A/N: four stages of breakup, I'm currently in stage two: Anger xD. A sweet story with a sweet five who loves y/n more than anything? At the moment I just don't see it. That's why I don't post any of my stories, but rather write new stories where Five is an asshole. That doesn't mean that I'll never post sweet five x Y/N stories again, it just means that I'm still angry at the moment, and in order to be able to write again, it helps me to let my anger out
Warnings: spoilers for season 4 episode 5-6, angst
The world had barely spun for a few hours since Five and Lila had vanished, but when Five and Lila finally returned, Y/N knew something was wrong. she stood in the doorway, watching Five and Lila enter the living room, their faces marked with weariness, their eyes carrying the weight of experiences that no one else could understand. The moment Five met her gaze, Y/N felt her heart clench. Something was wrong. There was a distance in his eyes, a hesitation in his movements that hadn't been there before. This was not the same man she had fallen in love with, the man who had fought tooth and nail to survive countless apocalypses, who had faced the end of the world and returned to her every single time. This man was differentâdistant, almost as if a part of him had never truly come back.
Lila stood beside him, her presence like a shadow that Y/N couldnât shake. she had always known Lila was fierce, cunning, and strong, but now she could see something moreâa bond between Lila and Five that hadn't been there before. It was in the way they stood, too close, the way they glanced at each other as if sharing secrets. It made Y/Nâs stomach churn with a sickening sense of betrayal.
She knew something had changed, something that would shatter her world.
It wasnât long before she couldnât stand it any longer. âFiveâŚâ Y/Nâs voice wavered as she stepped forward, searching his face for any sign of the man she loved. But he looked away, his jaw tightening as if he couldnât bear to meet her eyes.
the tension in the air was palpable. Diego stood beside Lila, their three children clinging to their mother, oblivious to the storm brewing beneath the surface.
Y/N felt the tears prickling at the corners of her eyes, but she held them back. She couldnât fall apart. Not yet.
âWhat happened?â she asked, her voice barely above a whisper.
Fiveâs silence was deafening, and when he finally spoke, his words cut through her like a knife. âWe were gone for seven years, Y/N. Seven years in a timeline we couldnât escape.â
Y/Nâs heart pounded in her chest, the blood rushing in her ears. âI know it was hard, but you made it back. Youâre here now. We can fix this, Five. We can go back to how it was.â
Five shook his head, the pain in his eyes unbearable to witness. âItâs not that simple. Things changed⌠I changed. I didnât want this to happen, butâŚI fell in love with Lila.â
Time seemed to stop. The world around Y/N blurred, and all she could hear was the sound of her own heart shattering into a million pieces. She stared at Five, her mind refusing to comprehend the words that had just come out of his mouth. Lila? Lila, who was married to Diego, who had three children with him?
Y/N felt the blood drain from her face, her vision narrowing as the weight of his confession settled on her shoulders. She wanted to scream, to hit him, to do anything to make the pain go away, but all she could do was stand there, trembling with fury and betrayal.
"You bastard," she whispered, her voice low and deadly. "You absolute bastard."
Five recoiled as if she had slapped him, but she didnât care. The anger was boiling over now, a volcano ready to erupt. The room was deadly silent, the tension thick enough to cut with a knife. Everyone was staring at them now, the shock evident on their faces. Diegoâs expression was unreadable, his eyes fixed on Lila, who looked like she wanted to disappear into the floor.
"You want to know what kind of man you are, Five?" Y/N spat, her voice shaking with fury as she faced him and the others. "Youâre an asshole. An ungrateful, selfish asshole who couldnât keep his dick in his pants long enough to remember the woman he was supposed to love!"
The room fell into stunned silence, everyone staring at Y/N with wide eyes. Five opened his mouth to speak, but Y/N cut him off.
âHow could you? After everything weâve been through, after everything weâve fought for, you go andâŚfall in love with someone else? And not just anyone, but Lila? Diegoâs wife? The mother of his children? I would rather sleep with a mannequin than ever fall in love with someone else, but I guess thatâs the difference between us, isnât it?"
Five flinched, but he didnât back down. âI never meant for this to happen, Y/N. We were stuck there for seven years. We didnât think weâd ever make it back.â
âSo you gave up?â Y/Nâs voice was rising now, the anger bubbling over. âYou just gave up on us, on me? You preferred to think about having sex with Lila instead of finding a way back to me? The old Five never gave up. He never wouldâve stopped fighting to get back to the people he loved. But youâŚyouâre not him anymore, are you?â
Tears welled up in her eyes, but she refused to let them fall. She turned her gaze to Lila, her voice dripping with venom. âAnd youâŚyou disgust me. How could you do this to Diego? To your children? You betrayed them. You betrayed all of us.â
Lilaâs face paled, her mouth opening and closing as if she wanted to say something, but the words wouldnât come. Diego stood beside her, his expression still unreadable, but Y/N could see the hurt in his eyes, the pain he was trying so hard to hide.
Y/N couldnât take it anymore. She turned on her heel and stormed out of the house, the door slamming shut behind her. The moment she was outside, the tears she had been holding back finally broke free, streaming down her face as she collapsed onto the cold ground.
She wrapped her arms around herself, sobbing uncontrollably, the pain too much to bear. She had lost him. The man she had loved more than anything, the man she had waited for, had hoped for, had fought forâŚhe was gone. And in his place was someone she didnât recognize, someone who had betrayed her in the worst possible way.
Y/N had no idea how long she sat there, crying until there were no tears left to cry.. She felt completely and utterly alone, as if the world had turned its back on her.
But then she heard footsteps approaching, and she looked up to see Diego standing beside her. His face was filled with sorrow, his eyes red and puffy, but there was a softness in his expression that offered a small comfort.
âY/NâŚâ Diegoâs voice was gentle as he sat down beside her. He didnât say anything for a while, just sat there in silence, letting her cry. When she finally managed to calm down enough to speak, her voice was hoarse, broken.
âI donât understand, Diego. I donât understand how this happened. How could he fall in love with her? After everything weâve been through, how could he justâŚforget about me?â
Diego sighed, rubbing a hand over his face. âI donât know, Y/N. I really donât. Lila and IâŚwe had our problems. I wasnât always the best husband, and I know why things went wrong between us. But you and FiveâŚyou two were perfect together. You were the strongest team Iâve ever seen. I donât understand how he could do this.â
Y/N let out a shaky breath, the pain still raw and aching in her chest. âI thought we had something special. I thought he loved me more than anything.â
âHe did, Y/N. I know he did,â Diego said softly. âI thinkâŚI think being stuck there for so long messed with his head. It changed him in ways we canât understand. But that doesnât make it right. It doesnât make it hurt any less.â
Y/N sniffled, wiping at her eyes. âI donât know how to move on from this, Diego. I donât know how to live in a world where Five isnâtâŚmine.â
Diego put an arm around her shoulders, pulling her close. Y/N leaned into him, grateful for the comfort even as the pain tore at her heart. She felt Diegoâs chest heave as he spoke, his voice thick with emotion.
âYouâre strong, Y/N. Stronger than anyone I know. Youâll get through this, I promise. And Iâll be here for you, whatever you need.â
Y/N nodded, though the pain still felt unbearable. She clung to Diego, letting the tears flow freely again, her heart breaking with every sob. She had lost the man she loved, the man she thought would be by her side forever. And now, she had to find a way to pick up the pieces and move on, even if it felt impossible.
As the day wore on, the two of them sat together, their grief shared and understood. And while Y/N knew the road ahead would be difficult, she also knew she wasnât alone. She had her family, her strength, and the hope that someday, the pain would lessen, and she would find a way to heal.
But for now, all she could do was cry and try to make sense of the shattered pieces of her heart.
Hey, I read your last Five fics which I absolutely loved and I was wondering if I could request a (Five x Reader) or (Five x OC) in which Five betrays the MC with Lila in the subway and when they come back MC leaves him and meets someone else who she falls deeply in love with (probably married her new partner and even has children) and years later Five finds her and he tries to fix everything because he realized that whatever happened with Lila was not real love and then he witnesses MC with her new family and realizes that it couldâve been him if only he wouldâve treasured her love and stayed loyal to her?
I just love angst with a happy ending for the person who was betrayed and a miserable life for the traitor.
a/n: iâm inclined to agree, bad people deserve to get whatâs coming to them!! i know everyone really wanted a pt. 2 to the cheating!Five fic and thatâs what this turned into so⌠hope you enjoy!â¤ď¸
summary: youâve moved on, fiveâs still recovering from the life that couldâve been
warnings: cheating
word count: 2.2k
tags: @snixx2088
pt. 1
Five checked the address in his notepad for the hundredth time since heâd left his apartment. He looked back up at the house with its neat entryway and wide, glorious front garden. There were cream roses spiralling around the white picket fences and he wondered if you were the one whoâd painted them. You'd always had a knack for fixing things up and making them shine better than they had without you, himself included. Your entire house, no, home, was beautiful - but what else did he expect? It was yours, after all.
He took a deep breath, wringing out his hands that were already sweating profusely. He hadnât felt nerves like these in years. It had been so long since youâd last seen him and your life looked so perfect and picturesque without him in it that he felt selfish for dirtying your lawn with his presence.
Things had been difficult during the split, you couldnât even hold his eye or be alone in the same room as him after the events of Christmas Eve. But even after everything, youâd still been straight with him, and civil too, when you told him that you were going to stay somewhere else for a while. You'd needed some time before the two of you could be close again and, of course, heâd agreed. To tell the truth, at the time he hadnât even minded. He had Lila then. Why was there any need for you to stay around?
But after a while, she had left too. For Lila, their seven years together really only had been a fling, a spur of the moment. She went back to her husband, her family. And Diego, being softer than you were, let her, no matter what sheâd done or how badly sheâd hurt him. The two of them had pushed forward and eventually theyâd made it to the other side. They werenât the same couple as they had been, but they were doing better, and for them that was enough.
After that, Five had grown bitter towards you and the way youâd reacted. Why couldnât you see things the way Diego had? Why hadnât you taken him back and reassured him that you would fix it all, like his brother had done for Lila? That was how things were supposed to go.
He was angry at Lila for a while too, for choosing her family over the future he wanted with her. He hadn't understood how their affair was formed by circumstance, not love. He knew better now.
Looking back, a small part of him actually respected you more for turning him away. It was strong of you to choose yourself for once and he was proud of how youâd pushed through, even when he had begged and pleaded for you to take him back.Â
He wouldnât do that today, he promised himself, as he marched on and up the steps of your front porch. He brushed his hair out of his face and then he reached up, knocking on the door. He heard the soft thump of feet on the hardwood floors draw closer.
The door opened and there you stood, smiling, âHi!â You paused as you registered who it was that stood in front of you. Shocked, you said, âOh! You are not the mail.â
Five laughed softly, shaking his head, âUh⌠I am not, no.â He silently looked over you, taking in the ways youâd changed since he last saw you. Your hair was slightly longer than it used to be, but it looked good, suited you. As did the outfit you were wearing. He didn't dare to say that out loud though.
âI⌠Hi, Five. What can I do for you?â You asked, stepping out onto the porch and gently closing the door behind you. Heâd missed your soft-spoken voice and hearing it made a dreamy smile form on his face.
âI wanted to check on you, see how youâve been.â He gestured to your front door, âMay IâŚ?â
You hesitated for a moment but then you sighed, nodding and smiling weakly, âYeah, of course. Come on in.â You say, opening the door again and leading him inside. Youâre walking three strides ahead of him as you ask, âCan I get you anything? Tea? Coffee?â
âUh, yeah. Coffee would be great, actually.â He says, blinking up at you in slight surprise as he steps into your home. He was expecting more resistance. The interior of your home is just as nice as the outside. Itâs warm and so clearly full of the love that youâve put into it. His eyes are drawn to the pictures on the shelf in the walkway.
There are a few of you with his siblings. Heâs not surprised about that. In the wake of your divorce, it was you that theyâd sided with and, even now, they were still treading lightly around Lila and him at family functions. What does surprise him are the two children that Klaus has his arms wrapped around in the family portrait at some celebration or other. They feature in several photos, dressed in pretty dresses and sporting toothy grins in almost every one.
Before he can overthink it, your voice is calling out to him, âFive?â You poke your head out of the kitchen door and he smiles resignedly. He stands up and follows you into the kitchen. He sits on one of the stools at the island.
