I need to be awake in three hours but I'm just thinking of this
Like, Aimsey right. I have many many problems with them. But my biggest problem is how they try to paint themselves as this huge advocate for queer people, women and mental health to their audience
And yet they shit on Dream. If you're truly going to be an advocate for any of this, talk about the biggest victim of homophobia in your own community. Sure Drean doesn't get called slurs every day (that's an Uber exclusive âšïž) but at the end of the day, the reason Dream gets treated like that is because he himself is queer and he welcomes a queer female audience with open arms
But no, Aimsey just uses him and and the rest of dteam as punching bags. They see them as less. Aimsey can not and will never be a truly safe space until they acknowledge what Dream has been through and the role they played to help perpetuate it. Aimsey proves the whole thing about how people's queerness is judged on morality
Dream is the biggest victim mcyt has ever witnessed and yet all they see is a villain. Congrats the right wing smear campaign worked.
Aimsey and the rest of the Brighton bastards can tout all they want about how they want to support victims and queer people and marginalized communities but until they're able to see past their own biases and accept the blatant hate they've helped spread, they will never be that. They will be two-faced liars who only accept you when it's to no harm them. As soon as they have to make themselves uncomfortable for your rights and comfort, all they give is scorn
Associating with Dream is hard, it is let's not kid ourselves. Even as fans it can be difficult and most fans feel like they have to hide when they're out in the real world. But that's precisely why it's so important that anyone who claims to be all for marginalized people is also willing to show support for Dream
That also goes to Catelyn. She called George out happily without hearing his side of the story but it was crickets when it came to punz.
This goes to Sniff who was all to eager to tear Dream down and share Andi's story but has been deathly silent on every other matter. This goes to Rue who in the midst of people reeling over what was found out about Wilbur took the opportunity and painted Dream as an enabler when he was simply in the room. This goes to all of them, every single one who can't keep Dreamâs name out of their mouth as the general public slowly forgets theirs
And it goes to their fans too. Their fans who happily alienate and ostracize Dream fans on the basis of us enjoying our silly little guys. They who blindly believe every awful word that's thrown Dreamâs way without wondering what he did to be called that and never question why they're so eager to hate him
I mention Dream the most because he's undeniably the center of all this, but neither George nor Sapnap are safe from this either
It frustrates me to no end because they're so incredibly preformative. Dream never outright says go support victims, but every month he quietly donates to a charity in support of victims
He doesn't try and claim he's an advocate for queer people, he just exists and fosters a community where you can be openly about that. He also designs delightfully subtle pride merch. He doesn't claim he's an advocate for mental health, but he occasionally mentions his own struggles as a teen and how he got through it and tells us it'll be okay even if it doesn't feel that way or he'll say yeah I'm medicated now and it helps
He isn't loud about any of this. He just quietly makes it known his thoughts and feelings in small ways that resonate deeply with his audience.
He's not an advocate, he's just someone who when accused of something decided to try and do something good while clearing his name. He's not an advocate, he's a queer person that exists. He's not an advocate, he's just a young adult who struggled in his younger years.
He's not an advocate but he's made his space a safe one regardless of who and what you are.
I got severely off topic and rambled sorry đ
donât apologize, i appreciate hearing your thoughts <3
these parts of what you said really stood out to me:
âAimsey proves the whole thing about how peopleâs queerness is judged on moralityâ
âThey will be two-faced liars who only accept you when itâs no harm to themâ
âAs soon as they have to make themselves uncomfortable for your rights and comfort, all they give is scornâ
youâre right; if you want to foster a safe space for marginalized groups, you cannot pick and choose who is valid and who isnât. we see this in so many different spaces and in so many different ways â the second that someone whoâs part of a marginalized group isnât liked anymore (usually because of othersâ moral superiority complexes), they are completely alienated from their community at the hands of loud âadvocatesâ.
one thing that really bothers me about all of this is that the main strength in advocacy is education. educating people is advocacy. and then these creators come forward claiming to be advocates who foster safe spaces, yet their only forms of âeducationâ or discussion are heated rants about other creators they donât like, vagueing ongoing situations or drama, and shitting on creators like dream. and the worst part is how obvious it is that they havenât even attempted to think critically about any of the hate theyâre spreading. also, spreading hate is not advocacy! ever! spreading hate is not âsupporting victimsâ! youâre inherently taking away from victims when you shift the focus onto someone to target. turning someone else into a victim isnât supporting victims.
and about all the action dream has taken to support people in marginalized groups: thereâs even a massive difference between those other creators & dream in terms of the messages they spread and the behaviours they encourage. dream has ALWAYS told his fans not to spread hate or fight people on his behalf. he has ALWAYS encouraged empathy, understanding, and compassion, and shown it himself even when the other party doesnât necessarily deserve it and hasnât shown him the same. he doesnât go on hate-rants about other creators. he ALWAYS gives people the benefit of the doubt and tries to look at things from every possible perspective.
yes, talking is a huge part of advocacy. but an even bigger part is action. content creators make their agendas and intentions clear through their actions and behaviour, but their fans often get distracted by their words (i.e. âthis is a safe space for queer peopleâ). all of those examples you listed of ways dream has been a silent advocate makes his agenda clear. the same goes for creators like aimsey, who make empty promises and then do things that directly contradict the things theyâre saying (claiming to support victims, yet completely ignoring all of the ways dream has been victimized).
advocacy is uncomfortable, period. being a large voice in a community and using that reach to support marginalized groups can shine a huge spotlight on creators. and once you see where a creator draws the line, where their support and âadvocacyâ ends, their intentions and agendas become visible very quickly. and usually, the point where advocacy becomes too uncomfortable for a creator happens much sooner than people would expect. this is the issue with fans taking a creatorâs words at face value; if those words arenât backed up by any action, often times that means theyâre untrue.