Off The Record | Steve Harrington
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
The next morning felt dangerously normal.
That was the first thing you noticed as you followed Steve through the automatic doors of the grocery store with a cart rattling softly beneath his hands. Nothing about the last few weeks should have allowed normalcy to exist between the two of you anymore. Not after the months of damage sitting unresolved between you like broken glass neither of you knew how to stop stepping on.
And yet somehow, standing beside him in the produce section while he argued with you about avocados, it almost felt easy.
“You’re squeezing them too hard,” you said, watching him manhandle an avocado with absolutely no technique whatsoever.
Steve looked up innocently. “How else am I supposed to know if they’re ripe?”
“That thing is fighting for its life.”
A laugh escaped him before he could stop it, low and warm and real enough to make something tighten painfully in your chest. God, you had missed that sound. You hated how much you had missed it.
He held the avocado out toward you. “Okay then, teach me, Paparazzi.”
The nickname still did something awful to you every time he said it now. Softer than before. Like he understood it meant something now instead of just being a joke between you.
You took the avocado from his hand, trying not to think about how your fingers brushed his in the process.
“See?” you said quietly, pressing your thumb lightly into the skin. “Not too hard.”
Steve watched your face more than the avocado.
“Right,” he murmured. “Got it.”
Your stomach flipped unpleasantly when you realized he wasn’t listening to a single word you were saying.
You quickly looked away, placing the avocado into the cart before he could notice the effect he was having on you. That had become a recurring problem over the last twelve hours. Every time you let yourself relax around him for even a second, he’d say something gentle or look at you too softly or do something stupidly thoughtful, and suddenly you’d remember exactly why you fell in love with him in the first place.
In the moment it felt nice, but then the logical side of you knew it was dangerous.
Because no matter how easy this felt right now, your heart still remembered the image of Courtney tangled up in his sheets.
Your chest tightened instantly at the thought.
Almost subconsciously, you folded your arms tighter over yourself.
Steve noticed immediately, his smile fading slightly. “What?”
You shook your head quickly, turning toward another display before he could study your face too hard. “I’m just thinking.”
You grabbed a random tomato you didn’t even want just to have something to do with your hands. “You don’t have to analyze every mood change I have.”
Steve’s expression had softened now, concern replacing the teasing look from earlier.
“Because half the time lately,” he said carefully, “I can practically see the second you remember I hurt you.”
The honesty of it knocked the air from your lungs a little.
You looked down at the tomato in your hands.
Part of you wanted him to stop noticing things about you so easily. It would’ve made this so much less complicated.
Instead, he reached over quietly and took the tomato from your hands before placing it back in the display. “You hate tomatoes,” he said.
And somehow that hurt too.
Because he remembered things. He noticed things. He cared. Which made it infinitely harder to reconcile with the version of him that had looked you in the eyes and tried to destroy you at that party.
You swallowed and turned away before he could see your expression shift again.
For the next few minutes, the two of you moved quietly through the aisles together. But it wasn’t awkward silence. It was the kind that came from familiarity. Your bodies naturally adjusted around each other without thinking. Steve pushed the cart while you reached for ingredients. He handed you things before you even asked for them. At one point he grabbed your favorite cereal off the shelf without a word and dropped it into the cart like it belonged there.
Every little thing he did felt intentional now. Not a single moment felt performative or manipulative, and a cynical part of you wished it did.
Because if he’d been cruel all the time, this would’ve been easy.
Instead, Steve Harrington was standing in the frozen foods aisle remembering your favorite snacks and walking slightly slower whenever you fell behind him and looking at you like he was still a little stunned you came back at all.
It made your resolve feel thinner than it should’ve.
You were halfway through deciding between pasta brands when a voice suddenly cut through the aisle behind you.
Both of you turned at the same time.
A girl about your age stood a few feet away staring at him with obvious recognition. Pretty. Blonde. The kind of girl who looked like she’d spent high school sitting on the sidelines of a basketball game in a cheer uniform, knowing exactly how attractive she was.
