I just got back from watching the new Doraemon movie and I have⦠some very mixed feelings about it all
My spoiler free review:
I would say that in my opinion Nobita and the Undersea Devil is a movie that sets out to achieve some very ambitious goals and unfortunately misses the mark despite having the building blocks to be great
It tries to be too much in one movie and because of that every element suffers and ends up falling flat
My full review:
(I recommend that if you havenāt seen it you should go check it out and come up with your own opinions before commenting back here)
What I liked:
My god these kids are so stinkin cute Iām going to cry
This movie spends a lot of its effort into making the gang into a friend group that actually likes each other
They are so affectionate with each other that the emotional scenes land harder as well
The animation and art are superb as always
The design of the sea people and their society is also very clever combining both aspects of coral and deep see creatures together
a few scenes are very well executed with the acting, lighting, and sound design coming together beautifully to express the tension of the scenes
this movie is also surprisingly not afraid of getting super dark; like we genuinely assume that Jaian and Suneo actually died and the threat of literal execution is treated with the gravity it deserves
the theme the story tries to tackle is also very unique, the clash between what is ālogicalā and what is ārightā that drives the characters to change is one Iām not sure Doraemon has tackled before
Also Iām happy that this movie had the guts to give Shizuka a more expressions even the quote on quote ugly ones
Shizuka rarely gets the chance to express her emotions as sharply as the boys do so I like that she gets to actually cry, and be expressive and take initiative in this movie
Things I didnāt like:
the pacing of many parts felt very rushed, many of the aspects of the story would have benefited from having more time to marinate and develop like Eruās development, Buggyās past, and the conflict as a whole
The overall jankiness of the story makes its good moments less powerful -for example to make the ruler of Mu bow before a person is a powerful symbol that could convey the power of change but because they made him do it twice and so easily that action just lost its impact on me
There is also a lot of tonal dissonance in this movie, like the gag with the hammer while Suneo and Jaian were literally dying, and other incidents like it make the mood of the story confusing in some ways
the story also included a lot of detail that I feel were underutilized or just unnecessary
For example I feel like the āmachine that scans your brain and decides if you are evil or not and throws you in prison no matter how actually guilty you areā would have worked so well as a metaphor for a prejudiced society that judges people based on appearance so Iām pretty bummed that that plot point never gets expanded on
Additional I feel the environmental message of the movie is a bit sloppy tacked on, almost like an afterthought, along side the human/sea people conflict
In my mind either the movie should have cut that part out for the sake of streamlining the plot or they should have weaved it in better into how humans harm the world to show why the sea people might harbor so much mistrust of humans
The plot itself also has weird plot holes everywhere, it almost feels like the writers had to cut down on scenes for one reason or another and that caused the story to be a lot more disjointed
The ship and money never gets explained, why the nuclear weapons were only disabled now of all times, the weird fabric thing that fell out of Nobitaās shirt when he got shot doing absolutely nothing, etcā¦
also while I love the gang to death Nobita and Doraemon were frustratingly stupid this time around
I feel like the confrontation with Poseidon could have been done so much better because why did they just try to shoot it???? Twice????
Also how in the hell did Buggy actually destroy the ai core, it jus seemed weirdly fast and instantaneous to me
Overall this movie was pretty decent to me in that itās a pretty fun watch but still Iām deeply frustrated by what it could have been
If I could re-write this movie I would keep a lot of the same core aspects just expanded different
I would change a few details like maybe the rulers of Mu have been using their mind scanning tech to imprison those who could potentially pose a threat to the safety of society even if they havenāt done anything wrong in an effort to protect themselves and their citizens.
Maybe Iāll throw in some jokes about how Buggy is a cheaper model because it has no safety precautions and can self destruct. And expand on why Buggy doesnāt act when things go wrong because that is the ālogical protocolā is complacency. And expand on the moment Buggy spends with the Gang.
Along side it I would make Eru and Buggy spend time together as well as parallels in a sort of way due to how they are breaking free of them systems of what is ālogicalā compared to what is ārightā. Because in the og movie it seemed pretty out of place to me for Eru to talk about Buggyās sacrifice when they barely interacted with each other.
And instead of the rulers of Mu just immediately agreeing to go with Eruās plan they dismiss him, saying āitās too riskyā or āwe shouldnāt trust humansā and āour technology has proven to us that humans are untrustworthyā
Because of that Eru has defy orders and break the gang out himself because he knows complacency will get them all killed and he knows now that the gang are good people who do not conform to what society dictates as āevilā and he shouldnāt either
Now thereās three groups going against each other. The Poseidon Ai trying to destroy the world, the government trying to find and dismantle the formerly dormant nukes hidden all over the region even though itās a futile task, and the Gang and Eru trying to stop the problem at its roots.
Now this creates a parallel between Mu and Poseidon, both being parties stuck in their own ways, believing themselves to be right, and trying to maintain that image even if it means destroying everything around them. The key difference is why they would do something like that and how willing they are to change for the better.
While Poseidon canāt face the truth right in front of its face, willing to destroy the world for no reason other that spite and following its literal coding with no deviation, Mu has people to protect, their hearts -however misguided- can be changed for the better if they make the choice to accept change. Change that comes in the form of the Gang when Mu finally decides to help them by drawing away the enemy forces and listening to Eru.
The final confrontation happens differently (I donāt know how because I am very bad at fight choreography but it has to different, Doraemon and Nobita cannot be this idiotic for the love of all thatās good) but what remains the same is that when all hope seems lost Buggy sacrifices itself illogical to save those who it calls friends, using its foreshadowed self destruct feature to destroy Poseidon. Once again reaffirming that doing what is right is sometimes not doing what is logical.
When Poseidon is destroyed and the Gang returns to Mu is when the rulers finally bow before them and thank them for their sacrifice and speaks their hope for a better future between sea-people and humans. Where everyone is commemorated by Eru during his speech for helping him see the truth and pushing him to change, all 6 of them including Buggy.
Or something like that. Feel free to add your own thoughts :DDD












