Toxic Roleplayers and YOU
(Iāve had this post sitting in my drafts for a while. Iāve been on the fence about posting this for a few reasons. This post is not directed at anyone. This post is a result of talking to counselors over what happened to me, talking at great length to friends, and generally a desire to inform what this type of abuse looks and feels like so that if anyone is in the situation they have a way to step away.)
Okay, before I start talking about toxic roleplayers I want to take a time to discuss toxicity in terms of being around people.Ā
Toxic people in a word are people who have behaviors or relationships that are unhealthy. The most noticeable of these are people who only speak negatively about everything. The least noticeable of these are the people who are smiles, and charisma to the public but behind the scenes manipulative, controlling, and blameless. Curious about what are some of the warning signs? Have a link.
The type of toxic roleplayer I have personally run into is the Narcissist. Charming, socially skilled, and with a personality of a thousand blooming roses they can do no wrong.Ā
And thatās because for those deeply embroiled in the Narcissistās world, itās always your fault. Always. Ā In an RP setting this can range from your character being responsible for the Narcissistās characterās pain, to ooc blaming. An example of OOC blame as follows.
Me: Hey remember that plot I wanted to do, can we do that next?
Them: Oh well you never said that you wanted to do it now.Ā
Them; I mean I guess we could do it after *Major plot started just now*
Me: But thatās what you said last time.
Them: Oh my god! I just wanted to run this plot. You have to be better about communicating to me. You know how I am.Ā
Me: Oh⦠sorry.Ā
The above is speech crafted carefully. There is no acknowledgement of the other personās needs. Any hint of blame is gone from one person and directly dumped on the other person as full blown blame with the added caveat, of making the other party feel guilty. Of course you should know how they are! How dare you. You monster.
This is a pattern of interaction, first and foremost, itās also how timid personalities become dominated. And Narcissists love them some timid personalities. Or vulnerable peeps. And the RP community has an abundance of both.Ā
And then thereās Gas lighting. Gas lighting is one of the most insidious forms of manipulation. It can turn a rational person into an emotional train wreck. Years and years later I still go from being sane to crying in the bathroom because I hit a low point and oh god I just ruined friendships and no one wants to be around me and wow how awful I am. Gas lighting is manipulation at itās finest and can leave serious emotional scars. Ā But what is gas lighting?
Me: Hey can we talk?Ā
Them: Sure! :)
Me: Iām really bothered about the ways youāve been talking to me.Ā
Me; I feel like you donāt want to do my plot at all.
me: It really bothers me, and itās feeling really hurtful.
Them: Wow all I ever do is give and then you turn around and say Iām hurting you?Ā
Them: I just needed some space and youāre being too emotional. I canāt handle this right now. I took a step back to give myself a break.
Them: you need to get your head straight. Like I love you and I care about you but Iām not going to let you bully me while youāre hysterical.
Gas lighting like above usually presents when youāve had this relationship going on for a while. It will start out small and casual. Small like oh well I think youāre over reacting. And thereās no big deal or explosive anger on top. Sometimes the anger isnāt explosive, sometimes itās a concentrated simmer. Either way the person who is shy or timid is the one to start going āOh man. Is it me? Am I really that hysterical? Am I that bad? This person I trust is telling me these things. OH GOD IT IS TRUE.ā And thatās when you wind up crying in the bathtub while two small dogs give you really worried looks.Ā
And the worst part about that shit is you believe it. It takes a lot to get over that. I still have times where I get paranoid that the abusive people in my past were right and no one wants to be around me because Iām hysterical and crazy and mean. It is normal to have these thoughts once you get out, the important part is to constantly tell yourself your feelings are valid and to make a mantra out of the good things you are.Ā
But if it was really that bad no one would ever get sucked into that trap!Ā
This type of toxic person is all smiles and charisma. They are happy, perky, peppy, super extroverted, letās party! Theyāre fun and they lavish attention on the meeker personalities. Youāre special! Youāre my special darling. Who wouldnāt be wary of a new friend that thinks youāre awesome. And thatās the spider web. You become elevated to this amazing place as the right hand of this celebrity. You can do no wrong, youāre special! You, yes you!. And then once they have you hook, line, and sinker, youāre no longer special. Youāre the prize thatās been won. For me, looking back at my experiences I feel sick when I think about the courtship phase. If you are someone that fell for the bait, you are a special prize and any one that plays with you should treat you with the respect you deserve. you deserve respect and love. Tell that to yourself in the mirror ever day while standing like superwoman/super man. You are a fucking delight, and worth respect.
