Eddie Munson x Fem!Reader (Part 3)
Summary - Slow-burn romance in 1986 Hawkins. A new girl transfers to Hawkins High, catching the attention of Eddie Munson and the patient game of hearts begins.
Fluff, slow-burn, no Vecna. Just Hawkins, Hellfire, and a new girl.
Word Count - Around 2300✨✨
Song inspiration - Summer Of ‘69 by Bryan Adams released in 1984
—————————————————————————
Family Video had a way of trapping time.
The fluorescent lights hummed overhead, constant and faintly irritating, while the bell above the door rang at irregular intervals. The air smelled like plastic VHS cases and microwave popcorn that had been sitting too long under the warmer. It wasn’t glamorous. It wasn’t exciting.
You slid a tape into the rewinder, watching it spin fast enough to blur, and let your thoughts drift the way they always did during the quiet parts of a shift.
Robin was perched on the counter, legs crossed at the ankles, reading the back of a movie case with exaggerated seriousness. Steve stood a few feet away, reorganizing a shelf that was already perfectly organized.
“You know,” Robin said suddenly, “this movie claims it’s ‘heartwarming.’ That’s how you know someone cries in it.”
Steve snorted. “That’s not true.”
“Oh, it absolutely is,” she replied. “If a movie says it’s heartwarming, someone’s parent dies, or a dog learns a life lesson.”
You smiled faintly, sliding the tape back into its sleeve.
Family Video had been an accident. A good one. Dustin had dragged you there one afternoon like it was the most obvious thing in the world, introducing you to Steve with too much enthusiasm and Robin with zero warning. Somehow, two days later, you were clocking in for your third shift of the week.
It helped. Having somewhere to be. Something that expected you to show up.
Still, your mind wandered.
It always did, back to Hawkins High, back to that corner table.
Dustin, of course, was the loudest presence in your thoughts. He checked in constantly, like he was afraid you’d disappear if he didn’t keep an eye on you. He walked you to school, walked you home, knocked on your door just to tell you something he’d forgotten earlier.
He made Hawkins feel smaller. Safer.
Mike was quieter, but steady. He always made room at the table, always included you in the conversation even when it veered into rapid-fire D&D jargon. When you didn’t understand something, he explained without making it feel like a test.
Lucas noticed things. That was his way of caring. He asked if you’d eaten. Asked how your classes were going. Once, when you looked tired, he slid his drink across the table without a word.
Gareth and Jeff were chaos incarnate, but in a strangely comforting way. Gareth liked to tease, liked to push buttons, but he always checked your reactions first. Jeff explained rules patiently, walked you through dice mechanics like it mattered that you understood.
And Grant, quiet, observant Grant, sat beside you more often than not, notebook always open, scribbling stats or sketches. He didn’t talk much, but he listened. Really listened.
They all cared differently.
You hadn’t realized how much that mattered until now.
“You’re doing the stare again,” Robin said.
You blinked, looking up. “What?”
“The one where your eyes go glassy and you look like you’re narrating a coming-of-age movie in your head,” she said. “It’s very artsy.”
Steve glanced over. “She’s thinking too hard. That’s usually the problem.”
“I’m literally just standing here,” you protested.
“That’s when it happens,” Robin said gravely.
You laughed under your breath, leaning against the counter. “I was just thinking about my friends.”
Steve raised an eyebrow. “The dungeon kids?”
“They’re not just-” you stopped yourself, then sighed. “Yeah. Them.”
Robin’s interest sparked immediately. “Okay but I like them already. Anyone who commits to a theme that hard is my kind of people.”
“They’re good,” you said simply.
The bell chimed, cutting the conversation short. A middle-aged man stepped in, scanning the shelves like he was afraid something might jump out at him. You greeted him automatically, slipping back into the routine.
Check out. Rewind. Shelve.
Still, your thoughts drifted.
And inevitably, they circled back to Eddie Munson.
He didn’t take up space the way the others did. Didn’t demand attention. Didn’t make himself known. He lingered at the edges, watching, listening, noticing.
You’d caught him looking more than once. Never staring. Never obvious. Just present.
He didn’t tease you like Gareth. Didn’t explain things like Jeff. Didn’t chatter like Dustin.
But he always made sure there was room at the table.
Always made sure you weren’t interrupted.