The only sound comes from you, pouring out his coffee. You fetch yourself a water and then slide his mug towards him. He smiles gently, taking the warm beverage into his hands, âThank you, love.â
Leaning on the counter, opposite him, your head snaps up to look at him as you laugh nervously. Catching his mistake, Five shakes his head, laughing a little himself, âSorry. I guess it's still a force of habit.â
âItâs fine.â You say with a small smile, sipping from your own glass. The silence becomes comfortable. There was something familiar about this routine, enjoying the quiet company of one another and it settles any nerves left in Five.
Steadying his breath, his eyes search the kitchen for answers of what your life has looked like these last few years. More than a few times, heâd asked his siblings and theyâd given little or sometimes even nothing to work with. He wished he still knew your ins and outs like he used to.
He finds his answers hanging up in a frame on the far wall. Itâs a nice photo of you, your happiness shines out of it and watches over the room. Thereâs someone else in it too. Five doesnât recognise him but by the placement of his hands, he knows what he must mean to you.
Five clears his throat, pointing to the photo with his mug, âWhoâs the guy?â
You look up and feel your cheeks flame as you find the photo you had taken on your last vacation, âHeâs my partner.â You say and your smile is shy as you talk about him. One mention of this guy and youâre already indescribably smile-y.
It makes Fiveâs stomach churn when you say, âWeâve been together for nearly five years now.â
âOh, wowâŚâ He says, eyebrows raising. Heâs trying and failing miserably to mask his surprise and pain. Itâs not as if he expected you to come running back into his arms with some crazy love confession or anything, but he didnât think youâd have moved on either.
What hurts the most is how happy you look to be talking about your new partner, your eyes lit up with affection that used to be reserved for him, âThatâs⌠thatâs amazing, congratulations.â
You smile softly, wrapping your arms around yourself as you set your glass down, âThank you.â
âAnd the kids in those photos in the hallwayâŚ?â Five says, glancing over his shoulder as if theyâll come barreling in at any second. Heâs not sure he could face two girls with eyes just like yours staring back at him.
You nod, âTheyâre mine, yeah. Theyâre three. At pre-school right now, but, you knowâŚâ You answer, shrugging and smiling at the thought of your twin little girls.
After your time at The Commission, youâd been terrified of the mother you'd be. Some days it still felt like you were waiting for the other shoe to drop and for you to turn into a cruel, awful person. But, you hadn't so far and your partner was always there to soothe you when those thoughts started to creep up on you.
You were still learning that it was okay to be a mother and have had your own life before that as an assassin. Being a good killer didnât stop you from being a good mother and you were more than capable of giving your girls the love they deserved. Everything you did was for the good of them and you were doing an amazing job at giving them a happy and completely normal life.
âJesus, wowâŚâ Five laughs to himself, running a hand over his face as he looks back at you. Heâs speechless, hearing about the wonderful life that youâve built yourself. He feels a deep-rooted guilt spring up in him. He never gave you that life but it was plain to see how much you craved it and how you were thriving in it.
Heâd spent so long saying that maybe, one day, in between all of the chaos of your lives, youâd find time for a quiet life like this. Heâd spent every waking moment pushing the future and its commitments as far away as he could, arguing that all he wanted was to focus on you whilst he had you in his arms. But he had never given you what you wanted and now youâd found it with someone else.
Swallowing down the ache in his chest, he pulled his mug closer to himself, seeking out the warmth of it on his palms to ground him, âYou look really happy.â
âI am, I really am.â You say, smiling softly at him. You were happy that Five had come here today, that you could get some true closure on your time together, it felt like a lifetime ago now. Sunlight poured into the kitchen and your bracelet shimmered under its rays, a dazzling silver.
A strained smile makes its way onto Fiveâs face at the sight of it, yet another symbol of the fact that didnât belong to him anymore. It hurt to admit it but silver suited you far better than gold ever did, and heâs sure that thereâs a metaphor somewhere in there but he wasn't ready to face the truth behind it yet.
You take another sip of water and thereâs a peaceful silence that falls over the room that gives you both the chance to absorb everything thatâs passed between you in the last two decades. You look over his features and tilt your head to the side, âWhat about you, though? Howâre you doing?â
Five could answer with what heâs really thinking - that heâs sorry for putting your dreams on the back-burner and that he didn't treasure you the way should've the first time around. He wants to tell you that if you go with him right now and give it all up that he can be the one to provide for you instead and he wants to tell you that he would be so much better than your new partner ever could - but he wonât, he promised he wouldn't.
Instead, he smiles weakly, shrugging his shoulders as he sits up, âIâm doing okay.â
Youâve said it yourself, youâre happy as you are and, unlike him, you're not hung up on the 'what ifs' and the 'could've beens'. You don't need him anymore and he's not selfish enough to risk ruining your happiness just to make some pathetic promise that you both know he won't keep.
âYeah? Thatâs good. Iâm glad.â You smile and the genuinity in your voice is the real kicker. Youâre such a good person that you still care enough to want to know that heâs alright after everything, when he's still weighing up whether he should ruin your relationship or not.
He canât help but question if he ever deserved you in the first place.
Thereâs a knock at the door and the both of you jump slightly. You laugh, âThat must be the mail.â You set your glass down, padding out of the room.
He chuckles to himself, nodding, âLooks like it.â He mutters, finishing the dregs of his coffee and places the mug down on the counter as he stands up. He has to get out before he ruins your life all over again with words that you don't want to hear.
Walking back into the room with two boxes on your hip, you watch as he picks up his coat, âOh! Please, donât feel rushed, you donât have to leave yet. I donât have to go get the girls for another few hours.â
Five shakes his head, âNo, it's alright. Iâll get out of your hair.â He says, walking into the hallway, âThank you, by the way, for the coffee.â
âOf course, youâre welcome.â You say, following behind him as he walks out of the door.
He hovers on the porch and you smile kindly at him, âJust... please, donât be a stranger, Five.â
I saw your requests were open and because I'm very hurt/comfort I would like reader to be fives spouse and then the subway happens like the after of everyone learning about it at the house and having to bring up what happened with not only Diego but us as well who thought we [Five and spouse] were happy??? Immaculate. Also I hope you're doing well stay hydrated!
a/n: thank you so much for your request, i am super hydrated, thank you :)) i really loved writing this (even if it is a little angsty) and i hope you love it just as much
summary: you thought you were happy together - if only you knew how wrong you were.
warnings: mentions of canon compliant violence, cheating (obviously), lila x fiveđŹ
word count: 2.1k
pt. 2
Christmas Eve would always be a time of joy and merriment for many, and the same had been true for you for all of your life. Even when youâd spent a few decades working as a trained killer for The Commission, the holidays were always a normality and a comfort that you could fall back on, without fail. In between snapping necks and pulling triggers, youâd seen the snow covered hills of Lapland and the warm festivities of Munichâs Christmas Markets and now that you were retired, you could enjoy it all with your family.
The family that your husband, Five, had brought you into. Whilst there was some initial shock from the Hargreevesâ siblings as they found out that not only had their brother aged forty-five years without them on a post-apocalyptic Earth but that he had actually gotten engaged in that time, slowly but surely, they had let you in. They were chaotic, at the best of times, but you loved them all the same and you knew that youâd do anything to protect them now. They were your family, just as much as Five was.
Youâd met Five at the commission, when he was worn down by a lengthy four decades of solidarity and youâd pieced him back together. Youâd shown him that living wasnât just a means to an end and that it could be good and loving. Youâd joked at the time how silly it was, that the two of you had found love at an organisation designed to kill, for the most part, innocent people. Heâd said heâd do it a thousand times over if it meant heâd get to you.
After spending the last few years trying and failing to stop the apocalypse, you werenât quite those people anymore. Instead, you had grown and evolved but youâd never had the luxury of waiting around for the two of you to settle down and retire like youâd both hoped for. So, when youâd come to this timeline, Five powerless, you hadnât looked back. Youâd gotten married, whilst you knew you still could and youâd lived the last six years in bliss. Five had softened now that there wasnât the weight of impending doom on his back and you both got to be enveloped in the love youâd worked so hard for without consequence.
Tonight, you had gone over to Diego and Lilaâs place to spend the evening with your extended family. At some point in the evening, Five and Lila had reappeared from whatever theyâd spent the day doing and since heâd got back, Five had been unsettled. His eyes kept flickering over to Diego and Lila, constantly. He looked seething. Your husband had never been one for public displays of affection and Diegoâs increasingly wandering hands mustâve been beginning to anger him, you thought. Five frowned, how was he supposed to enjoy his evening with that sitting across from him?Â
Noticing his restlessness, you slipped your hand over his comfortingly, feeling the cool metal of his wedding ring slide over your palm, âYou okay?â
Five glanced back at you. He cleared his throat and nodded, smiling gently at you, âIâm alright, love.â
Occasionally, Lila would look over at him. She looked shy and timid under Diegoâs touch, a look youâd never seen on her before. Lilaâs love had always been performative and outlandish. Her affection was everywhere and to see her look so strained in his company was strange. It was entirely foreign to watch it play out and it didnât match the Lila Hargreeves youâd come to know. Diego noticed too.
Even Luther noticed the tension in the room. He watched as Five rolled his shoulders for the hundredth evening, âWhat is with you tonight? Youâve barely said a word, Five, when does that ever happen?â
So, it wasnât just you then? You thought to yourself. A ball of anxiety began to develop in your stomach. You searched Fiveâs face for the root of the problem. Five sighed and adjusted himself, âItâs called thinking, Luther. You should try it sometime.â
A flurry of shock and distaste shot up from everyone as he said that and you shrank slightly in your seat. Five bristled as you got closer. You frowned.
âI do think, I think youâre an asshole.â Luther clapped back, pouting as he leaned back against the couch. At this moment, you happened to agree. Five didnât brush you away, physically, but he kept his eyes forward, anywhere but down at you. You felt dread in the pit of your stomach.
Five continued to avoid your gaze as Allison sighed, brushing her hair from her face, âOkay, can we not do this right now?â Her eyes drifted pointedly to Claire, Grace and the twins in the corner of the room, happily occupying themselves with toys and the tv which displayed a graceful ballerina one of the girls was currently trying to imitate.
âNo, letâs. Letâs do this now.â Five said, smiling bitterly at her as he stood from the couch and dropped your hand.
You sighed, sitting forward, âFive-â
âFive, itâs gonna be okay.â Lila interrupted, smiling reassuringly from where she sat. Your head swivelled around to her, in time with Diegoâs, eyebrows furrowed in confusion.
Before you had the chance to question Lila, Five smiled sarcastically at you all, moving his hand to cut her off, âNo, itâs not gonna be okay.â
Diego shot from his seat, chuckling, âHey, come on, man. Donât talk to my wife like that. Not tonight. Not on Christmas.â
Five squares up to him, broadening his shoulders and raising his eyebrows at his brother, âYou going to do something about it, fuckface?â
An uproar of protests from all of the others. Your eyes widen as things begin to escalate and you stand up, reaching for his arm, âFive!â
He glances back at you. Diego scoffs and steps closer, prodding Fiveâs chest, âYeah, Iâm gonna K-I-C-K your A-S-S, man.â
âOh wow, somebodyâs passed the first grade.â Five says sarcastically, still not backing down.Â
âFive.â You say again, more forcefully as you step up to them. Lila gets up and steps between them, putting her hands on each of their chests and pushing them away from one another. Your eyes flare as you watch her fingers skim Fiveâs chest. They follow her hand up to her wrist and-
âWhat is that?â You ask, reaching for her wrist. A silver bracelet, woven like vines, dangles from her arm. You roll your sleeve back, looking at your own bracelet. The one that Five had given you on some anniversary or other, heâd had it made especially for you - strung together with gold, because silver was too trivial for someone like you, heâd said.
The bracelet felt trivial altogether as you looked at its pattern now, beside Lilaâs - practically identical to your own. Cheaper, yes, but still like yours, âWhatâs what?â Lila asked innocently, taking her wrist back.
âThat thing on your wrist.â Diegoâs eyebrows furrow as he takes Lilaâs wrist and he glances between your wrist and Lilaâs, âYou hate bracelets. You traded the one that I got you for Valentineâs last year to the pawn shop. WhatâŚâ
âWhere did you get it?â You demand, looking her in the eye with a determination that you havenât felt in years. Lila stands there guiltily, leaning in Fiveâs direction and your heart sinks. Diego watches, the dots connecting in his mind.
âDid you give her that?â He asks, stepping closer to Five. Lila reaches out for him and he shrugs her off, âNo, answer the question, Five. Did you give her that?â
âI made it.â Five answers, hands slipping into his pockets. Heâs casual, as if it means nothing, and that only makes it hurt so much more because if this gift to Lila means nothing, then you must mean even less.
