The U-571 Boarding Party, Ranked
HOn Thursday, my favorite NFL team is probably going to draft a college quarterback named Carson Wentz. Every time Iâve heard the name, Iâve flashed back to the 2000 film U-571, specifically the line:Â âCan you understand me, Mr. Wentz? Can you speak passable German? Can you read and write it? Or are you just a farm boy with a German name?â
which is a good movie because itâs not only a submarine movie, and itâs hard to make a bad submarine movie, but because itâs about a small group of people setting out to accomplish a task during World War II, and itâs damn near impossible to make a bad movie about that.
Hereâs a ranking of the people who wind up aboard the U-571--not the crew of the ill-fated American submarine S-33, including Bill Paxton, Jon Bon Jovi (who gets decapitated with a hatch cover) or David Keith, who plays the black turtleneck-wearing Marine special ops ass-kicker.Â
Which is a shame, by the way. David Keith is the best. Having David Keith in your movie and killing him off half an hour in should be a capital crime. You know who else Iâve loved in pretty much everything? Keith David. Tell me you wouldnât watch a buddy cop movie or a road trip movie starring David Keith and Keith David. You would. Maybe the only reason nobodyâs made that movie is because weâre afraid itâd be too awesome.
1) Seaman Bill Wentz
The sonarman who gets dragooned into the boarding party because he speaks fluent German and the team needs another interpreter. He is a rock. He saves the mission by speaking up when Hirsch freezes, he translates all the controls when they need to dive the boat and nobody else reads German, he mans the sonar array--heâs one of two or three secondary characters who are so almost unrealistically competent and unflappable that itâs only through their efforts that the crew lives through Matthew McConaugheyâs character development.
2) Chief Henry Klough
If you want tough but nurturing, rugged but sensitive, under the banner of a stupendous mustache, by God you call Harvey Keitel. Heâs the real mentor figure to McConaughey in a movie where Bill Paxton just could not have given less of a shit, and mercifully drowns relatively quickly. The Chief almost brains Mazzola for suggesting theyâd be better off with him in charge, but Mazzola was right.
3) Tank
Poor Tank. Imagine Scotty if the Enterprise was broken when he got there, and he had to fix everything himself, and all the directions were in German, and Captain Kirk spent the whole movie berating him for what a shitty job he was doing. And he gets knocked out cold by an escaped Nazi. But Tank always got the job done and saved all their sorry asses repeatedly, even if nobody ever said thank you.
4) Rabbit
When itâs time to choose which of the little guys to send back to fix the aft torpedo tube, you know Andy chose Trigger because it was dangerous and Rabbit was cooler. Rabbit shot the German radio tower and was just Johnny-on-the-spot the whole way, despite looking terrified the whole time.
5) Lt. Andy Tyler
Eventually he figured everything out, which I guess is how character arcs work. And even then, the only kept fucking up at the start because he cared too much about his men, which, as character flaws go, is a pretty good one to have. Once he took command of U-571, crippled, under fire and with a skeleton crew that no idea how anything worked, he sank two German ships and delivered the Enigma safely to the Allies, along with six of the eight men under his command. Thatâs not bad, all things considered.
6) Lt. Hirsch
Starts out looking all badass in his office, then loses it a little under fire, but brings it all together at the end. I always thought it was interesting that it was Hirsch who went back and beat the German captain to death with a wrench--seemed like Hirsch would be last guy on the boat to get his hands dirty. Thatâs probably my favorite shot of the whole movie.
Also, Hirsch gets credit for being played by Jake Weber, who was the badguy in Meet Joe Black, which is one of those movies that I feel like I love way more than the general public consensus.Â
7) Eddie
Having one of the survivors of the S-33 be a black cook was one of those nods to how the heroic American military of World War II was still segregated, but that storyline only goes far enough for Eddie to tell the audience that Andy--whoâs not only white but sounds like Matthew McConaughey--isnât overtly racist and therefore must be a good dude. Heâs okay.
8) Trigger
Poor guy. Also thereâs probably an alternate timeline where Tom Guiry had Aaron Paulâs career.
9) Captain Wassner
The original captain of U-571, pulled out of the water by the American boarding party. Ruthless, fearless, resourceful, also played by Thomas Kretschmann, whom Iâve always thought was pretty good in everything Iâve seen him in, from King Kong, where he plays a sea captain, to Valkyrie and Fyodor Bondarchukâs Stalingrad, where he plays a Nazi officer, to U-571, where he plays a Nazi sea captain.
Heâd be much farther up this list if he hadnât ordered that boat full of civilians gunned down, or if he werenât a literal Nazi.
10) Mazzola
Mazzola was the fucking worst. I do not regret his death in the slightest.















