Unfortunate Reunion Party Pt. 10
Yay finally posted part 10! I re-read some previous parts, and gosh.. so many typos I need to edit later...
Always talk to the cops when you have your lawyer next to you
Aaron Hotchner X BAU G.N. Reader
Warning: Angry reader, swearing
I wiped tears and my nose with my sleeve, still sniffling. With a crack of a smile, Aaron handed me his blue-black hankie.
“Don’t wipe it with the sleeves,” he said sternly.
Every the father, I shrugged but grabbed his hankie. Even wiping, I inhaled Aaron’s scent on the hankie.
“Still sad. But strange because I lost my memories like from movies.” I half opened my mouth and closed it, thinking about his weird behaviour of Edisis. Aaron patiently waited for me to talk. “He laughed.”
“Yeah. I know people move on after they lose their loved ones. But still, they’re hurt. But, Edisis was not. He really laughed -even if it was a little- and smiled, like he didn’t lose his granddaughter.”
“Is it possible that he is just a good actor?” Aaron asked calmly.
“Possible. Besides, he looked happy when he said the bullies are under his care in the morgue.” I frowned, replaying how Edisis behaved. “He knew my name. I’ve never told him. Maybe he knew who I was when I arrived in town. Or he just remembers me from the funeral.”
“Everything is possible,” Aaron just nodded, pondering options and chances. Suddenly his phone rang, and he answered. Even though the voice was not clear, I could easily recognise Reid’s quick tempo sentences.
“Reid, find out more about Dr Edisis and his granddaughter. See you at the station,” Aaron said and hung up. Then he looked at me, gesturing to the car. “Morgan and Prentiss brought Johns.”
“But he isn’t talking and asked for his attorney.” I nodded.
“Always,” Aaron shrugged.
I tentatively grabbed his fingers, unsure if I could just hold his hand.
“Even shocked, you caught how the doctor behaved.” He tightened the grip on my hand. “Ever the BAU agent, hmm?” He smiled gently at me, and I could mirror the smile.
Everyone was in the interrogation room except Rodriguez, who was excluded by the captain. Apparently, Aaron told the captain about the relationships between the victims, Johns and Rodriguez. I was sure the captain wouldn’t budge as everyone knew each other in his town, but the captain surprisingly listened to Aaron. I concluded that the captain listened to Aaron because he was the FBI and didn’t want any trouble with the bureaucrat when there was a serial killer among them.
Johns was sitting alone, shaking his right leg. He tightly held his hands together in front of his face, touching his forehead. Pray as much as you want, I snarled inwardly.
In the corner, Aaron and Rossi whispered lowly about something. Aaron silently stood there pensively, then nodded.
“It’s possible,” Aaron told his mentor. “Prentiss, do you also think the same?”
Prentiss, who was blankly observing Johns, slightly jumped as the leader called her. “You mean Kirvy’s parents?”
“To be precise, the father,” Rossi corrected the younger profiler.
Prentiss shrugged. “Yeah. He was definitely hiding something. He was calm as if he was expecting us when we were there.”
Aaron and my eyes contacted, reminding us of the meeting with Dr Edisis.
“But couldn’t it be because their son was brought for questioning?” JJ asked curiously.
“That’s another possibility,” Rossi hummed. “If I quote him, ‘I’m fucking happy that those scums met their torturous deaths.’”
“The victim’s torture was not published public,” Reid frowned.
“He might have heard from one of the officers here,” Morgan sighed at the suggestion. Because if that were the case, it would be back to square one. “Or he knows the UnSub.”
“Unless the whole town is conspiring against them,” I muttered, remembering what Eric Kirvy told me.
Silence fell heavily onto us.
Aaron checked his watch and looked at the anxious man in the interrogation room. “We should talk to him now.”
“Can I?” Reid asked promptly, and naturally, everyone looked at the younger man strangely. Reid never participated in interrogation unless either Hotch or Rossi asked him.
“You sure?” Morgan asked with a hint of concern in his voice.
People who didn’t know Morgan would think he didn’t trust Reid or that Reid was capable of interrogating. But including Reid, every member of BAU knew Morgan. It was a brotherly concern. Everyone knew about Reid’s horrible school life because he was just intelligent.
Reid gave a reassuring smile to Morgan. “Yeah, I’ve done this before.”
Aaron nodded toward Reid, and Morgan patted Reid’s shoulder.
I gulped when Reid entered the room quietly. Unlike how I had imagined, Reid wasn’t awkward. He confidently sat in front of Johns, who watched the younger man warily.
“Dr Spencer Reid from the FBI,” Reid introduced himself and didn’t wait for Johns to reply or react. “You made my friend’s life miserable.”
I blinked, comprehending what had just happened.
“What’s he saying?” Even to my ears, my voice was full of panic.
Aaron put his hand on my shoulder to calm me down. “Let’s leave it to him.”
I looked at Rossi for help, but Rossi shook his head. Aaron was the team leader; currently, I was there as his subordinate. I must listen to Aaron. But wouldn’t that jeopardise the interrogation?
Johns only narrowed his eyes at Reid. But Reid didn’t falter and put the folder in his hand on the steel desk.
“Did it feel good? Hurting others because you just could?” The doctor asked nonchalantly, but Johns’ fists quivered as he looked down.
