Redneck Ph.D.

Communication Scholar, Comic Fan, and Cultural Critic

[redneck-phd]

Family Feuds and Fierce Faith: The Media Circus of the Pentecost Bands

The family drama of the Davis sisters captured Midwestern newspapers in 1889 with numerous publications cross posting stories similar to this one. (Effingham Democrat, Effingham, Ill. November 27, 1889) This article is from a larger, forthcoming chapter “On the Warpath for God: The Adventures of Pentecost Band Women 1885-1890“ in Spirited Sisters, a forthcoming collection from Pennsylvania State…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Reconsidering the Pentecost Bands' Evangelistic Tactics 1885-1890

The Pentecost Bands made St. Joseph, Mich. their headquarters in 1886 as they launched revivals along the Illinois Canal line (photo credit: The Inland Waterways of North America by David Edwards-May.) The Pentecost Bands, established in 1885 in the small Michigan community of Parma, hold a rich history that extends far beyond rural landscapes. Contrary to common assumptions, these bands were…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

The Pentecost Bands: History, Theology, and Legacy of the Early Evangelistic Movement

An early photo of the Pentecost Bands, prior to 1892 because found Vivan Dake is in the front/center right. (Photo Credit: Chris Hanson Collection) The Pentecost Bands were an influential yet short-lived group that began in 1882 as an evangelistic outreach in Iowa. Founded by Free Methodist elder Vivan Dake, his wife Ida, and several others, the group’s mission was to spread the gospel. However,…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Christopher and Blanche Stamp: Free Methodist General Conference Evangelists

A November 1912 announcement in The Daily Inter Lake about revival services in Kalispell, Montana. Christopher, Blanche, and their daughter Ada are noted as preaching. Christopher Stamp became a General Conference evangelist around 1904, and the Stamps’ speaking engagements garnered media attention wherever they went. While Christopher was the official General Conference evangelist, Blanche…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Reconsidering the Pentecost Band Evangelistic Tactics

The Pentecost Bands made St. Joseph, Mich. their headquarters in 1886 as they launched revivals along the Illinois Canal line (photo credit: The Inland Waterways of North America by David Edwards-May.) The Pentecost Bands, established in 1885 in the small Michigan community of Parma, hold a rich history that extends far beyond rural landscapes. Contrary to common assumptions, these bands were…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Do Not Be Silenced: Pushing for Egalitarian Theology in Doctrine & Practice

Silenced is for sale at all major online bookstores, including Amazon. Ebook $45; Hardbound $80.50 A week ago, I had a chance to return to Spring Arbor University (SAU), my alma mater with my sixteen-year-old son, who is beginning his college search.  As much as I love SAU, I am deeply worried about the university’s lack of connection to its Free Methodist history and even its own mission. A key…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Pentecost Bands as Advocates for Social Purity

A group photo of Pentecost Band Members from 1900. (Courtesey Chris Hansen Family Photo Collection) Historically, Free Methodism was tied to numerous social causes (and still is to this day). Its founding principles emphasized care and inclusion for everyone, strong abolitionist ties, and an emphasis on returning to the “old time Methodist” principles, such as entire sanctification. However,…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Michigan Pentecost Bands Cause Local Uproar in 1886

An undated photo of some women from the Pentecost Bands. Some newspaper accounts note women as young as sixteen and seventeen leaving home to join a Pentecost Band. (Photo Chris Hansen Family Photo Collection) Because the Pentecost Bands were essentially traveling revivalists, their members had the opportunity to influence countless individuals, It wasn’t unusual for a young adult to attend a…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Pentecost Band Leaders Embrace Marital Purity

The White Cross Army Pledge- (link to the book below). The White Cross Army was modeled after temperance organizations and attempted to create a social movement favoring strict sexual abstinence, except in marriage for the purpose of procreation. While Free Methodists during the Progressive Era were known for following stringent Holiness lifestyle guidelines. (For example, simple dress, no…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Dake's Influence on Pentecost Band Theology

An early photo of the Pentecost Bands, prior to 1892, founder Vivan Dake is in the front/center right. While the Pentecost Bands were loosely affiliated with the Free Methodist Church (mostly through connections of leaders such as Vivan Dake and the mentorship of Free Methodist General Superintendent Benjamin Titus Roberts), they diverged from mainstream Free Methodist theology on several key…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Pentecost Band Initial Organizational Guidelines

A photo of Pentecost Band members, undated but likely early 1900s. (Photo Credit: Chris Hanson Collection)   While the Pentecost Bands did eventually branch into overseas mission work (Africa, India, and Europe) in the mid-1890s onward, from 1885-1889 the bands ministered in the midwestern United States, traveling around Michigan, Ohio, Indiana, and Illinois.   Guidelines for band membership and…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

A Brief History of the Pentecost Bands

An early photo of the Pentecost Bands, prior to 1892 because found Vivan Dake is in the front/center right. (Photo Credit: Chris Hanson Collection) In 1882 Free Methodist elder Vivan Dake along with his wife Ida, J.B. Newville, Henrietta Muzzy Abbie Dunham, and J.L. Keene formed an evangelistic outreach group they named the Pentecost Band. The six were based in Iowa at the time, and God called…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Shiny Happy People Podcast

I’m happy to share that my spouse, Andrew, myself and our friend Jeff are hosting a podcast review of each episode of the new Prime Duggar documentary Shiny Happy People. The documentary was released on Amazon Friday, June 2, 2023, and is a four-part series looking into not only the Duggar family, but the underlying theology of their show and the influence of conservative, Christian leaders such…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Jinger Duggar's Book Illustrates the Toxicity of Complementarian Theology

A few years ago, I was interviewed by a journalist writing about Gothard’s Institute for Biblical Life Principles (IBLP) and how his views on gender might have contributed to the numerous accusations emerging about his sexual abuse of women who had worked with him. I don’t think the journalist ever got the article published, which is, unfortunately, what sometimes happens in freelance…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Christian Media & Complementarian Theology: This Partnership isn't a New Thing

While my more recent blog posts have been about historic examples of women in ministry, I want to take a few posts to connect why the study of historic gender concerns in American Christian culture is relevant to issues Protestant American culture still faces today. Gender roles and family roles are very black-and-white in conservative, Christian culture and allow little deviation. (stock photo…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Free Methodist Women in the South Part I

During the 1890s and early 1900s numerous women wrote to The Free Methodist to share reports about their local congregations or the evangelistic crusades they were leading. Over the next few posts, I’ll be republishing ministry reports from women who lived and ministered in the southern states.  Their stories are remarkable, and they should be allowed to tell their stories in their own words…

View On WordPress

[redneck-phd]

Clara Wetherald A Methodist, Then a Free Methodist and Finally a Congregationalist

Gaylord Congregationalist Church (Now First Congregational United Church of Christ) Clara Wetherald noted in her testimony at the 1890 Free Methodist General Conference that when she was younger she thought the only way a woman could preach was if she married a minister. So, that’s exactly what she did when, at seventeen, she married John Wetherald, an ordained elder in the Methodist Protestant…

View On WordPress