Why is Drar*y so popular among HP fans but not Hinny? Besides Drar*y, i think second most popular in fandom is Harmion* ship, not Hinny or Romione. So I wonder why canon ship in HP not that popular. As Hinny & Romione shipper, it's really hurt me whenever I read a hurtful comments regarding my ships in facebook, tumblr and ig.
The most popular ships, according to a search through A03, are:
Draco Malfoy/Harry Potter (33271)
Sirius Black/Remus Lupin (14305)
Harry Potter/Severus Snape (11205)
Hermione Granger/Ron Weasley (9216)
James Potter/Lily Evans Potter (7582)
Hermione Granger/Draco Malfoy (7238)
Harry Potter/Ginny Weasley (7074)
Hermione Granger/Severus Snape (3492)
Harry Potter/Tom Riddle (2919)
Remus Lupin/Severus Snape (2675)
Romione is usually a secondary ship though- to Drarry.
Harmione used to be popular- but they faded into relative obscurity compared to Drarry over the last 10 years.
So time for some SHIPPING HISTORY:
Before the 5th book:
Hinny’s popularity has never been high- back before book 6 Harmione was the popular ship- Ship wars were mostly Harmione vs Romione- with a side of Hinny, and a tiny bit of Lunarry.
Then the sixth book came out:
The second Hinny became a thing , Harmoanians were suddenly on the attack. Fandom in general had a MELTdown.
Romance was the most important thing to fandom- there were tons of people shocked by Hinny happening (they shouldn’t have been. It was very obvious.) But with romance being ‘TEH MOST IMPORTANT THING EVAH! SQUEE’ they were really mad that the all important romance wasn’t given a lot of screen time.
They wanted the books to switch genres in order to build up the romance ‘properly,’ basically. Fandom is STILL that way. We indulge in fanfiction where romance can be the center of attention- but the books didn’t do that. How dare they. :P
Anyways- people have always disliked the Weasleys for some reason (classism), and Ginny got a TON of hatred.
There are lots of reasons Ginny was hated:
she broke a ton of ships
she is pretty athletic and sassy- many of the readers prefer Hermione because they identify with a nerdy smart unpopular selfrighteous girl over a ‘jock’ character
she’s not the ‘main girl’ of the book- so has had less screen time
by this point Ginny was also barely in the films- Hermione was being powered up and beautiful- while they made Ginny a shell of a human and did little to vamp up Bonnie’s looks
People wrote her off as a fangirl/stalker character
no one was paying attention to Ginny and so saw her character development as ‘sudden’ (it wasn’t.)
Then the movies caught up to the books-
Kloves was a huge Harmione shipper, so that got a TON of attention in the scripts and films.
Daniel Radcliffe was a Lunarry shipper and put a ton of his acting into that.
On film Hinny got NOTHING at ALL except like 2 ‘sad looks’ by Ginny? Until book 6- and then they didn’t even interact? It was awful.
So movie-based fans hated Hinny (and movie Hinny DESERVES the hate. It’s AWFUL.)
Romione gets established in both universes (book and movie) very firmly. (Even though it was not handled the best in the films.)
So with Hinny being hated by movie fans, and disliked by many of the book fans- and movies influencing book readers as well- Hinny was firmly established as a disliked ships.
Then there’s the Draco thing:
Meanwhile- Draco has always been popular in fandom- but the girl he was always involved with in the books (Pansy) was not well developed compared to other characters.
Dramione used to be VERY popular. People LOVE the idea of ‘redeeming draco’- but with Romione being written into the plot so firmly, Dramione lost a ton of shippers over the years because it was messy and upset all the character interactions a lot- and so many of them turned to Drarry. Keeping Romione is easier than Dramione.
Drarry became more and more popular- Hinny was hated, and getting rid of it in lieu of another ship was easy- it didn’t upset Harry’s relationship with the Weasleys, Got in that hothot m/m goodness fandom (again mostly women) crave, has the ‘forbidden love’ people crave, and then they also get that ‘smarmy bastard sex machine in leather pants paired with an uptight ‘good guy’’
That’s the same reason Wolfstar is so popular. It has that trope- troubled ‘bad boy’ and ‘uptight haunted good guy’ that people cream themselves over. It can be a super cute ship- and there are great fics /art out there for it, but the main appeal is the tropes, imo.
At the end of the day, certain tropes have more appeal to people. It has little to do with the books much of the time- and given everything- Hinny and Romione are simply ‘boring’ to many people, unsexy to others, and ‘poorly done’ to a lot of people.
I disagree- I think they’re awesome! :) But feh- the biggest bummer is not getting as much fan content with my ships, and having to come across SO much hate for Ron and Ginny everywhere.
I got the ships I wanted in the books :). I have a lot of cool artists and writers to follow, and enjoy writing and drawing them myself- and you can’t help what’s popular at large.
🙄
Got a lots of notes today on this one.
And to be clear- why I’m ‘giving a history lesson’ is because I was around in this fandom back in the fiction alley days- I’m talking about tropes from 20 years ago back when I was a kid 😂
Looks like you got the HARMonians up in arms.
Classism is a factor, I think. However, I think that anti-ginger bigotry is a bigger one. Some people HATE redheads in a major way. There are a number of theories as to why this is, but that’s a giant can of worms for another time.
Still, I say that the biggest reason for people hating the Weasleys is, was, and always has been butthurt shippers. Next to nobody hated the Weasleys before Harry/Ginny and Ron/Hermione started looking more and more like the endgame. Sure, there were always some who didn’t like one or more of the Weasleys, but the big, virulent hatred of them (along with the associated bashing campaigns) erupted suddenly onto the scene like a big, loud, stinky fart. And it was just as inappropriate and unwelcome.
I grew with the series in the infancy of fandom space. The very first fanfic I ever read was in 1998 shortly after I read PS for the first time. It was a super cute epistolary between Harry and Hermione where you could see a crush developing. I wish I knew where that was. Ginny hardly existed at this point. I loved her in CS and even wrote a little fanfic of my own about them in a notebook but I didn’t know how to publish online back then (forgive me, I was hardly 10 lol).
Harmonie and wolfstar dominated the scene for a long time. Then came the Severus ships (both self, with Remus, then god forbid the children) and Jily.
Drarry, I feel, didn’t have a huge insurgence until the onset of Tumblr. The LGBT+ acceptance was a major cornerstone in early tumblr and I really think it changed public perception (at least in my backwoods small town USA eyes).
Though Hinny was always in backseat, in the 3rd row cramp seats, only a stone throw from crack ships, imo. Tumblr helped it gain popularity immensely.
Eh I don’t know where I’m going with this other than incoherent agreements and anecdotes.


