Steve blinked in surprise before recognition crossed his face.
“Oh my god,” he said. “Megan?”
She laughed immediately. “Wow. I can’t believe you actually remembered me.”
Your stomach dropped a little.
Of course he remembered her.
Steve had probably kissed half this town.
The thought came bitter and immediate before you could stop it.
Megan stepped closer, smiling warmly at him. “It’s been forever.”
“Yeah,” Steve said. “Since what? Junior year?”
Your chest tightened quietly. You tried not to let it show.
Megan’s eyes finally slid toward you curiously. “And who’s this?”
Your body entered fight or flight mode immediately, preparing to be brushed aside like your first time meeting Courtney. But before you could even open your mouth, Steve answered easily.
The words hit you so hard you almost physically reacted.
Your head snapped toward him immediately.
Steve didn’t even seem to realize what he’d said at first. Or maybe he did? Because when his eyes flicked toward yours a second later, there was no panic there. No hint of backtracking or regret.
Just something warm and certain.
It made your pulse stutter traitorously in your chest.
Megan smiled instantly. “Oh my god. That’s actually so cute.”
You opened your mouth, fully prepared to correct him, but Steve’s hand landed lightly against the small of your back before you could.
“Yeah, this is…” Steve glanced at you carefully for a second before saying your name softly.
The way he introduced you felt different than it would’ve months ago. Less like a flirtation and more like something he genuinely cared about.
Megan smiled at you warmly. “Nice to meet you. I knew Steve way back when.”
“Unfortunately,” Steve muttered.
She laughed. “Please. You were such an asshole in high school.”
You snorted before you could stop yourself.
Steve looked offended. “Wow. Okay.”
“She’s probably right,” you said.
“Oh, so this is how it’s gonna be?”
Megan grinned. “Honestly, good for you, Steve.”
She shrugged lightly. “You seem different.”
Something shifted subtly in his expression at that.
“Yeah?” he asked carefully.
“Yeah,” she said simply. “Happier.”
Your chest tightened again.
Megan looked between the two of you one more time before smiling knowingly. “Anyway, I won’t interrupt your domestic little grocery trip any longer.”
Steve rolled his eyes. “Thanks.”
“It was good seeing you.”
She waved once before disappearing down the aisle.
The second she was gone, silence settled between you again.
You stared very hard at the pasta shelf.
Steve cleared his throat softly beside you.
You let out a quiet breath. “Your girl?”
His ears immediately turned pink.
You finally looked at him.
Steve rubbed the back of his neck nervously. “That just kinda came out.”
“But,” he added quickly, stepping closer to the cart, “I also didn’t hate saying it.”
Your stomach flipped violently.
“I know,” he interrupted softly. “I know we’re not there yet.”
The gentleness in his voice almost hurt.
“But I meant it,” he admitted. “Maybe not officially. Not in a way I deserve yet.” His eyes held yours carefully. “But in my head? It’s you. It’s been you for a long time.”
You had to look away again.
Because the worst part was you believed him.
And believing him was becoming terrifying.
The drive back to his house felt quieter after that. Like both of you were thinking too hard about the same thing but neither wanted to say it out loud first.
When you got inside, Steve carried the grocery bags into the kitchen while you started unpacking ingredients.
“You cook,” you said. “I’ll supervise.”
He scoffed immediately. “That sounds fake.”
You laughed quietly despite yourself, and Steve’s expression softened instantly at the sound like it was still the best thing he’d heard all day.
You needed to stop reacting to him like this.
But then he’d lean against the counter looking unfairly pretty in a plain gray sweatshirt while talking about whether garlic bread counted as a full food group, and suddenly your heart would start acting stupid all over again.
At one point while he cooked, music started playing softly from the little speaker near the sink. Some old song you vaguely recognized.
