In This Life and The Next Pt. 2 | J.P.
You have finally found each other again—after time was rewritten, after fate tore you apart and left only memories in its wake. But the world does not make it easy. You are twenty years younger than James. His friends do not understand. And worse—he does not know the truth of what you have become.
(Ask and ye shall receive!!! Part 2 of In This Life and The Next. You can read the first part here)
𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘
You are twenty years younger than him. The world does not let you forget it.
The ones who love James do not let him forget it, either.
Sirius is the first to confront him. "This is a joke, right?" he says, but there’s no humor in his voice. "You? In love? Since when?"
James’ jaw tightens. "Since now."
Sirius scoffs, shaking his head. "No. No, you don’t get to say that like it makes sense. You—James Potter—have never truly been in love. Never. Not once. And now you expect me to believe that after all these years, after everything, you suddenly are? And with her?" He gestures sharply. "She’s a kid, James. A friend of Harry’s. You’re supposed to be an Auror, not some lovesick fool chasing after something that shouldn’t even be a thought."
James exhales sharply, his patience thinning. If only they knew. If only they could remember. He has spent years, a lifetime, wandering through a world without you. He remembers what it felt like to live with the absence of you, to search for something that no longer existed. And now, now that he has you again, they expect him to simply let it go?
"She’s not a kid. She’s a grown woman who knows what she wants. And so do I."
Remus folds his arms, his expression unreadable but his words measured. "It’s not just the age gap, James. It’s you. You’ve never done this before. You’ve never cared like this. How do you know it’s real? How do you know you’re not just grasping at something because it’s there? Because she looks at you like you matter?"
James clenches his fists, nails digging into his palms. They don’t understand. How could they? In their minds, he has always been the same James Potter—the reckless one, the unshakable one, the man who never let his heart rule him. They have no memory of the weight he has carried, the loss that haunted him in another life. If they did, they would not question him now.
James swallows down the words that threaten to spill, the truth clawing at his throat. If only they knew. If only they could remember. He has spent a lifetime without you already—a life that felt hollow, incomplete. And now, faced with their skepticism, he cannot tell them. He cannot let them know the weight he carries, the second chance he has been given. So instead, he clenches his fists and exhales sharply. "I know exactly what this means. I wouldn’t be here if I didn’t."
Lily’s voice is calm, but there’s something sharp in her eyes. "James, I believe that you believe that. But you’ve never had to navigate love before. You don’t know what it’s like to build something with another person, to make compromises, to think about what the future actually looks like with them. She’s still figuring herself out. And whether or not you mean to, you have all the power in this. That’s what scares us."
Power. James swallows. He knows it’s true. He is older, more experienced, established in his life while yours is just beginning. But it does not change the fact that he knows you. That he has known you beyond what time would allow them to comprehend. If only they remembered—if only they could recall what it had been like when you were all equals, standing together in a life now lost.
Sirius lets out a hollow laugh. "And what? You think you’re going to settle down? Get married? Have kids? Since when have you ever wanted that, James? You’ve never cared about things like this before. And now you expect us to believe that’s changed? That you even know what you're doing?"
James stares at them, heart pounding. He has never known love like this before, true, but not because he was incapable of it. It had simply never found him—until you. Until fate twisted its cruel hand and gave him a second chance that no one else in this room could begin to fathom.
Then, Harry speaks. "It’s weird," he admits, rubbing the back of his neck. "Really weird." He looks James in the eye. "But I trust you. And I trust her. And if this is what you both want, then I won’t stand in your way."
Sirius throws up his hands in frustration, but Remus only sighs. The argument does not end cleanly. It lingers, unspoken, in the spaces between their words, in the way James feels their stares long after they leave the room.
𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘
Time passes in stolen moments.
James doesn’t talk about the argument, but he feels its weight in the way his friends look at him, in the silence that lingers whenever your name comes up. He should care more. Maybe, once, he would have. But then you arrive at his doorstep, eyes alight with something he can’t name, and none of it matters.
You fill his space with laughter, with warmth, with something he’s never had before. The best days are the ones where you curl up beside him on his sofa, your presence so natural it’s as if you’ve always belonged there. He memorizes every detail—the way your fingers trace patterns against his wrist, the way your smile softens when you think no one is looking. But there is something else, too. A shadow behind your gaze, a hesitation when you think he isn’t paying attention.
James notices.
He tells himself he won’t push, that you’ll tell him when you’re ready. But the unease festers. It builds in the quiet spaces between your visits, in the way you linger at the door as if there’s something you want to say but can’t. He wants to believe that whatever is haunting you will pass, that you will let him in.
But the days slip through his fingers like sand, and James cannot shake the feeling that something is slipping away before he’s even had the chance to hold it.
𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘
The room is suffocating.
