Kelley Reviews: Mama Mia: Here We Go Again!
Last night I went to see Mama Mia: Here we go again! I had low expectations but high hopes. I recently re-watched the original musical and was shocked by how bad the singing was. All but Meryl Streep and Amanda Seyfried were terrible! I mean, I get that theyād wanted big name actors but come on, at least have other people sing for them like in the first high school musical! I could go on and on but this isnāt a review of the first one, itās a review of the second.
Keeping that first movie in mind during my viewing I was pleasantly surprised. With many new cast members and a healthy spoonful of auto-tune, this movie was miles ahead of the first one. (Though a couple of the original cast members do get some solos that shouldnāt have been allowed to happen, but they were smallāI can forgive that). They improved the music but kept the same kitschy feel that the first one had without going too over the top. In other words it stayed on brand. The story itself had some great improvements with some more serious moments between the characters. Pay attention to what is said throughout, especially in the flashback scenes, thereās some important and easily missed foreshadowing that takes place.
Another plus of the movie is the whole past story that is interwoven with the present. The parallels are wonderful and the men who play the young versions of daughters dads are cast perfectly. Theyāre also not bad to look at.
While yes, there are some weird random plot things that happen, I almost feel that it could have been purposeful due to how many of those there are in movie number oneāthough I know they werenāt. Despite these things and the cheesiness, I would recommend seeing this movie. In the end there are some truly beautiful, touching moments between the characters that made me a little emotional, which surprised me. Itās a fun watch and thoroughly entertaining throughout!
Beware! This is the SPOILER part of the review!Ā
What I liked:Ā
As I said above, I liked the music! Overall I thought the new cast was decently talented enough, especially for a movie from this franchise (if you can call it that). Sophie has always been good and Lily James of course we know from the live action Cinderella, was great. The three young guys were also pretty decent when they were required to singāthey werenāt amazing, but they were passably good for this movie. Even Donnaās two friends seemed to have improved; maybe it was the auto-tune, but, whatever it was they definitely sounded better.
I really liked the story as well. The overall plot felt more real than the last one and I think it even adds to the first movie. In the first one, the pain Donna felt from being betrayed by her lovers felt a little flat to me. It was nice to have it explained. I also loved the fact that Donna was deadāstay with me. At first I was disappointed, but then I came around. It added a huge emotional subplot that made for some really sweet moments between the characters. At the end, when Sophie sees her mother during her sonās baptism I even got a little emotional! Great plot point. very smart move from the writers.
The look. This movie has a very specific aesthetic that I think is beautiful and fun. Thereās this one scene in which Sophie and sky sing āOne of Usā and they keep going from NY to Greece and the transitions were very creativeāalmost creative enough to mask how bad Dominic Cooperās voice was in comparison to Amanda Seyfried. Almost. And the revamped hotel contrasting how the town looked in the past, even to the choreographed dances it all felt cohesive.
The outfits. Especially the ones from the 70s they were awesome! I want those ruffled jeans! I want all of young Donnas outfits.
What I didnāt like:
Alright so there is a lot not to like in this movie if you donāt buy in to the inherent cheesiness and kitschy-ness of Mama Mia. That being said, ignoring all that, there are still problems that could have been addressed to make this movie even better.
The older actors singing. I will say, Rosie and Tanya, played by Julie Walters and Christine Baranski, Ā greatly improved their singing somehow in this movie. Maybe itās the auto-tune or maybe they let them sing more seriously in this movie, whatever it was, they sounded better to me in this one. Dominic Cooper and Pierce Brosnan however, had not improved. They actually got worse. And yes they had very minimal singing, but guys! If you knew they were still bad whyād you let them sing??
The horse. When young Donna meets Sam, she is seeking help for this horse thatās been trapped. He helps her out and the horse is sort of there in the rest of the movie but doesnāt really matter overall. And the woman at the end who actually owned the horse and the future hotel, what was she doing?? She basically observed that this random girl had moved into her place and was riding her horse was like āyeah sure thatās fineā? What? I think they should have had her get caught in a storm and stumble into his house for shelter or something like that. The horse worked at the beginning but then the writers were just like, āCrap now we have to incorporate this horse to make it seem relevant.ā
Speaking of Sam. I wanted more of him, and not just because I enjoy him. Heās the guy who broke her heart. I needed more scenes of them togetherāat least one more. Or a montage maybe. Sure their relationship was believable-ish but it did feel like they were fulfilling a checklist of Donna sleeping with all of them. Like okay letās give just enough background to make it believable that she would do him.
Last thingāI think. Donnaās whole āIām not that kind of girlā act throughout the movie. It got a little annoying. Especially when she literally had sex with Harry the same day she met him because he was hot, nice, and a virgin. If that doesnāt scream āthat type of girlā I donāt know what does! Not that Iām judging Donna but if thatās her character, commit to it. Her actions said one thing and her mouth said another. Even her friends werenāt surprised to see that she had several guys on her hook when they came to visit. If they had committed to her character a bit more, the type who falls in love easily and fast, it would have felt that much more believable.
All that being said, I still loved the movie and had a great time watching it. I recommend it to anyone who loved or just kind of liked the first one. This one is better and highly entertaining. Let me know what you thought of this movie! You can follow me on twitter @alwayskelley and join the conversation!








