The good thing that took you seven months to answer that ask is that at least it’s been seven months since some people were saying that Vi had lovers at that time lol but your answer is great but you know that some fans like the idea that Vi was sleeping around not because it’s just a hc and it makes sense to her character but because they HATED that they chose to show Caitlyn sleeping with Maddie and Vi only hallucinating Cait like it’s truly one of the many reasons why they need Cait to “pay”
i do think some ppl project a certain type of masculine archetype that's (to me) at odds with the depth and complexity of her character in canon and it bums me out mostly bc canon vi is sooooo cool and interesting and forcing her to fit a different mold seems like such a boring choice to me! and i agree that there are definitely some fans who seem to kind of resent the fact that other characters (caitlyn in this case) had roles or storylines that they hoped to see for vi instead
i was SHOCKED when maddie showed up in bed with Caitlyn! scandalized in the best way! to me it's such a great move, even before the reveal of Maddie's true role it says so much about where Caitlyn is at that moment
obviously accepting the mantle of the commander and leading a crackdown on zaun is a huge erosion of caitlyn's moral position - nearly a 180 from where she starts as a bright-eyed only barely traumatized idealist in s1. she goes from loudly advocating against an Incursion into zaun at the end of the season, to being the face of the war in s2. that's loud and blunt and obvious and it rules, of course. but i think cait's relationship with maddie adds SO much delicious depth to it all
Maddie's a subordinate. caitlyn is her BOSS. it's kind of impossible to imagine the caitlyn of s1 even contemplating a relationship like that, where the power disparity and (perceived lmao) experience gap is so pronounced. Maddie is honestly the perfect choice for an attempted rebound because she's SO different from Vi.
so much of what attracts Caitlyn to Vi is that Vi doesn't give a fuck about Caitlyn being a Kiramman. when they meet, vi gets to know her just as caitlyn, as a person trying her best to do something good. whatever vi feels for her, Caitlyn can trust there's no ulterior motive or outside influence at play. that's extra true because vi doesn't need to impress her at all. she's blunt as hell and mostly very honest and straightforward (early attempts at ditching Caitlyn aside) and she absolutely does not stand on ceremony. Caitlyn trusts Vi. She trusts Vi's good heart. i think she kind of counts on that to help guide her
which of course doesn't work out because vi's good (and battered) heart beats in opposition to caitlyn's drive for vengeance at all costs.
therefore, maddie as the anti-vi has a perfectly crafted persona to bait caitlyn. she objects to the brutality just enough to not make caitlyn suspicious, but she never pushes hard enough to actually challenge Caitlyn. she's not close enough to Caitlyn, doesn't mean enough to her, to make it painful to betray or dismiss her. i think Caitlyn was kind to Maddie, if distant. but i do think it was an intentional choice to be with someone who would do what she wanted, tell her what she wanted to hear, let Caitlyn lead without pushback. someone she didn't have to see as an equal
which is what makes Maddie's true role even more satisfying imo. there's a sick karmic angle here. if that relationship is a symbol of caitlyn's moral erosion, a selfish indulgence that she's not particularly proud of, then the fact that it ends in such a brutal betrayal for her is the perfect twist of the knife
also lbr maddie is frankly funny as hell for all that. like, I don't condone it, but - oohhh remember when Caitlyn dismissed her from the room so she could have a private argument with her ex that she just started a war for??? all the times she pulled away when they were done fucking? the way she clearly didn't take any of Maddie's (admittedly falsely presented) suggestions seriously? Maddie might have known she was playing Cait the whole time but CAIT didn't know
"i did appreciate your warmth" is CRAZYYYYY. I'm always thinking about what a good line that is. it's a dig, of course, at cait's obvious coldness and distance during their relationship but it's ALSO a brag. noxian spy for "thanks for fucking me crazystyle" right before putting a bullet in her skull. or well. trying to.
sorry this got way off topic i just wanted to talk about the maddie stuff because i think it's so fucking good