Of course I loved her.
I have always loved Alex. Of course I have. It was Alex who said hi to me first. I was new and Alex was always so bold. So it was her first, but we were us maybe from the first moment. certainly by the time we sat next to each other at lunch that day and then every day after.
It was me who gave Alex chicken pox and I know that doesn’t sound like love but when you love people you share things. We shared that. The long days isolated from everyone else. It suited us, our own little itchy world in my parents basement surrounded by stacks of magazines and the classic movies that were the only entertainment my parents stooped to keep on hand for their solitary child. Alex told me once she thought I resorted to writing out of sheer boredom.
It was me who shared that too. Maybe not much better than chickenpox. Alex read my first halting attempts at fairytales and my angst-ridden teen poetry. Then, later, my first novel and she still always gets the first finished draft of whatever I’m working on. She always has something droll to say about it, but she reads it all. Every time.
It was Alex who first bloodied a man’s nose for me. It’s happened so often they all blur together. Men are terrible and Alex is Alex. I do remember that first time he was just a high school bully who backed down. There were times they weren’t. We’ve shared enough ice packs and bruised egos, been in enough fights for and with each other to know where to be gentle.
So when it was Alex who told me she was in love with me and then kissed me in my car outside her house, like she couldn’t keep it back anymore, like a gasp for air in oncoming tides... I kissed her back, took her face in my hands and disengaged gently. Told her how much I loved her. That there was a boy, Sean, in senior year with us I was going to prom with. I don’t know if it was gentle enough. She still winced and things were strained for a while. But when prom did finally come around I ditched Sean long enough to find Alex with a flask out on the bleachers by the football field. We drank and made each other laugh. So, as it turns out, we shared that too.
And graduation. And college and two whirlwind nights in Italy when Alex flew out to surprise me the year I studied abroad. And then finally the same city again where we could see each other every day. Which we did. For a while.
She got married. And it was me, because it’s me and we’re us, who drove her to that first date. It happened a lot that way in those days. Alex and I stealing time together between her shifts and my writing and all our separate social events and travel and all the life that we didn’t share anymore by grabbing the fifteen minutes between things...plus the length of the car ride. Just snippets here and there. Not enough, but something. Something.
I liked her when I finally met her, weeks later when it was clear she’d be around for a while. I liked her. She was funny and warm and thoughtful. Impossible to hate. Later...I’d try. But for now we became fast friends and the occasional twinge at sharing mine and Alex’s world with someone else passed quickly and nearly went away.
I didn’t understand until I was standing in front of Alex in a dressing room the day of her wedding that something came loose inside me I’d never be able to name. Or take back. That had maybe always been coming. Or grown over time. Or that I just didn’t recognize as always being true like the supreme idiot I sometimes I am. It doesn’t matter. What matters is this: Somewhere between high school and her wedding day I’d fallen in love with my best friend. Too late. A day, and a lifetime shared, too late.
I thought it would fade, go back to where ever it had been lurking inside me all these years. But it didn’t. I went away then. Hid at home. Behind my work. Avoided Alex and everyone else in the world. What else do you do when a friend who had been in love with you gets married and you figure out you’re in love with her too? When she’s married. And her wife is funny and warm and thoughtful...and a friend of yours now too.
It was her...who came and found me. Knocking on my door with two cups of coffee and that gentle smile. Impossible to hate. She came to tell me she knew I was busy, but that she missed me. She never mentioned Alex. But it hung there between us I think. I never asked. Not once. And she never said. But I think maybe she knew.
And life carried on. The years passed. I dated here and there. The two of you were happy. To the end, you were happy. And I was there. I know that doesn’t sound much like love but Alex, you have to know by now...you share things with people you love. She shared you.
Of course I loved her.
















