He doesn’t have the energy to go through it all again, finally coming down from the adrenaline rush of Remus having woken him up, surprised him in his most vulnerable state, not prepared in the least to face the people he had hurt the most. It feels like he’s run a marathon, or that he’s been crying for hours, the way his body just feels so tired, breath a little too hard, everything slow and foggy. And the thing is, he knows that with Lily there’s nothing he’ll be able to say or do that will be enough. Hell, that’s what he’s expecting with everyone, now, given everything he’s seen so far.
It just makes him wish even more that someone would be brave enough to do what he hasn’t been able to do himself. More cowardly thoughts that he just can’t shake in the face of everything he’s fucked up. He had come back to try to be brave for once in his sorry life, and even that hadn’t worked, the chance destroyed before he even got it. He wasn’t stupid enough to believe that Lily, or Remus, or anyone else would have enough pity, or trust, to give him the chance Dumbledore was going to.
And so what was the point?
Maybe the only way to do what he’d wanted now was to just give them the satisfaction of seeing him suffer for what he’d done.
“Dumbledore shouldn’t have sent me. I’m too weak, too much of a damn coward. When they realized I was a spy, they tortured me. I wasn’t strong enough to give up my life, though, and they made me believe that somehow it might be better, to at least be seen. I regretted it from the moment I did it, but I was too afraid to know what to do,” he shakes his head. “They saw the worst of me, and encouraged it. Seeing the way they laughed at what I’d done to you all, it wore me down, made me want any chance to fix things; I wanted to leave, but I was too afraid. It took a long time to figure out how to get back without anyone noticing before I crossed the border, but I sussed it out because of Sirius doing the same.”
Peter pauses, trying to catch his breath, calm the way his whole body seems to be shaking. He can’t look her in the eyes. “I thought…I thought maybe if I made it back, and told Dumbledore everything I knew, everything I had told Riddle before he had the chance to use it all, maybe I could change things, even though nothing can take back what I did,” he explains, with a sigh, voice quiet. “He was gone before he could tell me what to do, though. But I still have to try. I’ve got nothing left, if I try, and fail, and you all decide I deserve to die instead, well, I deserve it. At least I’ll have tried.”
She barely blinked at him while he gave his sorry excuse for an explanation. Lily has a lot of questions to ask, is burning with them, sick with them, even, but she won’t ask. At least not now--not for a long time, if ever. Questions like why did you do it and who did you endanger to save your skin and why didn’t you just die on their side, stay their problem and not become mine. Her eyes are steady on him, boring into him, watching for signs of a lie.
He’s scared, that much seems obvious, genuinely scared but that could be anything. Scared that she’s going to hurt him. Scared that she’s going to snap his wand. Scared that she’ll kick him out of the castle and tell him to fend for himself. Peter Pettigrew has a lot of reasons to be scared, Lily knows, and she figures there’s an extra reason crouching behind her, something looming ahead: she’s going to tell James.
She shoves that thought from her head forcefully. Later. She’ll figure that out later. God, she can’t tell James, how could she even get the words out?
Later. Lily exhales, a hiss through her teeth. Does what she does these days: takes her head and sets it on straighter. A few degrees to the left. The personal passions of Lily Evans-Potter exist in her periphery, but they don’t press at her eyes when she looks at Peter now. Her own style of leading, not Dumbledore or Kingsley or Remus but her own. Her hands tremble, still: she can’t make it all go away yet.
“You’re not going to die,” she says, suppressing the irritation that wants to creep its way into her voice. “Not tonight, at least, and not in my care.” Oh, how much she wishes she didn’t have to say that. Because it seems so justified. Take the rat out of the equation. As easy as setting down a trap and letting the rodent fall into it. Humane, even. Best for everyone involved, after what he did.
But those thoughts disgust even her, even through her anger. Murder is hardly the appropriate solution to any situation, and Peter does not seem to be an active threat. He’s been here, hiding out, long enough, to have done someone harm if he’d intended to, and he clearly hasn’t taken any opportunities to do so. Even if he hadn’t known she and Remus are wandless, he could have done something. Escaped or snuck up on Remus in the middle of the night and--
Well. He didn’t, and that’s what Lily is focusing on now. There’s too much to unpack in his response for one conversation. Her head is pounding and work is going to be hell tomorrow.
Lily rubs her eyes, finally, pressing until little spots burst on the backs of her eyelids. Peter’s still there when she opens her eyes, and she can’t help scowling a little at him. “What is it you want to try, Peter?”