Once, when a comment about Hellfire had turned sharp, Eddie had leaned forward just enough to redirect the conversation. You hadn’t thanked him. He hadn’t looked at you.
“Earth to new girl,” Steve said, waving a hand in front of your face. “You okay?”
“Yeah,” you said quickly. “Just thinking.”
Steve nodded, expression softer. “Hawkins does that.”
Later, during a lull, Robin leaned over the counter. “You’re settling in,” she said.
She smiled. “That’s how it starts. Quietly.”
The shift ended with the sun low in the sky, light spilling through the front windows in warm streaks. You clocked out, pulled on your jacket, and stepped outside into the cooling air.
Dustin was already there, bike tipped against the curb, grinning like he’d been waiting all day.
As you headed down the street, you thought about your house waiting for you. The lights. The quiet. The way Hawkins was slowly, carefully making space for you.
And somewhere, just out of sight, Eddie Munson existed. Patient, unreadable, unhurried.
Like he was rolling the dice.
And willing to wait for the outcome.
—————————————————————————
Dustin found the tape in the last box.
The one marked MISC. in uneven black marker, shoved into the corner of your living room like it had been forgotten on purpose. The house was quieter now, most of the boxes gone, furniture finally in place, the late afternoon sun slanting through the windows.
Dustin sat cross-legged on the floor, surrounded by old notebooks and tangled cords, rifling through the box with the kind of curiosity only he possessed.
“Hey,” he said suddenly. “What’s this?”
You were in the kitchen, wrestling with a stubborn cabinet door. “If it’s another extension cord, throw it-”
“No,” he interrupted. “It’s a tape.”
You stepped into the doorway just as he lifted it fully into the light. The label was handwritten, slightly smudged with age.
[Your Old School’s Name] — Varsity Cheer, 1985
Dustin blinked. Once. Twice.
“…You were a cheerleader?”
You closed your eyes. Just briefly. “Put it back.”
He looked from the tape to you, disbelief written all over his face. “You never said you were a cheerleader.”
“This is not a ‘never came up’ thing,” he said. “This is a you did not disclose vital information thing.”
You crossed your arms. “It was a year ago.”
Dustin grinned like he’d just uncovered buried treasure. “Do you have a VCR?”
Fifteen minutes later, the tape was in the VCR you’d inherited with the house, humming softly as it rewound.
The screen flickered to life.
Static buzzed, then cleared.
A football field filled the frame. Stadium lights. A crowd roaring in the background.
Hair pulled back, uniform crisp, movements sharp and confident. You smiled on screen, bright and sure, lifting another girl into the air like it was nothing. You hit every move cleanly, landed every jump perfectly.
“That’s you,” Dustin said quietly, like he was afraid to break something.
You leaned against the wall, arms wrapped around yourself. “Yeah.”
The tape rolled on. Chants, stunts, the crowd reacting to you. Dustin didn’t say anything for a long moment.
Then, softer, “Why didn’t you tell me?”
You hesitated. “It just… feels like another life.”
The tape clicked to a stop.
The front door creaked open not long after, Eddie Munson’s voice carrying in from the hallway.
“Henderson, if you’re stealing her snacks again-”
He stopped short when he saw the TV.
Paused mid-frame, you were frozen in motion, mid-jump, hair flying, confident smile caught forever.
Dustin looked between the two of you. “Did you know she was a cheerleader?”
Eddie’s eyes shifted to you. Slow. Careful.
“No,” he said. Then, after a beat, “Can’t say I did.”
You braced yourself for a comment.
Instead, Eddie nodded once, almost to himself. “Takes a lot of work,” he said. “People think it’s easy. It’s not.”
He met your eyes briefly, really looked at you and then glanced away, like he’d said more than he meant to.
“Guess you’ve got layers,” he added lightly.
Dustin beamed. “Told you she was cool.”
Eddie smirked faintly, shoving his hands into his pockets. “Yeah,” he murmured. “I’m starting to see that.”
And just like that, something shifted.
Like Eddie Munson had rolled the dice again.
And gotten a result he hadn’t expected.
—————————————————————————
Authors Note - I keep on bringing up the dice because of the entire “Roll for Patience” but I’m not entirely sure if I like it.
Also this is actually two chapters that I smushed together. So I hope it’s good🤍.
With Robin and Steve I tried to show their friendship like it is in the show but it’s actually kinda hard. I’m trying🥹.