I knew you were trouble â jack wilder
warnings: rookie fbi!reader magician!jack fingering p in v oral (f!receiving)
summary: youâre chasing a magician who steals from everyone, including you.
a/n: took it upon myself to write a jack wilder fanfic cause thereâs barely any and itâs criminal I also havenât watched the movies in a year so bare with me if itâs inaccurate !
âHey! Stop him, my wallet!â
You werenât even supposed to be near the docks that night, it was supposed to be a quick walk to clear your head after a miserable day of paperwork at the Bureau. But of course, the second you decided to breathe like a normal human being, someone decided to commit a crime right in front of you.
You turned just in time to see a guy sprinting through the crowd, hoodie pulled up, backpack bouncing against his shoulder. The man yelling after him looked like a tourist, all sunburned and confused, clutching at his empty pocket.
Your brain didnât think. Your badge was still clipped to your belt, your legs were already moving.
âFBI!â you shouted, cutting across the walkway.
The hoodie guy glanced back, surprised, and you caught a split second look at his face. Sharp features, a wild spark in his eyes, the kind of grin that made you instantly sure heâd done it on purpose.
He ducked left between two food stalls. You went after him, dodging a family with ice cream cones, almost slipping on the wet pavement.
He didnât. Of course he didnât.
He jumped a railing, landing hard, and you followed, the impact stinging your knees. You were close enough to hear his breathing, the scuff of his sneakers against the concrete. You could tell he wasnât just some random pickpocket. He was fast. Precise. Like heâd done this before, a lot.
He cut down another alley, and for a second you thought youâd lost him, until you saw a flicker of movement by a side door. He was trying to duck through it.
Your hand caught his arm, fingers digging into the fabric of his hoodie. He jerked back in surprise, turning halfway, and the motion pulled you both off balance.
For one dizzy second, the world spun, you caught a flash of his face, that same grin but closer this time, his eyes meeting yours in something that wasnât quite fear and wasnât quite amusement. Then he twisted. Smooth. Effortless.
The next thing you knew, heâd spun you around like it was a dance move and slipped free. You stumbled forward, caught yourself against the wall, turned backâ
No sound. No footsteps. No exit door swinging. Just the faint echo of the city and your own heartbeat hammering in your ears.
You took a few steps down the alley, looking behind dumpsters, checking corners, but it was empty. It didnât make sense.
You pressed your hands to your knees, catching your breath. âWhat the hellâŠâ
By the time you got back to the Bureau, you were exhausted, hair sticking to your face, shoes covered in grime. The fluorescent lights inside made you squint.
Dylan Rhodes was still at his desk, jacket off, tie loose, his usual âIâm too tired to careâ expression firmly in place. He glanced up when he heard you drop the recovered wallet onto his desk.
âLose a fight with a trash can?â he asked.
âFunny,â you muttered, brushing dirt off your sleeve. âCaught a thief. Kinda.â
He raised an eyebrow. âKinda?â
âYeah. I had him. For like, two seconds. Then he Houdiniâd his way out of my grip.â
Dylan leaned back in his chair. âSo, you chased a suspect without backup, got thrown around, and lost him.â
You frowned. âWhen you say it like that, it sounds bad.â
âIt is bad,â he said, but his tone wasnât mean â just exasperated, like he was too used to this kind of rookie chaos. âYou couldâve gotten hurt.â
âI wasnât planning to,â you shot back.
âPretty sure no one plans to,â he said. Then, after a pause â âYou at least get a look at him?â
âYeah.â You sat down across from him, resting your elbows on the desk. âYoung. Mid-twenties maybe. Street type. Hoodie, dark hair. Fast as hell.â
Dylan typed something into his computer, nodding. âMaybe weâll pull him up in one of the security feeds. Iâll check it out tomorrow.â
You exhaled, leaning back in the chair. âThanks.â
âGo home, rookie,â he said, already focused on the screen again. âYou look like youâre about to fall over.â
Your apartment wasnât much, one room, small kitchen, view of a brick wall, but it was quiet. You dumped your bag on the couch, kicked off your shoes, and collapsed onto your bed still half in your work clothes.
For a few minutes, you just stared at the ceiling, replaying the chase. The way heâd moved. The twist that had knocked you off balance. The fact that heâd looked you dead in the eye before vanishing into thin air.
