Neighbourly Care part 6 (NSFW)
Pairing: Agatha Harkness x Rio Vidal x Reader
Summary: You're home for the holidays and despite the hustle and bustle of family gatherings, your mind is stuck on your two hot neighbours just next door. And when an opportunity for some time alone with them presents itself, how could you refuse?
-OR-
Agatha and Rio tease you relentlessly at a New Years party and you can't wait until its finished to fuck them so you sneak away
Warnings: 18+ MDNI, switch Agatha, switch Rio, Switch reader, threesome (duh), Mommy/Daddy titles, strap-ons, vibrators, fingering, oral, marking, reader has a vibrator used on them in front of other people, alcohol consumption, scissoring, light choking, maybe more? who knows, it's so long I've definitely missed something
Words: 6.4k
A/N: We're BACK baby. This was supposed to be released at the start of Jan to be seasonal but alas it is being released now. This is just shameless smut tbh
AO3 | Part 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Masterlist
The holidays at home always blur together: long afternoons curled up on the couch, listening to old family stories, plates of food that never seem to end, and the comforting hum of familiar voices filling every corner and yet this year feels different.
The quiet warmth of home should be grounding, but instead, it leaves an ache in the pit of your stomach. Agatha and Rio are just next door. So close that if you stepped outside, you could probably hear their laughter through an open window. But proximity doesnāt mean access, and knowing theyāre near without being able to touch themāto taste themāhas your nerves fraying with every passing hour.
You try to focus on the holiday routine, but your mind keeps drifting, fingers itching to grab your phone. It starts with subtle messages: a teasing remark, a playful emoji, a simple āwish you I could be with youā. But restraint crumbles fast, and soon, the texts turn flirty.
And thenā
MILFs Anonymous
Rio: You should really learn to close your curtains, cariƱo. You never know whoās watching ;)
Rio: *click to open image*
The moment you open it, your breath catches.
Agatha is naked in front of the window, bent over just enough to make your pulse quicken, her back arched, ass pressing into Rioās hips. Rioās hand grips her firmly, fingers digging into soft skin, and thereās a faint red tint blooming across Agathaās assāa clear sign of exactly what theyād been doing before taking this picture.
Your brain shortcircuits.
Because even though you canāt see it, you know the look on Rioās face, the way she holds Agatha steady, the slight tilt of her hips. Youāve felt it beforeābeen pinned beneath that same unrelenting grip, left breathless by the sharp sting of Agathaās nails in your skin, Rioās voice low and taunting as she urges you to take what you're given.
You swallow hard, your mind replaying flashes of memoriesāAgatha's gasping moans, the way Rio growled in satisfaction as she pushed deeper, the sting of Agathaās teeth on your shoulder as she struggled to keep quiet. The way they ruined you. The way you begged them to.
But it wasnāt just the two of them in the picture. Through the window, reflected in the glass, you can see yourself wrapped in only a towel, fresh from the shower, completely unaware of what was unfolding right next door.
Oh shit. They had been fucking each other while watching you.
A fresh wave of heat rushes through you. They knew youād see this and they knew exactly how your thoughts would spiral.
ā
For the rest of the day, no matter how many people surround you, no matter how desperately you try to push the image from your mind, you canāt stop feeling the heat coiling low in your stomach, a slow, aching pulse between your thighs that refuses to fade. Every time you slip away for even a moment, closing yourself in the bathroom or lingering too long in the pantry, you try to find any sort of reliefāpressing your thighs together, letting your fingers ghost over the damp heat through your underwearābut itās never enough. The house is too busy, the walls too thin, and the risk too high.
And then it gets worse.
When you step outside that afternoon, something entirely unexpected greets you.
At first, it doesnāt make senseāa massive tent pole structure stretching across your backyard, spilling into Agatha and Rioās. Men move around, securing ropes and hammering stakes into the ground. You frown, stepping closer to where your father stands, watching the setup unfold.
āWhatās going on?ā you ask, confusion evident in your voice.
