Gabriel: He Hath Turn'd A Heaven Unto Hell
I felt like clarifying my earlier Meta on Gabrielās Gaslighting in Good Omens.Ā
So like, we know that Gabriel is a dick but what makes him worse (and abusive), is how he uses his position of privilege and power over Aziraphale.Ā
Even though Iāve read some amazing metas that assert Aziraphale would be canonically higher ranked than the archangels, the bureaucracy favors Gabriel. While Aziraphale may have been given troops to command and a garden to protect, Michael refers to Gabrielās choices when confronting the evidence against Aziraphale for his demonic āboyfriendā, Sandalphon allows Gabriel to direct the āsurpriseā meeting in the bookshop, and Gabriel appears at the airfield, in a position equal to Beelzebub, Prince of Hell.Ā So even if it isnāt a God-ordained position of power, he clearly is treated as the authority figure over Heaven.Ā
His abuse is rooted in the desire to gain and maintain power and control over Aziraphale. AndĀ like real talk, Show!Gabriel is sickeningly effective at emotionally abusing Aziraphale, and his most insidious tool is gaslighting.
Broadly, what I mean is that Gabriel is (trying to) reshape Aziraphaleās perception of reality using techniques like:Ā
pretending not to understand why Aziraphale is so worried about being unable to stop the war (Withholding);Ā
purposefully making Aziraphaleās feelings/interests feel insignificant (Trivializing);Ā
Changing topics when Aziraphale starts to question his or Heavenās motives for the war(Diverting);Ā
Forgetting or denying events that have previously happened (Denial)
Purposefully questioning the victimās memory/even despite knowing their account of events to be true (Countering)
Gaslighting IS abuse. Full Stop.
Although it can masquerade as genuine confusion or concern, theĀ National Domestic Violence Hotline reminds us how over time, these abusive patterns of behaviors lead to a victim who ācan become confused, anxious, isolated and depressed while losing all sense of what is actually happening. Then, the victim may start relying on the abusive partner more and more to define reality, which creates a very difficult situation to escapeā
Because? Honestly? Gabrielās behavior is not nice, or innocent.Ā Ā
Who here can honestly say that Aziraphale doesnāt constantly second-guess himself?Ā And that he doesnāt have trouble making decisions?
Or ask himself if heās too sensitive? too soft?
Maybe that heās confused, or crazy? That he has to apologize for Heaven/Gabrielās behavior to friends? That he feels like he has to withhold information to avoid making excuses or explaining Heaven/Gabrielās behavior?
Does anyone think heās happy despite apparently āgoodā things happening for angels? That he should feel happier for his circumstances?Ā Or that he knows something is terribly wrong, but unable to express what it is? To Gabriel? To God? To Crowley? Even To himself?Ā
We already know he uses lying as a coping mechanism to avoid put-downs!Ā And When heās away from Heaven heās a radically different person. That heās more confident, more fun-loving, more relaxed when away from his abusers.Ā
Heās absolutely joyless around Gabriel,Ā
and been made to feel he canāt do anything right.Ā
These are all the symptoms of being gaslit (gaslighted?), and it takes a heavy psychological toll on Aziraphaleās mental health.
Through gaslighting, Gabriel can control Aziraphaleās perception of reality and consequently control his actions.Ā