Unpolished Musings
Had some interesting conversation with one of my co-workers today😅
He asked me if I've watched any new shows while we had the season off work🙃
I'm still sorta new to anime, but yeah, I started with MHA, went to Dr. Stone, watched season one of Rising of the Shield Hero before I stopped it🙃 Solo Levelling, and I've watched all except for the finale of AOT.
So we started talking about that. He said he hasn't watched AOT, but he's kept up with the plot through other people who've watched it. And we kinda commented on Hype-Train Mechanics and why we kinda just avoided it when it first came out.
I said I started watching it once before, but didn't get more than a few episodes in before quiting it cuz of the gore, but now that I'm older, I guess I have a thicker skin...?🙃 And the only reason I actually started watching it again was cuz that song that goes "If the world was ending I'd wanna be next to youuuuuu" and someone made a post saying "this song is about AOT", and my brother was looking up stuff about it, too, and found a post of someone online saying "AOT is basically 'If the jews deserved it'." And the combination of those two things is what made me wonder "What the hell is going on in this show?" Lol so I watched it.
I kinda just started explaining why it's NOT even that🤣 Cuz like the Marleyan's are all about "Eldians are Bad and forced others to Bare their Children and this and that, and Island Devils blah blah blah" the rebels are like "Ymir was Good and built bridges and Roads and all this and that!"
But in MY mind being Eldian and being "A Child A Ymir" are TOTALLY seperate things, first of all, because YMIR WAS A SLAVE! She didn't CHOOSE to do any of those things. She was FORCED to do the Eldian King's biddng and bare the Eldian King's children, who were then forced into a life by their King and Father who they HAD to obey. And I was kinda surprised when my co-worker actually seemed to be in agreement with me on this, cuz when I was saying this same thing to my brother, he acted like he didn't get what I was saying at all...🙃
So then I got kinda excited and started going on to say that when "The Mainland" came into the show, it was actually hugely disappointing to me. I lost so much interest in the show after that, but I kept watching it pretty much just to get it over with(which, also when I said this to my brother, he acted like that didn't make any sense either🙃) and my co-worker was like "ExACTLY bruh!"
I even said I don't even really know WHY it was such a disappointment, but he goes "I mean, it's cuz it turned into a Man-vs-Man. Cuz BEFORE it was kinda like a whole 'We're all Human' kinda thing, and it pretty much did a whole 180°."
And I😦 Duh... yeah, pretty much. Exactly that😅 Essentially a whole Genre shift, there🙃
And we started talking about Eren's character and all that stuff, and my co-worker was talking about "WHY did he have to go THAT far, though, bruh."
And to me it WAS disappointing the way they took his character, it felt like a huge let down, but at the same time He's Limited, his time as a Titan is Almost Up, he's Desperate, everything that's happened to him and his people is Essentially All the Marleyan's Doing: terrorized by Titan's for how ever long, controlling/commanding/weaponzing the Mainland Eldians, threatening to wipe out everyone he has LEFT in the world and make sure their last moments are filled with Terror. He could have found a way to expose the truth of Ymir to the world, maybe, but there really wasn't any guarantee that it would change ANYTHING or save ANYONE, and all he really WANTED is to save whatever family he has left. To let them Live Out their lives in Peace. Specifically THEIR lives. No regard for the future, no care for the past. And the only way to "make peace" is to be sure NO ONE can ever threaten them again... and how do that? Basically destroy the entire rest of the world. It's the only sure way🙃
So, yeah it was super disappointing how it went, but I still kinda get WHY Eren went the way he did.
Even so😑 what was the point?
That mass extinction and Genocide is unavoidable?😑
Marlryans: Bias and Fear "Eldian's Must Pay for their Sins. Wipe out the Island Devils."
Bad.
Zeke: "Let Time Erase all Eldians and their suffering from the Earth."
Still Bad.
Eren: "I deserve to Live in the world I was Born in. You kill and threaten all that matters to me, I will protect them By Any Means Necessary While I Still Have The Power. No one will threaten them again. No one will be LEFT to threaten them."
Born of Desperation and a Literal Death Deadline that you can sort of understand, but STILL BAD!
So that's the bit that my Co-worker had a problem with "What was even the Message, here? That genocide is unavoidable? Bruh. That's not true!" And I kinda can't stop thinking about it.
For real, what IS the message?
Cuz it COULD have been avoidable, so what was the point of dragging it down this road?
I guess it COULD have been something to do with the lessons of history, maybe?
I mean, with the Marleyan's they had a Version of history that paints Eldians as evil beings. The Rebels had only Glimpses of a Beneficial History and Assumed the Marleyan's version was all lies and fables to guilt them into suppression and slavery.
The only one who had the full scope, the full Picture, the history witnessed and explained in it's ENTIRETY was Eren... but he has other things in mind. He doesn't care about Educating anyone. Like I said before, he has no guarantees about taking that direction, and he's running out of time. But he's essentially disregarding the past and any future AFTER a lifetime. He doesn't care what happens AFTER all his friends grow old and die. He just wants THEM to be able to have peace in their lifetimes on the island and everyone else be damned.
So I guess in that way it COULD be a commentary on what false/broken/disregarded histories can lead to...? Maybe? Idk, but now I can't stop thinking about it...
Anyway! It was an interesting day and an interesting conversation!😀👍

