Your dad turns to you with a wide, easy smile, as if the sight of an entire-ass event tent appearing in your backyard is completely normal. āOh, the fencing between the yards was getting replaced, right? So we thought, why not take advantage of the space? Weāre throwing a New Yearās Eve party with Agatha and Rio. A big oneālots of peopleāshould be a good way for them to meet the neighbours a bit better.ā
Your stomach flips. āA joint party?ā
āYep!ā He seems blissfully unaware of the way you bit your lip; youāre a flirty drunk and there is no way youāll be able to help yourself even with a house full of guests. āJust made sense, really. They only moved in a couple weeks before you went back to college so theyāre still kind of new here, and itās a great excuse for everyone to get together.ā
As if summoned by your rising anxiety, your mother enters the conversation, casually slipping her phone from her pocket. āOh, that reminds meāwe have a group chat for the planning. You should be in it, too.ā
Before you can protest, your phone buzzes with a new notification:
Mom added you to New Years Party šš„³š¾
Looking at who was in the chat, you see itās just your parents, Agatha, Rio, and now you.
You stare at your screen, the weight of the situation settling into your bones. Thereās no escaping them at this party. Theyāll be there, looking devastating, flirting in ways no one else will recognise, taunting you. And worseāyouāll have to pretend it doesnāt matter.
The moment youāre alone, you do the only thing that makes sense.
MILFs Anonymous.
~15:48
You: You two didnāt think to tell me about this party???
~15:51
Agatha: We thought you already knew, darling.
~16:02
Rio: Canāt wait to see your outfit ;)
You let out a groan, flopping onto your bed, heart hammering against your ribs.
ā
The next couple of days blur into a frenzy of preparation. The towering pole tent in the backyard transforms into something breathtakingāa canopy of warm string lights crisscrossing above, casting a golden glow over the dance floor, lounge areas, and bar stations. Tables are filled with food and drinks; fire pits crackle steadily, promising warmth against the winter chill.
Your parents, ever the enthusiastic hosts, are in full planning mode. Your mom bombards the group chat with a steady stream of last-minute tasks, while your dad orchestrates the outdoor setup like a seasoned general.
"Can someone make sure the drinks are properly chilled?""Surfaces still need to be wiped down!""We need more iceāany volunteers?"
Between messages, youāre swept into the chaos, lugging bottles of wine to the bar, adjusting decorations, untangling fairy lights. But no matter how hectic things get, Agatha and Rio always seem to find a moment to steal you away.
It starts small.
As you carry a tray of glasses into their kitchen, Rio appears behind you, pressing in close, her breath warm against your ear.
"Mmm, darling, seeing you follow orders is doing things to me." Her fingers trail down your arm, barely touching, but enough to send a shiver racing down your spine. Before you can react, sheās gone; back to chatting with your mom like nothing happened.
Then thereās Agatha. Youāre kneeling down, adjusting a set of flickering LED candles on a coffee table, when she approaches. She tilts your chin up with two fingers, forcing your gaze to hers.
"Careful, sweetheart." She smirks as her thumb brushes over your lower lip. "If you stay on your knees too long, Iām going to start getting ideas."
Heat floods your body, your pulse hammering wildly. Theyāre relentless, playing a game you have no hope of winning. And thenābecause the universe isnāt done with you yetāyour mom unknowingly delivers the final blow.
New Years Party šš„³š¾
Mom: Hey! Would it be okay if Y/N stayed with you guys tonight? Aunt Carol and family are taking up all our rooms.
You donāt even think about how your momās making you give up your room without asking; youāre too busy staring at your phone, heart pounding.
Youāre going to be staying with them again.
Excitement flutters in your chest, hot and electric. After days of teasing glances, fleeting touches, and whispered words meant to unravel you, youāre finally going to have them to yourself. No stolen moments. No interruptions. Just you, Agatha, and Rio.
But that thrill is laced with something deeper. Because if theyāve been so relentless with their flirting, not knowing when theyād next properly be with you, what the hell is going to happen now they know they get to have you all to themselves?
You swallow hard, fingers gripping your phone tighter as their responses roll in.
New Years Party šš„³š¾
Rio: No worries :)
Agatha: Donāt worry, we will take good care of them, just like we always do.
You choke on nothing.
Your mom, blissfully oblivious, just reacts with a thumbs-up emoji and moves on with planning. Meanwhile, you sit there, phone still in your hands, trying to process the fact that youāve just been thrown straight into the lionās denāand youāre not coming out unfucked unscathed.
ā
You stand before your mirror, hands smoothing down the fabric of your costume.
Itās bolder than anything youād normally wear. The cut, the way it frames your body, the teasing flashes of skināyou look hot.
