Changing the Shape of X-Mas - Silver & Gold Review
Front lawns are beginning to look like north pole snowglobes and Sufjan Stevens is caroling with his comrades again, what joy! Songs for Christmas was Stevens' first commemoration to Christmas with delicate versions of Christmas carols and light-hearted yuletide originals, making a definite mark on the holiday experience. With five volumes and over 30 songs, the first box set showed the world his love for the holiday and his commitment to spreading Christmas cheer. But his fondness has grown into an obsession and I think people are a little bit bewildered. The next five volumes have a variety of voices, stories, mystical creatures and musical genres to say the least. Recorded from 2006-2012, Silver & Gold shows all of the different sounds of Stevens, it is a concatenation of The Avalanche, The BQE, All Delighted People EP, and Age of Adz.
The first album, Gloria, is the closest thing to the Stevens that I know. With a comfortable 8 songs, Gloria is a very delightful start to the box set and has a nice balance between covers and originals. "Lumberjack Christmas" is an upbeat, catchy original and is very reminiscent of his writing style during The Avalanche. Just like what Stevens did in Songs for Christmas, he is taking the archaic carols from centuries past and rejuvenating them. "Coventry Carol" dates back to the 16th century and is part of a mystical play called The Pageant of the Sheamen and Tailers. Stevens and his cast bring out such a pleasant air in this cover by staying true to the original; a tactic that is hard to come by in this box set.Â
"Auld Lang Syne" ends Gloria on such a blissful note and is worthy of much praise. The way that Sufjan Stevens and his comrades share in the melody on some of the songs in this box set brings such warmth to the songs, which is perfect for this type of holiday setting. However, the heat evaporates when the jarring notes of "Jingle Bells" are pounded. We are headed for the weirdest part of the box set with I Am Santa's Helpers!, which was most likely recorded while he was working on The BQE. Although it is not a complete mess, there are many moments when I begin to feel disoriented and wish for the songs to end. Luckily, each track doesn't span longer than about 2-3 minutes each.
Sufjan is taking the songs we know so well like, "We Wish You A Merry Christmas" and "Jingle Bells" and forming them into a grotesque display of the holiday. He is definitely making some kind of a statement when he gives those songs an erratic edge because the rest of the songs are so beautiful and lofty. One of the best examples of the bizarreness of this album is "Ding-aling-a-ring-a-ling" where time isn't kept and the dissonance hurts my ears. Stevens knows it too when he says, "alright, let's do a real song," at the end of the track.
With so many odd tunes, it's hard to enjoy some of the ancient carols on this CD and I'm seriously ready to move on halfway through it. I actually did take a two day break from this box set to clear my head of Stevens before I could continue onto Christmas Infinity Voyage. When I came back to the box set, a gorgeous version of "Angels We Have Heard On High" welcomed me back with open arms. It was so memorable that I was even singing this song in the shower and throughout the day. But right when I think I am back with the Stevens that I remember, I am transported into the future with "Do You Hear What I Hear?" It is clear that this part of the box set was recorded during Age of Adz with vocal modulation and heavy drum beats.Â
One of the most interesting songs on Christmas Infinity Voyage has to be "Joy To The World". It is a perfect combination of Age of Adz and All Delighted People EP, from its softness to its zealous drum fills. Towards the end of the track, Stevens adds one of his favorite riffs from the 25 minute song "Impossible Soul" on Age of Adz. He is busting out everything on this track and even ties in "Do You Hear What I Hear?" into the song at the very last second.Â
This CD keeps my attention but doesn't necessarily flow with the rest of the box set. There are moments when I questioned if these were even Christmas songs or if he just threw them in for shits and giggles. I would have preferred to have had just one or two of these electronic songs because they are overwhelming at times. There isn't much constraint in this box set. Â
The next two albums are a bit more congruent and pick up where Gloria left off. Let it Snow! has a lot of different voices that give this album a unique precedence. Additionally, it is enjoyable the way that Sufjan covers these songs. He does it with matchless technique, giving these songs new lyrics or just creating new melodies for them. "Ave Maria" has a starry, mystical air with it being sung by Cat Martino. It is one of the first times that I've wanted snow outside and a cup of nog.
"X-mas Spirit Catcher" has the perfect Sufjan Stevens appeal with fetching instrumentation and rhythm. Even though there is weird breathing at the end, it is more fitting than some of the oddities that occur in the past couple of albums. When "Let It Snow! Let it Snow! Let it Snow!" is creepily sung, my first reaction isn't disdain like it was during I am Santa's Helper! because it ties together better. I like this version because of the creativity and it gives me the feeling like it should be in the Nightmare Before Christmas or something.
The final album, Christmas Unicorn, is unorthodox and gives the box set a very prolific ending. There is a guest appearance by Vesper Stamper on "Up On The Housetop" and has a strange intrigue, drawing us in with heavy rhythm and spacey synth. The classic Christmas song, "We Need A Little Christmas" is covered with excellence; my girlfriend and I were singing with the track all over the house and dancing. This is one of the albums I would play at a Christmas party or during a cold winter night.Â
The track "Justice Delivers Its Death" gives our box set its name, being a rendition of "Silver & Gold" by J. Marks. It is an incredibly dark song and makes me wonder if the theme of this album is death. Game, box set, match is all I can say when "Christmas Unicorn" is triumphantly sung at the end of this album. The words and melody give this song such a perfect balance, something that could relate to any believer of mystic. Christmas Unicorn is my new favorite holiday creature and once I finish constructing a paper mache unicorn, I'm going to dress it and display it proudly.Â
With so many songs for Christmas, it is hard to believe that Stevens had a life outside of Christmas for the past 12 years. When Songs For Christmas hit the shelves, this was a remarkable accomplishment for Stevens and was his way of changing the shape of Christmas for all. With Silver & Gold, Sufjan is still altering the holiday experience and giving his fans a unique way to express their excitement for this time of year, but in a very odd way. It makes me wonder if he is ever going to stop making Christmas volumes and if they are all going to continue to reflect his studio albums. It was an unusual couple of days listening to this box set but if anything, it put me in the mood for this holiday season. My only hope is that his next five volumes aren't as asymmetrical. 7.6/10