man and the thing abt reid's incredibly racially fetishistic descriptions of shane is that an author who actually gives a shit about depicting characters of color well could use descriptors like that as characterization work. like, i can absolutely buy an 18 year old narrator looking at another 18 year old boy and going, ugh, he looks way more mature and grown up than me! this sucks!
but this needs to be challenged later is the thing. the narrative can't just be like "and that's true! and stays that way forever!" the narrative can't even just ignore it forever after those initial descriptions. the contrast or further exploration is necessary.
like. give me shane acknowledging the stereotype exists! let him think to himself like, "it fucking sucks that im short and dont have much body hair compared to my stupid white teammates. i feel like a walking stereotype. i hate this." (and then backpedaling in his own mind like "not that. being like a stereotype is bad. because short hairless asian men are real and valid. it's just ME--"
and, like, okay say shane is still in the process of going thru the late stages of puberty at 18. then where is the converse of shane's comparison of them both, where ilya goes OH SHIT, WHEN DID HIS SHOULDERS GET SO BROAD? FUCK HE'S ABOUT MY HEIGHT NOW, HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO HANDLE EYE CONTACT LIKE THIS. BOOBS IN MY MOUTH? WHAT? HELLO?!
i'm just saying like there are so many ways to handle this that aren't as jawdroppingly racist as playing it completely straight the way rachel reid's actual writing does. you just have to start from a place of seeing poc as people and not fetishes, which... 😬
anyways. my kingdom for a character study of shane and his thoughts on his appearance. guy who is like, "i have never looked like the white boys and men im constantly surrounded by and im deeply aware that the (mostly white) girls who ive associated with through them have always found whiteness more attractive so i dont really consider myself attractive bc im very aware of the physical features on my face and body that look nonwhite and it makes me lowkey uncomfortable to think about too hard but i also know i probably am wrong because ive been voted sexiest player in the nhl and done thirst trap advertising work but theres a disconnect in my head about that still because Im Not White and i just dont think about myself as attractive even now. but hey at least i finally got taller!"
and meanwhile ilya's just out there like









