Summary: Oikawa wants to break up because the shade of his once bright relationship has darkened and itâs his fault for not loving her enough.
Fic notes + warnings: Oikawa x fem!reader, mentions of fluff (through flashbacks), angst, mentions of cheating, one-shot, swearing(?), established relationship, song fic, based off of Shade by Yukika.
Song link: https://youtu.be/rK69AriTIZc
Note from the author: Hi, hello! So, this is probably one of my first ever angst fics and I have been meaning to write this for MONTHS now and havenât had time. Once I heard this song I knew I had to write something based off the lyrics! I hope you enjoy this as much as I enjoyed writing it! Sorry if there is any errors in grammar or any of that, Iâm too lazy to edit. Lots of love! -Cyber
Oikawa stared at the ceiling of his bedroom with a peacefully sleeping (Y/n) by his side. His mind scattered with the only coherent thought being the thought of breaking off his relationship with his current girlfriend. At this point, He knew it couldnât stay just a thought and that it had to be an action made in his part. He needed to break things off.Â
The longer he stared at his ceiling the worse his thoughts got and the twist in his stomach tightened.
Because Iâm a bad person, because I donât love you.
Tooru glanced over at (Y/n)âs sleeping form and felt his heart clench. He knew what he was doing was horrible. He knew he was a horrible person for staying after what he did. He was horrible for not loving her the way he used to. She deserved to be loved but he couldnât give that to her.
Your shade is darkness to me, goodbye.
Staring at (Y/n) peacefully sleeping, he couldnât help but feel this disgusting guilt in himself over what he had done and her not knowing anything. It made her once warm, bright, caring nature feel dark and all because of his own guilt. All of this because of something he did to someone who didnât deserve it. Someone who didnât know what he did.
Maybe it wasnât love between us. Was that an unjustified, meaningless relationship?
Tooru rationalized with himself almost every night that their relationship was just a simple, forgettable high school relationship. One that people would call silly in the future due to them thinking it was truly love. He was right, wasnât he? They were only in high school, itâs not like those relationships last. Thatâs what he told himself. Though, he knew the truth. He knew that (Y/n) was possibly the best thing to happen to him. That (Y/n) loved and trusted him. She accepted him for himself, his flaws, and never once wanted him to change. She loved him for who he was even though he felt he didnât deserve it.
The momentary tremble, the momentary joy
Tooru felt like his heart was about to explode as he awaited (Y/n)âs answer. Her (e/c) eyes staring at him wide and her whole face covered in shock. It felt like hours to him as he waited for her to answer. Suddenly, he heard a laugh. A laugh he had grown to love throughout his time getting to know the girl. One that never failed to make his face break out into a smile.
âYouâre telling me, the Oikawa Tooru: Captain and setter of Seijoh; Aoba Josaiâs idol, is asking me out?â She asked smugly while smirking up at him. âwhat happened to âMy only love is volleyballâ, hmm?â she chuckled as she referenced what he had once said to a confession he had gotten earlier that year. The sentence alone was enough to make his face heat up in embarrassment.
âYou know I only said that to get her to leave me alone!â He huffed making her laugh once more.
âNo way! Are you embarrassed, Tooru-kun?â (Y/n) teased. Tooru glared slightly at her response and swallowed back the slight hurt from her lack of answer. âYou know what, letâs just forget about this, (Y/n)-chanâŠokay? Iâll see you later.â He quickly dusted off what he said earlier and smiled to save face from the embarrassment of being rejected. Turning on his heel ready to forget this happened and head to practice.
âWait, Tooru!â She quickly grabbed his hand, âIâm sorry, I would love to go out with you.â Her voice trembled slightly like she suddenly realized he was serious about his confession. Those trembly words were enough to send his heart into overdrive. Before she knew it, Oikawa scooped her up in his arms and smiled.
âTooru!â She squeaked out of surprise. There was a beat of silence as he held her and took in the joy of this moment.