Very convincing, I bit my lips to stop myself from cursing at the man who couldn’t hear anything from this side of the room. No way in hell Johns would regret what he and his friends did to me and others. I wouldn’t believe that. He must be acting.
“If you want me to talk, bring F/N. I’ll talk without my lawyer then.”
I took a step back, and I bumped into Aaron. He silently squeezed my shoulder, and others glanced at me briefly before turning their attention back to Reid and Johns. Everyone was stunned by Johns. Who in their right mind wants to talk to cops without lawyers?
“And what would you do to my friend?”
I chanted Reid’s name in my head. This was getting too personal for my team and me.
“Just talk,” Johns replied plainly. But his fingers were fidgeting, and now he was shaking both legs under the table.
And I had to make up my mind.
Before Prentiss and Morgan could protest, Aaron held his hand up to silence the team. JJ looked at me worriedly, and I just nodded at her.
“He said he’d talk if I’m in there. I can bring out information.”
“You sure?” Aaron asked in a professional manner. Just concern for his colleague. And this man told me he sucked at acting, I rolled my eyes in my head.
“I survived Edisis. With the info Reid and Garcia looked up, I might able to fish some info from him or even truth without involving his lawyer.”
Rossi opened the interrogation room, causing Johns to wince at the sudden sound.
“Reid.” He gestured outside with his chin.
Reid frowned at the veteran profiler but left the room without glancing at the nervous man behind. Johns didn’t even glance at Rossi or even Reid exiting the room.
“I’m sorry,” Reid apologised as he entered to room. “I just got angry for what he did to others and F/N.”
I put my hand on Reid’s forearm. “I’m just glad you’re looking out for me.” And I'm pretty sure I didn’t see Aaron narrowing his eyes, did he? Then I grinned at my team to hide my nervousness. Although I knew they could see through me. “Wish me luck.”
“If I sense any trouble, I’m gonna pull you out. Whether you like it or not,” Aaron said with a curt nod.
I breathed in and out deeply to calm my nerves before I entered the room and faced the man. Now or never.
I entered the room, schooling my expression, and sat before Johns. He didn’t look up, just shaking his legs nervously.
“Not even a hello?” I said cooly.
Johns practically jumped from the seat and stared at me. I ignored his stares and opened the folder that was held by Reid before. One by one, I placed photos of the crime scenes and the state of the victims’ bodies when they were found. I must be really sick if I was thrilled by showing Johns the photos of his friends’ unfortunate demise. Johns’ breath got heavier, and he pulled himself away from the table, trembling. Well, he was definitely not the UnSub we were looking for, and I wasn’t sure if he was connected to this at all. Did I read Edisis wrong?
“Why are you showing me this,” he gritted out.
“I thought you’d want to know what happened to your best friends,” I replied flatly.
“Please,” he gulped as he buried his face in his hands.
A jolt of memory flared up in my head, and I nearly ran out of the room. I begged. Everyone begged. Begged to stop. And they didn’t. I wanted to lash out. I curled my hands into fists, my nails digging into my flesh so I won’t do anything that I’d regret later. However I want to give this particular UnSub a prize; I was here to catch them and pay for what they have done.
“Then let’s talk, shall we?” I nearly snapped. I slowly put away the photos back into the folder, chewing the moment of the man’s discomfort.
The interrogation room was curtained with thick impenetrable silence. All my senses focused on the man before me, who started chewing his bottom lip and playing with his wedding band.
“I’m sorry,” he finally managed.
“I’m sorry?” I asked sharply.
“I’m sorry I didn’t help you and others when they tortured you.” He stuttered out. “Unlike you, I was a coward and couldn’t stand up against them.”
I wasn’t sure what to say. Should I say, ‘thanks for acknowledging that’? Or just snap ‘too late’?
“If you’re sorry,” dammit, my voice trembled, “tell me everything you know.” I had to bite my tongue not to add ‘unless you want to be the next’.
“I really don’t know who’s responsible,” Johns gestured with his hands defeatedly. “I just received an email, that’s all.”
“An email?” I glanced behind me, knowing my team was listening and Garcia would be already grilling Johns’ emails.
Johns nodded. “They said I had to employ Thomas Kirvy as my redemption. Every required detail was sent through the same email.”
Unless they were a friend or family to Thomas Kirvy, they wouldn’t have picked up the boy’s name who died years ago. My mind replayed the discussion the team had before questioning Johns.
“You could’ve just ignored it,” I pointed out. Even though Garcia would eventually dig up, I wanted to know what made Johns do it.
“It said they’d tell everything what my gang did during high school to my family.”
I couldn’t help but snort, and he flinched.
“When did you receive it?”
“Just after the reunion party.” He cautiously looked into my eyes. “You were there, didn’t you?”
I gave him a thin smile, knowing exactly what he was thinking. “I didn’t kill them. I was crying on my boyfriend’s shoulder,” I snarked bitterly. Something broke in me when I saw a surprised look on Johns’ face. I abruptly stood in anger, towering over him. The chair made a loud thud as it fell on the floor. His face was pure horror as he saw the change in me.
“You thought you had completely broken me, didn’t you?” I snarled. “You knew I would never trust others because of you. You knew I would always have a destructive relationship because of what you put through!”
Before I could lunge at him, someone grabbed me from behind.
“I didn’t mean that! You have to trust me, and I didn’t mean that! I’m sorry!”
“I’m so fucking glad they got what they deserved!”