AD theory. Toby is AD and Spencer's twin is black Widow!
Toby A.D. Theory & Spencer Twin Twist …………….I have a lot more to add to this to make even more sense.. but this is it for now. This theory will only include, aside from a couple, clues from the Timejump (6B on) and after. It will explain why I believe Toby is the Big Bad as well as a Spencer Twin reveal as the twist. *The number 5 will play a big role in this theory! Marlene King likes numbers and I think that after the time jump the new number 5 and multiples of 5 (10,15,20…) reappeared often! Clues! ⦁ In ep. 6.11 spencer visits Toby and there is a large 5 on one of the work bench. ⦁ Next we see a car with the license plate 55555 ⦁ When the liars are watching the camera of Aria leaving the Radley the time is 3:11:55 which added equals 15 (multiple of 5). ⦁ Toby was out of town when Hannah received the breakfast saying, “Poor Jordy”. ⦁ In Ep. 6.13 we seen that AD is wearing a hunter green jacket in the closing scene while cleaning off the electrical levers in Radley. Toby is wearing this exact later on in episode 7.07! Emily and Caleb both are seen wearing a green jacket in the series but these are different colors and both have fitted sleeves around the wrist, Tobys is exactly the same. ⦁ The hole in Sarahs closet was sealed off by someone with extensive carpentry skills ⦁ PREGNANCY CLUE: When Spencer has a flashback of her pregnancy scare it makes a point to show us the clock… it is 3:12 which = 5!! Toby is sitting beside the clock. There is also a “Deer Crossing Sign” on her wall which is odd; this refers to Tobys accident later on. ⦁ In the episode Caleb sends a virus to AD’s Computer there is a carpenter/workman vest laying in AD’s car seat. ⦁ In Ep. 6.18 hannah sends the message to AD that she killed Charlotte. The closing scene shows AD building the BOARDGAME in the background. We can see the beginning of the BG and the tools all around. There is red electrical wire, a white foldable tape measure, a bright red thing with two handles on the end and a lot more. The wire, tape measure, and red thing are ALL at tobys house in 6.13 when Caleb tells him about spencer; same color same everything! BAD Toby! Also, in the AD closing scene is the Hastings campaign background; Toby is also tied to the election. This and the jacket are HUGE clues! ⦁ Toby is well rehearsed in FRENCH and so is AD. Also Toby has glasses now and AD pretty much always wear glasses. ⦁ In Ep 6.20 a lady calls Toby pretty eyes, which is something that all A’s have been called. ⦁ When the cop in the mask attacks hannah, you can see he has green eyes if you pause it at the right time. Also cop cars are not easy to come by, but Toby has one. ⦁ OOhhh.. remember when TOBY could draw very well. In the first ever episode Toby was drawing and was good it. AD can draw which relates to the comic book. ⦁ When they find DOLL hannah at the Bell tower, caleb looks at his phone it says 4:01 which equals 5!! If you notice toby is being odd when they are talking about who killed charlotte, he knows a lot of details and is seriously invested in this convo I believe this is bc he is AD and wants to know who killed Charlotte of course. He doesnt have a whole lot on interest in helping the girls after this. ⦁ MARY DRAKE CONNECTION- When toby and Spencer break into Marys room at the Lost Woods it Focuses on her room number which is non other than 5! In Marys room we also see a book that says MASK MAKING. She is tied to AD. ⦁ Also Toby has learned to many new skills such as using dibblers to break into places and also keeps one on him all the time. ⦁ When Toby is getting engaged we also see a large number 5 again right next to the Red thing that AD had while building the GAMEBOARD. ⦁ The address to Rollins burner apartment is 23 Wexford st apartment 109. The first number =5 and the second set =10. her they are again. ⦁ When Toby shows up the the burner apartment he has a KEY! This is odd, cops do not get access to these things, not to mention the girls already bribed the apartment manager for his key. Toby unlocks the door without saying anything and then realizes the chain is locked. After that is only when he announces himself as a cop because he knew rollins wouldnt change the door. Remember when the girls used rollins phone to text the mystery # to meet at the usual spot? Jenna showed up to alisons house which was not the usual spot; not at alisons thats to open. Who shows up to the usual spot… TOBY! Also this season when cops show up its more than one or at least the detective, they would not send Toby by himself then call in for backup. This story was all Tobys cover. Also the address is a direct link to TOBY. ⦁ SPENCER TWIN Connection- When Aria and Jason are at family services aria says that they are number 5 in line. They are looking for Mary Drakes other child. The number 5 is here again. I will ADD more clues later, but these are also some observations I want to point out. 1. Hannah, Aria, and Alision were the girls that were injured by AD. Alision was beat by the cop and had a spill down the stairs, aria and the fire, and hannah was tortured. Emily eggs were stolen and spencer has been hurt in regards to family matters. AD is much easier on Emily and Spencer physically; the eggs thing with Emily is a awful situation, but I do believe AD thinks he is being easier on her. He dont want to harm her (even though he is, but his twisted mind dont see it this way). 