I've reread the myth and I am still set in my interpretation of things so enjoy my little amateur analysis of Lucid Dream w tons of screenshots below cause I spent way too much time on it xoxo (warning: its long)
Caleb doesnt lose his memory with strong emotions, and him having amnesia was part of MCs chip-induced dream in attempt to come to terms with the reality that the Caleb from her past is indeed gone for good
Most importantly to start off with, he has a black hole inside of him at all times preventing the chip from accessing his brain. This is clearly stated at the very end of the myth. So there shouldnt be any way for him to lose his memories because of it- unless that black hole fails ofc and I think if thats ever the case it would be a BIG serious thing and not something that he would just recover from over time and regain his memories like seems to happen over the amusement park chapter
the chip was attempting to do what it did to Kevi and rewrite the strong emotions that night, but it failed. He was even still himself after it 'succeeded' before passing out- remember with Kevi that the change was almost instant so in theory Caleb would be the same
i also wanna add that i believe calebs pain and subsequent passing out in that ch are due to the attack earlier not the removal of his memories. they were trying to destroy the chip for some reason and it was going haywire cause of it (maybe just his anger in general of us potentially getting caught in the crossfire getting too out of hand causing the rewrite program to try and start?)
Plus im sure that fending off the rewrite takes a LOT of effort on his part
theres an argument to be made that its not a dream and just caleb potentially pretending to have amnesia, there are hints during the amusement park that that version of him knows something- outright mentioning the chip when you collapse is the biggest ofc
But i feel like theres no reason for him to pretend, especially for as long as he did before MC collapses. Idk how much I believe this idea honestly I feel like itd still be more likely that he had actual amnesia, his memories started coming back, but he kept playing along cause shes having fun, than for him to pretend from the start
but i think its all a dream
not only are things called a dream twice, but the world ending is also mentioned multiple times as well and i think thats her subconsciously knowing this ideal time with him wont last
The world is the dream itself with the caleb she misses and has been in love with
The fleet showing up is reality/her waking up
She doesn't want to accept reality so she tries to run and keep the illusion going even for a moment longer
She knows the Caleb she grew up with is gone, that the one before her is a different person now
Shes struggling to fully come to terms with this, its why she jumps at the chance to gaslight an amnesiac caleb in her dream to relive the past for even a short period of time
Another important detail that i think everyone misses is the fact that its fairly obvious when we drag the collapsed caleb back home we take him to his room, but when we 'wake up' after the vine dream we are in our own room
After caleb collapses ontop of us after the chip attempts to wipe his memories, you can see that MCs eyes blink a little before it fades to black and the vine dream starts, so we obviously pass out there too
I don't think she wouldve gotten up in the middle of the night and left his side on her own- i mean she reaches out for him as soon as shes awake and bolts out looking for him when hes not there. She still thinks shes in his bed with him
But would an amnesiac caleb (dream or irl) take the time to move the unknown sleeping girl beside him into another room? That doesnt feel likely to me ngl. He mentions she was next to him when he woke up, but youd think he mention moving her too if that were the case
Maybe if its Caleb pretending I could see that happen, but like I said prior idk if I believe that he'd pretend
And infold very much wouldn't make such a mistake when it comes to backgrounds especially in a Myth where every detail seems to be important- its an intention decision to have MC wake up in her own bed and not Calebs. I think from that moment on is her dreaming
And going back to an earlier screenshot once more real quick
I personally think Caleb mentioning the chip at the very end of the amusement park right before MC passes out could be the dream blurring with reality as the fleet is closing in and shes waking up
That line is spoken by IRL caleb as he finds her passed out with the red mark of the chip on her arm potentially trying to activate and he rushes her to the base to get it dissolved where she finally wakes up in reality
The one thing im still not fully sure about is her potential memory loss as a result of the chip dissolving, while still remembering the dream. She very obviously doesn't remember how Caleb got the bite on his hand when she very much would have been awake in reality during that sequence which shows she did lose something (she even alludes to that herself)
Could dreams not count as actual memories that would be affected? Did she perhaps struggle so hard against the chip in the dream that it was basically protected?? Maybe it really was just simply a partial memory loss and it just didnt reach her dreams???
And we can't forget the line "Dreams are meant to be dreams" near the end either! And the comparison of those 3 days with amnesia Caleb to the vine dream. Those days didn't happen in reality and they must die alongside the version of Caleb she used to know, no matter how painful it might be
in short- Lucid Dreams is about MC struggling to accept the reality that the Caleb she grew up with and loved is gone. That the person she now knows today is someone so different, with so many secrets that she struggles to see him as the same person
She injects the chip in attempt to be closer to him- to be trusted to know more about him again and be by his side in a desperate attempt to cling at the best friend she knew like the back of her hand
The fear of him losing his memories like Kevi- that he might lose ALL his memories from their lives together was so intense caused the chip to start to activate that night and she had the amusement park dream. Clinging to what little of the past she still can, convincing herself itll be fine they can still be together like before
But you can't escape reality for long, and she has to accept the new Caleb in front of her. That dream and the Caleb of the past must stay in the past. Now she has to get to know him once more, and re-fall in love with the man shes been in denial of her feelings for for so long
And yea. I dont know how else to end off this silly analysis I did but thanks for coming to my ted talk!
i personally dont subscribe to the whole "Caleb could lose his memory with intense emotions" hc but everyone has their own interpretations and its not like im not against it either!
heck i could be very wrong in every aspect of my take