Now that I’ve been back a few days, I’ve had time and distance to reflect on my trip, and the amazing food odyssey that I experienced. As a part of that, I thought it would be interesting and fun to score the restaurants.
I decided to borrow my ranking system from the Washington Post’s Tom Sietsema. Here’s how it works:
First, any restaurant with a star is excellent. Just to make the list and be scored means that the place is worth a visit. The good news is that thanks to my research, I had very few restaurants come through with zero stars, but they’ve got their own space below. With that in mind, here’s what the various stars mean:
**** — Outstanding. Really something special. Usually marked by an interesting point of view, innovative or elevated approach to the food, technical excellence and great service. Among the best restaurant experiences I’ve had anywhere, beyond this trip.
*** — Excellent. Great food. Great service. But not quite as distinctive or elevated as a four star place.
** — Darn good. A place that I’d be happy to visit again.
* — Perfectly fine. Often these were places that I liked, and was glad to have tried, but wouldn’t go back.
0 — Crap. No good. I’m sorry I visited, and I discourage anyone else from going.
So, with the scoring system sorted, let’s look at the scores:
**** Stars
Outstanding, innovative and elevated.
Peg Leg Pete’s
Pensacola Beach, Florida
Michelin’s criteria for two stars is “excellent cooking, worth a detour.” I would happily plan a long weekend in Pensacola just to return to Peg Leg Pete’s. Yes, it’s a dive bar. Yes, the menu is almost entirely fried. Yes, the food was served on styrofoam. And I don’t care a whit. The seafood was fresh and perfectly cooked. The beer was local and excellent. The staff was kind and welcoming. And the Key Lime Pie was made by someone’s grandmother in her home kitchen. The bill was less than $30. For all of the high-end places I tried, this was the best meal of the trip.
Key Lime Pie at Peg Leg Pete’s.
Shagbark
Richmond, Virginia
Chef Walter Bundy spent years creating high-end, French-inspired classics at Lemaire. Now he’s using those techniques to elevate southern cuisine, making the most of local and seasonal products, and delivering something that’s next-level good. If a Michelin inspector ever made it to Richmond (fat chance), Shagbark would be worthy of serious consideration for a star. Bundy’s food isn’t as playful and evocative as Sean Brock’s: The experience is more serious and considered. But Shagbark would be a great restaurant in any city. Richmond is lucky to have it.
Pimento Cheese and Ham Salad at Shagbark.
Fisher’s
Orange Beach, Alabama
Fisher’s has pulled down big accolades. Like Brock and Bundy, Chef Bill Briand is elevating southern food, and using the best ingredients, plucked out of the sea and delivered to his kitchen from the fishermen who use his marina. I’m sorry I didn’t get to try his fine dining offering, but his ability to elevate a simple fish taco, reimagine sweet potatoes, and deliver it with a sense of humour across a bar tells me all I need to know. Like Peg Leg Pete’s, I would happily go out of my way to return to Fisher’s.
Ajax Diner
Oxford, Mississippi
Located on a busy town square in the middle of a college town, you could forgive the Ajax for turning out burgers and beers. Instead, they produce home cooked classics that you’d be happy to eat at your grandmother’s kitchen table. The Ajax was probably the most traditional place I went, but they embrace tradition all the way, revel in it, and turn out great food flavoured with love. If I lived in Oxford, I’d be a regular.
Meatloaf and sides at the Ajax Diner.
*** Stars
Excellent. Great food and service.
Commander’s Palace
New Orleans, Louisiana
High-class throw-back cooking in New Orleans most beautiful neighbourhood. What’s not to love? Great ingredients brought together into some of the south’s most iconic recipes. Service with a smile and laugh.
Gallatoire’s
New Orleans, Louisiana
Cornerstone of the French Quarter. Stand in line with local residents and well to-do out-of-towners, then revel in some of the best cooking around. Trust your waiter. They know what’s fresh and tasty.
Husk
Nashville, Tennessee
Sean Brock’s Nashville spot. His menu was playful and brilliant. The food was excellent. And I totally buy into his philosophy. I wish I’d been able to go for dinner, as I suspect that would have been a more elevated experience.
Indian Pass Raw Bar
Port St. Joe, Florida
They harvest the oysters, then shuck them, then bake them, in just a few hours. Serve yourself. Pay for what you eat and drink. Settle in for the afternoon, or the evening. Worth a detour. You won’t regret it.
Le Bakery
Biloxi, Mississippi
Vietnamese is now local cuisine across the gulf coast, and this is one of the best spots to find it. Fresh bread that a Parisienne would love. And you couldn’t find a better Banh Mi from Hanoi to Ho Chi Min City.
Monell’s
6th Avenue, Nashville, Tennessee
Home cooking around a communal table, making new friends over great food. What’s not to love? Ultra-traditional with fabulous flavours in big bowls. Another place that I’d love to be a regular.