After one last steadying breath, you step out of your room.
The party is already in full swing by the time you make your way downstairs. Your house, the backyards, and Agatha and Rioās house are all packed, laughter and music spilling from every direction. Guests roam freely between the connected spaces, glasses in hand, conversations buzzing with holiday cheer. Familiar faces from high school mix with family, friends, and neighbours, the crowd a blur of movement and warmth.
But you only have eyes for them.
Rio and Agatha stand near the bar, unmistakable even from across the yard. Theyāre dressed as pirates and they look absolutely devastating.
Agathaās coat fits her like a dreamādark, regal, and cinched at the waist in a way that accentuates every curve. Gold buttons gleam under the dim lights, the ruffled blouse beneath teasing glimpses of skin. Her long hair tumbles in wild waves over her shoulders, and the sharp smirk she wears makes her look utterly untouchable.
Then thereās Rio. Her deep red tunic borders on scandalous, left open just enough to reveal her cleavage. Her pants hug her hips perfectly and it makes your mouth run dry. The hat, the sharp gaze, the effortless dominance in every movementāitās almost unfair.
ā
The night blurs into a haze of warmth and music, but you barely see them. Theyāre the perfect hosts, moving through the party with easy charm, laughing, drinking, and acting like they arenāt slowly breaking you.
Every time they pass, theyāre touching you in some way.
A lingering hand at the small of your back. Fingers skimming your wrist. A squeeze at your hip. Soft whispers against your ear, too low for anyone else to hear.
Itās torture. Slow, deliberate, intoxicating torture.
And thenā
āLong time no see.ā
You turn, blinking as a tall guy in a sharp tux grins at you, tilting his martini glass in greeting. You recognise him vaguelyāsomeone from high school, back for the holidays like everyone else.
āYouāre looking good,ā he says, eyes dragging down your outfit before reaching out, fingers grazing the fabric. āI really like the costume.ā
You arch a brow, looking him up and down. āAnd youāre dressed as...ā
He smirks, lifting his glass again. āBond. James Bond.ā
Seriously? Could he not be bothered to put in any effort?
The conversation shifts into polite small talkāheās studying business now, home for the break, blah blah blah. Itās easy, meaningless chatter. Until he leans in closer, voice dropping.
āYou know,ā he muses, ā007 always gets the hottie in the end.ā
You open your mouth, not entirely sure whether to laugh or shut him down.
Suddenly youāre not alone. Rio and Agatha flank you, cutting off all space and oxygen.
Agatha moves first, wrapping an arm around your waist, her palm settling firmly over your ass, squeezing just enough to make your breath hitch.
At the same time, Rioās fingers find the back of your neck, her thumb dragging over the sensitive skin there.
The shift is instant.
Mr. Uninventive hesitates, eyes darting between the two of them. āUhāā
āWe need to steal them for a moment,ā Rio interrupts smoothly, leaving no room for argument.
āParty business,ā Agatha adds, amusement curling at the edges of her words.
Before you can even process whatās happening, theyāre guiding you away. Through the house, up the stairs, and into their bedroom.
The door slams shut behind you.
Agatha and Rio move in tandem, running their palms over your body, mapping every inch with a reverence that makes your head spin. Lips followāfeatherlight kisses pressed to your jaw, your neck, your collarbone. Every touch, every whispered breath, is a deliberate act of worship.
āLook at you,ā Rio breathes against your skin, voice thick with hunger. Her fingers trace the curve of your waist, slipping just under the fabric of your costume. āYou have no idea what youāre doing to us, do you, baby?ā
Agatha hums in agreement, her mouth warm against the shell of your ear. āYou look so fucking good like this,ā she murmurs.
Their words make your skin prickle, heat pooling low in your stomach. You can barely breathe with how theyāre touching you, how theyāre speaking to you. But just as quickly as they praise, their hands slow and then stop entirely.
āThen again,ā Agatha continues, her tone turning sharper, her fingers digging into your hips, āmaybe we shouldnāt be too generous with our compliments.ā
You blink up at her, dizzy with need, but Rioās grip on your chin forces your gaze toward her instead. The playful glint in her eyes is gone, replaced by something darker.