âYou made it⌠for her?â You say, hurt and grief for the life youâve had together seeping into your voice. And just when you think he canât get any more cruelâŚ
âWho does it look like I made it for?â He says, looking over at you, and your heart shrivels up painfully. A dull ache blooms in your chest and you canât even form a response because heâs being so cutting and itâs something youâve never had from him before.
Diego steps up, pressing a hand to your arm and giving it a gentle squeeze as he pushes you back. He takes a breath and looks between Lila and Five, biting his lip, âIs there something going on between you two?â
The two stare silently for a moment and Lilaâs voice grows soft as she looks at her husband, âDiego-â
Diego holds his hands up and turns away, âHoly shit⌠Holy shit, I was right!â He says, pointing at them both, his voice a mix of anger and disappointment in the people heâd trusted.
âBook club, a- all this time, you- you were cheating on me withâŚâ He canât even get the words out properly as he looks at them, his stutter resurfacing as his emotions get the better of him. He looks over at you, your eyes widen further, if thatâs even possible as you realise things for yourself.
âOh my god⌠oh my god, I am a complete and utter fool.â You say, laughing in shock as you mentally take a step back from the last few months.
This is what you got for letting your guard down, you supposed, âI canât believe you⌠why did I never⌠you were never doing research, were you? You were off with her.â
âNow, just wait-â Five starts, holding his hands up and trying to approach you at the same time that Lila says, âNo, we werenât cheating on you. At least, not when you thought we wereâŚâ
âWhat? What is that supposed to mean?â You ask, scoffing and folding your arms over your chest.
âIt means that, for us, itâs been seven years. I blinked us to the subway and we got stuck down there.â Five said, stepping forward.
âPlease, tell me youâre joking.â You say, shoulders dropping as your heart clenches, all of your defences falling.
âLove, I wish I was.â He says tenderly, stepping closer to you again. He takes a deep breath, âWe were lost for seven years, Y/N.â
Seven years. Heâd spent almost as much time with her as he had with you. Were you really that disposable? Youâd thought that things were good between the two of you, great even, but the moment heâd been out of your sights, heâd done thisâŚ
Breaking down, you sit back on the couch, putting your head in your hands as you blink back tears. Five sighs, sitting beside you, âWe went through a lot of timelines and I promise, I never stopped trying to get home, you know I never would, but⌠I got tired. Tired of failing over and over and I had to stop.â
âI wouldnât have given up.â You say, drying your eyes as you look up at him again. Five smiles tiredly, shaking his head.
âYou canât know that.â He says, looking over at you. His eyes are soft, but it doesnât stop the harsh sting of what he says.Â
âI can, because I love you, itâs as simple as that.â You protest, looking at him brokenly, âYou wouldnât have stopped looking if you loved me the way that I love you.â
He rubs his thumb over his clenched knuckles, sighing, âDonât say that. You know that I love you.â
âOf course. And her? What about Lila? Do you love her too?â You challenge, eyes flitting over every pore in his face, seeking an answer or an apology, anything that isnât going to confirm what you so deeply fear; that he doesnât love you anymore.
Lila perks up from where sheâs standing beside Diego. Diegoâs face drops and all either of you can do is watch as your partners lock eyes with one another instead of you. Five sighs, glancing back at you, âY/N, now is really not the time for-â
âDo you love her?â You ask again.
He glances between the two of you and sighs again. It feels like thatâs all heâs capable of doing right now, sighing. You want to scream or yell or cry because that isnât fair, he doesnât get to be frustrated or hurt when this is his fault and you shouldnât be feeling bad for him when he looks so defeated but you just canât help it because itâs Five, your Five, and youâve never known anything else but wanting whatâs best for him.
He parts his lips, about to speak, before Claire interrupts from where sheâs sat on the floor, âHey, grown-ups! Look at the TV! Isnât that Uncle Ben?â
Five stands up to look with the other Hargreeves and you steady yourself. This is okay, you think, you can let things go on as normal. Just for a little longer.
Summary; In which everything is outed between Five, your husband, and Lila, your brother in lawâs wife.
âThen he goes and spoils it all by saying something stupid like âI love you.â
Warning; Angst, cheating, spoilers for S4.
A/n: I found this season to be terrible, but ugh the angst I can make with it is juicy.
You feel nauseous, bile raising in the back of your throat, tears pricking your eyes threatening to fall. You feel embarrassed. All eyes on you, Five, Diego, and Lila.
You want to scream.
Youâve known Five since The Temps Commission, and youâve spent years together happily married. You felt awful for being jealous of his looks towards Lila, but you just thought you were being paranoid; you could trust him. You always had.
Still, you were right. They had both been acting strangely when they returned. Exchanging heartbreaking smiles, lingering looks, and delicate touches.
Then the fucking bracelet.
You slap Five across the face with an unsteady hand, hoping to make a mark. Your wedding ring was on the hand that you smacked him, and the blow caused a tiny cut in his face.
Loud âoosâ and a gasp come from the siblings on the couch.
"You are disgusting. Were you with his wife, your brother's fucking wife?" Five just looked at you, his cheek cupping, grief rushing through him. You push him away when he reaches out to you.
âYou donât understand. We were stuck there for seven years. Every day I thought about coming home to you, but it felt hopeless. I felt like I was going insane.â He trying, desperately wanting you to understand, but how can you?
âSo, what, You gave up? You gave up on finding a way back?â You shake your head in disbelief. Five would never give up, the man in front of you is not the man you met all those years ago.
The one you married wouldâve fought tooth and nail to get back to you.
âI knew something was going on since you got back; Iâm not blind, Five. I⌠I thought I was being paranoid; I felt horrible for not trusting you, my husband." You look down at your ring; its typical shine is dulling.
All those years, the surviving, the fighting, saving the world. Together. Was all forgotten and all for nothing within a couple of hoursâfor you at least.
âIt took seven years for 45 long ones to be nothing.â You mumbled taking the ring off, and throwing it at himâwhich he caught, a terrified glance at it in his hand.
There was a stunned silence, Klaus perched on the couch waiting for more along with the others.
You feel exposed, you don't want to be vulnerable while thereâs onlookers, gawking at your ruined marriage taking place in your in-lawâs living room.
âFive, I hope those fleeting moments with her were worth it.â
You turn your heel and walk away, ignoring the pleas from Five and the siblings for you to come back.
Some part of you that will love Five unconditionally wants him to run after you.
Your hands are tight around your arms, shaking.
You remember the train Five talked about...
You cautiously take steps down to the train station, the overhead lights buzzing eerily. No one was there, only yourself and the lone train.
Staggering to one of the doors, you quickly get on. Not looking back.
You take a seat, when your legs give out. Tears watering down your face, you do nothing to wipe them away. Youâre tired. You donât look back.
The train dings, the lights flickering, the train ramping up, and the doors shutting. You nervously tried to play with your ring finger but there was nothing to fidget with.
You donât look back.
If you did.
You wouldâve seen Five. Standing there solemnly, heavy tears going down his face as the weight of this breaks him. His fist tightens around your wedding ring, you leaving breaks him.
The wind from the train blows his hair to the side as he watches you leave.
Five Hargreeves x Fem!Reader
Synopsis: You and Five return after seven years away in a different timeline- but you donât return alone
Word Count: 1.8k
Tags: Fluff, No Lila and Five, Pregnancy, Children, Season 4 fix it (kinda)
Note: Got so much love on the last one I wrote this! Try to ignore spelling mistakes it's currently 3am.
ââ â§
Stuck with only your irritable CIA colleague Five Hargreeves was anything but a good time. You both got lost at the godforsaken subway station he mistakenly teleported you both to. Travelling for a year by his side certainly mellowed you out. His personality slowly making you feel comforted as you both explored multiple timelines together trying to find your way home.
Surprisingly, the idea he possessed powers was the easiest thing for you to come to terms with, probably due to your job at the CIA making it seem plausible to you that the government does hide a lot- theyâre even hiding the whole science of separate timelines. After around a year of trying and failing to find your way home, you and Five decided to ease off the vigorous schedule you unwittingly created, finding a timeline safe enough to stay in for a while allowing you both to rest and brainstorm ideas of how you could both find a way home to your families.Â
You both made a mistake. Falling to know how long a while would be you find yourselves still in the timeline you chose as your âtemporaryâ home six years later. Finding each other a lot less frustrating than at the start of this. You suppose thatâs an understatement as you watched Five play with your child, a girl who possessed brown hair and green eyes not too dissimilar to her fatherâs. It almost wasnât fair how much her features favoured his. But, seeing his beauty reflected upon her features could never be something you would complain about.Â
âMaybe if we get lucky the next one will resemble you more,â you remember his words from a few days earlier when you started to show a hand placed under your abdomen smiling as if this was the greatest gift he could ever receive. But you donât think it would matter if this one ended up looking like their older sibling and their father. If anything you would prefer it- not that you would ever admit it.
Picking another fresh strawberry from the greenhouse of the abandoned home you now called your own. You placed it into the basket plans to make jam and jelly already filling your mind when you felt yourself begin to flush from the sweltering heat of the sun beating down upon the glass. Your skin heating up to a point of large discomfort, sweat beginning to gather at your temples. You sighed knowing that you couldn't continue to harvest anything else unless you wanted to face Fiveâs rath over you overheating again.Â
âMom!â Maxine ran towards you eagerly hands encircling your legs as she got close enough for a welcoming hug. She quickly looked up towards you big green eyes staring at you prettilyÂ
âHiya munchkinâ You stroked the top of her hair as she smiled up at you with glee
âWhat doing?â the three-year-old questioned head titling as she waited for your responseÂ
âStrawberriesâ was all you replied grabbing the basket to show herÂ
âHave one?â she asked pointing at the basket, batting her eyes to try to sway your decision. You simply plucked one out of the basket and gave it to her relishing in the delighted smile she sent your way before biting into the sweet fruit. You smiled at her before looking up to meet the other pair of green eyes that had made their way into the greenhouse. Five watched the interaction of his favourite girls softly only moving closer once you looked at him.
âEverything alright mumma?â he questioned noticing your flustered expression from the moment he and Maxine stepped foot in the conservatory
âA bit hotâ you admitted with a shrug of your shoulders as he drew closer, trapping Maxine in between the two of you as the back of his hand touched your forehead he hummed in agreement with your words
âLetâs get you inside the house, donât need you getting heatstrokeâ You forced down the urge to roll your eyes at his dramatics and simply nodded in agreement
âSome cold water and a sit down would be nice.â
He grabbed one of your hands and Maxineâs with the other leading you both back towards the house. After placing the basket of strawberries in the kitchen you quickly sat down on the couch feeling a slight ache in your feet while Five grabbed you a glass of water with more icecubes than you could even count, you smiled in thanks as he passed it to you while Maxine sat next to you, a small children book in hands that she was determined to read to you and her younger sibling as she wanted them to be just as smart as her.Â
You could hear Five pattering around the house, tidying up before you could even think about it. Maxine had quickly given up on trying to read, getting bored after two pages and was instead sitting playing with some wooden blocks by your feet. You furrowed your eyebrows when you couldnât hear Five moving around anymore a stark silence surrounding you now.
âEverything alright?â you shouted trying to figure out where he had gotten to, heart fluttering when there was no reply. Setting your glass down on the table in front of you as you rose from your rather comfortable spot on the couch, you walked into the other room where your lover was his body was stick straight, eyes not daring to leave the notebook in his hand. âWhat?â you questioned softly walking towards him, eyeing the words on the book as you got close enough.
âThisâ he began astounded âIs our way home, itâs written by me but I didnât write this. Another me did.â you simply nodded before smiling Â
âLooks like weâre going home.â
ââ â§
You and Five found yourselves outside of what he assured you was his brother Diegoâs house. Maxine who was resting her head on his shoulder, legs wrapped around his middle looked astounded by the snow while nerves filled you- the last time you saw any of his family was when you were put on the case that got you lost in the timelines to begin with and even then you barely saw his brothers and sister-in-law as they were quickly taken to hq for a show round to get them out of the way. You didnât even want to think how you would explain this to them let alone to your own family but you guess this is the easier of the two as they all had powers and also been to multiple different timelines. Five set Maxine down next to you as he rapped on the door you quickly grabbed her hand before she could run off into the snow when the door openedÂ
âYou back!â the man, Diego you assumed, smiled as he looked at FiveÂ
âI amâ he stared at his brother almost in shock that he had seen him for the first time for him in seven years
âGoodâ the man confirmed âWe were all starting to get worried.â his eyes then turned towards you and the brunette-haired little girl who was trying to hide behind you âAnd you are?â he questioned and you quickly gave him your name his eyes sparking in recognition for some reason as he crouched to the ground to greet your daughter âAnd who is this little princess?â he asked quietly as Maxine started at himÂ
âThis is Maxineâ is all you said feeling Fiveâs eyes on you knowing he wanted to wait until you got inside to drop the bomb you could see Diego begin to connect the dots as he introduced himself to you but he was clearly confused because he would know if Five had a child in the last three years in this timeline at least.
