Plz give the girls a full fwb!caleb fic ur little ficlet was so good like it had my cootamunk QUIVERING ā¼ļø
Note: I just want you to know that cootamunk has had me in tears since yesterday. Literally couldnāt stop laughing and now I canāt stop saying it. Youāre a hilarious genius and I luv you. This is for you, babe. Enjoy!
Creds to @/anitalenia and @/strangergraphics for the dividers!
Rating: Explicit - !!Minors DO NOT Interact!!
Warning: Smut, Caleb is a little controlling and rough.
Word Count: 2,251
Summary: Caleb finds out that youāre trying to go on a date and shuts that shit down.
Jealous&FriendsWithBenefits!Caleb/Reader
Hey. You up?
The notification that appears at the top of your phone screen stops your doom scrolling. You smile just a little to see that familiar message with the name accompanying it. You look at the time, not surprised that itās almost two in the morning. You never go to bed at the time you intend to, unintentionally looking and reading through a whole bunch of things from your roulette of consistently used apps.
You open your messages, twiddling your thumbs before you get ready to answer. Tonight could go one of two ways: Youāre either about to be put to bed with sex or youāre about be up for another hour or two watching something youāve already seen before until you and Caleb pass out on the couch.
When Caleb proposed being your first after you shared your fears of giving yourself to someone who didnāt deserve it, you thought he was joking. But when he looked at you with those serious eyes youāve grown to be able to identify so well, you knew that you were about to tread into some dangerous territory. But you let it happen, and you were convinced that if you ever had sex again, it wouldnāt be what Caleb showed you, what he did to you.
Youāll never forget his gentleness, his praise and respect. The way he put you and your needs above his own. Your thighs always press together just thinking about how you watched him slide on a condom and look into your eyes before he began to slip inside. You worried about pain, but Caleb had prepared you so well, gotten you so wet, that it was nothing but blissful pleasure.
āYouāre doing so good for me. I got you, pretty.ā
āItās okay, hold onto me. Iāll make sure it feels good.ā
āIf you need me to stop, donāt hesitate to tell me. This is about you.ā
You were addicted. And you were scared that your newfound desire for consistent sex was because it was Caleb who made you feel so good. You tried convincing yourself that you just wanted to feel that full and taken care of again, but you knew better.
No other man would do what he didāwould feel like he did. So when you vented to Caleb about how much you enjoyed yourself, you played it off and said that it was going to be scary showing yourself like this again to a stranger. But, then he said what you wouldāve never had the guts to.
āWe can still have sex if you want. I mean, neither of us are dating or anything. Friends with benefits, you know? It doesnāt hurt to just feel good and we trust each other enough.ā
You didnāt hesitate to accept and itās been history ever since. He comes over all the time and you still operate like friends, but when heās hard and youāre wet, you two fuck like a couple madly in love.
He always comes over at some point when he has a break or you go to his place. If heās up for itāhe always isāheāll make the drive to your apartment when itās past midnight because he tends to get off work late. Tonight is no different. Finally, you start to write your reply.
Hey. Yeah, everything okay?
Yeah. Iām outside. Open up?
Your eyebrows raise in shock. Heās outside already? Thatās a first.
Your oversized shirts falls mid thigh when you stand and you walk to your front door, not needing any light to see since the moon is so bright that it casts a gentle light into your open floored space. When you open the door, Caleb looks at you with a tight smile.
āYou sure youāre okay? You texted me like you werenāt here, yet you were standing outside this whole time,ā you chuckle. But Caleb doesnāt laugh, he just holds that expression that you canāt read.
He steps inside when you move over and you shut the door behind him, locking it while looking at him take off his sweater.
āCalebāā you start, but heās cupping the side of your face and kissing you with so much intensity. You accept it, melting into his hold as your hands snake into his hair, pressing your body close to his as your tongue licks at his mouth.
It must be one of those nights where we talk after, you think. Heās done this before and so have you, where youāre so overwhelmed with something that you need to release physically before you can do it verbally.
Heās eager in his urge to pull your clothes off, tickling your skin with his fingertips as he grabs the hem of your shirt to lift it over your head. Youāre just as grabby, pulling his shirt off and tugging at his pants to get them down. You kiss your way to the couch and he falls backwards when you gently push him.
You can see him, but just barely. You donāt feel like cutting a light on, so the moon illuminating through your windows will have to do. You slide your panties off and your pussy squeezes around nothing when you hear how ragged his breathing is and the wet noises that you know is him stroking his cock.
You crawl onto his lap, bracing your knees on both sides of him as you raise your hips. You put one hand on his shoulder and use the other to grip his length to put him where you both need.
āCalebā¦Oh my godā¦ā you whine as your body takes him inside, making you two become one.
You feel him twitch inside your walls as you start to move just a little bit, rubbing your breast against your palm as you hold onto him.
āIām in love with you,ā he finally speaks for the first time since his arrival and you nearly freeze, but he doesnāt let you. He keeps your hips moving, keeps thrusting into you from beneath as you choke on your breath from his words and actions.
āThe thought of you letting anyone but me get the privilege to see you like this makes me fucking nauseous.ā He kisses your shoulder as he moves snugly within your warm cunt, and all you can do is listen to him because heās not giving you a second to speak.
