Regulus & Remus || The Library.
It was something he had always hated even as a child, having to make a choice. He had had that desire stamped out of him young, he wasn’t supposed to be thinking for himself at that age – he was supposed to follow what his parents said and did and never question it. That’s what he had done for years and at first it was effortless he would walk and talk and act the part, it wasn’t until he started school that he started to question just why he was supposed to do this and that. That was when he had begun to learn the hard way that that wasn’t something he was permitted to do. He had learnt at first with harsh words and severe looks and later at the end of his Father’s wand if he was home and if not his Mothers and he couldn’t honestly say which was worse. It hadn’t taken him long to realize that if he simply kept his mouth shut and did what he was told he was rewarded, praised and treated like an adult. So he had gone with the easy route, unlike his brother who had never stopped questioning and before he left he had even resorted to provoking their parents to the point that even Regulus was scared of what they would do.
He had the uncomfortable feeling in his stomach as he regarded Remus that this wasn’t much of a choice at all. This was his only option and while that did make things easier it also angered Regulus because he was bitter against the old man who would give him knowing looks in the corridors yet he wouldn’t do a damn thing. His foot began to twitch beneath the table and he knew that he needed to move before it got worse and his whole leg would follow it so he stood himself up, stretching himself gracefully and acting as if nothing was amiss before he turned away from Lupin and began to leisurely stroll around the room. He wanted nothing more than to pace but he knew better than that, Merlin moving was probably too big of a giveaway of his agitation as it was but he couldn’t of sat still for much longer. His fingers fiddled with the cuffs of his shirt as he walked and he closed his eyes as he imagined himself stood in the Headmasters office professing everything. His stomach rolled at the thought.
‘I want to trust you.’ The words were laughable but they were meant truthfully he knew and he wouldn’t throw them back into Lupin’s face, not after he’d promised to himself that he would do whatever he could to make this easier. It was true that Regulus had given Lupin rather a lot of his trust but that didn’t mean that his word was gold – Regulus barely knew the boy when it came down to it. He knew he was simply prolonging admitting that he’d be following Lupin’s words but he wasn’t quite ready to get them out of his mouth just yet. He had thus far managed to ignore the warm feeling he’d felt when Remus had said he wouldn’t give up on him and as Regulus looked at the boy out of the corner of his eye he knew that he was telling the truth, he wouldn’t give up on him. “Self-destructive.” He muttered to himself as he turned once more around an old desk, lip curling slightly as his robe swept against the surface and gathered dust, what did Filch even do all day?
He straightened his back, cleared his throat and turned back towards Lupin with his mask firmly in place. A wry and slightly dark smile curled on his lips and he clasped his hands against his stomach and leaned forwards as if he was eager, “Not much choice in it really do I? Either way I’m going to end up my life in the hands of another person – better the devil you know and all that.” He waved a hand as if to dismiss his words before shrugging his shoulders and stuffing his hands into the pockets of his robes. “Thanks for the pep talk Lupin, I can take it from here. Best get back to your chums hmm? I’m sure you have some third years just begging to be terrorized.” With that he stood back and stared at him with raised eyebrows, the path to the door clear.
He didn’t for a moment believe that Lupin was really just going to turn his back on him now but he hoped that he would. He’d made the mistake of gushing out his feelings to him like some Hufflepuff 2nd year with a crush already, he didn’t want the Gryffindor to see him beg – which he no doubt would have to to Dumbledore. There were also matters that he didn’t doubt Dumbledore would bring up regarding his family and Regulus didn’t want Remus there for that, he didn’t want him to get an even more negative view on them than he already must have from what Sirius had said.
Remus watched Regulus with a careful gaze as he slowly rose to his feet and almost – but not quite – paced the classroom. There was something about his actions which seemed strained, and Remus could hardly blame him for that. Regulus was on the verge of breaking; it didn’t take the most observant seventh year Gryffindor to realise that. But he put on a good show. It was astonishing how alike he and Sirius were when it came to masking what they were really feeling, really thinking. But Remus had been exposed to it long enough to recognise the signs. That’s all it was, a show, and Remus didn’t believe it for a second. However he knew better than to mention it. Remus didn’t know what to do when faced with Sirius’ brother, but he knew better than to test the pride of a Black, pride which was already very much under threat.
Rotating in his chair so as to follow the movements of the boy, Remus’ brow was still gently furrowed in a frown. It was an expression that graced his features often, seeing as he had a great deal to worry about without Regulus’ problems on top of his own, and yet there was a greater sense of trouble working through his mind than there usually was given the severity of what Regulus had confessed to him. This wasn’t about anyone’s sorry existence. Regulus could stand to lose a great deal more than his pride, and Remus felt a sense of responsibility over him that he presumed was what his fellow Marauders had been feeling towards him all this time. It was strangely relieving, not relying on the help and kindness and friendship of others, but being the one to offer it to another instead. But Regulus was right; as much as Remus might have denied it in the past, and as much as he’d continue to deny it, there never really was a choice. That was the nature of war. It enveloped you, consumed you, entirely against your will. Regulus didn’t have much say in the matter, but he could fight it.
Remus flinched at Regulus’ words. As easily as that, Remus was dismissed. With a quick word of thanks, Regulus cleared the path for him to leave. Only Remus sensed that it was a challenge. If he so much as flinched towards the door he’d be doing the very thing he’d sworn not to do, turning his back on Regulus after he’d exposed his darkest fears. Remus would not rise to the challenge. It might have been easier on them both if he had, but despite what appearances might suggest he didn’t bend to everyone’s will quite so easily. If that were the case, he as well as James, Sirius and Peter probably would have been expelled (or at least suspended) years ago. Remus could be incredibly stubborn when he set his mind to something. Rising to his feet, Remus stood so that he was on a level with Regulus, hands in his pockets, clearly conveying that he had no intention of bailing.
“Then put your life in the right hands,” he began, returning to the conversation from which they’d departed leaving it very much unfinished. “Put it in the hands of someone who cares whether you live or die.” Remus lost some of his composure as he continued. It terrified him that Regulus might have questioned this, thus his voice almost rung with challenge. But there was no denying it; Dumbledore was a damn sight better than Voldemort. Remus knew this because the headmaster had been kind and just enough to allow him a place in the castle alongside the pure, and by pure Remus referred to everyone whose blood wasn’t tainted with lycanthropy. Perhaps if Regulus knew this he might think differently of Dumbledore. Or perhaps he’d be alot less willing to accept the counsel of a werewolf. “Voldemort can only promise you one thing. It’s what he’s set out to do from the very beginning. You do have a choice and if you choose Dumbledore you stand a chance of surviving at least.”
Remus took a step so as to close some of the space between them. There was something about the name, the topic of discussion, the fact that they were discussing their own deaths and the war that held the wizarding war in its tight clutches, that compelled Remus to speak quietly, despite the Muffliato spell he’d cast upon the room. “Why do I get the feeling you aren’t going to talk to him?” Remus asked, the wince in his expression betraying just how much he had invested in this. The third years could wait. Peeves could wait. Remus may be a prefect, but under no circumstances did patrolling the corridors take precedence over this.