âI will explain everything once we get inside- canât let the missus get coldâ is all he said to Diego as the man allowed you into his home.Â
He quickly led you to the living room where to sat on the sofa, Maxine being picked up by Five and placed on his lap when she tried to climb onto yours, you turned towards him to complain but quickly stopped when you met his glower instead choosing to put a comforting hand on your tummy a habit you kept from your first pregnancy. Diego called for his wife Lila to come to sit with him when the door opened revealing more of Fiveâs family he whispered their names to you as they walked in all choosing to sit down when Diego told them that Five was going to explain where heâs been and why his colleague, a word you hadnât been referred to as in a long time, was here. With most of his family here excluding Ben and Viktor, he cleared his throat to get their attention
âAs you all know the marigold has made our powers a little different to what we are used toâ They all made sounds of agreement âMy blinking takes only to a tube station where each stop is a new timeline and weâ gesturing to you âgot stuck, unable to find our way back until now. We were away for seven years but for you has only been a few hoursâ he took their silence as a sign to continue âThis is my wifeâ he spoke your name âAnd our daughter Maxine.â you sat in silence for a moment.
âWait! This is the colleague he was always telling us about?â Luther asked excitedly you turned to the larger man confused when Klaus and Allison quickly agreed with him
âI thought he was joking when he said there was a cute girl who he worked cases withâ Claire, Alisonâs daughter, announced making her mother and uncles laugh
âI canât believe you have a childâ Lila spoke eyes wide
âWell he is going to have another one in a couple of months,â you told the already shocked woman who quickly smiled at the revelation while the others called out congratulations to their brotherÂ
âHow far along are you?â Allison asked as she came up to you silently questioning if she could touch the small bump you simply nodded âWe think around thirteen weeksâ looking to Five who simply nodded
âShe only started showing a few days agoâ
âI canât believe itâ Luther called out while pulling funny faces making Maxine laugh as she got a little less shy around her family.
You smiled as you watched Maxine get up and walk towards Lilasâ children playing with them as Fiveâs hand found its way to yours stroking your knuckles. You never thought you could ever get home let alone come back home happier than you had left it. You suppose a thanks was due to your rather irritable husband and his wacky powers.
Summary: six years of travelling to different timelines, and Five isnât sure how much longer he can go on for. Until he stumbles upon a greenhouse, full of strawberries. And you.
Word count: 4212
A/N: so season 4 was a⌠thing that happened. This story is basically my own idea of how things shouldâve gone in ep 5. Instead of the weird Lila/Five situation, itâs just Five, and his chance of living a normal life with someone new. Hope you all enjoy, and feedback is appreciated :)
Number Five was never one to back down from a challenge. Having been through a series of different apocalyptic events, transporting to a timeline where he spent 40 years alone, and dealing with a misfit group consisting of his exhausting siblings, Five was up for anything. But the current situation he was dealing with? For the first time in his life, he was at breaking point.
After another wasted day spending hour after hour searching for any clues or information on how to get back to the correct timeline, Five returns to the subway, entering one of the compartments and slumping down in the first chair he sees. He rubs his eyes and lets out a visceral sigh, wanting nothing more than to go to sleep. He reaches into his pockets, pulling out a small pack of dried fruits. He rips it open and devours every last piece. He canât remember the last time he had a proper meal. He was becoming more desperate, rummaging through trash cans and foraging in bushes, hoping anything he picks isnât poisonous.
The compartment jolts and begins to move, making its way to the next timeline. Five wipes his hands on his already dirty pants, standing up and walking slowly to the door. He wonders whether his apocalypse counterpart will be waiting for him this time.
After several minutes, and Five almost falling over from his lack of sleep, he finally arrives, the doors opening. He steps out, immediately making his way up the stairs. No time to waste. He cautiously pokes his head out, looking around for any signs of, well, himself. Before he can move out more, something wizzes past his head. A bullet. He ducks, as more shots are fired directly at him.
âGive me a fuckinâ break,â Five mumbles, as he finally takes notices of the other him in the distance.
He sticks up his middle finger, and no soon after closes his fists, blinking as quick as he possibly could.
The Five with a gun disappears along with the destroyed world around him. Five drops his arms to his sides, turning around and admiring the new environment. Luscious, greenery surrounds him, with an array of different flowers sprouting from the ground beneath him. A small pond with fish glimmers in the sunshine, lily pads floating on top. He continues turning, finding himself standing next to a tall greenhouse. The glass was slightly foggy, making it difficult to see whatâs inside. Five leans in closer, squinting as if that would help. He can barely make out what appears to be pots of fruit and vegetables, some fully sprouted and others not yet ripe. His stomach rumbles, the feeling of hunger consuming him.
A rustle sounds from behind him. He turns quickly, coming face to face with a pair of shears. Five jumps back slightly. He then spots the person wielding said âweaponâ. A young woman, probably early twenties, wearing a light yellow dress and a pair of brown sandals. Five canât help but admire her beauty, if it wasnât for the fact she had a face like fury and didnât seem afraid of cutting him in half.
âCan I help you?â Her words are kind, but her harsh tone says otherwise.
Five canât exactly tell this young woman the truth. Showing up randomly in her back yard, covered in grime, gawking at her crops through the window. He raises his hands up in the air, trying to convey that he meant no harm.
âIâm so sorry,â he says, his throat sore having not spoken to anyone in quite some time. âI donât really know how I got here.â Thatâs not exactly true. âIâve been travelling for a few days now.â Try six years. âAnd I could really do with a hot shower and something to eat.â
The woman doesnât say anything, just staring, with the shears still held out in front of her.
Five puts his arms down, shrugging in defeat. âIâll just go. I truly am sorry, I didnât mean to freak you out.â He looks down. âOr step all over your rose garden.â He gingerly moves away from the destroyed flowers.
He turns and begins to walk away, hoping to find an exit as quick as possible. Blinking in front of this woman probably wouldnât help his cause. A warm hand grabs hold of his wrist, forcing him to stop and look back. She has the shears loosely hanging by her side, as her eyes pierce into Fiveâs. She seems hesitant, words forming in her mind. At last, she speaks again.
âYouâre telling the truth?â
Five nods incessantly, feeling like a child.
âAnd if I let you in and make you something to eat, you wonât try and kill me?â
Five holds back a laugh, knowing sheâs being deadly serious. âI wouldnât dare.â
The woman waits a beat, then huffs. âCome on, I was just about to start dinner.â
She moves past Five, walking into three greenhouse. He takes this as a sign to follow after her.
***
The young woman allows Five to use her shower, and heâs thankful for the change of clothes she provides for him too. The home is small and cosy, playing into the stereotypical cottage core of living. The lighting is soft, and the smell of pumpkin seems to waft through into every room. Itâs calming, itâs peaceful, itâs something that makes Five feel on edge. He isnât used to the domestic life, away from the terror and destruction, trying to save the world over and over. He knows he canât stay here long, but he wonât miss the opportunity of a proper cooked meal.
After putting on the change of clothes, Five makes his way down the hall and into the kitchen, a small buffet waiting for him. He finds it hard not to drool, the potatoes and fresh pie, along with the fruit and vegetables heâd spotted earlier. It looks incredible. He takes a seat, as the woman places down a final plate of tomatoes, sitting down opposite Five.
They dish out the food, filling their plates as high as they can, especially Five. He tries not to look like a slob in front of the pretty girl, but finds it hard not to drop some things down his top. She doesnât seem to notice, or pretends not to.
The woman takes a sip of her drink, clearing her throat. âSo,â her soft voice makes Five look up from his plate. âDo you have a name or is that one of the many mysteries of the man shovelling food down his throat like he hasnât eaten in several years?â
The woman isnât afraid of being upfront. Five admires that. Although, itâs not surprising considering heâs a complete stranger sheâs trusted in her home. He puts down his knife and fork, grabbing a napkin to wipe his mouth.
âNo, I have a name. Itâs Fi-,â he catches himself, unsure if his ânameâ would just create more confusion, and unwanted questions. âJerome. Just, Jerome.â
The woman squints her eyes, but doesnât push further, seeming to move past his stumble. âOkay. I wouldnât have pegged you for a Jerome.â
Five shrugs, not knowing what else to say.
âMy names Y/N.â
Five nods. âOkay. Weâre closer already.â
âDonât push it,â Y/N says, a small smile gracing her face. Five canât help but pull the same expression.
***
After a hearty dinner, and some obvious awkward silences, Five insists on helping Y/N do the washing up. The sun was beginning to set, and Five knows heâll have to leave soon, but something stops him from doing so. He doesnât want to admit it, but this was the most relaxed heâd felt in a long time. The fear or worry of something bad happening wasnât there, and as he stands close to the woman he had barely met 2 hours ago, he realises what heâd been missing in his 60 something years. A place to live, with a person who makes him feel safe.
âJerome,â the voice breaks through his thoughts, as Five almost forgets the name heâd given to this woman. âI feel like weâve skirted around the topic enough. Is there any reason you were in the state you were in, taking refuge behind my greenhouse?â
Five places down the plate he was cleaning, turning to face her fully. Her expression is calm, and her voice shows no sign of interrogation. Itâs a first for Five, as heâs become accustomed to people prodding him for information only for their own benefit. No oneâs ever shown true interest in him.
He shrugs. âItâs been a tough couple of years. More than that I guess.â Fives eyes glaze over. âI havenât seen my family in a long time, and I donât know if I ever will. And if I do, Iâm terrified of the state that Iâll find them in.â
Y/N stops what sheâs doing, also turning to look at Five, a look of worry taking over her face. He knows heâs said more than he should have, but he couldnât help it. Heâs not good at sharing his feelings, and when he does, heâs scared of what will happen once the flood gates are opened. He isnât sure if heâll ever be able to close them.
âWhat dâyou mean? Are they in some kind of trouble?â She asks, a slight shake in her voice. âAre you in trouble?â
Five shakes his head, not wanting to stress out this poor woman whoâs been nothing but doting to him. âNo! No, I just,â he sighs, knowing heâs really put his foot in it. âI just care about them, a lot. Too much. And I donât even want to think about not seeing them again.â
A soft hand brushes against Fiveâs cheek, as he glances at Y/N wiping a tear away from his face. He didnât even realise heâd started crying. He sniffles, moving away and rubbing at his eyes, fearing how red they may look. He sucks in a deep breath, calming his beating heart. Whether itâs from talking about his family, or the touch from the woman next to him, he isnât sure. But he fears heâs overstayed his welcome.
Five moves away from the kitchen counter. âI guess I should probably go. Donât wanna miss my train.â Although he knows theyâll always be one there waiting for him.
He heads for the door, remembering to go upstairs and collect his dirty clothes before he leaves. Footsteps are heard from behind him.
âUh,â Five swivels back around, as Y/N hesitates over her words. âThis may seem kinda forward, and a dangerous move on my part, but, I wouldnât be able to sleep tonight knowing you were out there in the middle of the night, traveling by yourself.â
Five holds his breath, not wanting to jump the gun, but already anticipating the next sentence out of her mouth.
âI have extra pillows, and blankets.â Y/N shrugs. âItâs not the most comfortable couch but Iâd say itâs more comfortable than the chairs on the train.â
Neither of them speak for a while. Five ponders her offer over and over, wondering if this is something he wants to decline. He needs to get back to his family. He needs to get back to help them. But so far, every option has been a bust. Heâs not sure how much longer he can go on for. It could be the apocalypse all over again. Stuck for 40 years, traveling none stop, unsure if heâll ever see his loved ones again. Could a good nights sleep really be such a bad thing?
He thinks the risk is worth it. âAs long as itâs not too much trouble for you.â
***
That one good nights sleep turned into three months, staying at Y/Nâs home, crashing on her couch. It didnât stop Five from going out, back to the subway, trying to find the possible solution to his six year problem. But the more time he spent with the woman, the less time he wanted to spend away from her. They grew closer, making meals together, gardening together, watching silly romcoms together. While Y/N taught Five how to bake, Five taught her how to fight. A young woman living by herself? It didnât hurt knowing some basic defence skills.