Ravenous Pig
Winter Park, Florida
Husband and wife team, James and Julie Petrakis doing their bit to elevate and renew southern cooking with a real emphasis on pork. From the homemade bread to the pork porterhouse, I left happy and full.
The Regional Kitchen & Pub
West Palm Beach, Florida
Chef Lindsay Autry getting into the elevated southern game with her brilliant cooking. More homestyle than Husk or the Ravenous Pig, but building from underused classics like Devilled Crab. Homemade parker house rolls were a winner, too.
The Roosevelt
Richmond, Virginia
Chef Lee Gregory’s place helped renew Church Hill and contributed to Richmond’s food renaissance. The Roosevelt manages to balance fine dining and neighbourhood stalwart, with great food I’d be happy eating every day.
Sally Belly’s Kitchen
Richmond, Virginia
Nearly a hundred years old, and still delivering great food every day. If there’s better potato salad on the planet, I don’t know where to find it. Also, cupcakes. And egg salad. And, and, and. Visiting Richmond and missing Sally Bell’s should actually be a crime.
Spoonbread Bistro
Richmond, Virginia
Stylish spot in the Fan by Chef Michael Hall. Another perspective on elevating southern flavours. Local and fresh. Great food driven by clever ideas. Another place I’d be a happy regular.
** Stars
Darn good. Worthy of a return visit.
Allman’s Barbecue
Fredericksburg, Virginia
Great Virginia-style barbecue. A classic. Huge portions. Yes please.
Blue & White Diner
Tunica, Mississippi
Old-fashioned road-side diner with stellar Sunday buffet. The only place to eat in Tunica.
Cafe Bouchee
Franklinton, Louisiana
Superb local fare with a cajun accent. Worth passing by.
City Grocery
Oxford, Mississippi
Big reputation, but merely darn good. Chef Currence is evidently innovating elsewhere.
Dandguerre’s
Nashville, Tennessee
Local meat and three that the tourists haven’t found yet. Definitely worth trying.
The Kitchen
West Palm Beach, Florida
Weird atmosphere. Good food. Great coconut cake. That’s enough to bring me back.
NOLA
New Orleans, Louisiana
Emeril Lagasse’s French Quarter spot. Cajun reimagined sort of works.
Obrycki’s
BWI Airport, Maryland
Crab cakes in an airport. Are you kidding? No. If you’re in BWI, eat at Obrycki’s.
Pierce’s Pit Cooked Barbecue
Williamsburg, Virginia
Great Virginia-style barbecue. An institution.
Puckett’s
Nashville, Tennessee
Tasty breakfast. Favourite of local police. Good food and nice service.
St. Roche Market
New Orleans, Louisiana
Food truck food behind permanent counters. Glad I went. Wish I lived nearby.
Taylor Grocery
Oxford, Mississippi
Great catfish and other local delicacies.
* Stars
Perfectly fine, but I wouldn’t return.
Apalachicola Seafood Grill
Apalachicola, Florida
Local ingredients, but lacking the care and attention. Go elsewhere.
Away from the World Burger & Beer Bar
Cedar Key, Florida
Decent burgers with a view.
Ballpark of the Palm Beaches
West Palm Beach, Florida
Hot dog before the game, with a fixings bar that included sauerkraut. #winning
Brickhouse Barbecue
Columbia, Tennessee
Perfect adequate barbecue if you’re just passing through.
Cafe Beignet
New Orleans, Louisiana
Good beignets without the queues at Cafe du Mont. Next door to my hotel. Winner.
Champion Stadium
Lake Buena Vista, Florida
Hot dog before the game. Yes, please. And darn tasty.
Cilantro Mexican
Vicksburg, Mississippi
A much needed Mexican diversion.
Felix’s Oyster Bar
New Orleans, Louisiana
No substitute for Acme just across the street. Go there.
Pancho & Lefty’s Tacos
Nashville, Tennessee
Great tacos just off broadway.
Ruby Slippers
New Orleans, Louisiana
Breakfast to battle the French Quarter hang over, just outside the Quarter.
Starlite Lounge
Richmond, Virginia
Hangover cure: burger with chilli and a fried egg. Tastes better than it sounds.
0 Stars
Dreadful and Disastrous. Avoid.
The Island Restaurant
Cedar Key Florida
The infamous culinary crime. How could you serve clams and pasta with no sauce? I still can’t believe it. Catastrophic.
Mary Mahoney’s Old French House
Biloxi, Mississippi
Frozen in time, but in all of the wrong ways.
The Grill at Libbie and Patterson
Richmond, Virginia
Good sandwiches. Wretched service. Will never return.
Woolworth on 5th
Nashville, Tennessee
Great idea. Amazing history. Bad food. Rooting for it to get better.