Thank you for being so open-minded and willing to hear both sides. It has been a cat fight, and I’ve recently tried to stay out of it. But the falsehoods being spread about Hayley have sort of prompted me to get back involved. It’s really sad that so much hate is directed at her and so many lies are being spread about her for 1) making Peggy popular and 2) daring to say that she didn’t like a ship that most people also didn’t care for.
If you want her real, undistorted take on things, I’d check out her Philly Wizard World Interview. She gave it right after CW came out and it covers how she likes Sharon, but not Staron. It’s also just a fun watch because she and Dominic Cooper are such good friends. And here and here are some links about what she’s actually said in full about other things, so you can read them without her being misconstrued or misquoted out of spite.
As to comics, I got rid a lot of old ones that I no longer read or like, so I don’t have issue numbers but I can tell you what storylines turned me off Sharon. Firstly, her origins.
(Tales of Suspense #75-#80 I think) Sharon and Peggy are originally sisters, and it’s made very clear that Steve is only interested in Sharon because she looks like his lost love Peggy. But a version of her that is nearer his age, since Peggy got older while he was in the ice. Peggy, who is very different in the comics, is very fragile because she was mentally abused. She’s still in love with Cap, and Sharon essentially bullies Peggy into accepting her relationship with Cap. It’s by and large what Sharon will always be to me: a woman who chose a man over the wellbeing of her sister.
Then there is Civil War in which Sharon shots Steve. She’s brainwashed at the time yes, but I think you’ll find upon reading that even with that she is still complicit. There’s also her PTSD storyline which is clearly meant to be a redemptive arch for Sharon. The problem is that it’s insulting to assume that giving her such an emotionally devastating disease (I live with a former soldier who has it. I am qualified to speak about it) doesn’t make her more likable simply because she has the illness. It just means she’s a cruel person, who is also mentally unwell.
I’d also take a look at the new Ironman comics. From her position of white privilege and power she accused a young black girl of being a “big hydra fan” and “declaring herself queen of Lateria.”
If you pick up any of these, I think you’ll see why Sharon is a character that is widely disliked and why it also goes above and beyond her time in the MCU.
If you are looking for some female characters worth loving, may I recommend Shutter, any Wonder Woman by Greg Rucka, and Promethea (Alan Moore gets preachy about magic in it, but she’s such a cool character and it’s such an interesting story, it’s easy to get passed.)
Thank you again for your sincere openness. Best of luck to you and if you do have time to read any of the above, please drop me a line and let me know what you thought!