Steve glanced toward it before looking back at you.
“You wanna dance with me?”
You stared at him. “In your kitchen?”
“You’re holding pasta sauce.”
You shook your head immediately, laughing under your breath. “Absolutely not.”
But Steve was already setting the spoon down.
“That nickname isn’t gonna work on me right now.”
“It literally always works on you.”
You rolled your eyes as he walked around the counter toward you, holding his hand out dramatically.
Your chest tightened slightly at the words.
You stared at his outstretched hand for a long moment before finally placing yours in it.
Sleep became impossible somewhere around midnight. You’d laid in Steve’s guest room staring at the ceiling for nearly two hours, listening to the old house settle around you in soft creaks and distant hums while your brain refused to shut off for even a second. Every time you closed your eyes, another moment from the day replayed itself immediately afterward. Steve smiling at you over grocery store shelves. Steve introducing you as his girl without hesitation. Steve swaying with you in the middle of his kitchen like he’d forgotten there was a world outside of the two of you entirely.
Because the more time you spent with him away from campus, away from the whispers and articles and basketball games and everything else, the easier it became to remember why this had hurt so badly in the first place.
You loved him enough that forgiveness was starting to feel dangerously possible.
With a frustrated sigh, you finally shoved the blankets off yourself and sat up. The digital clock on the nightstand glowed 2:17 AM in dull red numbers.
Maybe sugar would fix the situation. Or at least distract you from it.
You quietly opened the bedroom door and slipped into the hallway, the floor cool beneath your feet as you made your way downstairs. The house was dark except for the faint glow of moonlight spilling through the living room windows. For a second you thought you might actually be alone.
Then you heard the freezer door open.
You blinked in surprise as Steve straightened from the kitchen, an ice cream tub in one hand and a spoon in the other. He looked equally startled to see you standing there.
There was a beat of silence before he lifted the spoon slightly.
A laugh escaped you softly despite yourself. “Guess not.”
Steve glanced down at the ice cream in his hands before holding it up sheepishly. “I was hoping this would emotionally fix me.”
“Chocolate chip cookie dough.”
You nodded approvingly. “Acceptable.”
His voice was still rough with sleep, softer than usual in the quiet house. It did dangerous things to your nervous system.
You stepped further into the kitchen while he grabbed another spoon from the drawer without even asking if you wanted one. The gesture was so natural it made your chest ache a little.
You took the spoon from him quietly, your fingers brushing for half a second.
Steve climbed onto the counter instead of sitting normally, one leg dangling slightly while he peeled the lid off the ice cream. You leaned beside him a moment later, shoulder almost brushing his.
For a while, neither of you spoke.
The silence wasn’t awkward anymore. That was the thing that kept sneaking up on you during this trip. Silence with Steve used to feel charged in all the wrong ways. Full of tension and avoidance and all the things you weren’t saying.
But now it felt safe. It felt like both of you were finally too exhausted to keep pretending you didn’t understand each other.
The refrigerator hummed quietly behind you while Steve absently scraped his spoon against the carton.
Then, without looking at you, he said softly, “I’ve been thinking about coming clean.”
You frowned slightly. “About what?”
Your stomach tightened instantly.
Steve stared down at the melting ice cream for a second before continuing. “Everything with the donations. The pressure. Him trying to control the program through me.” He swallowed. “All of it.”
The tone of his voice made your chest tighten.
There wasn’t any anger in it, or dramatics. His voice was just heavy with pure exhaustion
“I keep thinking about what would’ve happened if someone else had found out first,” he admitted quietly. “If someone had published it before I had the chance to say anything.”
Your throat tightened immediately because you knew exactly what he was talking about.
Steve rubbed the back of his neck, eyes fixed somewhere on the kitchen floor now. “I think maybe I deserve it.”
Your eyebrows pulled together immediately. “Deserve what?”
The words hit so hard your chest physically hurt.
