I need to know what Steph thinks about Chloe managing Drugstore Makeup post-Reunion lol
Anon I'm so glad you brought this up because I was thinking about it through the entirety of Reunion 😅
I think, in all honesty, it would be awkward for both of them, lmao
(I haven't read the comics in a while, and I know they see each other in those, but I also know those exist in another timeline so I'm just using the context provided by the games)
When Steph and Alex play foosball in True Colors, Alex asks how long Steph played with her band, and Steph sighs and says "too long," so there are obviously still some feelings there (understandable, and I'm sure it's the same for Izzie as well)
NOW, by the time Reunion rolls around, in my hc timeline, Alex and Steph have already done the touring thing, gotten married, and settled down, so I doubt she thinks about it too much. When she learns Chloe is managing Drugstore Makeup, it's probably like, "okay, that's cool, but did it have to be DM?" type of situation. I mean, I would definitely feel awkward if my high school friend started managing the band I was in with my ex 😭
I'm not sure if Chloe genuinely doesn't know Steph was part of Drugstore Makeup or if the writers just didn't think to include any type of footnote about it, because when Chloe talks about her nerd friends Steph and Mikey, I get the vibe she hasn't heard from or talked to them since those years. Maybe Izzie talks about the old drummer (and maybe even refers to her as Steph) and Chloe just doesn't connect the dots, which I can absolutely see happening 😅 Then one day sees an old picture (I'm imagining the one of Izzie and Steph outside of the Lantern with their tour sign), does a double take and is like "what the fuck, Steph Gingrich?"
It's definitely something they can laugh about in the future, but yeah, the moment they both find out, it's super awkward. I would absolutely love to see a post-Reunion....reunion, where they reach out and reconnect!! And rope Mikey in as well :'))) old buddies