āYou really thought we wouldnāt notice?ā She asks, tilting your head back, forcing you to hold her gaze. āLetting everyone at this party get an eyeful of you? Letting that prick downstairs get close enough to touch you?ā
Your stomach twists. āI wasnātāā
Agatha tuts, cutting you off. āDonāt even try, sweetheart.ā Her grip tightens, her breath hot against your cheek. āYou were practically giggling at him.ā
āI was being friendly,ā you argue weakly. āJust being a good hostāā
āYou should know who you belong to by now,ā Rio interrupts, voice a low growl, her lips brushing yours. āThe only people you need to be good for are us.ā
Before you can stammer out a response, Agatha takes your hand in hers, guiding it lower and lower until your palm is pressed between her legs. Your breath catches, eyes going wide when you feel it.
Hard, thick, and waiting.
The heavy coat sheās wearing must have concealed it from view
Your lips part, a soft, startled noise escaping before Rio kisses it away. Then Agatha presses forward just enough to make sure you feel her, making sure you understand.
āStill want to pretend?ā She teases dangerously. āOr are you ready to be good now?ā
Rio doesnāt give you a chance to answer. Her fingers are suddenly slipping past the waistband of your underwear, gliding through your slick heat with ease. The first stroke has you jolting, the second has you gasping, and by the third, youāre already shaking in their hold.
āFuck, sweetheart,ā Rio murmurs against your lips, dragging her fingers through your wetness before circling your clit in slow, deliberate strokes. āYouāre so worked up. Is this all for us or do you want us to go fetch your friend from downstairs?ā
You whine at her words. āNo. Please, no, I want you. I only ever want you.ā
Agatha hums her approval, her hands busy with your chest, kneading, pinching, and rolling your nipples between her fingers in a way that has you keening. Her mouth isnāt far behind, her lips and tongue lavishing attention along your neck and collarbone, teeth scraping just enough to make you shudder.
āYou look so pretty like this,ā she muses, flicking her tongue over a sensitive spot, smiling when she feels your breath hitch. āSo desperate and needy. And you have the nerve to pretend you werenāt begging for us to do this?ā
Rio chuckles, dragging her fingers lower before plunging two inside you without warning. The sudden stretch knocks the air from your lungs, your knees buckling as she fucks into you with deep, practiced strokes. Her free hand grips your hip, keeping you steady as your body melts between them, thighs shaking, pleasure mounting too quickly to contain.
āThatās it, baby,ā she purrs, curling her fingers just right, rubbing against your g-spot in a way that has you seeing stars.
You donāt stand a chance. Between Agathaās lips on your skin, her hands teasing and playing with your chest, and the relentless motion of Rioās fingers, you unravel in their arms, your orgasm hitting you in waves that leave you breathless. You barely register Agathaās arm wrapping around your waist, holding you upright as your body trembles, Rio murmuring soft praises as she strokes you through the aftershocks.
By the time you finally come down, youāre a messāpractically boneless from the pleasure theyāve wrung from you. You hadnāt even noticed how thoroughly theyād been marking you until you glance at the mirror across the room and spot angry red hickies blooming all over your neckātoo dark to be ignored, too obvious to be passed off as anything else.
Rio just smirks. āYouāll figure something out,ā she says, unbothered.
Then something smooth and cool is slid down the front of your underwear and then pushed inside you. It slips in without resistance; youāre not surprised by this with how hard you just came, but you still jolt at the sensation, looking down in alarm, but Agatha hushes you with a soothing stroke down your spine.
āBe a good pet,ā she whispers. āAnd donāt take it out.ā
Your stomach twists in anticipation at what theyāre going to do.
Agatha opens the door, but before you can protest, Rio pats your ass and sends you on your way.
You try to focus, try to mingle, but itās impossible. Your legs are unsteady as you make your way back down the stairs, each step a struggle as the first soft buzz hums to life between your thighs.
You bite your lip hard, fingers gripping your drink tighter than necessary, heat spreading across your face.
Itās going to be a long night.
ā
Desperation eventually wins out.
The drinks, the teasing, the relentless vibrationsāitās all too much.
You donāt even think before your fingers fly over your phone screen, firing off a text to MILFs Anonymous in sheer drunken need.
You: I need you, Mommy.
The moment it sends, regret lances through you. Too much? Too needy? Too obvious?
But before you can spiral, your phone buzzes.
Agatha: Weāre in our living room, baby.
You practically start sprinting to them.Ā
ā
When you arrive, a group of guests has already settled in for a game of charades.
