Dating seguin and being insecure and trying to push him away and break up with him but he won’t let you
oh anon… how you know me so well
Okay so Im pretty sure you just wanted thoughts on this, but i had this idea and it just took form into a full imagine… SO ENJOY!
You Can’t Get Rid of me | Tyler Seguin |
Pairing: Tyler x Reader
Dating someone in the spotlight was never easy. Whether it be the constant comparisons between exes or self-doubts in general- often times You found yourself searching for reasons that explained why someone like Him, could like someone like you.
In your eyes, Tyler was everything- How could he not be? He was kind, funny, honest, loyal- not to mention his rockin bod- everything about him made you feel small in comparison.
It had been one of the main sources of your fights.
Another night of loud voices and slamming doors had ended with you sleeping in the guest room- Not because Tyler had asked you to, but because you were too stubborn to join him, Cash, Marshall and Gerry in the bedroom.
Tonight, the fight had been caused by Tyler asking you to go with him to a banquet- It was more or so a dinner with a few awards being handed out to players across the league, and as his girlfriend, he was expecting you to be in attendance.
In your mind, attending meant that you had to get dressed up in a fancy dress and heels- hair done and makeup perfect as you walked with Tyler as his arm candy for the night.
It wasn’t that you didn’t want to go, It was just that you felt as though you didn’t belong. You were never apart of his world, Hell you had met him at the gas station- the most average and mundane of places.
One of your biggest fears was making Tyler look bad, or him finally realizing that you just weren’t the effort or that you weren’t his type. You weren’t rich, you weren’t a model or the housewife type.
You hadn’t spoken to Tyler since the fight. The two of you were going on 7 days of not interacting and if you were being honest- you didn’t know where your relationship stood.
Had you two broken up?
Were you on a break?
Was this the end?
Swallowing your pride, you had gotten into contact with Katie- Jamie’s girlfriend and asked her to help you out. The two of you spent the entire day getting ready for the banquet, you were going to do this for Tyler, even if it meant bruising your ego.
As you stood at the entrance of the banquet hall, your whole body was tense- you hair was styled just the way you liked it and a red satin dress covered your every curve- perfectly complimenting you figure. Nude heels carried you towards the area where Jamie and The rest of the team was standing-
You had on a gold necklace and bracelet, both of which had been anniversary gifts from Tyler- holding your clutch against your stomach- you spotted him, His hair was slicked back and he was wearing a beautiful suit- It was grey and had soft intricate detailing along the sleeves- his dress shirt hugged his chest perfectly, but you could see the stress he was under-
From the furrow of his brows to the clenched strain against his jaw, his hands were typing furiously at his phone- his chest heaving from heavy breaths. As your own phone dinged- He looked up and spotted you.
Seeing you standing there, Tyler felt his heart clench. He got those sam butterflies that he first had that afternoon at the gas station and he sweared that you looked just as beautiful pumping gas as you did right now- dolled up for him.
“Tyler…” You breathed out heavily as you finally walked towards him. he hand immediately found your waist and he brought you close- kissing the top of your head and his free hand pressing against the side of your head.
“You came…” he spoke softly, his tone was drenched with an emotion you couldn’t quite place- it was somewhere between gratitude and shock.
Through the night, you had done your best to keep up with the mingling, talking to people Tyler introduced you to, and sticking rather close to him the entire night- his hand barely leaving your waist.
As you took a quick break from Katie and the other girlfriends to head to the ladies room, your eyes landed on Tyler and his teammates. He looked so happy and pleased, he fit in perfectly and as you looked around the room- you realized how out of place you were.
You were wearing a costume, but these women and men- this was their life, their environment. You were thriving. feeling yourself starting to become anxious and choked up, you snuck down a hallway and grabbed your phone.
“I need to go- I’m sorry, I cant do this.” You quickly texted Tyler.
As you tried to make your escape, Tyler quickly caught up to you- you were barely halfway down the street when the backdoor of the banquet hall opened and Tyler was jogging out.
“Y/N!” he called after you, quickly jogging to you and grasping your arm delicately, he noticed the tears in your eyes and the redness spreading across your face.
As you raised your hands and tried to step away from him, he placed his hands on your forearms- keeping you from taking off. “Tyler please let go- I can’t do this right now.” You spoke weakly.
Shaking his head, Tyler clenched his jaw. “No- you’re not doing this to me again- Why can’t you just come in and pretend that you’re enjoying the night?” he asked frustratedly.
your bottom lip trembled and instantly you felt all your emotions boil over. “Because thats what i’m doing Tyler! I am pretending!” You snapped.
“This is not my life! This is yours! I love you so much,,, But i cant do this- its over… You deserve so much more than me!” You protested. As Tyler stood there taking in your every word, you found yourself finally cracking.
“I can’t keep acting like somehow this all makes sense! I’m nothing Tyler- in comparison to all those other women in there, to everyone on your team with their fancy cars and their fancy clothes- in comparison to you…”
Your voice broke as he pulled you close- refusing to let you go as his arms wrapped around your waist. “I am nothing…” you breathed out.
Tyler gulped, you could feel him letting out a sigh- and it was in this moment that you thought everything had finally ended. He had finally given up and let you go. “Y/N… I don’t care if you’re rich or if you’re a model-” his own voice started to break and you cursed yourself for causing him so much pain.
“Hell… I would take you in sweatpants and in a grease stained shirt any day over someone so fake that I cant tell the difference between them and plastic.” he reassured you.
Pulling away just enough to cup your cheeks and look you in the eyes, Tyler smiled sadly. “I am nothing without you Y/N… and that might sound cliche- but i am tired of you pushing me away because you think you’re not good enough.” he spoke firmly.
“Y/N, You make me wanna be a better man- and i am so in love with you… So you can yell at me that you wanna break up and stomp away- but just know that tomorrow I will be at your front door- begging you to take me back until you finally do.” he chuckled softly.
You could help but lean into his touch as he wiped one of your stray tears- the two of you must have looked like a mess- standing on the street and pouring your hearts out to each other- but neither of you cared.
“You really mean that?” you asked him, a soft smile finally making It’s way onto your lips.
Tyler laughed and hugged you tightly, his head resting upon yours as he had you smothered into his chest. “Baby… You couldn’t get rid of me if you tried.”
All the good feels 😻


















