hear me out right… yandere!omens the first time YOU ever do something insane for THEM
maybe someone is flirting with them at a show or a bar or something, and you get that crazy insane look in your eyes like they always get 👀
Oh, this is fun for all of them because the moment they see you snap, there’s that little glimmer of pride in their eyes. They’ve been the obsessive ones up until now, doing anything to get your attention, to earn your complete devotion, proving just how deeply they’re devoted to you, jealous of anyone who dares to interact, and now, here you are, finally snapping.
Take the idea of someone flirting with them—some girl making a dumb mistake—and you stepping in to fix it.
Well, Noah goes absolutely feral over that. He pulls you against him, his hands gripping you tight and possessively as he asks you to repeat what you just told her: that he’s yours, and when you do, nothing sounds sweeter to his ears. It’s the way you say it, full of possession, full of claim, that drives him wild. “Did you mean it when you threatened her?” he asks, eyes locked on yours. You don’t hesitate. “Absolutely.” He lets out the softest, sickest little laugh. “I think I just fell in love with you all over again.” And there’s no mistaking it—those are hearts in his eyes. That boy couldn’t be more in love.
Out of all of them, Jolly has always been the quiet one when it comes to his obsession with you, and his reactions. Even though he never encourages or entertains any unwarranted flirting, he’s still caught off guard by your response. The way you snap the moment someone dares to make a flirty comment about how much they love him? Yeah, that shocks him. You get between them, make a direct threat, completely uncaring how you come across, because you want to make one thing clear: he’s yours. He’s surprised, but simultaneously pleased. “Goddamn. You always talk about how crazy I am for you, but—babe. That? That was fucking insane.”
You’ve seen how Nicholas can get, how manipulative he can be, but also how he frames his obsession with you as devotion. Watching you, seeing how deep your own devotion runs, almost to the level of worship he has for you, has completely besotted him, especially when he purposely enticed someone to flirt with him, hoping to provoke some kind of reaction from you. Honestly, he could never have anticipated this, but he loves it nonetheless. “There you are,” he whispers. “I’ve been waiting for that. For you.” He cups your face and kisses you like he’s grateful, like you finally understand what he’s felt all this time.
When it comes to Folio in this situation, all he can do is stare, mouth slightly open, before a slow, crooked grin spreads across his face. He’s fucking proud, mostly of how much you’re like him. How jealous and possessive you just got over someone innocently flirting with him. “God, look at you. You’re just like me. I didn’t think you had it in you.” And already, he’s imagining the moment you get home—how this obsession will bleed into you fucking one another, rougher than ever before.
You follow Matt’s lead the moment someone gets a little too close to him, making inappropriate comments. You lean in and whisper something in their ear while he’s just a little wide-eyed, a little breathless, and… scared? “You looked… dangerous.” He says it with a hint of fear, but also a thrill, because he’s never seen you like this before. “I liked it.”
Lastly, there’s Davis, always quiet and controlled when it comes to his rage and obsession. He would do anything for you, but the moment you snap and he sees that same fire in you? He’s ready to fall to his knees, both metaphorically and literally, especially when he catches the threat you make after someone gets a little too close to him. “You’d ruin someone’s life just for touching me?”, “Isn’t that what you’d do for me?” That’s when he realizes he’s finally met someone who truly understands and it should be no surprise to him that it’s you. After that, he only falls deeper, knowing he’s not the only monster in the room.