Five didnât want to admit it, but his family hadnât crossed his mind as often as it usually did before he met Y/N. Heâd become soft, wanting to be around her all the time, not wanting to visit the subway as often as he should be. Heâs lucky enough to call her a friend. He hopes she calls him that too.
***
Itâs late, and Y/N is sat on the couch, crocheting a few pairs of gloves and a long overdue jumper. People used to make fun of her for it, calling her an old lady, but she finds it soothing. And making your own clothes is a big bonus too. Five, or Jerome as she knew him, had been out most of the day. She never questioned what he was up to, only that he returned safe, ready for whatever sheâd cooked up for him during the day. She wasnât completely naive in thinking âJeromeâ has involved himself in shady business. But unless he plans on telling her, then she wonât bother pushing him on the matter.
A bang echos from the back of the house, specifically inside the geeenhouse. It makes Y/N jump up from her seated position, quickly rushing out to the source of the noise. It can only be one person, or thatâs what she hopes. Either way, she grabs for her shears before entering the warm glass room.
âJerome?â She whispers, watching her step, the only light in the room coming from the moon through the windows.
A muffled groaning reaches her ears, as Y/N blindly moves her hands over the walls, trying to find the light switch. She finally does, and flicks it on. A sharp gasp comes out of her mouth, as the brightness finally reveals her new friend curled in a ball on the floor, rolling in pain.
âShit.â
She quickly makes her way over to him, delicately wrapping her arms around his waist and slowly helping him off the floor. He stumbles, knocking into a few pots, almost making them fall off the table.
âSorry,â he mumbles, the word slurring under his breath.
âDonât apologise,â she says, making sure heâs steady on his feet. âLetâs just get you inside and onto the couch.â
They make their way through into the living room, Five dropping haphazardly onto the soft cushions, while Y/N finally gets a proper look at him. His clothes are ripped, the once pristine suit (one she bought for him as a gift) now in tatters. His hair is sticking up in all different directions, and heâs clutching to his side like his life depends on it. She reaches for his arm, prying it away to reveal an array of bullet wounds, still bleeding.
âYou should see the other guy,â Five jokes, tilting his head back and trying to forget about the burning pain running across his body. Funnily enough, if Y/N saw the other guy, heâd look exactly like him, considering this all happened due to an unfortunate run in with apocalypse Five.
Y/N stares at him with wide eyes. âReally? Look, I donât bother asking where you go or what youâre up to when you leave this house, but I think nowâs the time you tell me the truth.â
Five moves his head back down, looking her in the eyes. Sheâs terrified. And he hates that. He breathes in deep, taking her hand in his.
âIf you can help me patch this shit up,â he briefly motions to his wounds, âthen Iâll tell you who I really am.â
So thatâs what they do. Y/N retrieves the first aid kit from her bathroom, while Five opens up about his life before he met her, and how heâs not from this timeline. He isnât sure if sheâs believing what he says, as she remains quiet the entire time, only occasionally looking up at him and quickly returning to removing the bullets lodged in his side. But she listens. And allows him to pour his heart out to her.
âThe past six years were torture. Somehow worse than the forty I spent in the apocalypse.â Five turns his head and stares at the woman next to him, as she finishes up her work. âBut these last few months with you. I could finally be normal. I could live a life most guys would kill to have. And Iâm so sorry I lied to you this long.â
They fall into silence, the pair somehow closer together than they were a few minutes ago. Both emotionally, and physically. Y/N moves her hand and takes his, squeezing tightly. Fiveâs heartbeat picks up speed, only now noticing their close proximity.
âSo your real name is âFiveâ?â He nods at her words. She nods back. âHmm. It suits you a lot better than Jerome.â
They both laugh half heartedly, as they stare deeply into each otherâs eyes. She moves her hand up to his hair, moving it out of his face, trying to calm it down slightly.
She carries on talking. âI canât even begin to imagine what youâve been through.â Five rolls his eyes. She doesnât even know the half of it. âBut if I can be the person to keep you grounded, for however long youâre here for, then Iâm happy to do just that.â
Five smiles, glancing quickly at her lips.
She does the same. âAnd I hope youâre here for a long time.â
They both lean in, softly pressing their lips against each otherâs. Five cups her face, deepening the kiss as Y/N rests her arms atop his shoulders. They move in sync, careful not to cause any more damage to Fiveâs wounds, as she somehow moves closer, one of her legs wrapping itself around his waist.
They donât stop, clothes discarded, bodies intertwined, as their growing tension is finally broken. Five isnât sure if heâll ever get back to his timeline, but for now, heâs happy to call this place home.
***
Another four months, and still no sign of a way back. Although, Five canât deny he hasnât been trying as hard as usual. The peace and tranquillity has consumed him whole, falling into a proper routine with the woman heâŚ
Is it love? Could he truly fall for someone like this? Someone who isnât involved in the shit show heâs grown accustomed to? Someone who wants that quiet life, watering flowers and baking pies, with him? Maybe itâs what he needs.
Five stands in the greenhouse, picking some fresh strawberries, and trying a few to see if they were ripe. Heâs already found the perfect recipe to use them in. Something he knows sheâll love.
As if reading his thoughts, a pair of arms slip around his waist. Y/N rests her chin on his shoulder, peaking over to see the basket full of fresh fruit. She picks one up, moving away and popping it in her mouth. Five turns and looks at her, smiling wide.
âThey taste perfect,â she says.
Five takes her wrists, pulling her towards him and kissing her lightly. âSo do you.â
She laughs, holding him close and breathing him in. âThe cheesy lines donât work on me, bub.â
âI think they do.â He mumbles, bringing her in for another kiss, sliding his hands up and down her back.
They stay like this for a while, holding each other in the warm glass room. The sun starts to set, as Five looks out and realises what time it is.
âDamn.â
She looks at him, confusion on her face. âWhatâs up?â
He shakes his head. âNothing, I just need to do a double check of the subway before dinner.â
Y/N tries not to show her anxiousness, but some of it seeps through. After Five explained to her what the subway is and why he goes there every day, sheâs terrified at the thought of him leaving and never coming back. But she knows he wouldnât do that to her. Not without saying goodbye.
She steps back. âRight. Promise youâll be safe?â
He kisses her on the cheek. âI promise.â
***
Five spends some time looking around the platform in the subway, checking the lights, checking the maps, even poking his head into the tunnels to see if anything has changed. But nothing. It all remains the same. No sign of his past life waiting for him. Was that such a bad thing?
Holding a small flashlight, he shines it up and down, left and right, hoping his eyes will catch something new. A sudden pop from above startles him, the grip he had on the flashlight loosening. It falls and rolls onto the tracks. Five looks up, noticing one of the bulbs now flickering. He huffs, moving to the edge of the platform and jumping down. He retrieves the flashlight, hitting it a few times to try and get it to work again. It comes to life, flashing in front of him. Thatâs when he spots something.
âThatâs new.â
Five walks over, grabbing the mystery object and holding it up. Itâs a plain notepad. He flips it open, scanning over the messy handwriting inside. His messy handwriting. He canât help but let out a tiny gasp, as he figures out what it all means.
âThis is it.â Tears form in his eyes. âThis is my way back home.â
Heâs shocked. Heâs elated. Heâs emotionally drained. This is his chance to rejoin his timeline. To see his family after so long. To fix the mess theyâve created. But all he can think about in this moment is Y/N. How the hell is he supposed to break the news to her?
***
After another hour spent pondering this new found information, Five slowly makes his way back home. His home. Where the life heâd built was waiting for him.
He enters the house and walks into the kitchen, where Y/N stands by the stove, boiling something sweet and caramelly. Five just stares at her; humming a random tune, wiping her messy hands on the apron he bought for her when her old one accidentally caught fire. That was the most stress heâd felt since coming here. And if that was the only stress he had to deal with, heâd take it every single day.
She finally turns and spots him, smiling wide. âOh hey! I was worried for a sec, you were taking longer than expected.â
She moves closer to him, pulling him into a tight embrace. He holds her, not wanting to let go. Y/N can tell something isnât right.
She leans back. âYou okay?â
Five doesnât reply, only holding the notepad out for her to take. She does so, flipping through the pages just like he did, her expression perplexed.
âI donât understand-â
âItâs the way back to my timeline.â
She looks up at him, mouth slightly open, as her words fall short. Five can swear he hears her heartbeat speed up, as her breathing becomes erratic. Five isnât sure what to do, waiting for an explosion of emotions to rain down on him. But nothing comes. Neither of them do or say anything.
Five chooses to break the silence. âI donât wanna lose you. I canât. I donât think I could live the way I used to live. Not after living this life with you.â
Y/N bites her lip, suppressing a sob. âYou have to go.â
Five furrows his brow, hoping he heard her wrong. He tilts her head up to stare into her eyes, seeing the tears forming.
âNo,â he whispers. âYouâve become the most important thing in my life. The thought of never seeing you again, I canât do that.â
A tear falls down her cheek, as Five reaches out to wipe it away.
âIâd love nothing more than to stay in this little bubble weâve created,â she replies, finding it hard to keep her voice steady. âBut your family, your timeline, all those people? They need you more than I do. And I know deep down, you canât bear the thought of letting them die, knowing you couldâve helped.â
Five wants to ask her to come with him. Become apart of his family. He knows sheâd get on with them all. And theyâd all love her, possibly more than they love him. But he knows itâs cruel to ask her to leave her life behind. The house, the garden, the home that sheâs worked so hard on. And the thought of throwing her into the thick of it all. Putting her at danger? No chance.
He pulls her into his embrace, kissing her hard. They hold each other tight, their lips bruising as neither of them can stop the tears from falling.
Y/N is the first to pull away. âIf you ever get the chance to come back to this timeline, you know where to find me.â
Five smiles, not wanting to let her go. He kisses her once more. âIn the greenhouse, tasting just as sweet as the strawberries.â
notes: so i actually hated this storyline in the show but i also recognize angst potential when i see it so hereâs this
summary: after getting lost in the subway system, Five comes to a grave realization
Five Hargreeves doesnât love you anymore, and youâre completely oblivious to the fact.
Youâre in the kitchen of Lilaâs home baking holiday treats with your niece while awaiting the arrival of the rest of your family to begin the festivities. You smell of cinnamon and pinecones, and for the first time in years you actually feel content and happy with where your life is now. Sure, thereâs technically a looming apocalypse hanging over you right now, but itâs nothing you havenât handled before. Youâre actually part of a family now with a man who adores you, and itâs all youâve ever wanted.
âAlright, Grace, would you like to do the honors of putting the gumdrop buttons on the gingerbread men while I check on the sugar cookies?â
âYes, aunt y/n!â The girl exclaims cheerfully before immediately diving into the candy bowl. You laugh at her eagerness and turn towards the oven only to be met with the sight of Five in the kitchen doorway. He looks disheveled and unnerved, but youâre too engrossed in your own joy filled bubble to pick up on it right away and instead mistake him for being tired and overwhelmed with the situation surrounding Ben and Jennifer.
âHey, you made it!â You say with a smile as you press a chaste kiss to his cheek before turning your attention to the sugar cookies. Five can only stand there stiffly as he clings onto the ghost of your lips against his skin. He had hoped that by seeing you again, by being in your presence and showered in your love for him, the feelings he once held for you would return.
But as he stands there in the middle of the kitchen watching you run about, he realizes that he feels absolutely nothing.
Initially, he had wanted nothing more than to return home to you and his siblings. Five had fought tooth and nail trying to figure out a way to get out of that damned subway system so he could have you in his arms again and tell you how much he missed you even if for you he had only been gone a couple hours. But a man could only take eating so many subway rats and being shot at so many times. He had grown tired, weary, and depressed. For a moment it seemed theyâd be stuck there forever, and so he decided that maybe it was time to make the most of it.
What he didnât expect was to fall in love with his brotherâs wife.
A woman he had once hated with his entire being now was his sole companion, and whether it was due to some sick twist of fate or a moment of weakness, he had begun to look at her the way he once looked at you. With complete adoration and care as well as a fierce need to protect her and keep her safe. He knew the chances of ever seeing you again were highly unlikely, and the next logical step would be to move on. So he did.
But now here he is, back in his original timeline left to deal with the aftermath of his decisions.
In what was seven years for Five and three hours for you, the boy has fallen out of love with you. Your smile still may be as beautiful as ever and your scent of red berry plum and jasmine may be intoxicating to any other man, but he feels absolutely nothing when he looks at you. The spark is gone, and unbeknownst to you your relationship is about to fall apart.
