you mentioned that you were inspired by the vampire au of Marniesaras23 on ao3,
what are some of the punishments fledgeling shane might be subjected to other than spanking that might fit thematically with a supernatural au
and what would some reasons for punishment be? like refusing to feed from ilya, trying to escape, trying to hurt himself even, trying to hurt ilya
i REALLY love vampire aus so im really excited about this hehehe
I'm gonna be superrr NSFW with this answer lol, but I LOVE this question. I still want to return to writing the vampire AU, but for whatever reason, my muse for it fled before I ever finished The Turning, and I'm not sure why. (My muse will return at some point though; she always does.) I also still love the Marniesaras23 take on the fledgling trope!! Their fics are sooo cute!!
For the AU, I was envisioning a hierarchy where Ilya is over Shane but falls somewhere in the middle of the coven power structure. In case it isn't obvious yet, I loveeee writing out tropes where Ilya is protecting Shane from someone scary, so I was wanting to incorporate that into this AU. I was picturing a structure where sires have a great deal of power over their fledglings. The coven would be led by Ilya's sire, an ancient vampire who turned Ilya, who I would introduce as an OC. (I considered making Ilya's sire Grigori, at first, but it made me feel a little incestual, which is not a kink I personally enjoy!) The world is a dangerous place for vampires, who are hidden from humans, and they do best when living in covens, which allows them to have long-running relationships, in addition to security. The coven is made up of maybe 50 or so vampires, including other vampires sired by Ilya's sire, in addition to their fledglings.
In order to keep the peace and maintain order, Ilya's sire rules over them with an iron first, which also involves a lot of harder-core kinky/sexual punishments and rewards. The idea behind it was that these punishments that rely on pain/humiliation are easy to inflict and also uniquely suited for immortal beings, because when you're immortal, pleasure and pain is all that's left. I was thinking about things like lashings or spankings, but also more vampire-specific punishments, which play on the mythological vulnerabilities to garlic and iron. For example, being forced to ride a metal dildo that has some non-fatal percentage of iron, so that when the vampire is done, they're left with a burning, quivering hole that is swollen and sore and hot for a few weeks. I was also thinking about variations of figging that use garlic paste instead of ginger, just for the campiness of it all. I think it would be fun to incorporate some sort of vampire-culture specific takes on humiliation, but I'm not too sure what I would do. Nothing has really come to me yet on that front.
While the relationship between Ilya's sire and the other vampires would be a more dungeon BDSM vibe, I want the relationship between Ilya and Shane to be a muchhhh softer, more domestic-discipline vibe. The idea would be that Shane is a young fledgling, and baby fledglings aren't strong enough to be punished by the coven leader! They need to be acclimatized to life as a vampire and taught the rules of the coven, first. Fledglings also aren't strong enough to handle whippings or iron, so instead they're given over-the-knee spankings and such. I was envisioning Ilya being so so so soft with Shane, who is absolutely the most spoiled fledgling ever. Shane would be kind of bratty about being babied, at least until he learns about what it entails to be punished as an adult vampire. I've also seen a few fledgling AUs where sire venom has an influence on fledglings, either making them calm/horny/obedient, etc., and I would like to incorporate that in some sense, but I haven't decided how yet!
I think the flip side, though, is that Ilya is responsible for Shane's behavior, since he's the one who turned him. If Shane runs afoul of the coven leader, it is Ilya who is punished. I had an angsty scene idea where Ilya comes back to their quarters with his back bloodied from taking a flogging, and Shane cries as he licks his sire's back to close the wounds, so I want to create some tension within the coven power structure. I don't know if the overarching goal would be for Shane/Ilya to leave the coven or for the coven leadership to change, but I was thinking of doing something there!
In terms of what Shane would be punished for, I think all of your ideas would be punishable offenses! I think refusing to feed is the one Shane is the most likely to do, which I could see being a repeated issue. I don't think he would try to hurt Ilya, but he might do something that puts himself in danger. He also might rebel by trying to sneak off for a little while, if he's feeling too watched. I think other things like disrespecting older vampires (especially if vampires are considered aggressive, hierarchical beings) could get him in trouble. I think Shane also might just be generally "willful" over finding himself under Ilya's control, so there would be a bit of a power struggle there. It's very different from omega!Shane, who was brought up in a hierarchical society. This iteration of Shane would be adjusting to a new hierarchy he had never even heard of!! And I think there would be additional growing pains, there.
Anyways, I am sooo sorry to ramble, but I hope this answers your question!!! Thank you for asking it!! 💓💓💓