You sat up, grabbing your bag to unpack the usual mess, phone, badge, pen, random receipts. You reached for your walletâ
You froze. Checked again. Then checked the couch, your coat pocket, the floor. Nothing.
You dragged a hand down your face. âNo. No, no, no.â
He hadnât just taken the touristâs wallet.
You flopped back on the bed with a groan loud enough to startle your upstairs neighbor. âUnbelievable.â
You turned your head toward the window, watching the faint glow of the streetlights outside. Somewhere out there, that guy was counting your cash and probably laughing about it.
Down by the river, the air was cool and damp, city lights rippling over the water.
Jack Wilder crouched by the edge, pulling two wallets from his hoodie pocket. The first one, the touristâs, he opened lazily, sifting through it with practiced fingers. A few twenties, some loyalty cards, nothing interesting. He pocketed the cash and tossed the rest into the river without looking.
The second wallet, though, caught his eye.
He flipped it open, expecting the same boring stuff but there it was.
Your badge. Your name. Your photo.
Jack blinked, eyebrows lifting slightly. âFBI,â he murmured.
He glanced at the photo again. You looked serious, professional, not exactly how youâd looked earlier when you were chasing him down like you meant business. There was something kind of funny about it, though. The rookie agent and the thief.
He thumbed through the rest. Cash, a few cards, a folded-up photo â you and another girl, arms around each other, smiling.
Jack paused on that one. It wasnât the kind of thing people usually kept in their wallets anymore. It made you seem⊠real. Not just a badge or a title.
He hesitated, then pulled the photo and your FBI card out, slipping them into his jacket pocket. The rest he could toss.
He stood, watching the empty wallet sink beneath the waterâs surface.
âSorry, maâam,â he muttered, half-grinning to himself.
Then, as quietly as heâd appeared, Jack walked away.
You werenât even supposed to be there.
Thatâs what you kept reminding yourself as the government-issued sedan tore down the street, red and blue lights bouncing off every window you passed. dylan was driving way too fast, like he thought he was in one of those old cop shows instead of a real human vehicle with a very breakable passenger seat.
He didnât even look at you, just said, ânew orleans precinct. four magicians. pulled off a bank heist from vegas. donât ask.â
You followed dylan through the hallway, fluorescent lights flickering overhead, files clutched against your chest, until you hit a hallway lined with interrogation rooms. voices leaked out of each one.
Behind a one-way window, a lady sat straight in a chair. Reddish hair, black dress, expression like she was extremely unimpressed and unbothered. A detective sat across from her, waving a file around, but she didnât even flinch.
Merritt McKinney. you knew the face from news clippings. the mentalist.
Then your stomach dropped.
âThatâs him,â you said, voice barely above a whisper.
Dylan turned, frowning. âwhat?â
You pointed through the glass.
âThatâs the guy who robbed me.â
Jack Wilder was lying there, legs lifted lazily over the table like the concept of rules didnât exist. Hands cuffed to the table, but he looked completely at ease.
You froze in the doorway. He hadnât seen you yet.
âYou sure?â Dylan asked.
âYeah, iâm sure,â you said, still staring.
Ten minutes later, you were in the room.
Well, technically observing, like dylan had told you to. but you were sitting at the end of the table, pretending to take notes while your brain replayed the last time youâd seen him. The chase, the alley, the way heâd slipped out of your grip like jello.
âYou like magic?â he asked, grin lazy.
âSheâs here to observe,â Dylan cut in, dropping a thick folder onto the table. the slap made you jump. âDonât talk to her.â
Jack tilted his head. âOh, come on. you bring her in here, sit her across from me, and iâm not allowed to talk to her? thatâs kinda rude.â
âWhatâs rude,â Dylan said flatly, âis robbing a bank.â
Jack smiled. âi mean, yeah, but it was a good trick.â
âit wasnât a trick,â Dylan snapped. âit was theft.â
âAll magicâs theft if you think about it,â Jack said, leaning back in his chair. âStealing attention, stealing time, stealing the part of your brain that says this isnât real. We just take it a little further.â
You had to bite your tongue not to say something.
Dylan flipped open the file, the vegas audience, the french bank vault, cash fluttering through the air. âTell me how you did it.â
Jack raised his brows. âOh, weâre skipping dinner first?â
The comment earned a small smile from you.
