2. Amd you don't think he took the body to Amity because...
3. If it was magic, then when Pennt aura go? When Fyra pass the power you can see her aura and it the same color, somthing has going on there when Penny pass the power
4. Never sais it has to be Pietro aura to make Penny, they have diffrente personalities dispits having the same aura
6. The heroes can't get the staff back?
7. We didn't saw it and even if, in the SAME episode we saw that Penny aura is green when Cinder try to take her power, and it was change to gold because there is somthing that we don't see
8. Why wouldn't they? Did you forgot that one of the motive of the show is "Fight for every life" if there is a chance to bring Penny back the heroes will do it!
9. Nope! It was just Penny, every scream was in differente tone, we litteraly got the script that showed us she heard only Penny
10. No, there wasn't a portal next to them and how is that importent to what I said?
11. And so is the Ever After, but the rules there is different
1 and 5 didn't need an answer
I give a reason to why the human body doesn't matter as Penny can come back from that, or how she can die permently in the show
I'll admit that I didn't like for a second that Jaune killed Penny and it defently felt like the writers are just trying to shove him into the story, but looking back, giving Penny tells him there is somthing he can do (with empesis on him), telling him trust her on somthing (which eventually followed by silence in which we didn't hear what she tell him after the "trust me"), and the fact that it was HIS aura that we see when she transfer the power (and reminde you his power is Aura Boosting) she defently did somthing with his aura and the maiden power
So either she's inside of Winter which will be find in V10 or she's in the sword, or she's inside or Ruby (the voice in the head and the fact that Ruby was drawn to Penny sword despite in being hidden amd Ruby saying that she don't know why) or (and yes for now it look debunk) she was turn into Little/Somewhat (that one is less likely now but giving that the heroes are returning to the ever after it might be true)
There are a lot of ways for Penny to returne because her death amd everything after is revolve around magic, magic that even Ozpin doesn't know a lot about
Last one before I turn off anonymous because you need to just continue through reblog.
YES! They are literal fugitives at this point! HE WOULDN'T HAVE TIME TO GRAB A SEPARE BODY! IF ONE EVEN WAS AROUND! YOU KNOW VOLUME 8 WAS THREE DAYS WITH THEM AS CRIMALS IN ATLAS AND MANTLE FILLED WITH GRIMM! THERE WAS NO FUCKING TIME FOR HIM TO GRAB ANYTHING!
TO THE FUCKING AFTERLIFE! SHE DIED!
AND WITHOUT PENNY'S CORE IT WON'T BE PENNY
Just realized caplock was still on. Anyway, They can't even beat Cinder. Do you really think that can go through an army of grimm and snatch the staff from Salem who is most likely either keeping it with her at all times or putting in a vault after what happened with the lamp? Salem would killed three of them and turn Ruby into the next hound. THINK ANON! THINK!
Because when Cinder takes Powers from someone She is taking your literal soul that gets destroyed by the grimm and fills out the maiden powers. SHE IS DOING WHAT THE ATM DOES!
AND DID YOU LEARN NOTHING FROM SALEM'S BACKSTORY!? Plus, They are fighting for evey life trying to stop Salem. There is a war going on and the bad guys are fucking winning. Trying to bring back one person that is already dead is counterproductive!
You are wrong.
Did you not see the dozens of portals surrounding them in the background? The portal right behind Winter as she floated up in the air? Clearly you aren't watching the show or paying attention.
THE BLACKSMITH/TREE HAS SAID THEMSELVES THEY CAN'T DO ANYTHING TO ANYONE THAT ISN'T ABSORD BY THE TREE BEFORE DEATH! PENNY WAS ALREADY DEAD!
It does matter because even reason you have given is either stretching way out of possibilities of common sense or going into fan fic territory.
That we agree on with Jaune but You you really think Penny wasn't talking about killing her so Winter the better fighter than Cinder would get the powers and wipe the floor with the grimm armed bitch!. The girl didn't know hugs were warm until she was human! Penny know tech not aura or magic! All she knows about the Maiden powers is what we know. This is literally the scene two episodes before it where she tells Ruby to kill her so she can make Ruby the New winter maiden, WHICH ACTUALLY WOULD HAVE BEEN PERFECT BECAUSE THEN WE COULD OF HAD PENNY COME BACK TO LIFE!
No She is not in WInter because you literally see her disappear when the powers are transferred. Possibly the sword, yes. Ruby is suffering from PTSD at this point and getting ready to break down as she saw her kill herself, so no. I did see the little/somewhat theory and thought "seriously? what the fuck?"
You have to face it. They killed Penny in a way that she is not coming back unless divine intervention happens and we all know the brothers and their mother feel about bringing back the dead, boys don't like it and mother has the 5 second on the floor rule and its been five years.
Edit: ALso why do you think Oz, the man from the time of magic and created the maiden powers and vaults doesn't know how magic works? Because I think you are confusing him not knowing if the atm will work with that as I have pointed out multiple times.
you saying that Anon is streching stuff to much yet you do the same in the oppisite way!
Who said that Pietro didn't already had a body in Amity? Who said that the heroes won't come back to bring Penny sword back? Who said that Penny didn't plan somthing when she pass the power to Winter?
Iv'e saw all your beef with Anon and it frustrating me how you try to shut him down by reason that was never comfiremd to be true!
Anything you said had no canon to back for!
No because I am using information that the show has given us to back up my claims.
For example, in volume 7 we saw that Pietro working on Penny is only done in the Atlas labs and not his own. In addition the same night Watts tryian Cinder attack and Salem's arrival all of them are declared criminals and arrested on site and seeing their first priority was to get the hell out of Atlas, which required stealing a ship they are not having time to grabs a heavy as heel robot body. This one is simple, time. They are defending the last kingdom of remnant from Salem so whatever the reason for them to go back to the ever after it won't be for Penny it will be to find something to help them fight Salem, you all keep forgetting there is a war going on. Now if they come across a Penny sword while they are there then yeah I can see them taking it. And lastly the plan WAS to pass the maiden powers to Winter. That's it. And to prove it Penny died thinking her aura and soul were artificially made. She doesn't know Pietro was using parts of his as she and Ironwood started in in volume 2 and 3.only Weiss and Ruby know her soul is part of Pietro's. Oh and Maria.
That said. I don't have beef with Anonymous. We both want Penny to return. I just want it to make sense with the information we have now.
And you clearly need to rewatch volume 7 8 and 9 because whenever I answered the questions I rewatched them to make sure so you need to refresh your memories.
True but she also said "I'll be part of you" and "trust me" to Jaune, it wasn't some apology, a call to action or some last goodbye. She had a plan.
And we will see it in V10
RWBY is defenitly the kind of show that make somthing that was metaphoricly to being litteral later
Penny was able to understand Ruby semblence and that Blake was a fanus, she had enough time to realise how the maiden power and Jaune aura works
Also the idea that they will come back to the ever after to stop salem is assumption, like with what anon saying, what resorce theh can find in the ever aftet that will help them defete salem?
Just because we saw Pieteo work in Atlas lab doesn't mean that it the only place he can work with, and in fact we he actually had another lab in Mantle that we saw in V7 when RWBY first met him
His not the only scientist in the world, who said he can't use another one lab, even if the resorces is low he knowes how to make a new body for Penny
I am 100% belive that Penny doesn't know that her aura is actually from her father and I'm sure that when she'll come back and find out about it after Pieteo sacrefice his last one for her
