Expiredverse meets Canon:
How do you think Expired!Rosie and Canon!Rosie would react to eachother?
Do you think Canon!Rosie would envy Expired for having a closer relationship with Alastor despite (or rather because of) the lack of a soul leash binding them together? Would she realise how she very well could have irreversibly damaged their friendship -looking at Expiredverse, she wonders if they were friends?- as Alastor will never truly trust her after refusing to help him? She sees how Expired!Alastor doesn't flinch or tense when her alternate self pets his ears, despite grumbling about it stupid or embarrassing, and feels shame for the first time in decades.
Would Expired!Rosie be tempted to kill then eat her Canon self before taking over her town after seeing how she treated not only (an alternate version of) her best friend but another cannibal? Would she snap at her for treating Alastor, who had told her of the discrimination he and his mother faced, as less than? Would she see canon's toxic behaviour, and wonder if she would've made the same choices if Alastor had summoned her back then? Is she truly any better than her?
Okay, so, Expired!Rosie is actually very similar to canon!Rosie, as you will see when you get her pov. She's not nearly as nice or kind as Alastor thinks. I am actually going to include Alastor doing magic when he was alive/trying to summon a demon to secure himself in hell in Expired, the divergence point is just that he wasn't able to contact anyone in expired! Expired!Rosie would LOVE to own Alastor/have him join Cannibal town/possibly marry him - he's the one who got away!
But while Canon!Rosie has had Alastor as her thrall and that power dynamic between them, Expired!Rosie hasn't, and she actually likes and gets along with Alastor! She approves of how he does things and the orphanage! She likes him! And thinks he's far too nice and kind for Hell, cause she doesn't know he's the one killing overlords!
Canon!Rosie gets to see her other self and Alastor as actual, real friends, and be envious, and realise she's fucked up. Expired!Rosie gets to see what she would have been, how she would have treated her dearest friend
Expired!Rosie also gets the undercurrents more, because Expired!Alastor actually lets her know about it when more coloured cannibals show up, and she very well might want to kill and eat her counterpart!
On the other hand, that would mean she has to deal with TWO Susans...
I wonder if Lilith and Lucifer will pick up on how Rosie would love to have Alastor as one of her souls slash husbands while Alastor stands there oblivious?
On one hand, phew, thank Hell Lilith got to him first! On the other, they are pretty close already and they're both cannibals and what if she asks for his hand and he says yes?!!
He'd take a butcher knife and hack it off, then share a tasty bone broth recipe with her
Oh! Actually, what if that is a Cannibal Town tradition? Willingly offering up your hand in marriage for dinner?
If it was then the Morningstars are cooked, Alastor accepted the proposal because he trusts her and figures no one else would ever ask him, so she must be his only option