Jack sighed. âFine. We rehearsed, we traveled, we robbed a bank. ta-da.â
âThatâs not an answer.â
âItâs the only one iâve got.â
His eyes flicked back to you again. not in a flirty way, not even smug, more like he was cataloguing you. remembering.
Dylan kept talking, something about jurisdiction, international theft, and performance law. Half of it you tuned out. you were too focused on the small movements jack kept making, the twitch of his fingers, the restless tapping of his knee.
After maybe twenty minutes, dylan finally snapped the folder shut.
âYou think this is a game,â he said.
Jack smiled again, the kind of smile that didnât quite reach his eyes. âthis is the opening act.â
The next half hour blurred. agents shuffled papers and people yelled down hallways. by the time you and dylan made it to the front steps, the sun was already bleeding orange over the city.
The front doors burst open. the four horsemen walked out together, Dylanâs expression immediately went from tired to what the hell, and you just stood there, frozen.
Atlas in front, confident as ever. Henley beside him. Merritt with that same smug tilt to his head. and Jack. Jack at the back, jacket half-zipped, hands shoved in his pockets like he hadnât just been in cuffs thirty minutes ago.
Nobody stopped them. not the officers, not the agents, not even Dylan, who just stared like his brain couldnât process it.
âtheyâre notâ theyâre not evenââ he started.
âcuffed?â you finished.
âi donât know,â he said, rubbing his face. âthereâsâ thereâs paperwork, thereâsâ god, this makes no sense.â
But you couldnât stop watching jack. he turned once, mid step, glancing back at the building like he knew exactly where you were standing.
He didnât do anything. didnât wave or wink or pull some stupid trick. He just looked at you, one heartbeat longer than necessary, before turning back and walking away with the others.
You stood there until the street went quiet again, until Dylan finally barked somthing about âfederal nightmaresâ and stormed off toward his car.
You stayed a moment longer. The city lights were starting to come on, one by one.
And somewhere in your chest, under all the confusion and the adrenaline, you felt it â the same thing youâd felt the first night you saw him.
You stared at his file, the photo of him taken just yesterday before interrogation. Jack Wilder.
His dark hair was slightly messy and his eyes had that impossible calm about them that made him look like he knew a secret you didnât.
Cute, you thought. You shouldnât have been thinking that, especially not about a criminal who had just pulld off a string of high profile heists, but you couldnât stop yourself. Your stomach twisted with a mix of exasperation and something else, something you werenât ready to name.
You jumped slightly when the door opened and Dylan walked in. Your hand slammed down on the file before he could see what you were looking at. He didnât notice the blush creeping up your neck.
He was focused, serious, already running through his checklist in his head. You took a shaky breath and tried to convince yourself you hadnât just been staring at a criminalâs picture like he was some cute stranger on the street.
Later on your break, you walked to the small coffee stand around the corner from the office. The air smelled like roasting beans and the city, and for a moment it was a relief from paperwork and files and the endless stream of cases that always seemed to pile up.
You were halfway through deciding what kind of latte you wanted when movement caught your eye.
Someone with a hood pulled low over their head bumped into a man walking in the opposite direction. You barely had time to notice the casual apology before your instincts fired.
That bump wasnât just accidental. The personâs hand had slipped into the manâs pocket with the precision of someone who did it often. You saw the wallet leave the manâs grasp before he even knew it was gone.
âHey!â You called out without thinking.
it didnât surprise you who it was. Of course it was him. Jack Wilder. He looked up, eyes lighting up when he saw you, not in a friendly way, not exactly, but in that way that made your stomach twist into knots.
Without missing a beat, he sprinted down the alleyway, hood falling back slightly, revealing that familiar messy hair and sharp eyes.
You didnât hesitate. Your legs pumped, the streets suddenly smaller, somehow more familiar, as though evry corner, every alley, had been waiting for this chase.
You had done it before, back when heâd slipped from your grasp in the chaos of a different day, and you werenât about to let it happen again.
He was fast, but you were fast too. Youâd grown up on these streets, you knew every shortcut, every corner that might give someone like him an advantage.
You were just one street away from your apartment when you finally started feeling the burn in your lungs and the ache in your legs. Still, there was no way you were giving up. Not this time.