2. Hannahs career was wrecked, Aria has been torn from her friends, alision is carrying a baby and has lost all of her money not to mention the set up marriage, yet AD helped emily with a test and helped Spencer find her birthmother and has given her answers she has wanted since though started (even though it has caused a lot of problems). AD is Definitely trying to be better to them. Toby has always been close to Emily and Spencer. Motive: I believe Toby has a connection to Bethany Young and has been A from the beginning. I am not a fan of bethany being alive, but these are the clues that she is. ⦁ Marlene King Wrote on a blackboard the PLL ride is over soon. BY BY. Obviously this isnt how you spell Bye so I think this means Bethany Young. ⦁ Bethany is tied to horses and we see horses throughout 6B on. ⦁ Alsion wears a horse shirt through an entire episode, even when all the girls change she comes to her dinner party in this shirt. ⦁ There is a Horse drawing in Lucas’ apartment. ⦁ We see wooden horses at the Amish Furniture Place. ⦁ Patsy Cline Clue- Patsy loved horse; there is also a farm called Black Widow Farm/Walkin in the Moonlight Farm; you can adopt horses from this place…. remember when Bethany had the adopted horse name Custard?? ⦁ Melissa buried Bethany… who is the only person aside from that liars circle that is being messed with… Melissa. ⦁ Bethany is being brought up a lot this season. ⦁ Major Clue!!! Remember how Bethany was supposedly 17?? When the girls find Mary Drakes file Spencer makes the comment, “Charles was actually almost the same age is Jason. They changed his age so his connection couldnt be discovered.” Charlotte is already dead therefore this comment has nothing to do with her, it is talking about Bethany and giving us a clue that she can actually be same age as the girls. SPENCER HAS A TWIN CLUES ⦁ Hannahs Dream… Im sure everyone has read about it by now lol ⦁ The weird Spencer at the airport ⦁ Spencer in the last episode… no apple watch, changed four times, and yes she had a scar but it doesnt exactly look like a gunshot wound. ⦁ We know that veronica took spencer straight from Radley, well one child has been presumably been placed in family services; hence the redacted info Jason got. ⦁ Spencer was in a PINK blanket, yet one baby was seen being carried out in a white blanket. ⦁ The file that the girls find in the storm celler that Mrs. D used was Mary Drakes. When the girls discover that Mary has another child and they are reading about them it says, “BOTH STABLE”! Both as in two!!! ⦁ Dr. Cochran said he delivered two of Marys babies as there could be another one. ⦁ Tyler Blackburn the actor that plays Caleb said we have kind of seen AD, but not really, and that when we see it we will understand what he means. Sounds like a look a like to me. ⦁ Mary Drake once said the families even have hidden people…. we have already seen her so I believe this is foreshadowing something deeper. Okay so now my motive… I believe Toby is tied to Bethany Young somehow.. Remember his tattoo 9.01 FREE at LAST? Well this is the same night Bethany also ran away from RADLEY and if she is alive she is also FREE! What else, if you add 901 together it = 10! Which is another multiple of 5. Rollins burner apartment also has the numbers 901 in them as did a couple others. These numbers are significant. Above I have shows how Toby is tied to AD, Mary Drake, a pregnancy, and Bethany Young. The girls was the reason Toby was sent away at one point and they also blinded Jenna… but I think it is much deeper than that. I think it all comes back to Bethany. I think parts of Charlottes story was real, but not the part about Tobys mother. Bethany Young is the twin of Spencer Hastings. In the finale I believe that Toby will be revealed as AD, and then the twist will be that Spencer has a twin which is none other than Bethany Young and she is the black widow. Above I have connected Bethany to the Black Widow horse farm. Bethany has all the motive in the world to be a part of this. Falsely led out that night, she dont know who killed her, she was buried alive, was gave up for adoption while spencer had a great life; she would definitely want to hurt the Hastings and this has been happening a lot since 6B on. Also a fun note AD is the initials for LOST LOVE in FRENCH and could also been abandoned daughter. I truly believe this is the meaning of Tobys tattoo and the Jenna thing was always a cover. Im sure Toby didn’t really want to explain that his tattoo meant it was the day his step sister stopped sexually abusing him to everyone that asks; this would brand his body with a memory of a horrific experience.
@bryan-gleek-liar-oncer-potter check out my theory!
Thank you. I have much more clues! I’m new to tumbler though so I can’t get anyone to read it lol.
@tobys-little-liars
