⌠ââââ WHAT GRIEF WISHES FOR thomas shelby x obsessed!f!reader masterlist â taglist
ââââââââââââââââ
ââââââââââââââââ
wc. 2.8 k
premise. based on this ask! Years after the war and haunted by Grace's death, Thomas crosses paths with the woman he once thought he would marry: a woman who walked away when the man she loved returned from France changed beyond recognition. When she rejects his impulsive invitation to spend the night, Thomas's grief drives him to make one desperate wish upon a silver coin gifted by an old Romani fortune teller. "I wish she'd love me... and never leave me again."
warnings. DEAD DOVE DONT EAT!!; noncon, obsession au, supernatural happenings, canon typical violence
ââââââââââââââââ
chapter 2 â a wish
The moment your eyes met his, the noise of the Garrison seemed to retreat somewhere into the distance.
The laughter remained.
The piano continued its weary tune.
Glasses still clinked together beneath the amber lamps.
Yet Thomas heard almost none of it.
There was only the strange pull settling somewhere deep within his chest, quiet but undeniable, urging him forward before his mind had fully decided to move. It wasn't unfamiliar. Years ago, before the war, he used to feel that same inexplicable certainty whenever he saw you standing somewhere across a crowded field or waiting beside your family's painted caravan.
It was ridiculous.
He was no longer that man.
And yet...
His feet carried him toward you all the same.
The polished wooden floor creaked softly beneath his shoes as he crossed the room, pushing between occupied tables and barmaids balancing trays of half-empty glasses. The closer he came, the more details returned to him without invitation; the faint scent of lavender that clung to your perfume, the careful stitching along the sleeves of your violet dress, the delicate silver necklace resting against your collarbone, familiar enough to awaken memories he hadn't allowed himself to touch in years.
You noticed him approaching.
Your fingers tightened almost imperceptibly around the glass of whiskey before relaxing again.
Thomas stopped beside you.
For a brief second...
Neither of you spoke.
âHave a drink with me,â Thomas said at last, his voice low and steady, though it carried more certainty than invitation, as though the years between you could simply be stepped across without acknowledgment.
One of your eyebrows lifted, and a small smile touched your lips.
â...Hello to you too, Thomas.â you spoke gently, almost amused, though there was something else beneath it that he couldn't quite place.
Thomas blinked once, almost as if he had forgotten that it was expected to greet someone first, then, despite himself, the corner of his mouth shifted into the faintest hint of a smile.
Without another word he reached for your hand.
His touch remained careful, and when he turned your hand gently enough to press a brief kiss against your knuckles, the gesture felt strangely old-fashioned even for him.
Your laugh came softly.
âThere he is,â you hummed, shaking your head ever so slightly. âAlways the charmer.â
Thomas released your hand, âI've been called worse.â
âI imagine you have.â
For a heartbeat you simply looked at him, studied him.Â
Your eyes lingered over the faint lines time had etched into his face, the shadows beneath his eyes. You looked as though you were trying to find the young man you'd once known somewhere beneath the man standing before you now.
Perhaps you did.
Perhaps you didn't.
â...One drink,â you agreed finally, lifting your glass slightly before setting it back upon the bar. âI can spare one.â
Thomas inclined his head, âThis way.â
The private room remained much as it always had.
Separated from the bustling public bar by a heavy wooden door, it offered a welcome silence that muffled the music outside into little more than a distant melody.Â
Thomas pulled out a chair for you, you thanked him quietly before sitting.
Only once you had settled did he lower himself into the chair opposite.
The silence between you wasn't awkward.
It was...
Careful.
A barman appeared moments later, âThe usual, Mr. Shelby?â
Thomas nodded once, âA bottle.â
The man disappeared without another word.
When the whiskey arrived, Thomas poured two generous glasses before reaching into the pocket of his waistcoat, producing a polished silver cigarette case that had accompanied him for years.
He opened it, âCigarette?â
You looked at them for only a moment before giving a small nod, âThank you.â
You selected one, Thomas took another for himself before striking a match against the edge of the table.
The flame flared softly between you, he leaned forward first, allowing the end of your cigarette to catch the flame in an orange glow. Then he brought the match to his own.