âIâm so getting you back for teasing me earlier.â
Those emotions sometimes become an after-image that torments me
His stomach twisted remembering that day. He remembers the pure happiness he felt when he finally told her his feelings. The days after where he would tease her just to see her get embarrassed, where they would do stupid things together, where they would just want to be with each other for the hell of it. Those once amazing times made him feel sick and he knew he was at fault for it. All because he felt unfulfilled with the endless love he was given. All because he was selfish and wanted more.Â
Tooruâs eyes stung with tears as he realized the weight of what he had truly done. Just staring at her was causing him to feel guilty. Quickly turning away from her, he stared at his bedroom wall and waited for sleep to consume him.
Letâs break up, because I am a bad person. Because I donât love you. Your shade is darkness to me.
It was morning after the long night. (Y/n) was in the living room talking on the phone with her mother while Oikawa slowly made his way out of his room. He didnât want to face her. Last night was hard enough, but he couldnât tell her no when she asked to stay the night with him. He made his way to the living room hoping she would be to busy on the phone to notice him. He wasnât ready to talk to her yet. He didnât want to hurt her but if he didnât tell her then it would only cause more pain.
but could he even handle that pain? Could he handle no longer having her in his life?Â
âOh! Morning, Tooru!âÂ
He was too caught up in his thoughts to realize that he was in the living room. (Y/n) greeted at him with a bright smile and quickly went to end the call with her mother.
Stop it. I donât want to be sorry anymore. I donât want to see you being kind anymore. Would you hate me? Goodbye.
Tooru tensed slightly as she ended the call and turned to him once more. She was quick to see his change in body language and tilted her head in concern, âHey, are you okay?â
That question felt like he was being punched in the gut. He couldnât stand her caring for him after his unfaithful actions. He couldnât stand any of the situation anymore. Even though he wanted to wait to have this conversation his guilt was eating him alive. He would rather see her angry and yelling at him than her being so caring after him doing what he did.
âWe need to talkâ the words quickly left his mouth.
Memories can sometimes wear a smiley mask when the truth isnât really like that
(Y/n) was quick to agree and sat next to him on the couch. She seemed to notice his off actions. In honesty, He knew she has taken notice the past couple of days. He was avoiding her in the halls when at school. He would only see her in the mornings before class, during lunch, and during practice. Even during those times he wasnât himself. He wasnât her Tooru. His usually playfulness was forced. His eyes didnât match his smile but she never questioned. He knew she wanted to believe everything was fine yet even she knew everything wasnât fine.
âLetâs break up.â As he said those words, it seemed they both felt as if ice water was dumped on them. It was quiet. (Y/n) stared at him as if searching for reason while Tooru felt his stomach twist knowing her next move.
It was a simple question yet it felt like one of the hardest that Tooru had ever answered in his whole life.
By you, I wish I wasnât engraved in you mind like a cold you once had. I donât want be your past.
He felt like he couldnât answer. He knew that she truly loved him. He knew that this would hurt her deeply. He was someone that was deep into her life, someone that, if they left, would leave a scar on them. He absolutely hated that he was that engraved into her life.Â
(Y/n) was his best friend before he became her boyfriend. He didnât want all that to be done. He truly didnât want to be just in her past and nothing more than a douchebag boyfriend. He didnât want her gone from his life but he knew that he deserved to just be someone from her past. That she would move on with her life and he wouldnât be apart of it.Â
Her gaze seemed to refuse to leave his face as she waited for the answer. He hated that he could already see the hurt in her face. It was probably mirrored on his own. Tooru knew the next words to fall from his mouth would sting the both of them, but it had to be said. It needed to be said.
âI donât love you anymore.â
After a moment, a wobbly pained smile made it onto (Y/n)âs face. âI understand.â, She whispered out trying to cover the obvious pain in her voice. Her eyes were slowly filling with tears that she seemed to be fighting off. Tooru felt his throat tighten and his eyes burn with the same tears as hers. He had no right to cry after the harsh words he said to her but he couldnât help it.
