CLOSETED!ABBY ANDERSON X READER
𝚖𝚒𝚗𝚒 (18+) 𝚗𝚜𝚏𝚠 𝚌𝚘𝚗𝚝𝚎𝚗𝚝
Abby had never been close to anybody except Owen and even then she wasn't really into it so when she confessed she'd never been with a girl you decided to help her explore...
You and Abby are best friends, you were the one person she trusted most but recently she's been quiet, too quiet. Her silence now can only remind you of when she'd been procrastinating breaking up with Owen so obviously you were concerned.
It was "movie night" aka the only night you two were both free from patrol duties. You were sat on the couch of your shared dorm waiting for her to finish showering after her workout and by the time you'd picked a movie and laid out a bunch of snacks she was walking out of the bathroom in just a pair of boxers. straight past you to grab the shirt off of her bed. She knew you were into girls, knew you were watching, knew that her muscles were beyond impressive, which only made you wonder if she let you see her like this to boost her own confidence or if maybe just maybe you had a chance.
She slipped on her favorite sleeveless shirt and plopped down beside you. She looked over and tried to hide that stupid smug smile she'd given you countless times as she put her back to you "Can you braid my hair again?" she asked despite being perfectly capable of doing it herself, you obliged despite being perfectly aware.
Once you finished braiding her hair she laid down, legs sprawled across the whole couch, leaving room for you to lay your head between her legs, like "best friends" usually do.
After a while she kept sighing and playing around with your hair, so restless to the point you sat up and asked if she was okay when she replied with a simple "hm? no-yeah i'm fine" you gave her the most dissatisfied face you could muster "i'm not taking that as an answer, you've been all weird and quiet all week, cmon. spill the beans"
She stayed quiet for two minutes that felt like ten "When you... How did you know that you liked girls? Was it obvious or did you have to figure it out or?- Not saying that I am I just... been thinking about it a lot. i'm curious is all."
Your couldn't help the shit-eating grin that slipped across your face, you had a hunch and she had only helped to confirm that suspicion. "I thought I might've like some guys at first but then I just kinda realized I was looking for women not just at them. Like I'd been with guys but I never liked it the way they did, they were so into it and I was just bored wishing they were girls instead but I think it's kinda different for everyone. Do you think you might?-"
She froze like she couldn't think before nodding then shrugging like she was too shy to admit it but she needed someone to know, someone to help her carry this. "I dunno, I mean Owen was just kinda- it wasn't what I thought- the sex- I didn't even..."
You smiled at her "nothing wrong with liking a girl, do you wanna test it out? I know a couple girls you could go on a date or two with?"
She shook her head immediately "I don't trust them-"
"Well who would you trust?"
"Can I try a little with you? Ive never even kissed a girl so I don't know if I'd be good at it or if i'm into it but I think I wanna try- if you want?-"
She sat up looking at you like she was about to stress herself out. "If not I get it I just-"
You pulled her into a kiss and suddenly her hands snapped to your hips like they'd already be taught what to do, she whined in a way you'd only heard from her while getting patched up. She pulled you to straddle her lap and she couldn't keep her hips still.
"You okay abs?" You pulled back just enough to look down at her and let out a teasing huff as you looked down at her hands gripping your hips like they were holding on for dear life.
"I think I'm better than okay- Can we do that again? more-"
You leaned back down into another kiss only breaking it to pull your baggy shirt off (technically hers, stolen by you) and she looks up at you with eyes the size of the moon before playing with the waistband of your shorts, trying to peek under them without seeming weird.
"Can I take your shirt off?"
She nodded immediately and sat up for you to take it off easier.
You kissed down her chest and she immediately got to wrapping her thighs around your leg and grinding like she couldn't help herself, she was pathetic, whining, grabbing at your hips.
You kept kissing at the sensitive spot you found on her neck, letting her use your legs to help herself, finally getting her to start coming out of her shell.
She was soaking though her boxers even leaving her mark on your legs and this was the most open you'd ever seen her, mouth open letting out those pretty breathy moans, calling your name like she was about to cry till she her grip on you started getting tighter. Her hips moved faster to grind herself on your thigh and she moved one hand to dig her nails into your back and you sucked one of her nipples, just as you realized how close she really was you felt the wet spot on your leg grow, she let out a final loud moan before stilling her body. She was panting and flushed and oh so shy but it was too late for the now.
You watch her face as you slipped her boxers off and she easily complied even when you opened her legs. You dipped your head down to kiss at the poor swollen bud between her legs and she whined, grabbing the hair at the nape of your neck for some sort of emotional support as you got her familiar with your tongue.
"Pleasepleaseplease don't stop-" was all she could afford to mutter with how hard she'd been breathing.
You watched her as you said your tongue in and out, using your thumb to rub her clit and the tears in her eyes only fueled you more. She needed more, she was already so close again, whining out for you wasn't enough. She used the grip in your hair to keep you head steady as she stated to grind herself into your face, completely lost in the moment.
She went faster, more frantic, chasing until finally she let go. She twitched and whimpered as you licked her clean and kissed your way up her thighs.
"Poor baby" you muttered as she relaxed back into the couch.
"Shut up- You better not tell a soul."
"So you like girls or just me?"
She smiled before throwing a pillow at you.