For one suspended moment your faces hovered only inches apart, separated by little more than the tiny dancing flame reflected within your eyes.
Thomas caught the faint scent of lavender again.
Something inside him tightened unexpectedly.
He extinguished the match with a quiet flick of his fingers.
Both of you leaned back, smoke drifting lazily toward the ceiling.
âSoâŚâ Thomas began after taking a slow drag from his cigarette, watching the smoke curl between the two of you. âWhat brings you back to Birmingham?â
You wrapped both hands around your whiskey glass, your thumbs tracing absent circles against the cool crystal before answering.
âMy family stopped not far from here,â you explained calmly. âWe'll only be staying for the week before moving north again.â
Thomas nodded once, âA week.â
âMm.â
Your eyes wandered briefly toward the rain-speckled window.
âI thought I'd visit a few familiar places while I had the chance.â
There was something thoughtful in the way you said it. Something that made Thomas wonder whether the Garrison had been one of those places intentionally...
Or merely happened to be along the way.
Before he could ask, you looked back at him, âAnd you? How has life been treating you?â
A faint smile crossed your face as you continued speaking, âI've heard plenty about Shelby business⌠But not much about Thomas business.â
The distinction lingered between you, for a brief moment he considered answering with the usual response.
Busy.
Fine.
Working.
Instead...
âMy wife died.â
The words arrived simply, without embellishment or self-pity.
âNot long ago.â he added.Â
The warmth left your expression almost immediately, your fingers stilling around the glass.Â
âOhâŚâ you breathed the single word so quietly it was almost swallowed by the rain beyond the window.
âI'm sorry.â you spoke gently, holding his gaze, âI didnât knowâ
Thomas gave a slight nod, and silence settled again. Heavy silence.Â
You searched his face carefully before speaking once more âHow are you holding up?â
It was such an ordinary question. Yet Thomas found he had no ordinary answer. He looked down into the amber whiskey swirling gently within his glass, watching the lamp's reflection distort across its surface.
â...I just am.â he spoke, his voice carried no bitterness, no anger, only exhaustion.
âI wake up. I work. I sleep.â Thomas explained as if it was the simplest thing in the world.Â
Your expression softened almost imperceptibly, not with pity for the man sitting in front of you, you knew he wouldnât enjoy it. It was something more difficult to name.
You looked at him for a long moment, your cigarette forgotten between elegant fingers as smoke curled lazily upward, and Thomas found himself unable to decipher what rested behind your eyes.
There was familiarity there.
Perhaps affection.
Perhaps only compassion.
Perhaps nothing more than the sadness one feels when confronted by someone they once loved...
Or someone they almost had.
The rain had strengthened outside.
The bottle of whiskey between you had lowered considerably, though neither of you had spoken enough to explain where the missing liquor had gone. Smoke hung lazily beneath the ceiling, illuminated by the warm amber glow of the oil lamp resting between your glasses, softening the sharp lines of Thomas' face until he looked almost as though he'd stepped out of another lifetime.
He watched you, not openly or with great greed, but his eyes were on you constantly.Â
Every now and then your fingers would brush the rim of your glass, or you would tuck a loose strand of hair behind your ear, and each small movement seemed to pull another memory from somewhere deep inside him. It was unfair how easily you still occupied the spaces of his mind he had spent years trying to seal shut.
You had changed.
So had he.
Yet sitting across from you now, with the rain falling beyond the windows and whiskey warming his chest, it became dangerously easy to imagine that the years between you had never existed at all.
He should have known better.
Thomas finished what remained in his glass before setting it quietly upon the table.
His blue eyes found yours once again, âCome home with me.â
He spoke those words without hesitation, without the careful courtship most men might have attempted.
You didn't look offended. Instead, you blinked once before a small, almost disbelieving smile appeared at the corner of your lips.
â...Thomas.â you breathed his name more than you spoke it, lowering your gaze briefly toward your whiskey before looking back at him.
âYou really haven't changed in that regard.â
He said nothing. He simply waited. Perhaps somewhere inside himself he had already convinced himself that you would say yes. Perhaps grief had made him reckless. Perhaps loneliness had.