The air is thick with the scent of burning wax and damp stone, the flickering torch light casting shadows that stretch unnaturally across the walls. Hooded figures stand in a circle, their silent presence more terrifying than words could ever be. You kneel at the center of it all, the cold seeping into your bones, your heartbeat a frantic drum in your chest.
And then, the searing pain.
It spreads like fire, like something crawling beneath your skin, binding itself to you in ways you cannot undo. Your breath catches, but you do not scream. You will not give them the satisfaction. This was forced upon you, but you will not break. You refuse.
When it is done, when the brand is settled and the pain turns from burning to aching, you dare to lift your gaze. And that’s when you see him.
Evan Rosier.
His grip tightens around your wrist—not harsh, but firm, grounding. His eyes, sharp and searching, flicker with something close to disbelief. "I didn’t think you’d go this way," he murmurs, his voice low, controlled, but you can hear the crack beneath it. This isn’t just surprise—it’s something deeper, something dangerously close to betrayal.
You search his face, the one so familiar and yet so different from the boy you once knew in another lifetime. He doesn’t remember. He never could. And yet—
"Neither did I," you say, and the words are both a lie and the closest thing to the truth.
A moment passes, stretched thin between you. The ceremony moves on without pause, the murmurs of approval from the surrounding figures fading into the background. But Evan does not move. His fingers tighten for just a second before loosening, before glancing over his shoulder as if ensuring no one is listening.
He exhales sharply. "Then I’ll protect you." A pause. A breath. "As much as I can."
It is not a promise, but it feels like one.
He knows as well as you do—safety is a fleeting thing in times like these. But in this moment, it is enough to believe in the lie.
𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘
You stand before Dumbledore, hands clasped tightly at your sides, the weight of what you are about to say pressing down on you like lead. You have rehearsed this moment, crafted every word with precision, but under his gaze, they threaten to crumble.
"I want to work for you," you say, voice steady despite the storm inside you. "As a spy."
Dumbledore does not move, does not react. His office, usually brimming with quiet magic, is unbearably still. The ticking of an ancient clock fills the silence between you.
"I was inducted tonight," you continue, forcing your voice to remain even. "The Dark Lord believes I am his. I can make use of that. I can get you information, give you insight no one else can."
Still, he says nothing. His silence is not judgment—it is something worse. Consideration.
"I know what this will take," you press on. "I know what will be asked of me, and I accept it. But if I do this, I need to know that you will use what I give you. That it won’t be wasted."
Finally, Dumbledore leans forward, interlacing his fingers. "Do you understand what you are offering?" His voice is quiet, measured, but there is something heavy beneath it. "What this will cost you?"
You exhale slowly. "I do. And I am still here."
For a long moment, he only watches you. Then, at last, he nods. It is not approval, nor is it relief. It is inevitable.
You close your eyes for just a second, the weight of his actions settling over you like a heavy cloak. And then, before you can stop yourself, you speak again. "Severus."
Dumbledore’s gaze sharpens slightly, though his expression remains unreadable.
"I know he walks the same path I do," you continue, your voice quieter now. "He may not say it, but I see it in the way he looks at me. He knows what I am doing. What I have to do. Because he’s doing it too, isn’t he?"
Dumbledore does not confirm. But he does not deny it either. And that is answer enough.
You exhale slowly. "He doesn’t want me there," you say, half to yourself. "He thinks I’ll make a mistake, that I don’t understand what I’ve gotten myself into. But I do. I know what this means. I know the cost." And that is answer enough.
"Severus is a man of many loyalties," he says at last. "As are you. It is best to remember that."
A beat of silence. Then another.
At last, Dumbledore exhales, closing his eyes for a brief moment. When he opens them again, there is no warmth, no reassurance. Only quiet resignation. "If you must walk this path," he says, voice laced with something almost sorrowful, "then walk it carefully."
The words settle over you like a heavy cloak, suffocating in their finality. He does not question. He does not argue. He accepts.
And somehow, that is worse.
𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘
James does not know. He cannot know.
You live two lives, separate yet inescapably intertwined. In Hogsmeade, you let James hold you, let his hands linger as if they can keep you here, grounded in the warmth of The Three Broomsticks and stolen moments. But you are never truly present. Because when you are not with him, you are somewhere else entirely.
Hogwarts is your sanctuary. The Vanishing Cabinet is your escape.
In the dead of night, you slip through its doors, stepping from the stone corridors of the castle into the heart of a war no one suspects you fight. On the other side, Evan is waiting. The others are waiting. And you play your role as if it is the only thing keeping you alive.
Evan Rosier is your tether to yourself, though neither of you speak of it. He walks beside you in the dark, his wand always the first to strike, his magic landing before yours can hesitate. He makes sure your hands remain clean, though you both know that blood clings to you anyway.