āCould you deal with me killing a man for you? Because if you ever let him experience this, I wouldnāt hesitate. Tell me what you need from me and Iāll become that and more to fulfill your every desire.ā
You whimper as he grabs your ass tightly, keeping you moving so that you take him ass deep as you can.
āCaleb, what are youāWhat happened?ā you say breathlessly, confused and thrown off by his confession. Every time you try to stop moving, he wonāt allow it.
Caleb doesnāt want you to stop because if you stop feeling how good he makes you feel, youāll try and find a way to bullshit him.
āYou think Iām going to let you leave me?ā he groans when you squeeze him. āI know about your little date. Remember what you told me when we started this?ā
You never told him anything, but youāre not surprised that he was able to find this out. Caleb always finds his ways and youāve never understood how. The date was harmless, setup by a coworker of yours after she told you the guy liked you and he didnāt seem bad, so you figuredāwhy not? Well now, you know you made a terrible mistake.
You do remember what you said, and it replays in your mind like a voice recording.
āIf either of us start dating or anything, we have to cut this off. There wonāt be anymore sex, but we could still be friends. But if someone canāt deal with that, itās healthy for us to just cut ties entirely.ā
āYeah, you remember,ā he licks your neck. āI never agreed, I just let you try and ignore your feelings because you said you werenāt ready for a relationship. But now?ā he abruptly stands with him seated inside of you to the brim.
āIt looks like I have to make the right decision for both of us.ā
He walks through your dark apartment into your room with your small lamp on. You turned it on before you got up to answer the door and youāre glad you did, because you can see him so clearly now. And he looks hurtāhurt and angry.
āCaleb I didnāt meanāā
He roughly throws you down into the bed, still pulsing inside. You donāt even understand how heās this fucking strong, but itās turning you on so much that you know his cock is soaked with your slick.
āWhat?ā he growls, cutting you off, grabbing your hands and placing them above your head as he starts to pound into you so hard that you canāt breathe. Your bed physically moves, you hear the frame grate against the floor.
āTo hurt me, huh? To make me have to think that you were going to choose someone else over me? Over us?ā He spreads your legs, spearing into you over and over while your breasts bounce in his face. He roughly takes your nipple into his mouth, sucking and licking the peaked nub. He starts to suck on your breasts, leaving red marks that he intends to keep on you so youāll always look in the mirror and know who owns you.
He angles himself, sitting on his knees and you donāt know how heās able to make you so flexible right now, but youāve never been so spread in your life. His hand comes to your throat, not putting pressure but itās telling you what you two are without it needing to be said.
āCalebā¦ā you hiccup. āI canāt..Iām gonnaāā
Youāre going dizzy at how hard heās fucking you, how heās punishing your cervix with each brutally delicious thrust. His head falls to your neck while he keeps your throat in his palm, and when you hear him sniffle, you damn near cry yourself. You move your hands from above your head where he put them, tugging on his hair and tracing his back while his hips never lose their momentum.
āIāll make you see. Iāll make you realize how much I belong to you. I want to live in your body, I want to stay a part of you forever. Iāll do everything in my power, baby. Please take me, please, please donāt make me have to know what itās like without you.ā
āIāll never do that you,ā you whine as he circles his hips to make you feel every thick inch. āIām sorryā¦Iām here..ā
āShow me how sorry,ā you feel wetness of what you believe is a tear drop on your neck as he continues to hide his face in it. āIām not pulling out. Let me put my cum inside you. I want you to feel it. Youāll let me, wonāt you? Please tell me yes, baby⦠Iām so fucking close..ā
āYes,ā you affirm, your own orgasm impending. āGive it to me, Calebā¦ā
And when he whimpers as he slams into you just a few more times, his heavy load floods your fertile pussy as his cock fucks it into you deep. Even when you cry out from how hard you finished, heās still slowly rocking his hips, making you and him both feel that mix of pleasure and pain from overstimulation.
You feel the cum start to spill out, falling down and pooling beneath your ass. It sticks to your skin and stains your sheets but you donāt care. If you could stay like this forever, you would.
He finally pulls back to look at you and even if his eyes arenāt red, his face is flushed and you can see the wetness on his long eyelashes. Gently, you take your thumbs to his eyes to wipe his tears. You pull him down, kissing him so sloppily that you donāt care how messy it is. He follows your lead without hesitation, sticking his tongue down your throat and making you both pour the rest of yourselves into one another.
He bucks his hips, his cock slightly moving inside of you as a reminder that heās still thereāthat heāll always be. Heās not giving you a choice but to let him. And you canāt stop clenching, you canāt stop your hole from wanting to bring him deeper, to keep him there.
āCaleb,ā you say softly when you two are forced to pull away to catch your breath.
He just stares down at you, his eyes dancing across your face as his breath becomes steady.
āIām in love with you too.ā
He smiles hard, holding you tight as you wrap your arms around him. Heās more than happy that the feeling was mutual, that you want him just as much. Because he wasnāt exaggerating about killing a man for even daring to think that he could have you. He wasnāt playing when he said that youād never leave him.
But hopefully, youāll never have to find out how far heāll go. A man like Caleb in love is a man who has no shame or fear, other than losing you. And heāll go great lengths to prove that.
āForever,ā he mumbles. āYouāre never leaving me.ā
āNever,ā you kiss his neck. āI promise.ā
And he intends to make sure you keep it.











