Andy just looked down and listened as she continued to talk. It wasn’t often that he was the one who was silent in a conversation. He was bubbly and extroverted, usually it was pretty hard to shut him up, but in this moment he was at a loss for words. “I used to be so happy” he said with a small shrug, looking back at her. “And now I’m fucking miserable when I don’t have you next to me. I want to be with you every day- I think I’ve made that obvious. You just go back and forth so much, how am I supposed to know that you mean it now?” he asked, and he asked it genuinely. He wanted to believe her more than anything in the world, but it was hard for him with everything that had happened now. “That’s not what I want- I don’t want you saying you’ll marry me because I want you to, I want you to want to marry me. I’m not going to marry you if you don’t want to, I don’t want to trap you into a marriage because you think you’ll lose me if you don’t.” he said before looking back at her. “Yeah..Valentine’s Day doesn’t feel the same when I’m not spending it with you”
“Because I think I get it now,” Sarah said. There was a lump in her throat as she tried to hold back tears, and her voice was hoarse. “When you first asked me to marry you, I had never been without you. There was this little piece of me that worried that I was missing out on something or whatever. We were together since I was, like, eighteen. You’ve been all I’ve known since I was still that moody little brat who came straight out of Texas. So I doubted it because I was stupid and I thought there might me more to life than Nashville, but there’s not.” She sniffed and looked down at the ground. “I want to marry you. I want to be able to spend the rest of my life with you, because the time I’ve spent without you has made me realise that I don’t want to go through things without you. I’m fucking miserable all the time too, and I don’t want to be. I want to spend every day with you and I want to fight over taxes and other boring shit that adults do. You’re not going to trap me because there’s nowhere else that I’d rather be than with you, Andy.” There were tears streaming down her cheeks, which she roughly wiped away with the palm of her hand. “I know I’ve fucked up and made mistakes and I know there’s a million reasons why you shouldn’t trust me, but there’s one big reason why you should and it’s because I love you.” She shook her head, “Jesus Christ I sound like I’ve walked straight out of a Julia Roberts movie.”