âWhere did you run off to?â You ask him after setting the freshly baked sugar cookies onto the cooling rack nearby.
âI had an⌠errand to run,â he utters carefully, growing stiff when you wrap your arms around his torso and rest your head upon his shoulder. Calculatingly, Five hesitantly rests a hand on your back while the other comes to comb his fingers through your hair. Itâs a familiar motion that he is easily able to replicate in order to portray himself as the same doting partner you know and love. Lila had sworn him to secrecy, but he wasnât sure just how to break it off with you without telling the truth. So for now he would go through the motions and hope to god you didnât pick up on the fact that something was completely wrong.
âIâm happy youâre here,â you profess earnestly, peering up at him with fluttering lashes and a devoted smile. âI love you, Five.â
His chest tightens in agony at your words, his hold on you tightening in an attempt to ground himself as he harshly swallows down his discomfort. He meets your adoring gaze and smiles, carefully tilting your chin upwards to meet his lips in a tender kiss. Itâs believable enough to keep you feeling secure and oblivious to his detachment, and he hopes that maybe if he keeps this up he can forget all about Lila and go back to normal.
Even if it means heâs just playing a part.
Pulling away, he meets your loving stare and offers you a small smile. Hesitating, as if he has to force the words out of him, Five murmurs out a quiet, âI love you, too.â
notes: fulfilling a request asking for a shy!reader meeting Fiveâs siblings for the first time. it was actually very hard squeezing in so many characters into one piece
summary: despite trying his best to avoid it, Five is forced to introduce you to the family
The last thing Five wanted was for you to meet his family. If he could, heâd do everything in his power to keep you away from the chaos and stupidity that was his siblings forever. He didnât need them overwhelming you with their quarreling or reminding you of how utterly tumultuous his home life was, and he felt an unwavering need to keep you separate from the Umbrella Academy. You were the one thing he didnât have to share with his siblings, the one thing he had earned on his own without his powers, and the one thing that was normal in his life. He would do anything to keep his life from tainting your innocence by all means.
The discovery of your existence by his family had been completely accidental. When visiting his new apartment for the first time, Allison and Klaus had stumbled upon a framed photograph that Five had forgotten to stow away before their arrival. In the frame was a beautiful girl with kind features and a gentle smile, her arms lovingly draped around Fiveâs neck as he held her to his side and forced a lopsided grin for the camera. They knew Five had always hated photos, but it seemed here that he was willing to set aside his disdain for being photographed to please this mystery girl.
âWhat are you two looking at?â Five demanded after stumbling upon them staring down at the frame. Eyes widening when he realizes just exactly what the two are looking at, he quickly snatches the photo from Klausâs grasp and holds it protectively against his chest. âI canât believe this, I was gone for two minutes and neither of you could manage to stay out of my things.â
âWhy didnât you tell us you had a girlfriend?â Klaus asks, voice laced with mock offense as he clutches at his chest to mimic being wounded.
âThe details of my personal life are none of your concern,â Five grits through clenched teeth, his tone dripping in annoyance at their snooping and frustration at being caught red handed. How could he have been so sloppy? Five had always been meticulous about every minute detail and keen at covering his tracks when needed, and yet he had failed to protect the most important secret he held.
âSheâs gorgeous,â Allison tells him in hopes of assuaging her agitated brother, âand she looks really sweet. Why would you hide something like this?â
âThis may come as a shock to you, Allison, but you guys arenât exactly great at first impressions,â he explains condescendingly with a tight lipped smile, doing his best to hold back the urge to use more colorful language and insults. âThe last thing I need is for you guys to start hashing out old childhood issues in front of her and scare her off.â
âOuch, okay, noted,â she replies with a displeased frown. âBut thatâs still no excuse to keep your relationship a secret. I know weâre not always the most reliable bunch, but obviously this girl is important to you, Five, and if thatâs the case then sheâs important to us, too. Just give us a chance to prove ourselves- bring her to my place Friday for dinner so we can all get introduced.â
Five is silent as he mulls over Allisonâs offer, doubt clear on his features as he considers all the possible ways a family dinner with you could go. While there are a million ways for it to go wrong, heâs able to acknowledge the plausibility of it being a success. As much as he hated to admit it, his sister did have a point. They werenât always completely unreliable, and heâd be lying if he said he didnât think spending time with his siblings could actually be pleasant at times. And itâs not like you havenât been questioning him already about his family and the details of his childhood. Perhaps it was time to finally bite the bullet.
âYou get one chance,â Five finally relents in a firm tone, pointing his finger at them both in warning. âDo not screw this up.â
âHow exciting!â Klaus gasps with an enthusiastic clap of his hands. âOh, I have the perfect dish for this occasion.â
As Allison and Klaus immediately begin to discuss the details of Fridayâs dinner, Five can only force himself to quell his panic as best as possible and hope that youâre able to stand his family.
~~~
You fidget nervously with the pendant of your necklace as Five swiftly parks the car in front of Allisonâs home. Itâs beautiful, and by the looks of the warm lights that glow through the window it seems the festivities have begun. Despite your boyfriend having already turned off the car, you make no attempt to move, prompting Five to reach over and gently take hold of your hand in his.
âDonât worry,â he assures you in the softest voice he can manage. âThese idiots are more worried about impressing you than you are about impressing them.â
âTheyâre not idiots, theyâre your siblings,â you reprimand him gently before finally mustering up the courage to step foot out of the car. âAnd despite how much you act like they annoy you I know you really care about them. I just want it to go well is all.â
Five canât really argue with that- sometimes he hates how easily youâre able to read him. Itâs a feat not many can accomplish, and yet you managed to do so in record time. Itâs also just another thing he adores about you; you see him like no one has before, and your gentle nature and levelheadedness perfectly balance out his tense and combative personality. Youâre good for him, and he hopes his siblings see the good in you too.
The door swings open before you can press the doorbell and immediately you find yourself being pulled into the tightest hug of your life. A gasp of surprise leaves you at the sudden intrusion, and it takes everything in Five to resist the urge to immediately pry his sister off of you. He stares daggers at her innocent smile behind your back, but she merely waves him off before pulling away to look at you.
âIt is so good to finally meet you!â She exclaims cheerfully, excitement clear in her tone. âIâm Allison. Come in, come in.â
You arenât able to get in a word edge-wise as the woman practically drags you into her home and begins to show you around. A pleasant smelling aroma fills the house from the food that cooks in the kitchen, and animated chatter drifts throughout the hallways as the siblings gather and catch up on each otherâs lives.
âPlease make yourself at home and let me know if you need anything at all.â
âThank you, a-and thank you for having me,â you offer with a meek smile, your hands nervously wringing together in front of you. âIâve heard so much about you all and itâs finally nice to put faces to the names. Iâm y/n.â
âWell then, welcome to the family y/n,â Allison notes with a wink before disappearing into the kitchen. You almost jump in surprise when you feel Fiveâs hand rest against your lower back as he leads you into the living room to meet the rest of his siblings.
âReady to enter the lionâs den?â He whispers under his breath, and for a moment you genuinely canât decipher whether or not heâs joking.
Three men and a woman sit on the couch animatedly discussing the contents of the television show playing on the screen before turning silent at your arrival. The sudden attention makes you nervous, your throat drying up as you harshly swallow down your anxiety.
âLuther, Diego, Lila, Iâd like to introduce you to my⌠girlfriend,â Five utters after clearing his throat, obviously not familiar with the process of introducing a partner to family. He was still fairly new at this relationship stuff and still struggled at times with opening up. If he didnât care about you so much he probably wouldnât even bother, so you appreciate his efforts. âY/n, these are my brothers and my sister-in-law.â
âGirlfriend, huh? This is certainly an upgrade from the last one,â Diego teases with a wry chuckle.
âWasnât the last one a mannequin?â Lila prompts with a raised brow much to Fiveâs dismay.
âShut it,â he warns through clenched teeth, heat crawling up his neck at the mention of Delores. Leave it to those two to bring up his past at the worst time.
âA mannequin?â You repeat unsurely, your features contorted in confusion. Fiveâs eyes widen in panic, but Luther is quick to change the subject on Fiveâs behalf.
âItâs nice to see Five with someone for a change,â he notes with a nervous chuckle in hopes his comment redirects your attention off of the previous topic. âHow did you two meet?â
âI work at a coffee shop in town,â you explain with a sheepish smile, and Five visibly relaxes beside you as you start to recount the beginnings of your relationship. A crisis has been avoided thanks to Luther, and for once Five is grateful for his brotherâs conversational skills. âI was the only one who could make his coffee exactly the way he liked it, so he became a regular and would stop by every time I was working. We got to talking, one thing led to another, and, well, here I am.â
âWell, I for one think you are much too good for him,â Lila points out to the boyâs annoyance, âbut seeing him less uptight and ornery is a pleasant change.â
âThank you for that lovely observation, Lila,â Five retorts sarcastically with a roll of his eyes before escorting you out of the living room before the woman can embarrass him any further.
âDid you really date a mannequin?â You whisper curiously only for Five to immediately redden at your question.
âLetâs not hash out my dating history just right this second,â he instructs you before entering the dining room where a man has just finished setting down a heavy centerpiece on the table while another watches.
âHmm, a little more to the left,â the one with curly hair and heavy eyeliner instructs while scrutinizing its placement. His eyes glance over the table before landing on you and Five in the doorway, and he immediately gasps before rushing over to greet you. âYou must be y/n! Oh, it is so lovely to meet you. Iâm Klaus, Fiveâs favorite brother, of course.â
âI donât ever recall saying that,â Five points out with a raised brow and amused smile. Klaus simply rolls his eyes and waves his brother off with a tsk.
âYou donât have to, I can see it in your face,â he dismisses before returning his attention to you. âAnd that handsome man over there is our sweet brother Viktor.â
âHey,â Viktor offers with a timid smile and small wave. âNice to see you, welcome to family dinner.â
âThank you,â you reply gratefully, âitâs nice to finally meet you all.â
âWell, not all of us. A certain someone thinks heâs too good for family dinner,â Klaus huffs in annoyance before turning his attention back to the centerpiece. âDoes that look centered to you?â
âIt looks perfect. I love the arrangement youâve made,â you compliment much to Klausâs delight.
âFinally someone with taste!â He gasps before draping an arm around you much to Fiveâs dismay and guiding you back to the kitchen. âCome, come little one, you can help me pick which napkins to use.â
Watching your figures disappear into the hallway, Viktor glances at Five before stating, âI donât think youâll be getting her back for a while.â
âTrust me, Iâm aware,â the boy sighs in displeasure before heading towards Allisonâs liquor cabinet for a drink.
~~~
Much to Fiveâs surprise, dinner goes off without a hitch. The food is lovely, the conversation is pleasant, and despite your usually shy demeanor you were able to open up rather quickly to his siblings. It was obvious the family took a great liking to you, and his original worries about them scaring you off had been proven irrational and untrue.
From his seat on the couch Five watches as you animatedly converse with Luther and Klaus about a new bakery that just opened up in town, your smile never once leaving your face and their interest in your words never once dwindling. He doesnât think heâs ever seen you talk this much, and the sight brings a comfortable warmth to his chest at seeing you happy.
âSee? This wasnât so bad, was it?â Allison goads with a pleased smile. âEveryone had a nice time and y/n fits right in.â
âAs much as I hate to say it, Iâm sorry for doubting you,â Five relents with a soft smile. âThis was nice.â
âAnd we like y/n, so donât mess this up,â Lila warns him with a facetious shove to his shoulder. Annoyed by her words, Five rolls his eyes and shrugs away from her touch before refocusing his gaze on you. Your eyes meet for a brief second as you glance out into the living room, and you flash him a quick smile before looking back to Klaus who enthusiastically grabs hold of your hands and begins to demand a trip to the bakery with you while Luther attempts to insert himself into the plan. Despite how annoying his family can be at times, heâd be lying if he said it didnât bring a smile to see his face to see them all get along with the girl he loves.
âTrust me,â he utters carefully, his voice so uncharacteristically tender it takes the two women by surprise, âIâll do anything to keep her around for as long as I live.â
I am just so obsessed with the idea of Five and Reader's domestic life (without all those doomsday shite) đŤ so please, if you can, I'd love to read something related to that đđť
a/n: hi anon sorry for the wait ! i just started the fall semester and havenât had much time to write but i hope you enjoy this little slice of life -esque fic
warning: basically pure fluff
The dance hall is nearly empty save for the elderly couple rocking back and forth in each otherâs arms in front of the stage where the big band plays their last song of the night. Tired busboys and cleanup crew members clear away the tables and sweep up any mess to prepare for the next day of business. Despite the evening coming to a close, youâre in no hurry to leave Fiveâs arms as he delicately twirls you around the dance floor to one of his favorite songs.