Then, just like that, he vanished around a corner. Your chest heaved as you skidded to the turn, heart hammering, only to see him again. There he was, crouched slightly, hands on the door lock to your apartment building. It wasnât a mistake, it couldnât be. He was heading inside, like he knew exactly where he was going.
You ran the last few steps, heart in your throat, and pushed the door open, following him without even thinking.
The stairs blurred beneath your feet as you sprinted, counting the levels, wondering how someone could move that smoothly even after running so fast.
He stopped at your door, hands in the air as if he had nothing to hide, and you skidded to a halt a few feet away, gasping for air.
Your hair was sticking to your forehead, your chest heaving, and you felt like your lungs were going to catch fire any second.
âWhat? Why did you run here?â You finally managed, voice harsh with frustration and disbelief.
He shrugged, calm as if sprinting through city streets and breaking into your apartment lobby was the most normal thing in the world. He gave you a small smile.
You crossed your arms, trying to seem a little more professional. âWhyâd you steal that manâs wallet? Seems like you already have enough money.â
The recent bank robbery, the shows, the tricks â he clearly didnât need more money.
He tilted his head at you and replied simply, âWhy not?â
You narrowed your eyes, taking a careful step toward him. You reached for your cuffs instinctively. âYouâre under arrest.â
Jack didnât panic. He didnât run. He just started walking toward you slowly, and you stepped back, adjusting your stance.
âArenât you gonna arrest me?â He held his hands out.
you snapped the cuffs onto his wrists and grabbed his arm to turn him toward the door, ready to lead him out of the building. The click of the metal hitting the floor behind you barely registered over your own racing heartbeat.
And then they were gone. The cuffs had slipped off, falling to the ground with a quiet clatter, and before you could even act, he tugged on your arm, pulling you toward him. You stumbled, barely catching your balance, eyes wide as your heart hammered in your ribs.
âWhat are youâ youââ you stammered, trying to regain control, but all your authority had vanished in that instant. He was close, dangerously close, and calm. Hands still holding yours, gaze locked with yours.
The moment stretched long enough that you couldnât remember if it was seconds or minutes. You could hear your own heartbeat pounding in your ears, and for a brief flash you wondered how this was even real.
Then he leaned in slightly, close enough that you could feel the heat of his breath, and all the logic in your brain started screaming at you, reminding you that he was a criminal, a thief, someone who should never be this close.
His eyes flicked to yours, sharp and calculating, and that little grin tugged at the corner of his mouth. âYou really like keeping me on my toes, huh?â he murmured, voice low and daring.
Your mouth opened to argue, to protest, to say something smart, but before you could get a word out, he closed the distance. His lips met yours.
It was long, overwhelming, and impossibly intimate. Your chest pressed against his, knees threatening to buckle, and every sensible thought screamed at you to stop, but your body didnât care. His hands gripped your arms gently but insistently, keeping you close as the city noise faded into nothing.
your fingers tangled in the fabric of his shirt, tugging him closer still as if daring to bridge every inch of space between them. A low groan vibrated against your mouth when he finally pulled back just enough to breatheâbut not far enough for reason or restraint to catch up.
Jack stepped back toward your apartment door without letting go of your arm, his hand brushing the handle. âItâs lockedââ you said, breathing a little heavier. But just as the words left your mouth, the door swung open. You stared at it in surprise, then back at him, mouth slightly open.
âNothings ever really locked?â He frowned, shaking his head slightly, a small, almost mischievous crease between his brows, before leaning in and pressing his lips to yours again.
His mouth was warm against yours, his tongue teasing your lips apart as he guided you backward through the open door. The second it clicked shut behind you, he deepened the kiss, hands sliding down to grip your waist with possessive intent.
You could feel him smirk when your breath hitched at how easily this had happened, and worse? You didnât even care that heâd just broken in.
The couch hit the back of your knees before you realized it, his arms caging either side of where his body pressed into yours, his warmth seeping through every point he touched.
And yet, all coherent thougts evaporated when those large hands slid higher up under fabric of your shirt, forgetting rules entirely now because oh god, wasn't this better than arresting anyone anyway?
The world narrowed down to just him, the feel of his calloused hands on your skin, and the heat of his body pressed against yours.
He broke the kiss, lips brushing down the column of your throat, and you couldn't stop the soft whimper that escaped you. His hot breath teased your skin, sending shudders racing over your body. His mouth lingered there, as though he was memorizing every dip and curve of your neck, before pressing a gentle, almost reverent kiss to the pulse point.