“No, seriously.” His voice cracked slightly around the edges now. “Because maybe if I’d just been honest from the beginning none of this would’ve happened.”
You stared at him in disbelief.
“You think destroying your career is gonna fix this?”
He let out a humorless laugh. “I don’t know what’s gonna fix this.”
Steve looked up finally, and the expression on his face almost wrecked you completely. There was no ego left in him right now. No cocky basketball captain act. Just a tired boy sitting in the middle of a dark kitchen looking like the weight of the world had finally become too heavy to carry.
“My entire life,” he said quietly, “people have looked at me and assumed things came easy for me.”
“They think because my dad has money or because I’m good at basketball that none of it actually means anything.” His jaw tightened slightly. “And now every time I think about the championship or the captain thing or any of it, all I hear is him.”
“He made you feel like none of it belongs to you,” you said softly.
Steve looked at you like he hadn’t expected you to understand that so quickly.
“Yeah,” he admitted after a second.
Then he laughed quietly to himself, bitter around the edges. “The fucked up part is I almost handed him exactly what he wanted.”
You frowned slightly. “What do you mean?”
“When I saw your notebook.” His voice dropped lower now. “I thought you saw me the same way he does.”
Your stomach twisted painfully.
“Like I was just some spoiled kid who got handed everything.” He swallowed thickly. “And I got so angry that I stopped seeing you clearly.”
The tears hit your eyes before you even realized they were there.
That was the tragedy of all this, wasn’t it?
Two people loving each other so much they accidentally destroyed everything trying to protect themselves first.
You quickly looked away, blinking hard before the tears could fully fall.
Steve noticed immediately.
You shook your head once, pressing your lips together.
“No, because you don’t get to sit here and act like you didn’t earn everything you have.”
Steve blinked slightly at the sudden sharpness in your voice.
“You are so talented,” you continued, your throat tightening painfully around the words. “Like genuinely, ridiculously talented.”
“No.” You looked back at him now, tears finally slipping free despite yourself. “Do you know how hard it was writing about you all season?”
His expression softened immediately.
“Because every single game I had to pretend I was objectively observing some athlete when really I was watching someone who loves the sport so much it practically bleeds out of him.” Your voice shook harder now. “You think I would’ve fallen in love with you if you weren’t good enough to deserve it?”
Steve went completely still.
You laughed weakly through the tears. “You worked for that team, Steve. I watched you work for it.”
His eyes glistened immediately.
“You stayed after practices to help freshmen. You played through injuries. You carried pressure nobody else even knew about.” Your chest ached harder with every word. “Your dad donating money doesn’t magically erase your talent.”
Steve looked away quickly then, jaw tightening.
“You can’t let him win by giving all of this up,” you whispered. “Because that’s exactly what he wants. He wants you to believe none of it belongs to you unless it came from him.”
Steve’s breathing had gone uneven now.
You could practically see him trying to hold himself together.
“He doesn’t get to take credit for who you became,” you said softly.
For a second neither of you moved.
Then Steve suddenly laughed once under his breath, though it sounded suspiciously emotional.
“You know what your problem is?” he asked quietly.
You sniffed slightly. “What?”
“You see the best in me even when I don’t deserve it.”
Your chest tightened painfully.
“You do deserve it,” you whispered.
Steve looked at you then and suddenly the air shifted.
His eyes dropped briefly to your mouth before flicking back up again, hesitant this time.
Your heart started pounding immediately.
Slowly, Steve set the ice cream carton aside before leaning in slightly.
And then he stopped, giving you every opportunity to pull away.
The fact that he stopped nearly broke your heart all over again.
Because old Steve wouldn’t have.
Old Steve would’ve acted first and thought later.
This version of him looked at you like your comfort mattered more than what he wanted.
Your breath caught softly in your chest. Then, before you could think too hard about it, you closed the distance yourself.
The kiss was devastatingly gentle.