But after the honeymoon phase the veil comes off and holy shit. That beautiful celebrity who lavished you with praise and encouragement and this idea that youāre special is starting to treat you poorly. Suddenly youāre not one of the cool kids anymore. And man, that shit can get super dark super fast. This is hard to talk about because I still have the feeling that Iām being hysterical when I speak of these things. And to the outside it looks like youāre being hysterical, surely the celebrity canāt possibly be doing these things that hurt your feelings on purpose. Ā But that first example of blame is happening behind the scenes. Youāre being called hysterical. Thereās other things at work.Ā
On an IC note the roleplay is limited. Before there were hours wasted having fun thereās suddenly no time for you. If you ask for rp you are being a bother. The times rp will happen is when they demand it from you. On an OOC level you are no longer important. And any time you try to talk about it, itās immediately turned around to you being unreasonable, controlling, or hysterical. You may be in the middle of a plot but it was dropped and any attempts to finish the plot are seen as you being too demanding to the outsiders.Ā
The discard phase is where most of the lasting damage comes from.Ā
This part is where the gaslighting and the blame shifting happens. The narcissist is hunting for a new special toy while trying to keep control over you. If you wander to far they will come back and put you into a position where saying no makes you look like a bad person. Walking away at this point is not available. You walk away and they have fuel for the āeveryone leaves meā train of talking about how theyāre the victim. And itās a cycle.Ā
Some other key points to recognize:
Moodswings - rp partner has severe mood swings usually accompanied by a temper tantrum. This usually revolves on other peopleās needs no longer lining up with their needs.Ā
Trash talking - The rper will talk poorly about those in their discard phase. This includes former rp partners who backed away for ANY REASON. School, work, running another guild. Any. reason. Trash talking will include talking badly about other rp guilds and any rpers that donāt follow their rp dogma. If trash talking about their discards they will tack on a just kidding or other phrases to make it seem like they playing. the discard will not know this.Ā
Secret adultery - Ok. this one sounds weird and controlling, but follow me here. There is one on one relationship rp. The narcissist is simultaneously rping their half in the same timeline with another character. Which if people are adults is fine, do your thing, have that jam. BUT hereās the kicker, they are deliberately trying to hide this from the main person as well as telling the new rp partner things like ādonāt tell x! theyāre really possessive.ā or āthisāll be our secret romance.ā Ā OOC Communication is vital. if you want a cheating drama rp talk like a fucking adult. if you do not communicate it says that the people involved do not deserve respect and courtesy.
Sabotage - This in an rp world is saying things like donāt rp with them theyāre really possessive. or other forms of trash talking to new people to make them unappealing to new rp partners and further the idea that all they have is the narcissist.Ā
Now if youāre sitting here, feeling sick because all of this applies to you or loved ones take a big breath. Evaluate the situation. Do you as a person feel anxious or dread playing a game because the Narcissist in your life makes you feel like shit? Do you feel any of these things found here?Ā There is hope.Ā
Disengage yourself. Itās tricky, might involve a retcon or two. Write yourself out. Take a couple weeks to treat yourself to long walks, water, a hike, maybe some nice bath products. You are going to be hurting. Itās like ripping duct tape off a rug burn. Grieve. Remind yourself that you are a wonderful person and thatās why they picked you to add to their crown.Ā
Should I make a tumblr post and warn others about this person.
Tumblr has an unfortunate habit of bringing out the shittiest scumbags who will belittle you and make you feel worse for posting a call out. Just watch the WoW tag and look at the shitty people who are mad at a 15yr old girl talking about the grown men sexually harassing her and her posting the screen shots of Creepy McFuckface being a creepy mc fuckface.Ā
Keep the logs. Keep screenshots. If you do decide to post your story on tumblr, there will be white knights. There will be nasty people that will tell you you donāt have enough evidence. Be aware that these people would never believe that the toxic person in your life would ever do that. They have the charm of exceptional charisma and a personality that on the outside looks like a bucket of gold and rainbows. But there are people who will believe you and sometimes people will step forward with their own war stories.Ā
Seriously take the time to evaluate yourself before you decide, any choice you make will be the right one for you. It is absolutely okay to wait until youāre emotionally stable and itās absolutely okay to decide against a post until other people do so. Itās absolutely ok to not post at all. And some of the effects of gas lighting will persist for years afterwards. It is absolutely ok to see a therapist or a counselor for this type of emotional healing. Do not feel like because it happened in rp that lessens the validity of the manipulations.
Ā Be strong, and remember that you are a goddamned delight even if youāre crying at 2am about how crazy you must be from what they told you. You are worth respect.Ā
And keep logs and keep screen shots.