Gary doesn't blame her for being so surprised. He's still trying to figure it out himself. Not only that Gary had managed to find someone who didn't annoy him enough to be as smitten as he already is, but someone that doesn't mind the way he generally is enough to be just as smitten. It's not even that Gary's not a believer in insta-love, so to speak. He absolutely does. It's the same as the existence of aliens to him, in a strange sort of way. How many billions and trillions of people have fallen in love throughout the course of humanity? Even someone as dumb as himself can recognize how unlikely it is to have never happened, not one time.
It's just that Gary isn't the kind of person, isn't the kind of personality that would typically happen to. Out of the two of them, anyone would guess it would be Jenny.
Her eyes widen a little bit when Mapplethorpe says he follows her, and she quickly pulls her phone out to be able to look him up. "I gotta see- I'm still all flustered and worried 'cause o' this one."
"'M sorry," he mumbles. Though, hand still laced with Mapplethorpe and still blushing just from looking over at him, he isn't all that sorry.
"No, baby, don't be." She rubs up the side of his arm a little bit with her free hand, still looking down at her phone and typing with her thumb. "Just don't want nothin' happenin' to you 's all." Jenny pulls up his profile and squeals a little bit when she sees not only that she follows him back already, but that she knows good and well who he is. "Oh my god!" she happily shrieks. Jenny forces herself between them and hugs Mapplethorpe from the side, squeezing him tightly while she keeps looking through his posts. Many of which are familiar to her already. "Ahh, no way! I'm so glad one of us found you! You're so funny." She tucks her phone into the pocket of her robe and beams up at him. "Gary's been keeping you company, yeah? I hope he's been playin' nice."
"Yeah, I'm a real sweetheart."
"Yeah, I bet'chu are. Come, sit." She grabs one of each of their hands and drags them over to a vanity that's built into the wall, and the loveseat next to it. "Now that I know I ain't gonna cry over lookin' for you, I can start my fuckin' makeup."
When they sit Gary's arm immediately finds Mapplethorpe's waist, keeping him closer than the small couch would require. He just wants him close.
"You from 'round here, babes?" Jenny asks Mapplethorpe, briefly glancing up from the makeup she dumps out a bit haphazardly before she actually lays it out with some kind of reason.