Now, thereâs nothing between us. I donât want you to try hard to bother me, itâll be harder for me.
âCan we still be friends?â She asked weakly as she stood from her seat, her body no longer facing him. He knew she was crying and trying not to let him see. That action itself was enough to get a few tears to slip from his stinging eyes. A sob was bubbling in his chest but he forced it down.
Could they still be friends?Â
He pondered over it before. As much as he wants to still be in her life, he knew he couldnât. Every time he would look at her, he knew he would feel guilt and the pain of his own actions. Looking at her alone would make him want to hug her and tell her he was sorry hundreds of times, and he knew she would forgive him; but he didnât deserve forgiveness. He needed to suffer for what he did to someone who deserved nothing but the world. Even if it meant losing an old friend.Â
After a long silence, she knew his answer. Once again, she nodded as if she understood and quickly cleared her throat. âOkay thenâŠGoodbye, TooruâŠ.â The sentence died at the end of her throat as if she had one more thing to say but couldnât bring herself to say it. Tooru got up and walked her to the front door. He refused to meet her eyes as he opened the door for her.Â
âI love youâ were the only words she said as she swiftly left.
Will I be okay by myself? Will I be okay without you? Iâm afraid, but the longer we hold on itâll be more painful.
That night Oikawa laid in his bed, chest aching, eyes red from tears, and phone in hand .He questioned himself millions of times after what happened. Staring at the picture of the two of them on his home screen kept taunting him with the questions if he would truly be fine without (Y/n) in his life. Someone he considered his best friend. Someone who taught him that it was okay to not be the best. Someone who didnât judge him if he broke down from the stress of everything.
Deep down he knew that if he never broke it off, (Y/n) would only suffer more. That he would suffer as well but that his suffering was deserved. He was selfish but he couldnât let someone innocent be in pain because of his infidelity. If he had held onto her, she would no longer be the bright light that others needed.
Slowly, Tooru turned off his phone and closed his eyes finally letting himself sob. Letting himself understand the loss he caused and the pain he gave someone he deeply cared for.
Months have passed. Time has moved on, but Oikawa hasnât. Everything still hurt as fresh as the day he cheated. The day he ruined everything.Â
No one noticed though. On the outside, Tooru was still that happy-go-lucky, flirty, confident volleyball captain that girls loved. No one could tell that he was still suffering from his own actions months ago. The only one that was ever able to tell when Tooru was faking was (Y/n) and she has moved on, no longer apart of his life.Â
Wondering the halls, He was quickly pulled to stop when he heard a familiar laugh. One that he used to love but now only reminded him of his disgusting actions. He shouldâve kept walking but he couldnât help himself. He wanted to know how she was, if she was happy, if she hated him, he didnât care. He wanted to just see her once more.
I donât want to be sorry anymore. I donât want to see you being kind anymore. Would you hate me?
As his brown eyes made their way towards the sound, he spotted her.
She looked happy and laughing with a friend of hers. His heart felt like it was squeezed when she looked over in his direction. What was going to happen? Would she instantly ignore him? He wouldnât be hurt if she did.
But it didnât happened.
(Y/n)âs eye met Tooruâs and she smiled. A smile that held no malice, no pain, no anger. She lifted her hand and gently waved in his direction, the soft smile never leaving her face as she did so and with a small nod in his direction, she walked off with her friend.
Tooru felt sick. He felt confused. Why didnât she hate him? Why did she still treat him so kindly? Seeing her treat him kindly hurt so much worse than if she hated him. He wished she would hate him. If she hated him, the pain would stop. He did nothing but hurt her; yet here she was still treating him with that warm, bright kindness that brought him to her in the first place.
He stood staring at the spot she once stood and with his heart aching realized that he was finally just someone from her past.