REALISTIC RELATIONSHIP WITH CANON SIMON "GHOST" RILEY // Inconvenient details for fanfiction
It's been two years and I've somewhat forgotten what I wanted to write back then, but my opinion about Simon hasn't changed. So this is a follow-up to a post from two years ago!
The first two parts were about who Simon is not (not cuddly, not hypersexual, not a romantic fool) and how the military shapes daily life and hierarchy. Now — about what remains off-screen even in the most "realistic" fanfics. About boundaries no one discusses because they're uncomfortable, terrifying, or simply break the aesthetic of the "dangerous yet so tender man" that everyone absolutely adores
Spoiler: there's very little tenderness there, because Simon is truly BROKEN.
part one | part two | part three | part four
1. Being in a relationship with Simon Riley means you will never be on top.
Literally, of course, but most importantly — in bed.
It's not a joke, not fragile male ego, not "oh come on, let's try," not "maybe it'll be different with me."
It won't. Nothing will be different. He can not be bottom, can not submit, can not be pinned down, restrained, can not lose control of his body, even if he desperately wants to please you.
Because the last time he was held in such a position, he was being raped. He won't tell you that, of course. Probably never. Most likely you won't even suspect the details, or you'll learn them from his delirious rambling during a nightmare while you're trying to wake him up. He won't talk about it even then — maybe he'll just indicate that the fact of sexual assault happened.
Your task is to accept that whatever your preferences might be, only two positions will work in your bedroom — missionary and doggy.
2. Being in a relationship with Simon Riley means he won't say "I love you."
Maybe once or twice in a lifetime. And only after you prove you won't leave, even if he stays silent for years.
"I love you" are words that make something real. And real things can be lost. He's already lost everyone he loved. To say it out loud means admitting he has something to lose. He will rather show it through actions, often not the most obvious ones. That's his "I love you," and you need to learn to read that language, ideally even speak it.
And, on top of that, he doesn't know how to say "I love you" because no one taught him how since childhood.
3. Being in a relationship with Simon Riley means learning his empty silence.
Simon's usual silence means "I'm comfortable, there's just nothing to talk about."
And then there's the other kind.
When he stares at the wall and doesn't see it. When you call his name — zero reaction. He's not in the room. He's somewhere — in Roba's torture chamber, six feet under with a corpse, in the house with his family's dead bodies. At first, it's hard to tell the difference. But then you notice the horrifying emptiness in his eyes. It's important not to jostle him abruptly.
Any sudden movement can provoke Simon into aggression, which already lives in his subconscious, at the level of reflexes. And it's never directed at you personally, but at you as a sudden irritant. You need to sit next to him, never look him directly in the eyes, slowly touch his hand with yours, and call his name. And have a lot of patience to wait for him to return from there. Help him afterward, if needed, regulate his breathing, bring him something to drink.
4. Being in a relationship with Simon Riley means you don't hug him from behind.
Never. It's not cute. It's a trigger for him.
You hug him from behind — he breaks your nose with his elbow before his brain realizes it's you, that there's no one else in the room, and the arms behind him aren't some bastards but his partner. Then he'll apologize, very awkwardly, and he'll distance himself for a bit. But you'll learn not to do that. Just always approach from the front, let Simon see your hands. It's not difficult, and it means a lot to him.
5. Being in a relationship with Simon Riley means you accept that his body is not entirely his.
His left side — a solid scar from a burn. The skin is different, the sensitivity is different, sometimes it hurts for no reason. He doesn't like being touched there, not because he's ashamed, but because he believes your hands shouldn't touch that charred piece of meat. Sometimes he still smells his own burnt flesh.
You'll get used to not resting your hand on his left shoulder. Not tracing your fingers over the scars on his ribs. And if you accidentally do it anyway, it'll be more comfortable for him if you don't recoil when he flinches. Just removing your hand and continuing the conversation, or moving it somewhere else — that's the best option. He understands it's unavoidable in moments of intimacy and is forgiving about it, but it's especially valuable to him to know you won't deliberately do it in daily life.
6. Being in a relationship with Simon Riley means he will never be the "horny soldier" from your fantasies.
He has a low libido. Not zero, but such that sex is a pleasant bonus, not a vital necessity.
Most often he chooses to spend the evening without sex — it's not "I'm tired of you" or "I don't want you." He does want you. He adores you, but quality time with his partner is far more important to him than the opportunity to stick his dick somewhere.
And yes, I remind you — no horse cocks and no energy for three rounds in a row.
He's 35 at best, he gets tired, even though his endurance is excellently developed, his old wounds ache, and he's not a teenager who needs all of that commotion.
Simon has so many wounds and burns you can't count them. In my mind, half his body is burned, and such wounds, when located in the groin area, heavily affect a person's intimate life. Starting from simply pain during erection to the absence of that very erection. Even if we don't consider Simon being burned as part of canon — the take about fatigue and trauma still stands.
Those who write Simon as a lustful monster have never seen a real soldier/even just an ordinary cop after work, especially after a difficult operation. A real one lies down and sleeps for twelve hours straight, having removed all irritants from the house, because his body is at its limit. He has no time to fuck you until morning as the first order of business upon arrival.
7. Being in a relationship with Simon Riley means you give up hints.
He doesn't understand hints.
And not at all because he's stupid, but because there's too much noise in his head, chaos is audible, and every attempt to decipher yet another hint ends with him spiraling into anxiety and overthinking.
So if you need something, you say it directly, loudly, and clearly: "Hug me." "I'm sad, sit with me." "I want you right now."
Every time you speak directly, he exhales with relief because he doesn't have to guess where the catch is.
8. Being in a relationship with Simon Riley means you are the one who grounds him.
He has a nightmare — he doesn't cry when he wakes up. Rather, he doesn't sob — tears may fall on their own, he won't even notice. And he lies with open eyes, staring at the ceiling, touching his pulse on his wrist with the question "am I alive?" in his head.
If you wake up with him, it's important for him just to feel that you're there. To feel your warm palm on his trembling chest, right where his heart is, rather than hearing a million questions — "what happened? Are you okay?" You can (but do you need to?) talk about it in the morning, when the light scatters the darkness. For now, the darkness in his thoughts is dispelled by your touch.
Wow, the text turned out much longer than I expected, so I’ll post the final fourth part tomorrow and we’ll wrap up the analysis of Simon’s canonical behavior. Amen.