Steve made the quietest sound against your mouth, something halfway between relief and heartbreak, and suddenly his hand was against your jaw like he couldn’t quite believe this was real.
You kissed him again before he could overthink it.
It felt nothing like the rushed almost-moments you’d shared before.
When you finally pulled apart, both of you stayed close enough that your foreheads brushed lightly together.
Steve’s eyes stayed closed for a second longer before he whispered. “I missed you so much.”
Your throat tightened painfully.
Neither of you made it back upstairs after that.
At some point you ended up curled together on the couch beneath an old blanket, Steve half sprawled against the cushions while you rested against his chest. His arm stayed wrapped tightly around you even in sleep like he was scared you’d disappear if he loosened his grip too much.
For the first time in weeks, you slept peacefully.
Which was probably why the sound of the front door slamming open a few hours later startled both of you awake instantly.
Heavy footsteps echoed through the house and you could feel Steve stiffen beneath you immediately.
Before you could register what was happening, a cold voice rang through the entryway.
The second Steve heard his father’s voice, every part of him changed.
His body went rigid. His breathing practically stopped. Even the warmth that had settled into him while you slept against his chest seemed to vanish all at once, replaced by something cold.
You recognized it as fear.
Steve carefully untangled himself from you and sat up too quickly, running a hand through his messy hair while trying to shake the sleep from his expression. Beside him, your own heart had started pounding nervously in your chest.
The front door slammed shut as the heavy footsteps got closer.
You looked toward him uncertainly. “Should I…” you trailed off, eyes darting between Steve and the stairs.
The answer came too fast.
Steve stood immediately, already looking panicked at the idea of you disappearing upstairs before his father saw you.
Steve swallowed hard before holding a hand out toward you. “Just stay with me, okay? Please.”
Your chest tightened painfully at the look on his face.
You nodded once and took his hand.
The two of you barely made it into the kitchen before a figure appeared in the doorway and suddenly you understood Steve in a way you never fully had before.
Standing there in a sharply pressed coat with exhaustion and irritation etched permanently into his face was a man who looked at his son like disappointment had become second nature to him.
Richard Harrington’s eyes landed on Steve first.
Then slid to you before immediately hardening.
“What are you doing here?”
His father ignored the question entirely.
“I had to hear from someone else that you skipped the donor dinner last night.”
Steve’s jaw tightened slightly. “I wasn’t exactly in the mood for public appearances.”
“You don’t get to decide when you’re in the mood,” his father snapped immediately. “Not after the embarrassment you caused this family last week.”
Steve looked exhausted already, but now you could practically see him retreating into himself in real time.
Richard laughed humorlessly. “Sorry doesn’t erase the fact that you blew the biggest game of your career.”
The words hit like a slap.
You glanced toward Steve instinctively.
His face stayed carefully blank.
Richard finally looked toward you again. You caught a slight hint of recognition in his eyes before he spoke again.
Before you could answer, Steve spoke sharply.
The immediate defensiveness in his voice made something flicker across his father’s face.
Richard sighed heavily, pinching the bridge of his nose like this was all just deeply exhausting for him. “Of course she is.”
Steve’s posture straightened immediately.
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
“It means,” his father said coolly, “you’ve always had a habit of letting girls distract you whenever something important is happening.”
Beside you, Steve’s expression darkened instantly.
“What?” Richard continued casually. “Am I wrong?”
The word came hard enough to cut glass.
But his father just looked unimpressed.
“You had one job this season, Steven. One. Keep your head straight long enough to secure your future.” His eyes flicked toward you dismissively. “Instead, you’re here playing house.”
The humiliation hit you instantly even though you knew the comment wasn’t really about you.
Your arms folded instinctively tighter over yourself.
And unfortunately, Richard noticed that too.
“Nothing personal,” he said toward you, though there was absolutely nothing apologetic in his tone. “But girls like you come and go. Basketball doesn’t.”
Something in Steve snapped.