âReady to call it a night?â He asks with a careful smile after watching your eyes nearly flutter shut for a third time. He knows you well enough to detect when youâve reached the point of exhaustion, but he also knows youâre not one to ever admit this out of your own volition.
âTired already, old man?â You counter playfully, but you donât protest as he begins to lead you off the dance floor and out the doors to your car. Your feet are killing you and you want nothing more than to crawl into bed, and Five is fully aware of your current internal dialogue. He helps you into the car and even slips off your heels for you before taking his place behind the wheel.
âThis was nice,â he admits in a soft voice, glancing over at you in the passengerâs seat. Your head is pressed against the cool glass of the window as you watch the city streets pass by, and you let out a gentle hum in response to his comment.
âItâs nice we get to do normal couple things now,â you agree thoughtfully. âNo assignments to complete, no world-ending apocalyptic threats to stop, no timelines to fix. Just us getting another chance to relive our twenties again in a world where the moon is still intact.â
âIâm sorry about all that,â Five relents with a tired sigh. If not for him you probably never would have been wrapped up in all that mess in the first place, and he feels partly responsible for the chaotic nature your life had taken on the last few decades.
âHey,â you call gently, prompting the boy to glance over at your sincere gaze and soft smile, âI wouldnât change it for the world, you know that. I literally had the chance to, but I decided against it.â
âDonât remind me,â he scoffs quietly at the memory. The Handler had cornered you once with an enticing deal- a chance to return to your own time in exchange for Fiveâs whereabouts and his plans to stop the end of the world. She mistakenly underestimated your loyalty to the time traveler, and you had gifted her with a solid right hook in response to her offer. That all felt so long ago to you both now.
The headlights of the car drown your front yard in artificial light as Five finally pulls into the driveway of your humble home. After everything had been set back to normal and the Cleanse had been stopped, you both decided to move out into the suburbs and purchased a lovely little fixer upper in a quiet neighborhood where almost nothing seemed to happen. It was exactly the fresh start you needed, and every time you stepped over the threshold through the front door you felt your heart fill with warmth all over again just like it had the first time Five had carried you inside.
âI think we should get a dog,â you voice aloud for no particular reason as you flip on the lights and shut the door behind you. The house is cozily warm despite your absence, and already you can feel the eagerness rising within you at the thought of crawling into bed.
âA dog?â Five repeats with a raised brow as he hangs his coat on the wall and sets your heels upon the shoe rack next to his own.
âAfter married people get a house they usually start having kids, or they get a dog,â you explain with a casual wave of your hand as you walk through the hallway and into the kitchen to fix yourself a glass of water. âI think we should get a dog.â
âNot a kid?â Five teases as his fingers playfully poke into your side. You jump at the feeling, and he uses the distraction as an opportunity to steal your glass from you so that he may take a hearty gulp of water before you can protest.
âI donât think weâre ready for that yet. At least, Iâm not. I can hardly handle babysitting Grace and the twins as it is.â
âTo be fair, they take after their parents,â Five reminds you with a sarcastic chuckle before handing you your freshly refilled glass of water. âI think our kids would stand a better chance.â
âA Hargreeves child with a y/l/n as their mother?â You retort with a pointed look and uneasy smile. âNot likely. Iâd like to remain chaos free for at least another few years before we get to that.â
âI canât argue with that,â he relents with a sigh before wrapping his arms around you from behind and resting his chin on your shoulder. âWeâve had enough chaos to last us a lifetime. The kids can wait.â
âSo weâre getting a dog?â
âWeâll get a dog,â Five chuckles with a careful nod as he presses his lips to your cheek.
âCan we name him Mr. Pennycrumb?â
âMr. Pennycrumb?â Your husband retorts skeptically, pulling away to analyze your facial features in search of any falsehood or mirth. âWhereâd you come up with that?â
âI read it in a comic book once,â you offer with a simple shrug as if itâs the most obvious explanation in the world. Despite how much time heâs spent with you, you still always find a way to surprise him when he least expects it. Itâs one of the many things he loves about you, and itâs why your relationship has remained so strong after all this time. Itâs hard to reach a stalemate when youâre always keeping him on his toes.
âOf course, what was I thinking,â Five hums thoughtfully as he pulls away from your figure and sets your now empty cup in the sink. âMr. Pennycrumb it is.â
He presses a kiss to the crown of your head and turns to leave for the bedroom, but your melodious call of his name has him stopping dead in his tracks. You move forward to loosen his tie for him, an adoring smile on your face as you peer up at him through your lashes and quietly voice, âI love you.â
He grins, his gaze soft with a look that is only reserved for you as he presses his lips to your forehead and gifts you a tender hearted kiss. What he ever did to be lucky enough to have someone like you, heâll never know, but what he does know is that heâll gladly spend the rest of his time on this earth making you happy with the life youâve built together.
âI love you too,â he utters reverently before pulling you into his arms once more for another kiss.
May I request a five x reader where they are living domestically and just being happy and lovey dovey especially experiencing everything they did together while being in the apocalypse, the time commission, stoping the other apocalypses etc (five x Lila doesnât exist five x Lila doesnât exist five x Lilia doesnât-)
a/n: this piece is basically a big fuck you to s4 so enjoy five being happy and domestic with reader and not his own brotherâs wife. also five and reader are mentally older adults but physically in their twenties
warnings: language, fluff, mentions of pregnancy
summary: now that the timeline has been fixed and the world is no longer in danger, five can enjoy a peaceful life with you
The sunlight that bleeds through the curtains is almost blinding as Five begins to stir himself awake. Stretching out his limbs until he hears a satisfying pop, he lets out a sigh and moves to reach out for someone that isnât there. Your spot in bed is still warm which means you havenât been gone for long, but Five still rises with a sense of urgency when greeted with your absence. Call it muscle memory from dealing with multiple kidnapping ploys against you or an old habit that just wonât die off after having to remain vigilant when protecting you from the enemy, but the poor boyâs heart always skips a beat when you go missing.
He finds you in the kitchen brewing a fresh pot of coffee, your back to him as you hum along to the radio that plays on the counter and search for Fiveâs favorite cup in the cabinet. He has to pause and take a breath to remind himself that youâre not in danger, your life of protecting timelines and ending apocalypses is over, and the fresh start youâve made for yourselves isnât in any jeopardy. Youâre real, youâre alive, and youâre his.
âMorning,â Five softly calls with a careful smile as he rests a hand on the small of your back and presses a tender kiss to your lips.
âGood morning,â you great cheerfully before handing him his cup of coffee. âI didnât hear you get up. Did I wake you?â
âNot at all,â he assures you before taking a hearty gulp of the hot liquid. After years of being together you know how to make Fiveâs coffee just the way he likes it and could probably do so in your sleep if asked. Your thoughtfulness is just one of the many traits of yours that have him wrapped around your finger always.
âWe need to go grocery shopping,â you note dutifully as you peek your head into the fridge in search of breakfast. Frowning, you announce, âWeâre out of eggs, so I guess itâs frozen waffles for breakfast.â
âWhy donât we go out for breakfast today?â Five suggests with an innocent shrug.
âReally? But you hate breakfast places. They can never make your coffee right.â
âI also hate seeing you eat frozen waffles three days in a row,â he reminds you with a wry chuckle. Maneuvering you out of the way, Five closes the fridge shut and gives you a gentle nudge in the direction of your shared bedroom. âGo on, get dressed. You can wear that new dress you bought the other day.â
âYouâre right!â You exclaim with an excited gasp and rush off to your room before Five can change his mind. Not that he would, of course. Five would do anything to see you happy after all the shit heâs put you through in your time together. Sometimes he still wonders why you ever agreed to marry him, perhaps a slip of sanity or lack of care for your own wellbeing, but he wasnât one to complain. He liked living the quiet life with you, and he wouldnât change it for the world.
~~~
The night air is cool against your bare shoulders as you sit comfortably upon the porch swing and listen to the cicadas sing their evening song. The sun has long since set, but the string of lights that hang above you are enough to allow you to see the pages of your color by numbers book. Beside you, Five sits with a book in one hand while the other rests atop of your legs strewn across his lap. He enjoys sitting in the silence of your company as you remain glued together despite partaking in your own hobbies separately.
âWeâve been married for thirty years,â you state simply, breaking the silence but never once breaking your focus from your coloring book.
âSure have,â is Fiveâs thoughtful reply. Setting his book aside, your husband gives your calf a gentle squeeze and turns to look at your concentrated features.
âNot including your siblings, itâs always been just us. Together in the apocalypse, partners under the Commission, husband and wife.â
âIs that a bad thing?â He asks, not quite sure what point youâre trying to make. Are you rethinking the marriage? Are you finally starting to have regrets about marrying him? He watches with bated breath as you set your materials to the side and finally meet his anxious gaze.
âI want to start a family of our own,â you finally confess, nervously fidgeting with your wedding ring as you await his response with hopeful eyes. âI donât want it to be just us anymore.â
Sighing, Five leans his head back and shuts his eyes as he processes your request. He canât say heâs surprised by your question; heâs noticed the way you eye babies in public, how you linger just a little too long to admire the window display of the infant clothing store at the mall, how youâll hold the twins for hours in your arms and refuse to give them back until Diego has to physically pry them from your grasp. Itâs only natural for you to feel this way, but thatâs not the problem. The problem is Five isnât exactly sure how he feels about becoming a father.
âI donât know,â he admits carefully, taking great caution when choosing his next words so as to not upset you. âHaving a kid, becoming parents⌠it changes everything.â
âI know we couldnât before because there was the Commission and then the multiple apocalypses, and thatâs why I never asked. But Five,â you urge gently, shifting to sit yourself up on your knees so you can reach over and take both of his hands in your own, âall of that is done with. We fixed the timeline, and all that end of the world nonsense is over with for good. No one is coming after us anymore or trying to kill me to get to you. We can properly grow old now and have a simple life together, wasnât that always the goal?â
The boy is silent as he mulls over your speech. Youâre completely right; saving the world and resetting the timeline to its proper place in order to ensure you and his siblings could have the lives you deserved was always the end goal. But after spending his entire existence trying to complete that task, he finds it hard to adjust to his new life of normalcy. Perhaps heâs not exactly scared of becoming a parent, but scared of what a baby would mean in the grand scheme of things. It would be proof that his work is truly over now, that he can turn his survival mode off after having it set to fight for so many years, and thatâs a big adjustment for someone like him.
But when he looks at your hopeful gaze and sees the way you anxiously worry your lip between your teeth, he realizes that heâll do anything to give you the happy life you deserve. He brings one of your hands to his lips and holds it tight as he murmurs his answer into the skin of your palm.
âIf you think weâre ready, then Iâm in.â
âYou mean it?â You gasp while doing your best to withhold your excitement. Your eyes are wide and full of hope as Five lets out a soft chuckle before giving you a reassuring kiss.
âWe survived the end of the world several times, how scary could raising a baby really be?â
He isnât given an answer to his hypothetical question as you fling yourself into his arms and assault his face with multiple kisses along his skin. Itâs safe to say his answer has eased your anxieties, and the boy can only laugh as you express your gratitude.
âIâm so happy you agree!â You exclaim giddily, your hands coming to rest upon his chest to ground yourself as you then suggest to Fiveâs surprise, âLetâs start trying tonight!â
âWhat?â
~~~
âThat has to be the tiniest Hargreeves Iâve ever seen,â Klaus gushes adoringly as he takes in the details of the ultrasound photo in front of him. âLook at the little peanut, isnât it precious?â
âI canât believe Five is actually going to be a dad,â Allison notes in astonishment as the three of you turn your gaze to see him arguing with Diego over the proper way to baby proof your home while Ben eggs them on and ruins Lutherâs efforts at trying to keep the peace. Youâre only two months along, but Five is anxious to ensure that everything is perfect for your childâs arrival.
âYou know, you might just be the first 65 year-old woman to give birth,â Klaus points out cheekily. âYou should be in a world records book or something.â
âVery funny,â you retort sarcastically before taking back the ultrasound photo to hang up on the fridge. You falter for a moment when your eyes remain stuck to photo and your brain works on overdrive to commit the image to memory as best as you can.
âEverything okay?â Viktor asks after noticing the sudden change in demeanor.
