesn't seem to be what Glossaryck wanted.
He tried to do something to Moon, but what if that was for stop Moon from being eroded by dark magic? (That magic seems to make angst grow)
So, Why doesn't he make any excuses?
I wonder if his crazyness when manipulating Ludo in S2 is caused by being in Realm of Magic, where filled with dark magic. His facial expression was very different between when he was inside and after he left. Still he was able to move things rationally. You know, does he was be like "OK I'm a bad guy If you guys want to make me bad I could be"? Hmm.
He doesn't usually seem to mind about his finger. so, I wonder he had lost something important because of magic (sorry). Probably the reason he was so obsessed with get his finger back was because it reminded him things.
Moon made a deal with Eclipsa to beat Toffee by dark magic, because Glossaryck showed her that page of magic spell book. Eclipsa's dark magic had the effect of giving the monsters the fear that they would never win against Butterfly Family. Toffee's death leads to Eclipsa's awakening. Dark magic was ingrained in Moon for over 14 years, I think that would made grown her vengefulness. That may have made her life to hard, and may lead to her anger for Eclipsa.
Toffee revealed that he had something planned for unknown future vision before his death, but never said his plan wasn't wrong. I feel like some invisible force was at work for their choices. I think Glossaryck was talking about an invisible goat that can help something.
Besides, Being the only one who knows everything also means that no one can understand him. Then, I wonder if he had an unknown reason to for being sympathetic to Butterfly Family but also angly with them. I got feeling he was in dilemma between the two sides, may had gave up on being understood, then hostile to magic for the unknown reason, I wonder. So maybe it was best for him that Star said "Toffee was right".
However, this all may be too delusional.