Steve stepped slightly in front of you before continuing, voice suddenly shaking with anger.
“You do not get to talk about her like that.”
Richard stared at his son for a long moment like he genuinely couldn’t believe he was being challenged right now.
Steve’s breathing had gone uneven now.
“You don’t know anything about her.”
“I know enough. More than you might think.”
“No,” Steve repeated, louder this time. “You don’t.”
Your heart was hammering now because this wasn’t normal arguing anymore.
This felt deeper. Years of swallowed resentment finally starting to rupture open.
Richard crossed his arms. “You’re proving my point right now.”
“Your point?” Steve laughed sharply. “What, that I care about someone?”
The word landed like a gunshot.
You physically saw the impact it had on Steve.
His entire face just fell.
Tiny. Brief. Barely noticeable unless you were paying attention. And suddenly every piece of him made sense.
Every moment he’d overperformed. All the times he’d tried to seem unaffected. Every reckless decision or desperate attempt to be enough for everybody around him all the time.
Somewhere along the way, this man had convinced Steve that love was conditional. That worth was conditional. He was made to believe that failure made him disposable.
Your chest hurt so badly you almost couldn’t breathe through it.
Steve looked away briefly, jaw flexing hard.
“I played through an injured ankle.”
Richard shrugged coldly. “And?”
The silence afterward was devastating.
In that moment you suddenly understood why he’d looked at you with that awful smirk in the hotel room. Why hurting you had felt easier than risking vulnerability.
This was what he’d grown up with.
Love that turned cruel the second he disappointed someone.
Your eyes burned immediately.
Richard sighed impatiently. “You’re lucky I’ve spent years building relationships with this athletic department, because another performance like that and they would’ve buried you.”
Steve laughed softly then.
“You really believe that, huh?”
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
Steve finally looked back at him fully.
And for the first time since Richard walked into the house, you saw something in Steve’s expression other than fear.
“You think everything good in my life exists because of you.”
Richard’s eyes narrowed slightly. “Careful.”
“No,” Steve continued, voice trembling now. “Because I’m starting to realize how insane this actually is.”
“You donated money to a program and spent years making me feel like that somehow means I didn’t earn my place there.”
“You benefited from my connections.”
“I benefited from basketball.”
His father scoffed. “You think talent alone gets people opportunities?”
“No,” Steve snapped. “I think I spent years killing myself to prove I deserved the opportunities you kept holding over my head.”
The room went completely silent.
Your chest was tight enough to hurt.
Steve looked furious now. Devastated too, somehow.
“You wanna know the worst part?” he continued. “For a while, I actually believed you.”
Richard stared at him coldly. “You’re being dramatic.”
Steve laughed in disbelief.
“You lost one game and suddenly you’re spiraling.”
“It’s not about the game!”
The shout echoed through the kitchen.
Steve immediately looked guilty for it before dragging a hand through his hair again, breathing hard.
“It’s about the fact that nothing is ever enough for you,” he said more quietly now. “Not one thing.”
His father looked entirely unmoved.
“You’re emotional because you’re embarrassed.”
“No,” Steve said. “I’m emotional because I’m tired.”
Richard scoffed again, eyes sliding toward you dismissively. “And I’m sure she’s helping with that.”
Steve stepped forward instantly.
“Don’t talk about her again.”
The challenge in his father’s voice made the entire room feel dangerous.
Steve’s hands curled into fists at his sides.
“Or I swear to God I’ll tell the university everything.”
Even you stopped breathing.
Richard’s face darkened immediately.
“No.” Steve’s voice cracked sharply now. “I am done letting you act like you own me.”
Your heart was pounding violently.
Because suddenly this wasn’t just emotional anymore.
Richard stepped closer slowly. “You think exposing me hurts only me?”
“You lose basketball. Your scholarships disappear. Your future disappears.”
Steve’s jaw tightened painfully.
He glanced toward you and something in his expression shifted completely.
