Controversial Takes

Your controversial Harry Potter takes!

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Submit an ANONYMOUS ask containing your Harry Potter related take.

This account will act as a medium between the internet and your thoughts.

But, if you will submit a take that you want to be debated on, you may submit it as Non-Anon. Please take the debating to PMs and not on the post's comments

Sending questions to the (only) mod, aka me, are allowed. Just specify that it is a question to me. You do not need to submit a take and specify that it is one since sending things to the inbox will automatically be upheld as a take unless stated otherwise.

Tags to pay attention to in posts

#hp controversial Takes: Usual posts, the whole reason for the account.

#ooc hp controversial takes: Non-takes. Mod answering questions.

#up for debate: Non-Anon takes, profile of take submitter is fully visible. You may proceed to PM the submitter to further debate in private (not in the comments of the post or the inbox)

If you're submitting a take that revolves around a topic that can not only be related to Harry Potter and can be related to any other media in general then you will need to explicitly state that you're referring to the HP fandom/media

Do note that some submissions will not be posted for many different external reasons. But don't be afraid to send an ask as it is anonymous.

Tagging mainstream tags for traction

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Here's a take: I think we should all hold hands and just embrace the fact we have different opinions in the Harry Potter fandom.

The Sherlock fandom is almost as old as us and they're doing pretty fine. Why can't we be like that?

Controversial Take 189

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Sometimes I wish Bellatrix had been one of the main characters, so those dim-witted Hermione fans would stop trying to put her at the top of everything and acting with such weird misogyny like Hermione's the only well-written female character. Bellatrix is a million times more interesting and captivating and frankly smarter than the Gryffindor girl, whose intelligence was limited to books and politics.

I wish Bellatrix had choked her out with her own hands when she was interrogating her. It'd be more realistic a mediocre girl dying at the hands of a powerful, confident woman in every sense. God, Bellatrix is so hot.

Controversial Take 188

[hpcontroversialtakes]

All Bellatrix ships gross me out because everyone in canon shows annoyance with her and I pity everyone paired with her because they would just suffer her. She's also naive and weird, like nobody cares for company like hers. She's only useful and entertaining, but I bet everyone needed breaks from her. If she died everyone would either don’t care, be happy or be sad a bit and then move on normally. Like that's how tragic she was. Even Voldemort immediately moved on after she died. He got mad for losing his last asset and then his attention focused elsewhere. Didn’t even try saving her. Idk that's a sad existence. Voldemort while being tragic too at least had people deeply caring about him like Barty Crouch, Bellatrix and other Lestranges who'd do everything for him. She had no one like that. Only ship I kinda like is her and Andromeda because it's super tense, like Bellatrix lowkey hated Andromeda and that's interesting and they have that former sisterly bond so some level of care is obvious. But I don't get Bellamione, Bellamort, Bellasnape, Bellarius, Bellucius etc like all these people hated her or thought she was annoying etc

Controversial Take 188

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Tomarry only exists to pander to fans too weak to appreciate Bellamort because it's a ship with a real woman. Not some pathetic ugly git like Harry who'd never match the fierce personality of Bellatrix or Voldemort no matter how much his deluded fans try to make him darker and overpowered.

Bellatrix has no personality that's why people prefer Harry, who is also more interesting as the main character. Voldemort is more interesting than Bellatrix because he's complex and the main villan. Jesus why are these Bellatrix fans so weird and annoying? It's so obvious why people don’t care for bellamort, why do they twist it into some delusion?

Controversial Take 187

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Every character they try to ship Voldemort with has to be altered so much that they become a weaker knock-off of Bellatrix. Every single one. Be it Hermione, Harry, Nagini, Ginny, or some made-up character. ALL OF THEM.

That's impossible because Bellatrix has no personality besides having surface boring traits like cruelty or pride. That's not a personality. So cut this lying bs and stop talking about ships you clearly hate.

Controversial Take 186

[hpcontroversialtakes]

The marauders fans are simply parasitising on a popular fandom…

Controversial Take 185

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Ginny deserves better than Harry .

Blaise, Theo and Draco would be a better choice than the shit person she is married to, i bet she divorced that idiot with a scar on his forehead

Controversial Take 184

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Harry is a fucking moron who only survived because of his friends, he deserved to be beaten by his uncles for being an spoiled brat

Controversial Take 183

[hpcontroversialtakes]

If the books were more realistic Harry would've been sexually abused by every character who tried to take advantage of him. Starting with his uncle and cousin. He'd just let it happen.

Controversial Take 182

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Every character they try to ship Voldemort with has to be altered so much that they become a weaker knock-off of Bellatrix. Every single one. Be it Hermione, Harry, Nagini, Ginny, or some made-up character. ALL OF THEM.

Controversial Take 181

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Tomarry only exists to pander to fans too weak to appreciate Bellamort because it's a ship with a real woman. Not some pathetic ugly git like Harry who'd never match the fierce personality of Bellatrix or Voldemort no matter how much his deluded fans try to make him darker and overpowered.

Controversial Take 180

[hpcontroversialtakes]

No hate, but I just don't get Tomarry. People claim there's compatibility between them but I just don't see it. You gotta change a lot of shit via headcanons just so they can be at least a little compatible (if not a little forced too)

Controversial Take 179

[hpcontroversialtakes]

I bet Ginny cheated on Harry with Dean because he is awful in sex

Controversial Take 178

[hpcontroversialtakes]

Ginny deserves better than that disgusting idiot called Harry Potter, he doesn't care about before Half Blood Prince , he is a shallow idiot .

Controversial Take 177

[hpcontroversialtakes]

I love Hinny and they are my favourite and I believe Dominic and Gracie will make it more popular but I believe Romione will be the most popular couple like it is in the books and movies because people in general love drama and angst and Romione is exactly what most people prefer and love and let's face it Ron and Hermione is the best written couple in development throughout the series.

Controversial Take 176

[hpcontroversialtakes]

All Harry ships disgust me because every single character, even Umbridge, deserves better than the piece of shit that calls itself Harry.

Controversial Take 175