To be honest I am sympathetic to the view that women shouldnât be in the military, but for entirely different reasons to what misogynists say. It is not a straightforward subject and there are valid analyses on both sides, but if your priorities as a woman are physical safety and psychological wellbeing then I would worry for any female loved one joining the military.
Militaries are incredibly violent, warped and dysgenic institutions, and Iâm not even talking about the broader geopolitics of them serving as vehicles for foreign imperialism â because not all militaries do that. Iâm talking about sexual violence against serving female officers and civilians. From American women in the military raped and murdered by their colleagues, to Kenyan women raped and murdered by British soldiers at the permanent UK army base in northern Kenya. From Iranian women raped and murdered by soldiers of their own countryâs regime, to Sudanese women raped and murdered by both the Rapid Support Forces and official Armed Forces in the current civil war.
Not to mention the incredibly dysfunctional, almost other worldly culture of an organised army. The regimented routine. The fact that youâre living far away from home and your usual support network. The specific type of men that armies in particular attract âaggression is a valued trait. The ways that such men will look to unleash their frustrations with the regimented lifestyle, bullying from male colleagues, lack of privacy etc. The preoccupation with optics if you are in a country currently at war â meaning that your army cannot afford any public scandals, and is incentivised to silence whistleblowers who speak up about abuse.
Then there are also all of the arguments that feminists and socialists would make about militaries turning women of different nationalities on each other, sending female soldiers to harm civilian women in a foreign country for their own countryâs nationalistic agenda. I know this absolutely isnât true in all cases though. Of course we can understand why a Ukrainian woman would want to join her countryâs military and fend off a literal invasion. My concern though would be for her risk of facing sexual violence, not just from Russian men but Ukrainian men too. The same applies to both Palestinian and Israeli women. Hamas and the IDF alike are full to the brim with rapists. Why wouldnât they be. What military ever hasnât been full to the brim with rapists? Why would one army have some special immunity to these patterns, just because geopolitically they might be on the morally right side?
Admittedly I have a bias, given the only military-connected man Iâve ever dated (veteran of the British armed forces) was legitimately frightening and nearly trapped me into a coercive controlling relationship. But I also know many women who have dated soldiers or ex soldiers. Itâs always the same story as mine. Control freaks. Sex addicts. Poor temperaments. Domestic abuse record. Speed-runs and coerces every possible decision in a relationship, without foreseeing the consequences. Utterly incapable of foresight. Frighteningly intense personalities. Because intensity makes good soldiers. But it doesnât fucking make a good man.
I donât believe militaries deserve women, thatâs why I fear when they join. Iâm not advocating any kind of legal ban, what Iâm saying is that if you found out a woman you loved was considering joining the army or navy, I would seriously inquire further. I would treat it the way you would treat finding out a woman you loved wanted to start an OnlyFans, become a sugar baby, join a strip club or start street prostitution. Itâs not about morality, itâs about it being fucking dangerous to her safety, health and wellbeing.
Equally I understand the counter argument one could give of âBut if you donât have women join the military then how can you expect the culture and treatment of women to change inside the institution?â The same argument has been made â and to a degree proven true â for the police, politics, academia and the corporate world. Itâs a valid insight.
But the military is far more intense, life-altering and dangerous than any other walk of life (except sex work prostitution, which carries a far higher rate of PTSD and lowered life expectancy). I just donât want any women to serve as collateral damage. This is admittedly speculative but from what I have observed, the sort of men who join the military (especially the Paras, as my own ex admitted to me) are just more fucking intense and mentally disturbed than men who go into other careers. There are a myriad of reasons for this: the structure of the job, how they break you down psychologically to condition obedience, the targeting of economically disadvantaged young men for recruits, etc. None of which are womenâs problem to fix. Women deserve to be safe. Besides most men donât want women in the military anyway. Think about the mentality of that. If they donât want you there, what makes you think they will keep you safe or treat you as an equal?