“I almost lost her because of this,” he said quietly.
Richard looked unimpressed. “And?”
“And you still don’t get it.”
The silence that followed felt suffocating.
Then Richard straightened his coat calmly like the conversation bored him now.
“You’re making a mistake.”
“No,” Steve said softly. “I think I’ve been making the same mistake my whole life.”
For a second, something almost human flickered across his father’s face.
Then it vanished faster than it arrived.
Richard looked toward you one final time.
“You should be careful,” he said coolly. “Steve gets attached to things that make him feel better about himself.”
Your stomach twisted immediately, but before you could even react, Steve stepped fully between you.
The words came low and shaking.
“You’re seriously defending this girl to your own father? In my home?”
Steve didn’t even hesitate.
“Your home? You haven’t spent an actual night here in years.”
The answer hit the room like lightning.
Your heart physically stuttered in your chest.
Even Richard looked slightly thrown by how immediate it was.
Steve’s breathing had gone uneven again now, emotion bleeding through every word despite how hard he was trying to hold himself together.
“She’s the only thing that’s felt real in my life in months,” he said quietly. “So yeah. I’m choosing her.”
Your eyes burned instantly.
Richard looked between the two of you for a long moment before letting out a cold laugh and walking out the door. It slammed behind him hard enough to shake the walls.
For several seconds, neither of you moved.
Steve still stood between you and the doorway like his body hadn’t realized the threat was over yet. His chest rose and fell unevenly beneath the thin gray t-shirt he’d thrown on, shoulders tensed so tightly it looked painful. You could see the imprint his father’s presence had left on him in real time. The rigid set of his jaw, the way his fingers flexed at his sides, the slight tremor in his breathing he was clearly trying to suppress before you noticed it.
You noticed everything about him now.
Steve finally turned around.
And the second his eyes landed on you, the anger left his face entirely.
What replaced it was somehow worse. It was a thin line between shame and embarrassment.
It looked like he hated that you had witnessed that part of his life.
His throat bobbed slightly before he looked away first.
The words came out rough.
You frowned immediately. “Steve—”
“No.” He shook his head once, quick and frustrated, dragging a hand back through his hair. “Don’t do that thing where you try to make this okay. You shouldn’t have had to see that.”
His voice cracked slightly around the last word, and your chest tightened painfully.
For the first time since meeting Steve Harrington, you realized something terrifyingly simple: no one had probably ever been there to comfort him after his father verbally attacked him.
The realization settled heavily inside your chest as Steve leaned both hands against the kitchen counter, head dropping forward for a moment like he was trying to physically hold himself together.
“I just…” He exhaled shakily. “Jesus Christ.”
Steve laughed softly then, but there was nothing humorous in the sound.
“That was probably insane for you to watch.”
You realized with disbelief that the thing that seemed to upset him most wasn’t what had been said to him.
It was that you’d had to hear it.
Slowly, carefully, you stepped closer.
He still wouldn’t look at you.
“You don’t have to apologize for him.”
“Yeah,” he muttered bitterly, “well apparently he’s still my father, so.”
The self-loathing woven into the sentence made your stomach twist.
Without really thinking about it, you reached for his wrist gently.
Steve went still beneath your touch.
“You know what the worst part is?” he asked quietly after a moment.
Your fingers tightened slightly around his arm. “What?”
“When he talks to me like that…” His eyes shut briefly. “Part of me still feels like I’m 16 again trying to convince him I’m worth being proud of.”
The words hit you so hard you physically felt it.
Suddenly everything about Steve made sense in a way it never fully had before. The need to perform. The constant pressure he put on himself. The parties, his image, the desperate need to be liked by everyone around him.
It was never a confidence thing for him. It was purely survival.
“Steve,” you whispered softly, “look at me.”
For a second you didn’t think he would.
Then finally his eyes lifted to yours.
He looked emotionally exhausted in the way people look when they’ve spent years carrying something heavy by themselves.
