There is a list that evolves slowly, added to here and there. It’s everything they don’t talk about; John. Cassidy’s family. Her brother. His personal habits. These are the artificial boundaries that frame their unusual friendship.
There’s a moment when the slight smile freezes on her lips and she looks away, a moment where she’s out of time and in an alien landscape; he hits on something and stirs the waters of regret. Mostly because she knows, ultimately, that he isn’t wrong. It takes a moment for her to adress the comment and when she does, it’s butterfly winged whispers, as if she hasn’t the strength to deny his veracity.
“May be true, but I am not defenseless, John, far from it. Soft no means weak. Sweet no means dere’s a lack of steel when need be.”
She will never be a name spoken quickly and hushed in shadows, but she’d made an uneasy peace with it. But she listens to him, takes his words as they come. She hadn’t thought that she’d accused him–oh, but then maybe he’s peeling back the curtain of his psyche, allowing her the smallest glimpses behind. But for as much as his words reveal, his face hides away, his eyes giving nothing back but shadow-rimed blue.
“I’ve nevah found it so.”
And it’s a small truth. She could not live with herself if it wasn’t. And that was the secret of hate, the way it twisted even the best of hearts until they shrivelled, glutted itself on the pain, delighted in the consumption. But she couldn’t really speak for him. Despite their experiences, his were as valid as her own, and she could only wonder what it was that had hardened him in places where she’d seek softness.
“Have ya hurt someone, den?” Carefully probed tender places, that question, meant for him to answer if he would, or go unheard if he didn’t.
He catches her in the trap of his stare and she looks back plainly, neither afraid nor bold enough to pursue the depths therein. He weaves a spell of darker truths around her and her hand falls away from his face but at the last minute, just before she drowns in John, she catches herself on the cliff-edge of his knee and he looks away. She’s sure her cup with shatter from the pressure of his hands alone. Again she swallows down a new breath, and shakes herself of the rapt fascination he’d evoked. She knew John was dangerous, knew it from the first time they’d met, but she hadn’t realised the how and why of it.
She pries the cup from his fingers and sets it down and when she’s finished, she sits a little further away than before. The closeness was lethal and the rabbit hole he’s slipped down just begs her to follow, but she can’t quite make herself do so. Her sense of self-preservation might be withered, but it’s not completely absent.
And it’s then she realises what he’s taken from her.
She can say nothing in the face of his self-mocking soliloquy. She holds up her hands in her silence, and in that moment she is the spitting image of the Madonna, the lady of Grace.
“I…I don’t know…what I can say to you, that will make a difference, John. But you’re welcome to come find it.”
John doesn't doubt her ability to defend herself if need be for the most part, she's been nothing but capable since he met her and he's not one for underestimating others. No, it's more her unwavering kindness that gives him reason for concern, there are plenty of people out there willing to take advantage of such things, looking to manipulate and take what they can, she'd be the perfect target for such a thing. -- Hell, if he'd had any ill intent then he would've had multiple chances to hurt her or USE her.
Though that doesn't mean he's not at all worried about her getting physically injured too, it isn't just people that could hurt her, there were a lot of things out there looking for him and they'd have no qualms tearing her apart to make a point.
❝-- Never said that, wouldn't think it for a second.
Everyone has a bit of fire in 'em if they need it.❞
As much as he could go on to defend what he'd first said, he decides to leave it at that, avoiding explaining his concerns regarding her safety. If she didn't accept the fact that he is bad news before, she's not any more likely to do so this time, he just has to accept that. There's only so much he can do to protect a person when they're willingly ignoring all his warnings, Beth's stubborness was her own problem and he'd do his best to convince himself he has no weight to shoulder as he tried his best to deter her from his life.
It doesn't surprise him that she doesn't hate easily, she's the sort that wants to see the best in people and that makes it damn difficult to see them for all their faults. He knows his explanation about his own faults, about why people would hate him just might lift that veil of optimism from her eyes but he's still too drunk to care all too much.
If she turns him away finally, if she can't be near him, that will likely save her life. He can convince himself he's telling her the truth for that very reason, rather than it being just another attempt of getting it all off his chest. -- It seems it works to a degree as she pries the mug from his hands and decides to instead keep her distance, that doesn't go unnoticed by the mage.
❝-- Ain't anythin' to say. I know what I am, the kind of
person I am n' I know people are better off stayin' away
from me but people like you are stubborn n' care too much,
won't give up on me even when y' life is on the line.❞
He says nothing about the fact that he selfishly wants someone to stick around despite him trying to push them away, loneliness is just human nature and despite what some might think, he's still Human enough to feel it. It's being stuck between a rock and a hard place, either spend forever alone or make friends and let them perish.
❝-- If y' want me t' go, just say. I'll sod off for good.❞