So I was lurking your blog. I think it’s fine for people to ship dark ships like Max x Jefferson but I confess I am shocked hearing you talk of how bad Chloe is for Max when Jefferson kidnaps Max, drugs her more than once against her will and ties her up all without her consent. She’s scared in scenes with him, pleading with him to stop. He doesn’t. He even tries to overdose her. Curious on why you’d think Pricefield is bad when Chloe would never in a million years hurt Max like HE hurts her?
Jefferson might've hurt Max mentally (insulting her) / physically (a slap) during episode 5 -- a scenario which gets rewound in either canon ending, this means that, in Jefferson's point of view, he never ever hurt Max.
To me, this is not comparable to the ordeal Chloe's been putting Max through for years since their childhood. What we see in the game is but a slice of the abuse Chloe is used to inflict towards Max.
Let's take this 'moment of calm' from inside the Price house as some of the most important evidences of the abuse Max's been through:
Chloe: "Come on, open it chicken!"
Max: "Hold on. And I'm not chicken!"
Chloe: "Prove it! You drink first, Max!"
Max: "No way! It was your idea, Chloe!"
Chloe: "Whateva. Give me that bottle."
Max: "Well?"
Chloe: "Tasty. Very tasty."
Max: "Here, I want a sip!"
Chloe: "Sorry, this is not for kids."
Max: "Don't be greedy! Gimme some!"
Chloe: "Oh shit, the carpet!"
Max: "There's wine all over! What do we do now?"
Chloe: "My parents are coming! Cover it up..."
First of all we have Chloe insulting Max by calling her a chicken. Next Chloe pushes the transgression into Max first, and when Max refuses, Chloe quickly ploys a way to taunt Max into becoming willing to share the transgression with her, by assuring she liked it. When they spill the wine into the carpet though, Chloe orders Max to cover it, as if it was Max's responsibility (a mere guest at the Price house), not Chloe's.
Later in that same video, starting at 5:02, we have another 'moment of calm' where we can spot some most subtle nods to abusive behaviors coming from Chloe:
Max: "What do you truly want to do when you grow up?"
Chloe: "Max, I'm already grown up. What about you?"
Max: "Travel. That would be awesome. Explore the world. Go far from here..."
Chloe: "Far from me? Thanks a lot, dude."
(...)
Chloe: "Count me in. What would you do while I was bodyguarding you?"
Max: "Maybe take pictures of our adventures. I would love to be a photographer. As if I ever could be..."
Chloe: "What are you talking about? Max, you are a photographer. Your pictures could be in a museum. Someday they will. I believe in you..."
So Chloe thinks she's too grown up compared to Max, which is a display of her 'authority' over Max, as if Max must submit only because Chloe is older. Then when Max expresses the idea of fleeing far away, Chloe makes haste in guilt-tripping Max to say she should bring Chloe together. Later on, the expression "bodyguarding you" is the one which raises the biggest red flag in all this, because Chloe is masking her stalking into 'protection' for Max. Finally, when Max displays lack of confidence in her own skills, Chloe says her pictures COULD be in a museum, Chloe is feeding Max's anxiety instead of assuring her she WILL SURELY be in a museum.
You notice how Chloe carefully words her intentions in a way which is very dangerous for Max, damaging her self-esteem over and over, in just a single convo?
Now imagine years of constant bullying coming from your supposedly 'best friend', someone who should've wish you only the best, but ultimately treated you very, VERY poorly, so poorly that, when you see yourself suddenly free of them (the trip to Seattle), you don't want to ever talk to them again, because subconsciously you know your perpetrator's been toxic to you and your anxiety leads you to avoid them -- there's butterflies in your stomach, whenever you pick up the phone you suddenly begin to sweat, you know you don't want to talk to them, you want to avoid them at all costs... you want to avoid them so hard that, when you come back to your hometown years later, you still won't look into contacting your perpetrator again.
Max wouldn't had contacted Chloe. It just happened they met, and Max was under the power from her childhood aggressor once again, unable to refuse because she's been conditioned to not refuse Chloe. Along the game we see numerous other moments where Chloe guilt-trips Max into doing all sorts of things for her, some we can refuse and some we are not even given a choice. Not to mention all the dangerous actions like waving guns towards Max, getting involved with people of power, we all know how the story ends -- Jefferson wouldn't kidnap Max if the Dark Room was not found by them, his plans were focused to get Victoria instead, she had a folder already while Max didn't.
Compare years of conditioning from Chloe directly with the behavior Jefferson displays along the game -- he's always willing to encourage Max to submit her artistic work, never gives up on Max, and when she's captured, he confesses to her that she was his winner all along. Jefferson never meant bad things for Max, but between protecting Max and protecting his Dark Room secret, he choose the later when he comes to acknowledge Max is willing to spill everything.
Yes, I believe Chloe is much worse for Max than Jefferson could ever be.