Rio and Agatha are perched on the couch, the picture of effortless elegance, drinks in hand, looking entirely untouched by the chaos theyāve unleashed inside you.
āCome join us, Y/N!ā someone calls.
You hesitate. There are no seats left, not even an armrest to perch on.
Then Agatha smirks, tilting her head in invitation. āOh, come here,ā she says, patting her thigh. āWe donāt mind squeezing in a bit.ā
The breath leaves your lungs. Your body starts moving before your mind can protest, drawn like a moth to flame. The moment you lower yourself into Agathaās lap, you feel the firm press of her strap beneath you.
Your thighs clench. A small, involuntary whimper slipping past your lips, barely audible over the chatterāexcept to them. The vibrations in your underwear kick up just slightly.
Itās a warning.
You shift instinctively, trying to relieve the ache, trying to grind just enough, but Agathaās hands settle on your hips, holding you still.
āBehave,ā she whispers.
The game goes on, but you are utterly uselessālost in your arousal, eyes darting desperately between them, silently begging for mercy.
And then, just as your body reaches a breaking point, they stand. Agatha lifts you from her lap, setting you onto the couch as if you weigh nothing. Rio leans in closeāclose enough for only you to hear.
āYou should be more careful when texting,ā she whispers, smirking against your ear. āCheck which group chat you click on next time.ā
Your blood freezes.
They walk away, leaving you scrambling to open your phone. Your stomach drops. Your messageāthe Mommy messageāwasnāt sent to MILFs Anonymous.
It was sent to the party planning chat.
With your parents in it.
Crap.
The vibrations surge suddenly to a dizzying intensity, tearing you violently back into the moment. You slap a hand over your mouth, barely suppressing a gasp, legs clamping shut as pleasure floods through you.
Agatha and Rio glance at you from across the room, watching as you struggle.
Your fingers tighten around your phone, mind racing, body burning.
That text is going to be impossible to explain to your parents.
But right now? Right now, all you can do is bite your lip and try and survive until youāre alone with Agatha and Rio again.
ā
As the party inches closer to midnight, the energy shiftsālaughter growing louder, bodies pressing together as people eagerly anticipate the countdown. The air is thick with warmth, alcohol, and the unspoken anticipation of the nightās inevitable climax.
Unfortunately for you, the guy from earlier sidles up beside you, martini glass still in hand.
āAh, there you are.ā
You sigh, schooling your expression as you glance up at him. Heās grinning, slightly flushed from alcohol, his tux still crisp despite the hours of partying.
āWhereād you run off to?ā he asks, taking another slow sip of his drink. āI was hoping weād get a little more time together.ā
āBeen busy,ā you reply, voice flat.
He chuckles like youāve made a joke, leaning in a little too close, eyes dipping to your lips. "Yāknow, itās bad luck to not have someone to kiss at midnight. Wouldnāt want to start the new year off on the wrong foot, would you?" His tone is smooth and practiced, and though his words drip with charm, they donāt land the way he intends.
You open your mouth to shut him down, but shut it again when you hear a deep gasp from behind you.
āOh no,ā Rio drawls dramatically. āOops.ā
You barely have time to process before Rioās drink drenches the front of his pristine tuxedo. Thereās a second of pure silence. Then, from somewhere in the crowd, a drunken party guest howls with laughter.
āDude!ā they wheeze, pointing at the massive stain spreading down his pants. āYou look like you pissed yourself!ā
Why on Earth they find it so funny, youāll never know, but it does seem to make wannabe James Bond forget about flirting with you.
He goes stiff, face burning as he looks down at the damage. His jaw works, like heās about to lash out for being humiliated. Instead, he mutters something under his breath, pushes past the crowd, and disappears from sight.
Rio, standing beside you, smiles sweetly, swirling the remnants of her drink round the glass. āOops,ā she says again, voice filled with mock innocence.
At that moment, the countdown begins.
āTen!ā
Agatha shifts closer.
āNine!ā
Rio sets her empty glass down, her gaze flickering to you.
āEight!ā
You feel the first brush of Agathaās fingers along your cheek.
āSeven⦠sixā¦ā
Rioās hand slides down your back, resting just above your waist.
āFive⦠fourā¦ā
Agatha tilts your chin up.
āThreeā¦ā
Your breath catches.
āTwoā¦ā
Your pulse pounds.