Snape sees it too. He watches you from the edges, his dark gaze knowing, waiting.
"Rosier cannot protect you forever," he murmurs one evening, his words measured, precise. "The Dark Lord will want proof. And when that moment comes, no one else will be able to take your place."
You say nothing, but Snape does not need your answer. He already knows the truth. So do you.
And yet, Evan does not falter. When a man kneels before you, pleading, it is Evan who moves first. When the Dark Lord calls your name, it is Evan who steps forward, ensuring his curse lands before yours can. He does not speak of it later. He does not need to. You both understand what is left unsaid.
One night, after another mission where he has taken the worst of it, Evan exhales sharply, shaking his head. "You need to start playing the part," he murmurs. "I can’t keep doing this forever."
You meet his gaze, searching. "Then why do you?"
He hesitates, something unspoken lingering between you. Then, slowly, he reaches up, brushing a strand of hair from your face. His touch is careful, deliberate.
"Because someone has to."
The lie between you is thin, stretched too tight. One day, it will snap.
James is beginning to notice the cracks. His hands linger just a little too long when he holds yours. His fingers brush against your wrist absentmindedly, so close to the mark hidden beneath your sleeve. His eyes linger when you speak, as if memorizing, as if searching for something he can no longer name.
"Are you happy?" he asks once, quiet, uncertain.
You smile, effortless and hollow. "Of course I am."
James presses a kiss to your forehead, his arms wrapping around you like a shield. But even he cannot protect you from this.
The war is closing in. And you are running out of time.
Your life is an illusion, carefully constructed and meticulously upheld. The Dark Mark still burns on your skin, a phantom weight, a silent promise. You tell yourself it is necessary. That deception is survival. But Evan knows better.
He watches you, always. His eyes find you in the firelight, filled with something unspoken. Not pity. Not quite. Something heavier. Protective.
One evening, when the weight of it presses too hard against your ribs, you find yourself standing before Dumbledore, Snape at his side. The room is dim, candlelight flickering over stacks of parchment and maps of battle lines drawn in ink. You do not sit. You do not need to.
"They’re moving against the Ministry," you say, voice quieter than it should be. "Not now, but soon. It will be sudden. They expect the Aurors to be too scattered to react."
Dumbledore steeples his fingers, his expression unreadable. "Do you know when?"
You shake your head. "Not yet. But we'll find out."
Snape exhales through his nose, his gaze sharp as he studies you. "You risk too much."
"So do you."
A pause stretches between you, weighted with something neither of you will name.
Dumbledore nods, his voice softer now. "You have done well. But be careful. If they begin to suspect..."
"They won’t." You force the words out. "They can’t."
And then, because you cannot linger, because you cannot allow yourself to feel safe, you turn and leave, the door closing behind you like the snap of a trap.
Later that night, Evan finds you by the fire. He doesn’t speak when you sit beside him, doesn’t ask you to explain the tension in your shoulders or the way your hands shake. He only leans back, silent, waiting.
"The Dark Lord won’t look away forever," Evan finally says. "I can’t keep stepping in. Sooner or later, you’ll have to do it yourself."
You swallow hard. "I know."
Evan studies you for a long moment, then exhales. "You’re not ready."
It isn’t an accusation. It’s the truth.
For a fleeting second, you think of another life, another Evan—one who did not survive the first war. You wonder if, somehow, some part of him remembers. If that is why he looks at you this way. Why he refuses to let you fall.
"I’ll be ready when I have to be," you say, though the words taste like ash.
Evan exhales. "I’ll make sure of it."
The promise is unspoken, but it is there.
You step through the Vanishing Cabinet in the dead of night, slipping between realities, moving from student to soldier, from Hogwarts to the Dark Lord’s side, from safety to war.
And then, you return. Your uniform crisp, your books neatly stacked, your hands steady as they turn pages in the library. No one suspects.
No one except James.
He does not know what, not yet, but he knows something is wrong. And James Potter has never been one to ignore a mystery.
"You disappear sometimes," he says one day, fingers brushing yours over the table in The Three Broomsticks. "I send letters, and you don’t answer. Where do you go?"
You smile, tilting your head in playful amusement. "You make me sound far more interesting than I actually am."
But James only watches you, gaze unwavering. "You’ve always been interesting. But now, you’re hiding something."
You lift his hand, pressing a kiss to his knuckles, as if that will be enough to make him forget. "Don’t be silly, James. I’m exactly where I should be."
For now.
But even the best illusions eventually unravel. And James has always been too sharp not to see the cracks.
The war does not wait for love. And soon, there will be nothing left to hide behind.
𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘
James Potter has been hunting them for weeks.
