The 45 Greatest 45s: Nick’s Definitive Pop/Rock Song List of Lists
Subjective? Yes and no. What I’ve come up with below isn’t really based on much opinion. One of the three lists I used in my calculations doesn’t even give rankings. About fifteen years ago, I brought home a brochure from the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame and Museum titled “500 Songs That Shaped Rock and Roll.” It was selected [in 1995] by a panel of musical experts, including the curators of the R&R H.F. & M, rock critics, journalists, and historians and is intended as a guide to songs that have influenced the evolution of R&R, from rock’s earliest days to the mid-Nineties.
Later on I became aware of Rolling Stone magazine’s 2004 “500 Greatest Songs of All Time,” based on a poll of popular musician, critics, and industry insiders. Then I discovered yet another “top 500″ song list tucked away in the February 15, 1973 issue of the same magazine:
This was “One Man’s Parade of Hits: The Nation’s Top 500″ compiled by then-college student and current national radio programmer, Guy Zapoleon. He had taken Billboard magazine’s weekly “Hot 100″ national survey from the span of 1955 to 1972 to evaluate what people were listening to most over the years, long before “Soundscan” and digital downloads, when sales could be more accurately measured.
It gradually occurred to me that these three lists balanced the different criteria for a “great song”: what sells, what is remembered over time, favorites of popular artists themselves, and songs deemed important by pop music critics/historians.
My first step in consolidating them was to find the songs all lists had in common. It came out to 45 tracks (spooky, right!) Then I jotted down their rankings in the 2004 Rolling Stone list and the 1973 Zapoleon one. I found the average of these to come up with the following rankings:
45 “Soul Man” - Sam & Dave 22 “Blue Suede Shoes” - Carl Perkins
44 “Leader of the Pack” - Shangri-Las
43 “Good Lovin’” - The Rascals 21 “I Want You Back” - Jackson 5
42 “He’s A Rebel” - The Crystals 20 “Good Vibrations” - Beach Boys
41 “Born To Be Wild” - Steppenwolf 19 “Yesterday” - The Beatles
40 “Fire and Rain” - James Taylor 18 “Respect” - Aretha Franklin
39 “Sound of Silence” - Simon & Garfunkel
38 “Reach Out I’ll Be There” - Four Tops
37 “Chapel of Love” - Dixie Cups 17 “Bye Bye Love” - The Everly Bros.
36 “Heart of Gold” - Neil Young 16 “Let’s Stay Together” - Al Green
35 “Pretty Woman” - Roy Orbison 15 “Light My Fire” - The Doors
34 “Dancing In The Street” - Martha & The Vandellas
33 “The Letter” - Box Tops 14 “Maggie May” - Rod Stewart
32 “Proud Mary” - Creedence Clearwater Revival
31 “Love Me Tender” - Elvis Presley 13 “You Send Me” - Sam Cooke
30 “The Twist” - Chubby Checker 12 “Honky Tonk Women” - Rolling Stones
29 “My Girl” - The Temptations 11 “All I Have To Do is Dream” - Everly Bros.
28 “Mr. Tambourine Man” - The Byrds 10 “Louie Louie” - The Kingsmen
27 “96 Tears” - ? and the Mysterians 9 “Blueberry Hill” - Fats Domino
26 “The Great Pretender” - The Platters
25 “Great Balls of Fire” - Jerry Lee Lewis
24 “House of the Rising Sun” - The Animals
8 “You’ve Lost That Lovin’ Feeling” - Righteous Bros.
7 “Bridge Over Troubled Water” - Simon & Garfunkel
6 “I Heard I Through The Grapevine - Marvin Gaye
5 “Dock of the Bay” - Otis Redding
4 “Satisfaction” - The Rolling Stones
3 “Jailhouse Rock” - Elvis Presley
2 “I Wanna Hold Your Hand” - The Beatles
1 “Hey Jude” - The Beatles