You rested your cigarette between your fingers, studying the glowing ember for a long moment before speaking.
â...No.â
The answer came quietly, kindly.
Thomas remained perfectly still.
âNo?â he repeated, his voice calm enough that another man might have mistaken him for indifferent.
You offered the faintest shake of your head, âNo.â
Silence followed.
You searched his face for something, whether understanding, disappointment, or irritation, even you weren't entirely certain, but Thomas' expression remained frustratingly unreadable.
âI'm glad we spoke tonight,â you continued after a moment, your tone gentle enough that it almost hurt more than cruelty would have. âTruly.â
You smiled again, small this time, âButâŚâÂ
You looked down into your glass before emptying the last of it in one slow sip.
âI think it's better if I go.â
Thomas felt something tighten inside his chest, the sort of ache that settled between ribs rather than striking the heart.
He wanted to ask,Â
Better for whom?
Better because tonight wasn't the night?
Or because there would never be another?
But he remained silent. The uncertainty lingered between you like the cigarette smoke drifting lazily through the warm light.
You stood slowly, smoothing invisible creases from the skirt of your violet dress before reaching for your coat draped neatly across the back of your chair.
Thomas watched every movement. You finished the last draw of your cigarette before pressing it gently into the ashtray beside the bottle, twisting it once until the ember disappeared into ash.
Then you stepped around the table.
For one brief moment you stood beside him, close enough that Thomas could once again catch the familiar scent of lavender mingling with tobacco and rain.
He looked up, seeing that soft smile of yours again.Â
âIt was good seeing you again.â you spoke, before he could answer, you leaned down.
Your lips brushed his cheek, the kiss lasted scarcely longer than a heartbeat.
And after the shattered second of familiar warmth, you drew away.Â
âGoodnight, Thomas.â
You spoke the words quietly.
Whether they sounded like a farewell or merely the end of an evening...
Even Thomas couldn't decide.
He watched you cross the room, watched your hand settle upon the brass handle, watched you disappear through the door without looking back.
The latch clicked shut and silence returned.
For several long moments Thomas didn't move.
His fingers lifted almost unconsciously to the place upon his cheek where your lips had rested.
The warmth had already faded.
He poured himself another whiskey. Then another. The first disappeared too quickly to taste. The second burned all the way down.
He replayed the conversation again and again, searching for certainty where none existed.
You hadn't looked disgusted.
You hadn't been angry.
You hadn't told him never to ask again.
You had simply...
Said no.
But no to what?
To him?
Or only to the suddenness of the question?
He hated not knowing.
The Garrison finally emptied sometime after midnight.
One by one, the patrons spilled out into the quiet streets of Small Heath. Rain still lingered in the air, though only as a fine mist now, leaving the cobblestones slick beneath the glow of gas lamps that burned like little pools of amber against the darkness.Â
Thomas adjusted the collar of his overcoat as he stepped outside. The whiskey sat pleasantly warm in his stomach, dulling the sharper edges of the evening without quite stealing his senses. He wasn't drunk enough to forget, and he doubted he ever could.
Arthur stumbled through the doorway, already laughing at something neither Thomas nor John had heard, one hand slung carelessly around his younger brother's shoulders.
âI'm tellin' youâŚâ Arthur barked between bursts of laughter, nearly losing his balance before catching himself against the wall of the pub. â...that bloke never saw it comin'.â
John snorted loudly. âHe definitely saw your fist comin'.â
Arthur erupted into another fit of laughter.
Thomas merely glanced at them before beginning the familiar walk home.
The three brothers moved through the streets together, their shoes splashing through shallow puddles left behind by the rain. Somewhere nearby, a stray dog barked before disappearing into an alleyway, while distant church bells announced the late hour with slow chimes.
Thomas walked slightly ahead, his hands buried deep inside the pockets of his coat and his thoughts elsewhere.
He hadn't stopped thinking about you, not for a single moment. He could still picture the way the lamplight had caught in your eyes, still feel the feather-light brush of your lips against his cheek, still hear the uncertainty inside your goodbye.