Your fingers curled into the material of his shirt, desperate for anything to anchor you in this overwhelming moment. He nipped at the sensitive skin just below your ear, eliciting a soft gasp from you.
"God, the way you soundâ" he murmured, his voice a low rumble that reverberated against your skin "I could listen to it for days."
His lips continued their path along your jawline while your heart raced as he worked the buttons of your white shirt open, one by one. The way his hands lingered on your skin was so reverent, almost like he was worshipping you.
By the time the shirt was off, you were nearly trembling in anticipation, his gaze holding you captive.
Jack leaned back slightly, his brown eyes dark and full of something dangerous as they raked over where he knew exactly what effect this was having on you. His smirk grew sharper when your hips jerked up instinctively against nothing but air.
"You're so fucking pretty like this," he murmured roughly. He was hard, yhe sight made you shiver. He dipped down again, this time pressing an open mouthed kiss right between your breasts.
His lips continued their torturous descent over your stomach, and then suddenly, he paused.
he looked up at you for a brief moment, a smirk playing on his lips. "Lift your hips for me."
you whined and lifted your hips for him. Jackâs hands slid under you, gripping the back of your thighs as he tugged you closer to the edge of your couch, his fingers flexing possessively.
His smile turned downright filthy when another little sound escaped past your lips.
âSo fuckinâ eager,â he murmured before ducking his head lower, stillâhot breath ghosting over the damp fabric of your panties in a way that made every nerve in your body light up.
His fingers hooked into the waistband of your underwear, tugging them down just enough to expose what he'd been dying to taste since this whole damn thing started.
The second his tongue dragged up along slick heat? Your back arched off the surface beneath you with a gasp so loud it echoed, his answering groan vibrating against where his mouth now worked in slow, torturous strokes between your thighs that trembled around him.
His grip tightened on your hips, holding you in place as he lapped at you like a man starved.
Every flick of his tongue had heat pooling low in your stomach. You couldn't stop the way your fingers tangled into his hair, pulling, tugging him closer even though he was already buried so deep between those shaking thighs that there wasnât an inch left untouched by mouth or hands alike.
His eyes flicked up to meet yours in that moment, a wicked gleam in them as he saw what he was reducing you to a whimpering, trembling mess that could do nothing but lay there and take whatever pleasure he deigned to give you.
He knew how much you loved thisâhow much you needed it. And God, he was so damn good at it, every move deliberate and calculated as he pushed you just to the edge, then his fingers slid into you as he pressed an open-mouthed kiss to your inner thigh. They curled up, stroking, his thumb rolling over that bundle of nerves that set your body on fire.
your breath hitched and you moved to his lap, your thighs pressing against the sides of his legs. Jack groaned as you settled in, one hand gripping your hip while the other guided himself between your thighs, hot and hard against slick skin.
"God," he breathed out roughly before capturing your lips again with bruising force.
Jack's hands gripped your hips, fingers digging in hard as you rocked against him, every movement drawing a ragged groan from his throat. His head tipped back slightly when the friction of your bodies had him seeing stars.
"Fuck," he growled out between gritted teeth, pupils blown wide with pleasure as watched where two joined together so perfectly beneath dim light above.
The pleasure was overwhelming, every movement sending waves of sensation through your body. Jack's hands tightened on your hips as he guided you into a steady rhythm, slow and deep at first, but quickly building in intensity.
His breath came in rough gasps against your neck, lips brushing over the sweat skin there before his teeth grazed lightly along your pulse point just hard enough to make you whimper again.
Jack's grip on you tightened, his breath coming in ragged gasps as he felt that familiar tension coil deep in his gut. His eyes locked onto yours, dark with lust as the rhythm between your bodies grew desperate, frantic.
"Look at me," he demanded roughly, voice thick with pleasure when his fingers curled possessively around your thighs, his hips snapped up into yours over... over... until neither could hold back any longer
pleasure crashed over both of you, overwhelming, and consuming. It was like fire under your skin â intense and burning and so good you almost forgot how to breathe for what felt like an eternity at the same time that it wasn't nearly enough.
Jack's arms encircled you tightly, pulling you down against his chest as if he was trying to merge your bodies together.