A high-profile case—one that has consumed his every waking moment, led by whispers and half-truths, tracking the movements of Death Eaters embedded deep within the Dark Lord’s ranks. It has been long hours, sleepless nights, strategy meetings with the Order, every piece of information bringing him closer to tonight.
This was meant to be a takedown. A decisive blow.
Instead, it becomes something else entirely.
The battle is chaos.
Spells collide midair, flashes of green and red illuminating the vast, shadowed hall. The sounds of dueling wizards, the crackling energy of magic tearing through walls, the heavy weight of destruction—it is almost too much. The air is thick with smoke, dust rising from shattered stone, the metallic scent of blood lingering at the edges of his senses.
And then, he sees you.
It is a moment frozen in time.
His expression is unreadable at first—shock, disbelief, a refusal to accept what he is seeing. Your mask does not hide you from him. Nothing ever could.
You do not falter. You do not stop. You throw yourself into the fray, fighting with the others, knowing you must play your part. But James does not look away. He weaves through the battlefield, ignoring the shouts of his allies, dodging spells with reckless abandon, eyes locked onto you.
“James! Focus!” someone shouts, but he doesn’t hear them.
He is coming toward you, wand raised—not to kill, but to reach you. And you cannot let that happen.
You twist away, hurling spells in every direction, striking down just enough enemies to maintain your cover while ensuring the Order is not overwhelmed. You aim just off-center, just wide enough to miss vital points, just close enough that no one questions your loyalty.
But James—James does not stop. He pushes forward, breaking through the fight as if nothing else matters. His allies call his name, but he is deaf to them. He is moving toward you with single-minded determination, and in his distraction, he does not see it.
The spell streaks toward him, bright and deadly.
Your body moves before your mind catches up.
A curse leaves your wand, striking him—hard enough to throw him to the ground, hard enough to make it seem real, but just enough to keep him alive.
Pain flickers across his face as he crumples, his hand instinctively clutching at the wound. His eyes find yours, searching, questioning, but you do not let yourself linger.
Evan is there in an instant. A flick of his wrist. A flash of green. The only other witness collapses lifeless to the floor.
“You have to leave,” Evan says, his voice low but firm. “Now. Before they suspect.”
You hesitate, just for a second, but James is still watching you, dazed, confused, betrayed.
You turn away.
You disappear with the others, leaving James behind, wounded but alive.
𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘
Later, in the quiet of the safe house, Evan finds you.
He does not speak at first. He watches you, eyes darker than usual, his usual smirk absent.
“You saved him.”
It is not a question. It is not an accusation.
You exhale. “I had to.”
He nods slowly, the weight of understanding settling between you. “Your secret is safe with me.”
Relief floods through you. Evan has always been pragmatic, but this—this is trust. Not blind, not naive, but deliberate.
“I don’t care what side you’re on,” he continues. “But you need to be more careful. There are too many eyes watching.”
You know he is right. You have made your choice, and there is no returning to Hogwarts now. The illusion is shattered.
You step forward, hesitating only a moment before wrapping your arms around him. It is not desperate, not a plea—just gratitude. He stiffens for half a second before exhaling, his hands settling lightly against your back. It is almost familiar, almost like before, almost like the past life he does not remember.
Almost.
𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘 𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚𓆚 𓆘
James wakes to whispers.
He is recovering, the ache of the battle still fresh in his bones, but the worst wound is not the one left by your spell. It is the one in his chest, the one carved by the sight of you standing among them.
“She made her choice,” they tell him. “You have to let her go.”
The words scrape against something raw inside him. He doesn’t respond. Doesn’t argue. He simply stares at the ceiling, replaying it over and over—the way you moved, the way you fought, the moment your wand turned against him.
He should let you go.
He should. He knows he should.
But then Harry steps forward, quiet and sure, and says, “She’s never loved anyone like she loves you. There must be a reason.”
James turns his head, studies his godson, the quiet confidence in his stance. There is no hesitation in Harry’s voice. No doubt. Just conviction, clear as day.
James exhales, the weight in his chest unbearable. “She—” His voice falters, cracks under the weight of it. “She looked at me, Harry. And then she still walked away.”
Harry’s gaze doesn’t waver. “Maybe she had to.”
James closes his eyes. There is a war in his head, clashing between logic and feeling, between what he knows and what he refuses to accept. The others have already made up their minds. Sirius, Remus, Lily—they tell him it’s over. That she has made her choice. That he has to move forward.
James is not sure he knows how.
“She wouldn’t have done it unless she had no other choice,” Harry says. “You know that. You know her.”
James presses his hands to his face, inhaling shakily. It should be simple. Black and white. Enemy and ally. Betrayal and loyalty. But nothing about this has ever been simple.
When he speaks again, his voice is raw, a quiet promise forged in something far stronger than certainty.
“We must find her.”
Harry nods.
They will find you.
They will bring you back.