âGoodnight, Thomas.â
He replayed the words endlessly, searching them, dissecting them, finding meanings that changed every time he examined them. Had there been regret? Closure? Or had he imagined all of it because grief had made him desperate enough to mistake it for possibility?
âOi!â
Arthur's voice dragged him back. Thomas looked over his shoulder.Â
Arthur pointed vaguely toward a narrow side street. âI've gotta piss.â
âMe too,â John added immediately, already veering away from the main road with considerably less coordination.
Thomas sighed quietly through his nose, âI'll wait.â
The two younger brothers disappeared into the alley without another word, Arthur still muttering something incoherent while John laughed at a joke only the two of them seemed to understand.
Thomas continued another few steps before stopping in the centre of the small square.
There, illuminated by little more than the trembling glow of two gas lamps, stood the old stone well.
It had been there longer than he could remember. Thomas had never given it much thought.
He rested one hand against the weathered stone rim. Rainwater still clung to its surface, cold against his palm.
Thomas lowered his head.
He wondered where you were now, whether you'd already returned to wherever you were staying, whether you had fallen asleep, whether you'd thought about him at all after leaving the Garrison... or whether he'd simply become another familiar face encountered during your brief return to Birmingham.
âTommy!â John's voice rang loudly through the quiet square.
Thomas didn't turn. âWhat?â
John leaned around the corner of the alley, still very much occupied relieving himself against the brick wall, his words carrying far louder than necessary, âWhy didn't you shag her?â
Arthur burst into another drunken laugh.
âYeah!â he shouted, his voice echoing off the surrounding buildings. âShe's got great tits!â
Thomas remained facing the well, his jaw tightening almost imperceptibly, âIt wasn't like that.â
John laughed loudly, âBollocks! You practically stared holes through the poor woman all night!â
âShould've just taken her home!â, Arthur chimed in with another laugh.
Thomas said nothing. There was nothing worth saying.
His fingers searched automatically through the pocket of his coat for his cigarette case. Instead, something small slipped free, and a dull metallic sound struck the cobblestones.
Thomas frowned and looked down.
The silver coin.
For a moment he simply stared at it lying there. He'd almost forgotten about it, the old woman, the fair, the strange feeling that had lingered after she'd vanished.
He bent down and picked the coin up between thumb and forefinger. It felt just as unnaturally cold as before.
Thomas turned it slowly, the unfamiliar symbols seeming almost to shimmer beneath the damp light.
He scoffed quietly. âRidiculousâŚâ he muttered beneath his breath.
He was Thomas Shelby. He believed in guns, money, power, and consequences, not charms, not curses, not wishing wells.
Behind him Arthur shouted something unintelligible, followed by John's booming laughter.
Thomas looked down into the darkness below.
The water rested perfectly still. He sighed, more at himself than anything else, then, with an almost embarrassed flick of his thumb, he tossed the coin.
It spun once, then twice, silver catching the light for the briefest heartbeat before disappearing into the darkness of the water below. A soft splash echoed upward, and ripples spread across the water.
Thomas watched them without knowing why.
It was foolish, childish, meaningless.
Still...
The words left him before he could stop them.
âI wishâŚâ
His voice was barely more than a whisper, â...I wish she'd love meâŚâ
He closed his eyes for only a second.
â...and never leave me again.â
Silence answered him.
Thomas let out a quiet, almost self-conscious breath through his nose before reaching once more for his cigarettes.
âBloody stupid,â he muttered to himself.
He struck a match.
The cigarette caught.
Behind him, Arthur finally emerged from the alley, buttoning his trousers while John followed a moment later, still chuckling to himself.
âYou comin', Tommy?â Arthur called, swaying slightly where he stood.
Thomas took one slow drag from the cigarette before turning away from the well.
âYeah.â
âââ ę° đŞť ęą âââ
peaky blinders taglist . . .â§Ëę°đęąŕźâ§@drunkcigarettes-jpg @lucellu @hagarsays @afw5 @ourtiger04 @tsreader @jbrownta
a/n: I'm kind of loving this series... we love a slightly pathetic Tommy and his unknowingly irreversibly horrible actions