āOne!ā
Then, at the stroke of midnight, their lips are on you.
Agatha kisses you first, slow and languid, her tongue teasing at your lower lip before slipping into your mouth. Itās deep and possessive, and if anyone notices your neighbour kissing someone who is not her wife, theyāre too caught up in their own celebrations to care.
Before you can fully process it, she pulls away, only for Rio to take her place.
Where Agatha was slow, Rio is devastatingāteeth nipping at your lip, tongue sliding against yours, hands gripping your waist like sheās starving for you.
By the time she pulls back, youāre breathless, dazed, and aching.
ā
The party blurs after that. Thereās more drinking, more dancing, more laughter, but the tension lingers.
They donāt let you stray too far, always keeping you within reach, eyes dark with promise.
Eventually, the party begins to die down, and guests filter out toward your parentsā house to continue the fun on a smaller scale. You move to follow, but before you can take a step, a firm hand closes around your wrist.
Itās Agatha. Her grip is light, but her eyes are anything but. āStay.ā
She turns, calling out to the last stragglers near the door. āWeāre gonna lock upāprobably head to bed. Unfortunately, that means Y/N here is calling it a night too.ā
You know sheās lying and from the way Rio is standing behind you, so close you can feel her breath against your neck, you know exactly why.
The door clicks shut.
The lock turns.
And then?
They pounce.
Rio is on you first, shoving you back against the nearest wall, her mouth claiming yours with a hunger that makes your knees buckle. Itās all tongue and teeth, no patience, no teasingājust raw need.
Agatha isnāt far behind. She presses up against your side, hands already tugging at your costume, lips brushing against your ear as she snarls, āI thought theyād never leave.ā
You donāt get a chance to answer.
Rioās hands are already at your waist, yanking at the fabric, desperate to get it off. āFuck,ā she mutters, cursing the layers, fingers fumbling.
Agathaās laugh is low and wicked as she slides a hand between your legs, pressing against the soaked fabric of your underwear.
āOh, sweetheart,ā she coos. āYouāre soaked.ā
Heat floods your face, but you donāt get a second to feel embarrassedābecause in the next breath, Rio growls in frustration and just rips your costume open.
āRio!ā you gasp, but she doesnāt care.
āShut up,ā she mutters, eyes dark with want. āIāll buy you a new one.ā
She starts stripping you, hands rough and insistent. She doesnāt waste time, doesnāt go slow, just takesāpulling away fabric, tossing aside layersāuntil youāre left in nothing but your thoroughly wrecked underwear.
While Rio starts to undress herself, Agathaās hands trail down your arms before gripping your wrists and pinning them against the wall.
āLook at you,ā she muses, eyes dragging over your body like sheās memorising every inch. āYou really let yourself get this messy at a party?ā
Before you can snap back, your gaze flicks to Rio and the very, very obvious damp patch on her lacey black underwear.
Heat surges through you, and despite your situation, a smirk tugs at your lips. āIām the messy one?ā You tease, raising an eyebrow. āLooks like someone else has a problem too.ā
Rio follows your gazeāthen scoffs, shaking her head with a laugh. āKeep talking,ā she warns, shoving her thumbs beneath the waistband of her underwear. āSee what happens.ā
Now Agatha starts stripping, too.
And fuck.
Your mouth goes dry as the last of their clothes hit the floor, leaving you gaping at herācompletely bare, except for the harness strapped tightly around her hips, the deep purple toy attached firmly at the centre.
It makes your breath catch.
The sight of her so commanding and unapologetic aroused has your knees weak.
Rio spots your reaction immediately. Smirking, she slowly drops to her knees in front of you, dragging her palms down your trembling thighs.
"You're shaking, cariƱo," she murmurs, pressing a teasing kiss against your hipbone. "Been wound up all night, have you?"
Her fingers dip beneath the waistband of your soaked underwear. With a slow, deliberate drag, she peels the ruined fabric down your legs, letting it drop to the floor. And then she spots the vibrator still tucked between your slick thighs.
Her smirk widens.
"Look at this," she purrs, brushing her fingers against the damp, buzzing device. "You've been so good, keeping this in for us."
āNot like I had a chance to take it out. You guys have had me on a tight leash since midnight,ā you scoff.
āA leash, you say? Now thatās a good idea,ā Agatha hums from behind you, warm hands sliding up your arms before settling at your waist. She pulls you flush against her chest, letting you feel every inch of the hard length pressing against your lower back.
