Review: Manchester Orchestra – A Black Mile To The Surface
Picture from genius.com
Overview:
This album doesn’t make sense.
Or at least that’s what I thought until I listened to it on vinyl. As with most albums I buy, my first run at A Black Mile To The Surface was on my car stereo. It’s a radio test. A thoroughly innocent way to hear music. I switched off to appreciate some new music. It seemed like there were songs that didn’t flow together well, with huge gear changes between sections of the album. The Maze, and The Gold set a great pace which drops off suddenly after Lead, SD to give us 3 mellow songs that blend together into one. The album then finishes with an odd palette of heavy and light, fast and slow songs to finish the album. From a band that have crafted their previous albums to play smoothly between songs with natural highs and lows, this is certainly a disjointed play-list.
The melody is much easier to understand on the vinyl. This isn’t surprising when you look at how much Manchester Orchestra push their record sales. This album opened at #7 in the Billboard Top Album Sales Chart, and #2 on Vinyl Albums sales. Musically this album is in 3 parts – which is made glaringly obvious when you play it on a turntable. Turning the record over allows for a natural interval between the album chapters, which manifests in the 3 sides. It’s oddly like having 3 EPs.
The Breakdown:
Originality – 2/2 A lot of the themes throughout the album are very similar to previous albums: deceit, guilt, anguish, religion, family. Andy Hull takes on a new role in A Black Mile To The Surface – fatherhood. Learning that Andy had a baby girl (named Mayzie – where the title The Maze comes from) changes your perspective of the album. Previous MO albums have been journeys of self-exploration, who Andy Hull was, and why he feels the way he does. This album explores how he envisions parenthood, and current emotions. There are traces of their previous albums lurking in the background, as well as from the Swiss Army Man soundtrack (see The Mistake), but altogether this is a much more mature record than those previously – both in terms of sound and lyrics.
I give it a 2/2 for breaking the mould and trying something different, yet in keeping with the Manchester Orchestra modus operandi – the MO-MO if you will.
Melody – 1/2 This albums sets off with great pace. It follows suite of Simple Math in having a slow song to open the album up and then sets a drive with the second song – as Deer did for Mighty. The shift in gears between the parts of the album is a bit clunky but if you do decide to look at the album in 3 parts then this can be forgiven. A consistency in the MO style is Andy Hull’s vocal tone, ranging from piercing soul shouts (Lead, SD) to ghostly spirit (The Parts). The dark chord progressions we’ve come to expect from MO are certainly kicking around in the heavier songs as well. I anticipate that some of these songs like The Gold and Lead, SD will make for excellent mosh fodder. Something I want to address is the loss of two core members. Both Chris Freeman (keyboard) and Jonathon Corley (bass) have gone their separate ways from the band since the release of Cope/Hope. I personally feel the loss of their influence. Keys have played a large role in this band’s rise, sculpting the background landscape of many of the band’s greatest songs. Changing musicians may have lead to a different approach to this album. Also, as personal speculation, I think it has also meant that Andy Hull may have gone partly unchallenged in areas leading to more outside-the-box thinking and individuality in the record.
Lyrics – 2/2 Here’s the real focus of this album. Andy Hull is a father and the gravitas of this responsibility is quite clear. I wrote synopses for all the songs in my draft, and whilst themes like parenthood and anxiety feature throughout the album, there were a couple of tracks that stand alone in my opinion. My one qualm is that the third part (from The Wolf onwards) does not seem to possess a lyrical direction, and, at times, feel like afterthoughts to the album.
The Maze I think this is Andy Hull’s impression of how his baby girl sees him; a point of view perspective from Mayzie (rephrase). The perspective flips halfway through to show Andy’s gratitude to his child for bringing him out of dark places into a lighter, purer world. Compared to previous work it feels like Andy has hope for once – “you lift that burden off of me” – and is free from anxiety that so many MO songs are full of.
Lead, SD Neither Andy nor his wife are ready to be parents. They both feel like kids, crazy and wild, “high” and “deadbeats”, who get sobered up by the news that they are having a child. The racy arrangement and fleeting thoughts in this song are evidence of how unprepared Andy Hull feels for this role, containing constant references to how he is “losing it”. There are also themes of dependence. Without his wife Andy would struggle, “I’m lost without a single clue as to where I’m headed. I wait for her because without her I’m gonna sink.” He ultimately says “it took your blood on my blood to believe”, possibly that ‘we needed to have a child for me to trust and commit to you”. It’s a reaction song to hearing the news you’re becoming a father. Disclaimer: I could be completely off grid here though as Jake Cordiner (@jjjjaketh) from blinkclyro seems to think this song is about one brother trying to rob a store and the other trying to stop him – originally written for a concept album based on the story of these two brothers.
The Parts This is the love story (in brief) that let to Mayzie. It’s a really beautiful piece. Childhood memories of your first dates, bedrooms, appearance, that end in the birth of a child. This song has one of my favourite lines on the album – “I’m a water boy overwhelmed by the screaming” – the ‘Dad’ experience of labour. I think that line nails how every man feels in the birthing room at the birth of their firstborn. It’s a real gem of a song and shows Andy Hull at his prime. It’s a universal feeling for me when Andy sneaks in a solo track: Virgin – I Can Feel Your Pain, Mean Everything – 100 Dollars/ I Can Feel A Hot One. It’s always the cherry on the Manchester Orchestra album
Technicals – Production, Engineering, and Mixing – 1/2 This album is tight. Manchester Orchestra’s albums have been since Mean Everything. Every instrument is where it should be, and in a good way. Some bands can afford a little laxity in production, it suits their style, but Manchester Orchestra to me have always seemed like a clean cut kind of dirty rock. This album continues that theme. The overall style and feel is mellower. The majority of the album was produced by Catherine Marks of Foals, Wolf Alice, and newly surfaced The Amazons, of which the former two have taken very relaxed approaches to their most recent work. So there’s no surprise really that Manchester Orchestra have come forward with a softer approach on this album. I still have the feeling though that more work could have been put into the last third of the album to make it gel better. The tempo goes up and down too much between only 4 songs. There’s too much variation. I don’t really want to be shaken about by the songs, more guided through them. On the other hand they do feel very final, and bring about the close of the album nicely.
Overall Impression – 1/2 Even thoughI feel that I’ve sung its praises, this album hasn’t given me what I wanted. I was really looking forward to an alternative rock album to just lose myself in. I’m a bit of a stick in the mud at times. I’m not a huge fan of change. I would have been totally fine with 7 pure rock songs, and 3 Andy Hull solos featuring Manchester Orchestra; a formula that I think works for this band. Instead I’ve been gifted with this deep and thoroughly thought-through piece of art. The bastards. Overall though I like the album. It’s different, and I think I’ll appreciate it a few years down the line when I myself start to mature into an adult with more responsibilities.
Overall rating: 6/10
Best song: The Gold
Hidden Gem: The Parts
Editor: Rhys Edwards