âI just canât believe this is real,â you murmur quietly, blinking back tears that threaten to spill. âAfter everything weâve been through and everything weâve lost, I guess a part of me worries that one day Iâll wake up and this will all have been a dream.â
âI know how that feels,â Allison assures you with a comforting squeeze to your shoulder. âBut I promise you this isnât a dream, and whatever you need weâll be there.â
âBecause youâre family now,â Viktor adds on with a confident nod. âAnd we look out for family no matter what.â
âEven though at one point in our lives weâve all thought about killing each other,â Klaus notes humorously before giving you a tight squeeze.
âEverything okay over here?â Five asks, appearing at your side and placing a comforting hand on your back as you all turn your gazes towards the fridge and admire the newest addition to the family.
summary: when your thoughts come crowding in, fiveâs there to bring calm to the storm.
request (by @lilistar-quin): can i have five comforting reader because they have body dysmorphia and extreme self esteem issues because of their weight?? it can be left ambiguous as to what their weight is bc ik people struggle with body dysmorphia no matter what weight theyâre at, but iâd prefer an overweight reader :) if not then thatâs fine!!
words: 700
warnings: body dysmorphia, self-hatred (but it ends fluffy)
a/n: apparently editing is not a thing i do anymoreâso have this tiny lil blurb!!!! this one was definitely different to write as someone whoâs experienced problems with my perception of my weight. please just remember: you were made the way you are for a reason. there is beauty in every curve and dip and lineđĽ°â¨
âď¸âď¸âď¸
Itâs early evening, and the hateful thoughts are back again, scraping up against each other like burning sand.
summary: fiveâs exhausted and covered in blood, but you love him all the same.
request (by @oceanspray5): Hi! I was wondering if you could maybe write a Five x reader fic right after the S2 scene where he kills the Board? When he's waiting for the Handler and after his conversation with her he looks so heartbroken and defeated that it just breaks my heart for him. He needs a hug and some love after being betrayed like that so I was hoping a fic where he has Reader with him and gets that kind of support and a reminder that he's not just the killer the Handler is trying to convince him he is. Only if it's possible for you of course! And thank you in advance! đ
words: 614
warnings: small mentions of blood and killing, kinda short n unedited but otherwise nothin else:))
a/n: at this point my area of expertise is lil hurt/comfort blurbs with five and iâm honestly living for it
âď¸âď¸âď¸
Five stands in the deserted alley with his back to you. From the set of his shoulders, you guess heâs clutching AJ tightly to his chest.
âFive?â you whisper.
No answer.
And itâs then you realize how still he is, how he hasnât moved as he stares at the ground. You call his name again, and when he doesnât respond, you quietly make your way to his side.
He doesnât meet your eyes at first, staring unblinkingly at a patch of asphalt over your shoulder. His hands are clasped around AJâs plastic bag, and you realize with a sinking heart that his fingers are shaking. You cautiously move your own hands to brush over his, and when he doesnât flinch away, you bring your right hand up to cup his cheek.
âLook at me, Five,â you murmur, and he does. Even the slightest tilt of his head seems to weigh on him so heavily, and your brow furrows without even thinking at just how exhausted he looks.
Tears well up in his eyes as you brush your thumb against the apple of his cheek, his head moving the tiniest bit to chase your gentle touch.
ââM so tired,â he whispers, a single tear spilling down over his freckled cheek where his dimple would be were he smiling. You wipe it awayâa bit of dried blood comes off on your thumb, but you donât mind.
âI know, baby,â you say, smiling sadly. âI know.â The only thing you can think of to do is to wrap him in your arms, and he lets out a shuddering sigh as your scent envelops him. His hands are slow and shaking as they come up to return the embrace, finding purchase in the folds of your shirt.
âIâm done nowâno more killing, no more bloodââ Five trails off and you whisper a shh into his ear, cupping the back of his head in your hand.
âYou did what you had to,â you say. âAnd Iâm so proud of you for doing that.â
Hearing those words must release something in him, because he melts against you at last, more vulnerable than youâve ever seen him before. You keep your arms tight around him, giving him all the assurance you know how.
His eyes are still shiny as he pulls away slightly, so full of complications and exhaustion and love that your chest knots itself in two. You bring his blood-streaked hands to your mouth, pressing soft kisses to his knuckles and wrists. He sighs again, the feeling of your lips soothing his tired mind.
âI love you,â he says, and you know that he means both a thousand more things and just that at the same time.
âI love you too,â you say back, without hesitation. âAlways.â
His eyes deepen at your words, and he leans forward slightly to press his lips to yours. Heâs soft and sad against you, and the kiss is equal parts desperation and affection. After a long moment, he pulls back slowly, eyes still closed, and presses a kiss to your forehead. His lashes are gentle as they brush against your skin, and your fingers trail across the back of his neck with as much tenderness as you have.
The two of you stand there breathing each other in, and, despite all the distant danger and blood, you feel safe.
âSorry to interrupt, lovebirds!â A female voice comes from behind you, accompanied by the distinctive sound of heels tapping the pavement.
You and Five both know that the moment has come. Breaking apart with a small smile to the other, you turn around hand-in-hand to face the Handler together.
summary: fiveâs completely taken with you, and for good reasonâyouâre the first softness to come into his life.
request (by two lovely lovely anons): Could you write a story about Five x reader and dimples? Reader has subtle dimples too but they donât realize it until a very smitten Five points it out and itâs just fluff? And the Hargreeves siblings are just watching as Five and his best friend/crush are obviously in love but too shy to admit it? Thank you!
AND
if youâre taking requests can u write about the reader and five being in the friends to lovers trope and reader starts to overflow in awe of five and starts showering five with well-deserved and true and genuine compliments?
words: 704
warnings: none!! it is literally just fluff bros!!
a/n: god iâm yearning for human connection can u tell,,,, anyway here is an unedited lil blurb for ur reading pleasure!! as a person with lil dimples myself i can confirm that this hit differentđđđť i changed the requests a bit but pls enjoy:))))))
âď¸âď¸âď¸
Thereâs just something different when Five lays with you like this. The air in his lungs decides to take its time, and his eyelids seem to operate on a slower setting. Somehow, the intersection of your limbs sets him free.
your fingers have been slowly, slowly, steadily pumping into your friendâs pussy, from where youâre cuddled up together on the couch, and then pulling back out with a wet sound, for over thirty minutes. youâve been watching the clock, out of the corner of your eye, as she watches the movie. her eyes are already half-lidded and closed, her head pillowed back against the cushions. she looks like sheâs going to fall asleep, any minute now.
when she showed up at your house at thirty minutes to midnight, eyes wild with desperation, you didnât know what to expect. but when she asked you to please help her orgasm, as sheâs been trying but it hasnât been working from this angle, you hardly had to think before saying yes. she beamed, stripping off her shorts and then sliding off her panties, before climbing onto your couch, spouting thank you after thank you, and pulling you on top of her (still fully clothed) to make out.
you tried to take it slow, ease into this in case she changed her mind, but she was whimpering soon enough, rocking her hips up into yours, squeezing a hand between your bellies to wildly fuck herself. and then you had to take mercy, gently prying her wrist away before starting to finger her yourself. the little stutter in her breath when you first squeezed one all the way in was made of pure sin, but the little panting moans were worse. or better. you remembered how quick she had been, pumping her fingers in like thereâd never come a second chance, and decided to go slow. it paid off.
thirty minutes later now, here you were, watching her fall asleep. your friend was half-naked under you on your couch, hands idly gripping onto your biceps, having orgasmed within an inch of her life not ten minutes ago. your hand was still covered in cum. she had been euphoric, shining with sweat and screaming out shaky fucks, rocking wildly in the heat of her orgasm as you kept fingering her. shit, it was so hot. she was so hot. and now here she was, proving that she trusted you enough to fall asleep.
âŚfuck. youâre going to end up asking her out, arenât you?
well, you think, at least sheâs probably into girls.
the bed dips, and you feel your eyes slowly open. thatâs when you know that chris is home.
he whispers your name softly, with a warm sense of waiting as though he expects a reply. you know he doesnât, that by this time youâre normally fast asleep with no chance of waking up, but you take the time you have on the one night you are awake. âhello.â you call out, so quiet and dazed that if he didnât catch it, you wouldnât be surprised. however, he does, and you can practically hear the speed his head turns at.
your eyes are barely open, and youâre struggling to see a thing, but you can judge that he was mid-way through getting changed when you called out for him. silk-like and smooth, you know youâre right when he crouches down beside your body, hand shooting up to stroke the hair out of your face.
he treats you as though youâre a kitten: soothing, calm touches and strokes that make you curl into the comfort of his hands, desperate for the lazy scratch of his fingernails against your skin. like a magnet, your hand reaches for his body, meeting the cool surface of his bare chest. underneath your fingertips, you can almost feel the goosebumps rise, but you donât stop tracing your hand across his body.
you bring it up to outline his collar bone, wrapping it around the side of his neck before meeting his nape and tenderly running your fingers through his hair. he mustâve showered at work, because you can feel the slight remaining dampness and the soft curls thatâve started to form. you love itâadore them, evenâand he is well aware.
âare you getting in?â you ask, and if he canât tell from the tone of your voice, youâre desperate for an answer of yes.
instead of answering in words, he walks to the other side of the bed and crawls into the cover, bringing a cool chill to meet your skin. the new presence under the quilt is familiar, and the comfort of his body being so close once again feels strangely euphoric. youâve missed this. youâve missed him.
rolling over, you face your body towards his, so youâre both on your sides. itâs strange; the lights are out and only the peak of moonlight from behind the curtains provides a brightness to the room, but you can still make out his every feature. his nose, his eyes, his lips. perhaps youâve stared at him for too long, admired every inch of skin he has so well that your mind recognised it even in the dark. but knowing that, knowing him, brings the most shameless smile to your face. youâre lucky, you think, to have a love like you doâutterly sweet and saccharine like a maraschino cherry on top of a warm chocolate brownie. a love that feels like him.
the cool touch of his fingertips dips under your shirt, meeting your bare waist. gently, he draws them up and down, using one hand to create patterns on your skin and the other to bring you closer, pull you towards him. you wonder for a second whether he loves you like you love him, so unconditionally and selfishly and pure. but you donât have to guess, or debate or worry, because with the word of his touch and the utter fondness in his eyes, he is telling you he loves you a million times over.
goodnight, you mouth, not daring to break the calm silence that has settled between the two of you. without trying, your eyes are closing, but you still manage to make out the way he whispers back the words to you, a hidden grin kept subtle on his lips. he reaches forward, pressing the softest kiss onto your forehead, and settles with you like that. one hand securely on your waist, as though he could lose you if it wasnât there, and the other drawing none sense on your skin as he lulls you to sleep.
itâs silly, you think. he could be on the other side of the world, having not touched you for monthsâyears, evenâand heâd still never lose you. after all, you canât be lost if your heart is forever in the palm of his hands.
CONTAINS: christmas au, fake dating au, big family christmas au, hallmark movie au, slow burn, [f] fluff, [s] smut
â âWhen the most beautiful time of year rolls aroundâsnow falling, lights of every color hung, big sweaters keeping everyone warm and itchyâyou allot the time to see your family. But when your parents donât shut up about your cousinsâ successful relationships, you canât help but make up an itty bitty tiny lie about your wonderful and blossoming relationship with one very beautiful barista. Itâs only your luck that your parents actually want to meet him.â
Š jeonqqin 2021
Guiding Chan up to your childhood bedroom was stressful to say the least. His hand in yours acted like an anchor, and somehow the weight of his palm made your breathing steadier. You knew your parents were still watching, you could feel their eyes on your backs, and all you could think about was if they knew. Did they catch onto your lie? Could they tell that you and Chan werenât a couple? Of course they knew, how couldnât theyâ
âHey,â Chan whispered, tugging on your hand to stop you. He stood on the step below yours, way too close for you to stay sane, and lightly pressed his chest to the dip of your back. It felt like a perfect fit. âIâm going to spin you around and pick you up, okay?â
Your brows furrowed. âI donât thinkââ
But before you could protest, he already had a firm grip on your hips and was turning you to face him. Your cheeks were ablaze while he grinned up at you, and for a second you completely forgot about the stress of the party and keeping your parents oblivious and your stupid cousins ruining the secret. It was just Chan.
And just Chan was pretty nice.
Until he was slipping one arm under your knees and lifting you off the ground way too easily. You protested with various complaints but Chan simply continued up the stairs with a fond chuckle.
It was all for show. It was all for show. It was all for show.
minho's cats @necromancersupreme - Tumblr Blog | Tumgag