Rio hooks a finger around the toy and pulls it free with a wet, obscene little sound that makes your entire body jolt. Then, without breaking eye contact, she brings it to her lips.
Her tongue flicks over it first, tasting the evidence of your arousal. She hums, lashes fluttering as she takes the toy fully into her mouth, sucking it clean with slow, deliberate moans that send heat rushing straight to your core.
Your fingers dig into Agathaās arms, a whimper slipping past your lips.
āYou taste so fucking good,ā Rio purrs, setting it aside before leaning in, kissing and biting her way up your inner thigh.
Agatha moves at the same time, her hands skimming up your ribs before one closes firmly around your throat. She tilts your head to the side, exposing your neck, and sinks her teeth in.
The sharp pleasure-pain rips a gasp from you.
"Such a needy thing," Agatha husks against your skin, sucking another bruise into place. āWe only fucked you a few hours ago and yet youāre still dripping for us.ā
Rio groans in agreement, her breath hot against your thigh. Without warning, she grabs the back of your knee, hooks your leg over her shoulder, and finally presses her mouth to your pussy.
Rioās tongue works you open with devastating precision; she is utterly relentless. Every flick and swirl sends a fresh wave of pleasure coursing through your body, making your thighs tremble around her head. The grip Agatha has around your waist tightens, holding you up as you lose yourself to the sensation, your hands grasping at anything they can touch.
Youāre so close and Rio feels it. She moans against you, the vibration sending a sharp jolt of pleasure straight to your core. The tension snaps all at once, a ragged cry escaping your lips as an orgasm crashes through you, stealing the air from your lungs. Your body shudders, shaking in Agathaās steady arms as Rio eases you through it, licking up every last drop, prolonging the high until you can barely stand.
Only when your body sags completely against Agatha does Rio finally pull away, her lips slick and eyes hooded with satisfaction. But you barely get a moment to recollect yourself before Agatha is moving you both again.
She manhandles you effortlessly, flipping you over the arm of the couch with zero warning. She grips your hips and thrusts inside you in a single, smooth motion.
āFuckā!ā You arch against the cushions; the stretch is almost overwhelming, but you push back against her, wordlessly begging for more. And she gives it to you, setting a brutal pace that has your nails clawing at the couch.
Thereās no hesitation and no patience left. Agatha grip is firm, fingers digging into your flesh like she owns you. The heavy press of her body against your back, the way the harness hits deep with every roll of her hipsāitās overwhelming, all-consuming, and exactly what you need.
Itās only then that you register the low, shuddering groans Agatha is making, the kind that makes it feel like your body is alive with electricity. You realise she must have a grinding pad in the harness. Every thrust she gives you is giving her something in return, dragging that firm pressure right over her clit.
"Oh, fuckāso tight around me, baby. You like being used like this?" Agathaās voice is rough and strained, and it only makes you clench tighter around her.
But you still want more.
Your fingers scramble against the cushions before reaching back, finding a handful of soft, wild hair to yank.
Rio gasps, pleasure laced into the sharp pull, and follows, letting you drag her in front of you. Her pupils are blown, her chest rising and falling with heavy breaths.
You waste no time, your hands cupping the damp lace of her underwear, feeling the evidence of how much this night has affected her.
"You act all in control, but youāre just as desperate, arenāt you? Been getting off to this the whole time?" You moan, voice thick with pleasure, as Agatha pounds into you.
Rio lets out a breathless laugh, but it dissolves into a shaky whimper as you press a little firmer. "Youāre such a little brat," she whispers, but the way she rocks her hips into your touch betrays her. "Gonna make it up to me? Use that pretty little mouth of yours?"
At that, you capture her mouth in a searing kiss, swallowing her smirk and groaning against her lips as Agatha slams into you even harder. Your hands roam, greedy and impatient, trailing over Rioās stomach, slipping past the waistband of her delicate lace underwear. You moan into her mouth as you feel just how wet she is, a shuddering breath leaving her as your fingers slide through the mess youāve made of her.
Agatha grips your hips tighter. āThatās it, sweetheart,ā she growls, voice vibrating with pleasure. "Fuck her like you mean it, babyāmake her fall apart for us."