“You are not your father.”
His jaw tightened instantly.
“Yes,” you said firmly, “I do.”
Silence settled heavily between you.
Steve swallowed hard before shaking his head faintly. “You really shouldn’t be this nice to me after everything I put you through.”
The honesty of it nearly destroyed you. Knowing that the same crushing guilt he carried around constantly now was still lingering in his mind, haunting him.
You stepped closer until barely any distance remained between you.
“You hurt me,” you admitted quietly.
Steve physically flinched.
“Yet you also spent weeks hating yourself for it.”
He stared at you silently.
“And after seeing him?” you glanced toward the front door. “I think I understand why.”
Steve’s entire expression shifted at that.
For a long moment, neither of you said anything.
Then finally Steve looked away and muttered quietly, “I don’t want you thinking I’m some tragic charity case now.”
You let out the smallest breath of laughter.
“That’s what you took from this conversation?”
“You know,” you said softly, “you’re allowed to let people take care of you sometimes.”
Steve’s eyes flicked back to yours immediately.
The vulnerability there nearly took your breath away.
It was terrifying, realizing how much softer he’d become with you.
The Steve from campus would’ve laughed this conversation off three different times by now. He would’ve hidden behind sarcasm or charm or flirtation.
This Steve just looked at you like he was trying to figure out whether he deserved kindness at all.
And somehow that version of him was the one you loved most.
“We should probably head back today,” you said quietly.
Reality settled back over the room immediately.
Steve nodded slowly. “Yeah.”
The drive back to campus that afternoon felt completely different than the drive to Hawkins had.
The sky outside remained overcast the entire drive, soft gray clouds stretching endlessly above the highway while Steve sat beside you with one arm resting against the open window. The wind pushed through his hair carelessly, occasionally lifting strands across his forehead before he shoved them back absentmindedly.
You caught yourself looking at him more than once. It wasn’t intentional. Your brain just kept drifting toward him now that things felt different.
Steve noticed eventually.
“You keep staring at me.”
You rolled your eyes slightly, focusing back on the road. “You’re being dramatic.”
Steve smiled faintly to himself before turning slightly in his seat. “You still came all the way to Hawkins for me.”
“I was worried,” you admitted quietly.
The sincerity in his response made your chest ache.
For a while after that, the car settled into comfortable silence. Steve eventually took over music despite your complaints about his objectively terrible taste, and somewhere outside Indianapolis you found yourself laughing quietly when he started aggressively defending some old rock song like his life depended on it.
“Did you just sigh during the guitar solo like some middle aged divorced dad?” The words barely came out, swallowed by the laughter you couldn’t seem to stop.
Steve looked deeply offended. “This is why opening up emotionally around you is dangerous.”
And the sound seemed to affect him instantly.
Steve looked over at you so fast it almost startled you.
“There you are,” he murmured softly.
Your heartbeat stumbled embarrassingly hard.
Even the way he said things now felt different too.
The realization followed you the rest of the drive back to campus.
By the time the university buildings finally came into view again hours later, something resembling hope had settled in the center of your chest.
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
a/n: i actually hate this chapter but i just need them to be fixed so i can rip them apart again wait what who said that ??
taglist: @veeweepeeknee @blackgurlieee @sincerellie @mhayes777 @daddyavesxx @napofaprincess @mj202323 @swirledyouintoallmypoems @solynoche @hstlut @1iliaanxz @turtlamour @superfreaksteve @beezusvreeland @bookmarkedmen @lacywithdrawal @ultimate--daydreamer @jeokeery @biologicallyyours @skelkitty @skkeletonns @exooojongdaeee @djolover4ever @softstaticclub @eller41 @ilovest3veh4rr1ngt0n @kurtsw7rld96 @jorkingtodjo @mortalselfprojected @dude-where-s-my-tardis @p-nkj @beelzebzb @dramallama9 @ttttt127