1. What is the purpose of a critique? Which particular critique conversation so far was most helpful, useful, or constructive for you as an artist? How did it inform or speak to what you do as an artist? Please describe.
For me, there are several central components that I look for in a critique about my work. First, I want to hear a gut reaction to my work from those viewing it. I look for how they react and interact with the pieces. This gives me a good, initial, idea of whether or not I am conveying what I want to convey. It also helps me to see potential implications of the work that I didn’t see myself. The second thing that I want in a critique is thoughtful feedback about how I could push the work farther. Hopefully, a critique will include thoughtful artists who have studied different things than I have. This provides a great collaborate conceptual arena to learn from others. Because these components are important to me, I try to give these types of feedback to others showing their work.
The critiques that helped me the most in my Senior Seminar class were the small group studio crits. This was an extremely valuable time where I could hear my peers’ individual opinions on my work and practice. In the class critiques, I think that we are not totally confident in what we have to say about another person’s work in front of such a large group. However, in these small critiques, we have time to hear more depth about the other artists’ work and respond without fear of sounding unintelligent. Since I was not in the other small groups, I cannot say what specific elements made my group so helpful comparatively. However, my group helped me define what it was that is important to me in my work. They also honestly (without judgement or dismissing my talents all together) what wasn’t working. This was helpful for me specifically, because I knew that those in my group cared about my success. They helped me see that the “janky” parts of my practice wasn’t working and suggested social practice.
2. What critique session was most challenging for you so far? What about the conversation challenged you? Please describe.
The beginning of the 6 Small Works critique was challenging for me. I do not claim to know the minds of the people around me as no one can ever truly understand what anyone else is thinking. From the initial comments being made about my work in this critique, it seemed as though those speaking were not giving my work proper respect. The thoughts that I receive in critiques are often reflections on how I am not a worthy designer. In my opinion, there should be negative feedback on work in a critique. But this should be for the purpose of helping the artist improve. Yet I often perceive an attitude from other designers toward my work that says, “give up because you failed in these ways.” I appreciate when others tell me my weaknesses, but only when it is not out of malice. Again, I may be misinterpreting how my classmates feel about my work. Unfortunately, without my prompting them, other students have come to me and noted how “weird” the feedback is in my critiques. In this crit, a few students began by giving all of the reasons why they didn’t think my work was art. Thankfully, my professor stepped in and changed the mood of the crit.
There was also a critique of another student’s that was difficult for me simply because of the subject matter. I found myself unable to even face the work because of my past experience with that topic. The work also offered me kindness and was not yelling at me, but was rather inviting me to come and consider it.
3. What is the role of the artist and the role of the viewer in the critique? How do you feel in these roles? What is the most meaningful viewing experience you’ve had so far this semester? Please describe.
I’m not sure what the artist’s role is in a critique. I think their role depends on the type of critique that is taking place. If it is the artist’s goal is to receive gut feedback from the viewer, then the artist should remain quiet at first. However, if the point of the crit is to get feedback from the full extent of concept behind the work, it might be valuable to speak first. Either way, the artist has a responsibility to listen well and be respectful to the comments of the viewer. If the artist wants to ask others to respond to their work, then they must be willing to kindly hear the viewer out.
The role of the viewer in a critique is to give the work the attention it deserves. My professor once told us to allow the work to speak to us. If we liked it, we should try to figure out why. If we did not like it, it was probably because there was something that we needed to reconsider in ourselves. It is important to be open to what the work is offering or saying. Sitting with the work before responding first, is a good habit. This way, the viewer can listen to the piece instead of trying to impose our own interpretation of it too quickly.
As I mentioned earlier, one of my classmate’s work was difficult but extremely meaningful for me. I felt like I wasn’t doing my part as a responsible viewer. I was unable to come close to consider the work. Instead, I tried to hide behind my fellow students to avoid facing the work. But I also tried not to completely disrespect the work by ignoring it. Thanks to my professor’s earlier advice about viewing art, I followed the disturbance where it led. I asked myself why this piece was bothering me so much and what was specific about this work that made me feel the way it did.
4. Do you think you were generous to your classmates in the critiques so far? Why or why not? What do you think would help you to be more involved and engaged in the conversation?
On the whole, I think that I was pretty average in my generosity in critiques. I wasn’t silent or ignoring the work, but I definitely could have put more effort into responding. I found that the more I knew about the work or had conversations previously with the artist, the better I engaged in the crit. When I consider the artist’s practice on a relatively consistent basis, I find that I have more to say or consider during the critique. With 22 students in our class, I don’t consider each work with the time it deserves. I also feel in critiques like with so many people, my responsibility to respond is far less. This is one of the reasons why the small group studio visits are so helpful. I need to engage with the work because there are so few of us besides the artist. It could be helpful to have more crit groups rather than full class discussions. Instead of having a class critique, we could be a part of 3 small groups with different students in each group. This way, we would hear feedback from all of our classmates, but it would be in a more intimate environment where everyone would be forced to speak their honest opinion.
5. What does it mean to you to make art in a community? How does artwork made by other artists affect what you do as an artist? How can you take better advantage of the built in art community you have at Biola?
Making art in a community is essential to good work, in my opinion. In high school, my best friend and I took art classes together. She would lean over during class and give me feedback on my painting whenever she saw something that she wanted to comment on. At the time, I didn’t realize that this was a normal and healthy way of creating art within the art world. But it is extremely helpful to have others who create and study art, give input on my work. By making art in a community, we can make our own unique work but learn from others. Art is meant to be seen, usually by more people than the artist. For this reason, feedback from others during the art-making practice helps to make work stronger. When I see other artists’s work, it helps me to develop a better critical eye. It also informs me on what others are making and what conversations are being held in the artistic community. It is not my natural inclination to ask for help. Because of this, I have a hard time asking for feedback from other artists if they don’t offer it voluntarily first. I could take better advantage of this community at Biola by reaching out first to give and receive feedback.
gracieabrams
germansingergirl
2087
yousharknotpass
titsay
blakekathryn
baratheonpilled
discoholicmusic
kianamaiart