Comparative analysis on Gender Performance
In my comparative analysis, I will be looking at the presentation of women in the following 3 music videos; âBad Bloodâ by Taylor Swift, âRun the Worldâ by BeyoncĂ© and âWorth Itâ by Fifth Harmony. Gender is a phenomenon that has been reproduced over time. Some would argue that we are born with a biological identity, however the culture we inhabit determines how we âperformâ gender. The media is a powerful element in the construction of gender roles in most societies, and these videos in particular all stand up for feminism and women empowerment. Taylor Swiftâs Bad Blood music video talks about the empowerment of women; they can be soldiers and play with weapons as well, it doesnât just have to be men as that is a cultural stereotype. BeyoncĂ©âs music video sends an unapologetically aggressive message promoting female empowerment and gives women strength to be confident in themselves. An example of this, is the use of the lyrics "smart enough to make these millions, strong enough to bear the children, then get back to business," which indicate that women are intelligent and deserve a good education in order to show our strength and independence. In Fifth Harmonyâs video, all of the female singers play a high class role, and in one occasion one of the girls is sitting on a table at her desk, with a male counterpart acting as her personal assistant in the background, which is normally stereotyped to be the female role. However in this case, they have reversed the typical roles of male and female, showing again that women are entitled to be in charge.
These videos also explore the idea of following our dreams, believing in ourselves and not letting gender get in the way of our true potential. BeyoncĂ©âs video is loud and proud in its relentless message, which is shown when she is clearly rallying the troops to her side, indicating that women are capable of leading and men do not always have to be in charge. In Taylorâs video, the character she and many other women play varies from the role of a soldier, boxer, a spy, a robot, killers, as well as riding motorbikes. This represents them as strong, fierce, clever and brave women, doing activities that men would stereotypically be assigned to do, but who says women canât do these things too? Similar to BeyoncĂ©âs video, Taylor has many females by her side and acts as the head officer as she too leads her troops against the enemy. They are walking through the visual effects of fire, which shows that these women are indestructible and nothing will stop them. In Fifth Harmonyâs video, one of the girls sing âIf you donât have a clue, Iâll tell you what to do,â which shows her authority and confidence within herself. The girls are staged in a group formation, coming together to show their dominance as women. Instead of the stereotype of women fighting or becoming bitchy with one another, the video encourages women to empower and support one another.
The three videos bring up a lot of stereotypes about gender. The role of women is stereotyped by society as being quiet, innocent or fragile, and to typically wear dresses, cook and do the housework, be submissive, look after babies, not being as strong or as smart as men and not being in charge. Most of the time, these videos show women doing the exact opposite to the typical female stereotypes. However in BeyoncĂ©âs video clip they are fulfilling the stereotype of women as flirts, when she sings âmy persuasion can build a nationâ and her flirtatious behaviour is supported through costume such as her cut out black dress or the lingerie she wears. In Taylorâs video the costumes that are used are very revealing with tight clothing which shows their feminine features even though they are playing the role of males. This video also fulfils the stereotype of women as always looking pretty and presentable, as all of the characters have perfect hair and makeup. This is also reflected in Fifth Harmonyâs video where every member is done up with flawless hair and makeup, as well as their cleavage showing through their outfits. The stereotype that women love to sing and dance is specifically shown as the girls have a choreographed dance routine throughout this music video.
Together, these videos inspire the audience to dare to live our dreamsâ be want we want to be, despite gender stereotypes. They show us that women are smart enough and strong enough to break any stereotypes, no matter what obstacles that get in our way. Gender determinants can change and we play a vital role as future explorers and inventors.
Links to the videos can be found below:
âBad Bloodâ by Taylor Swift - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcIy9NiNbmo
âRun the Worldâ by BeyoncĂ© - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBmMU_iwe6U Â
âWorth Itâ by Fifth Harmony - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBHQbu5rbdQ