the following is an imperfect freeform on perfectionism.
My perfectionism is destroying me.
I realized this after meeting with a wonderful mentor late last week. Among other things, she reminded me that women are far less likely to believe that they are qualified for a job than their male-identified peers, so it is crucial to apply, apply, apply. She also assured me of my abilities - graduating summa cum laude, a track record of student affairs work as an undergrad, multiple club leaderships. I am capable of getting a job and kicking ass at it.
I left refreshed with a folder of bookmarked job postings, ready to sit down and write some cover letters, but also knowing that I had a few obligations during the next couple of days that needed my attention. Don't lose focus, I told myself. Finish what you need to do, then buckle down this weekend.
Saturday morning came and went, and so did the afternoon. I looked over the postings again, and the doubt crept in. Database management? Your Excel spreadsheet budget doesn't count. Unqualified. You could probably learn how to use Salesforce, but you've never seen the platform in person before. They won't look twice at you. Unqualified. You don't know anyone who knows anyone at this company/organization. You'll be another random person coming out of the woodwork. Unqualified. Within fifteen minutes, my list of seven definite job postings had been whittled down to two. Even then, I had bullet-pointed some accomplishments for my cover letters, but I couldn't make them into coherent sentences. I was stuck.
I recognized this pattern from every essay I'd written in college. I'd procrastinate, claiming that I was working through the arguments in my head, but was really mulling over the looming deadline. Eventually I would hammer something out in the 18-24 hours before it was due, look over it once for spelling/grammar errors, then turn it in. Writing was always a fraught, private activity. I never shared my work with parents or peers. But the next week, I'd get the essay back with an A, so I didn't see a need to change my behavior. Despite the occasional praise of my writing, I always saw my work coming to light in spite of my bad habits, not because of my skill.
My friend recently lent me a book called The Rise by Sarah Lewis. In the introduction, Lewis examines the phenomenon of archers who can collect bullseyes one day and completely miss the target the next, often because they lose focus on their process and only see the "gold," the win, in front of them. I grew up with the privilege of excelling at academics consistently - not so much from being "smart" (which is an entirely subjective measure), but from having a learning style that gelled with the school structure of read-lecture-test. In college, I had to work much harder, but not always with the goal of learning more. In many cases, my "gold" was the A and the respect of my professors and bosses. Some examples:
I remember being relieved when my first-semester freshman grades came back and I got a single B+, since it had taken off the pressure of scoring a 4.0. However, as my professors came to know me as a "strong student," that pressure returned.
During my junior year, a midterm essay earned a B- and caused me to weep for hours. The next morning, I was in my professor's office, practically begging for ways to do better next time.
(The more I write about this, the more hesitant I am to post this. My academic privilege is glaring. Am I only writing about how hard it's made my life?)
Well, no, now that I think about it. My learning style and perceived writing strength have made my life much, much easier. It's the unfair expectations, the weight of failures and missteps, the doubts, that are hurting me. It's the thinking pattern I picked up somewhere that told me that receiving criticism is a bad thing (to avoid) that makes a bad person (to avoid becoming).
But by building a wall between myself and the world, how much growth have I denied myself? How many connections have I missed by refusing vulnerability?
Anyway. This is the story that leads to me sitting in a café in San Francisco, unable to write a page-long cover letter.
The first step is recognizing the problem.
The second step is learning and asking for help.
The third step is making conscious choices to make a change.
Here's to making some sort of progress in a struggle that will probably last the rest of my life. But I've got to start somewhere.