You thrust two fingers inside Rio with ease, curling them just right, coaxing a gorgeous whimper from her lips. She braces herself against the couch, hips bucking into your hand, her breath hitching every time your thumb brushes over her clit. Her head tips back, exposing the perfect column of her throat, and you canāt resistāyou latch onto her skin, kissing and biting your way down as she unravels in your hands.
Agatha doesnāt relent for a second; her pace is relentless, her moans growing heavier, and her body pressed so tightly against yours you feel everything.
The three of you move together, bodies lost in each other, the pleasure mounting higher and higher until finally, you all break at once.
Rioās cry is the first to ring out, her body tensing, fingers tangling in your hair as she falls apart beneath your touch. Agatha is next, hips stuttering, a rough groan tumbling from her lips as she pushes deep one final time.
You shatter between them, pleasure washing over you like a tidal wave, drowning in the heat of their bodies, the grip of their hands, the sound of their pleasure mixing with yours in the dark, breathless space of the living room.
ā
The three of you barely make it up the stairs, hands and lips desperate, laughter mixing with breathless moans as you stumble into the bedroom. Agatha ditches the harness the second you reach the edge of the bed, tossing it aside before Rio pushes her down onto the mattress with an eager gleam in her eye. Straddling her wife, Rio hooks one of Agathaās legs over her own, pressing their bodies together, the heat between them instantly electrifying
Agatha smirks up at her, hands tracing over Rioās thighs before gripping her hips, guiding her down. The first slow grind of Rioās core against her own pulls a shuddering gasp from them both, the wetness between their bodies making the movement slick and unbearably good.
You donāt hesitate to join, slotting yourself in behind Rio, one hand slipping between your own legs while the other moves to cup her breast. You drag your lips along the curve of her shoulder, sucking marks into her skin, letting your tongue flick behind her ear just to feel the way she shudders from it.
āFuck, look at you two,ā Agatha groans, voice thick with arousal as she meets Rioās slow, intoxicating rhythm. āYouāre both so fucking gorgeous.ā
Rio whimpers, grinding down harder, her pleasure clear in the way her body trembles against you. You can feel the slickness coating your fingers as you fuck yourself, matching their pace, your own moans spilling against Rioās flushed skin.
āCāmon, Daddy,ā you emphasise her title, fingers twisting her nipple just enough to make her gasp. āLet me hear you.ā
Rioās head falls back against your shoulder, her breath ragged as Agatha grips her ass, pulling her down with each roll of her hips, making sure she feels every bit of her. The pace quickens, and the heat between you all mounts unbearably fast. You can feel it building; Rioās legs begin to tremble, Agathaās nails dig into her skin, and your own fingers speed up, chasing that blinding pleasure.
āOh, fuckāā Rio gasps, her body going rigid as her climax crashes over her. She grips your thigh, nails digging in as she rides it out, the sound of Agathaās deep groan telling you sheās right there with her, lost in the overwhelming bliss. The sight of them both cumming together pushes you over the edge as well, pleasure searing through your veins as your own orgasm takes hold, your body tensing and then shuddering against Rioās.
For a long moment, all that fills the room is the sound of panting as your bodies tremble in the aftermath. Then, as the bliss slowly fades into warmth, Agatha lets out a breathless chuckle, running a lazy hand up Rioās side.
āWell,ā she muses, voice still hoarse from pleasure, āthatās one hell of a way to start the new year.ā
āYeah, if this is any indication of how the rest of the yearās gonna go, Iād say weāre in for a good one.ā Rio laughs, head still resting against your shoulder, and you canāt help but grin, pressing a soft kiss to her damp skin.Ā
You hum an agreement as the three of you collapse onto the mattress in a tangled, sated heap, bodies exhausted but hearts so full. Whatever the year held, one thing was certaināyou wouldnāt be facing it alone.
-----
Soooooooooo how do we all feel about the return of Neighbourly Care?
Agatha and Rio are rich MILF neighbours now ig... sugar mommies for reader yay or nay?
-----
taglist: @aceday @ctrlamira @lezbean-with-a-side-of-dilfs @noturlondonboy @darkangelchronicles @sevikasleftarm25 @kiaralee25 @4theluvofsapphos @lez-zuha @jujuu23 @gaylorvader @danveration @alwaysharmony @idkwhatever580 @lostbutlovely33 @sweetmidnights @6ange19 @masorciereviolette
My new favorite fandom















