Lady Gaga - Joanne Review
Lady Gaga has just released her new album Joanne. I’m not a huge Lady Gaga fan, but I do consider her to be someone who is musically adept and I respect her as a person since I can support the message she was always trying to convey early in her career. I never listened to anything by Lady Gaga excluding her hit songs like Poker Face, Bad Romance, and the other hits she had, so I decided to give this album a go and see what makes it good, what makes it bad, and if anything makes it ugly.
Joanne starts with the song Diamond Heart and right off the bat there is a clear Rock N’ Roll influence driving this song, and potentially this album. The melody in Diamond Heart was catchy, it opened up in the chorus, and it was cool to hear a fusion of Pop and Rock music. I only wished that the chorus had something added to it to make it much more impactful. The whole time I was just wishing the song would be bigger in the chorus, so it could really set up the album in a good way. Nonetheless, Joanne continues with A-Yo which continued the Rock influence and felt like a good continuation for Diamond Heart, almost as if Lady Gaga decided to open a concert set with Diamond Heart, it felt like A-Yo would be the second song in the set. A-Yo has a cool Twangy guitar and gave me a sort of Blue’s Brothers kind of vibe or something along the lines of that.
We then hit the song Joanne which brings the album to a halt. Joanne is a much slower paced song and much more organic in instrumentation compared to the first two songs that are heard. Granted the only synthesized sound is some strings in Joanne, but my one problem was that I wished this song wasn’t put so early, I wanted the energy to keep going. Gaga continues her album with John Wayne. John Wayne was cool to listen to since I constantly felt like there was this sexual tension that Gaga was clearly able to perform musically, but never relieved and brought it to a climax during the choruses. Similar to something I said in my review of Glory by Britney Spears (which you can find http://jofishh.tumblr.com/post/149674309006/britney-spears-glory-review) it’s like being ready to climax, but never quite getting there and always being let down. Also, is John Wayne slang for something is Lady Gaga just really into the actor? Whatever, I digress.
The next, Dancin’ In Circles, brings a latin feel to the album. This song had a really good latin feel, but I had two main issues with it. One, the chorus was just not fun enough for me to feel like I wanted to dance to it and two, while I enjoy contrast between songs in albums like this, when the first three out of four songs are very clearly influenced by early Rock and you decide to almost randomly plop a latin style song it becomes very inconsistent to listen to. But Lady Gaga rounds off the first half of Joanne with her single Perfect Illusion. I wrote an entire Review on Perfect Illusion (which is right http://jofishh.tumblr.com/post/150561169036/lady-gaga-perfect-illusion-review) so I won’t say much else about it, but I will say that I do take back my thoughts on the fact that the vocals sounded very over compressed. Most likely what I heard was a bad thing on Youtube where they compress the audio since Youtube streams everything.
The second half of Joanne starts off with a ballad type of song called Million Reasons. I have to say both subjectively and objectively I felt like this was one of the best songs off the entire album. Gaga’s vocal work really shines in this song and I felt the song built itself nicely while allowing Gaga to shine. The only thing I wished that changed was if there was some sort of break to make the final chorus much more impactful to listen to.
We then hear Sinner’s Prayer which just feels like a type of western song. There was a strange thing in Sinner’s Prayer where Gaga decides to just hop right into the chorus from the verse without some sort of break or lead in which was a little jarring to listen to. I did also hear some fairly over compressed vocals in this song which ruins the quality of the vocal work, but the theme of the song and the music fit each other perfectly.
The next song was Come To Mama, which I have to say sounded way too much like Rihanna’s Stay at the beginning, but then quickly turned into this song that came out of the 50s. Gaga then does a fantastic duet with Florence Welch in, what I feel is the second best song on the album, Hey Girl. Hey Girl definitely takes a jump from Come To Mama by being a little more 80s inspired instead. But Lady Gaga did this song and Florence Welch justice by allowing Welch to really shine in this song and sing in most of it rather than only giving her one verse and a background vocal part for the chorus.
Joanne is then rounded off with the song Angel Down. Angel Down is a slow song that is similar in nature to Million Reasons except with a little bit more of a serious tone that is almost lamenting in nature. While it was nice to hear I did have problems with it. First off, there was a strange abrupt ending that I heard, but I can potentially shrug it off since I listened to this album on Spotify and most likely Spotify cuts off a few seconds from the original recording. Also, the ending decided to have some vinyl sound effects as if I was hearing this album on a vinyl record, but one I’m not and two if you’re going to end the album like that, why didn’t you start it with the vinyl sound effects it would’ve made a cool roundabout way of finishing the album. Finally, Angel Down for some reason is very organic and then has very clearly synthesized string sounds. While I think synth strings can be cool to listen to, especially when utilized properly, this was a time where I sat here wondering why Gaga’s record company didn’t hire some string players to play the parts instead of using what sounds like a temp track.
Overall, I consider Lady Gaga to be a very adept musician who knows what she’s doing with songwriting and would put thought into what she writes, so I tend to expect more from her than other pop stars. Right off the bat i will say, there is no album coherence what so ever, there could’ve been something done lyrically that told me some sort of story, or the music could have been put it an order that felt like an experience to listen to, but instead I felt like I listened to a new collection of Lady Gaga songs that you can put on shuffle and enjoy with the rest of Gaga’s collections of songs. Even though I took back what I said about over compressed vocals in Perfect Illusion, I still heard that mistake in other songs like Sinner’s Prayer and John Wayne. And while I enjoyed the Rock elements of the first half (excluding Dancin’ in Circles) and the variety of the second half, I wanted one of these two things to be consistent. Gaga should have been straight Rock influence in all her songs, or created extreme variety in every song, or at least change the order so the songs that are all Rock influenced could be spread out a little.
After all this I will say on a subjective level I did enjoy and had fun listening to some of the songs on this album. I loved the latin feel of Dancin’ in Circles, I thought Diamond Heart had a really catchy and fun chorus even though it could have been bigger, and I still think Million Reasons is Gaga’s chance to shine as a vocalist. So, if you’re a Lady Gaga fan and have been waiting for this album go pick it up and enjoy some of the fun songs, but if you’re looking for a pop star that decided to put some substance and thought into song order or style consistency/variation then I wouldn’t go for it. Overall I felt Joanne wasn’t awful, but it had enough minor issues to not make it great. It’s like when get just enough points deducted on a test to get like a B- even though most of the questions were mostly correct. But I digress, check out Lady Gaga’s new album Joanne if you would like, that’s my review take it or leave it.